fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Post your R5 Images Here

  
 
Hathaway
Offline
Details
p.10 #1Post your R5 Images Here


RobAmy wrote:
@arbitrage@

Geoff here is one with the 400mm DO II + 2x

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50177927381_3a74496e1e_h.jpgGreat Egret (400mm DO II) by A & R Photography, on Flickr

I have never worked with a DO lens before. The background blur on this image looks a bit weird to my eye. Maybe it is my display. It does not look smooth/creamy at all. Almost like a paintbrush has been drug vertically across the OOF areas. Is that the lens, the background or my display?

Bob
Aug 02, 2020 at 08:56 AM
armd
Offline
Details
p.10 #2Post your R5 Images Here
Stoffer wrote:
Man, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.


While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
Aug 02, 2020 at 08:56 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.10 #3Post your R5 Images Here
armd wrote:
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.


I ordered both so I'll see how that works out.
Aug 02, 2020 at 09:02 AM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.10 #4Post your R5 Images Here
armd wrote:
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.


The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Aug 02, 2020 at 09:07 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.10 #5Post your R5 Images Here
Sy Sez wrote:
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?


Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.
Aug 02, 2020 at 09:13 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.10 #6Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Sy Sez wrote
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.


DPreview is good for getting info quickly. In the top bar Camera and Lenses. Cameras go back to 1996 for Canon. 1992 for lenses with a section of unknown year.

https://www.dpreview.com
Aug 02, 2020 at 09:35 AM
Sy Sez
Offline
Details
p.10 #7Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Sy Sez wrote
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.


From Canon Spec.: " With its built-in, 3-mode, and up-to 5-stop optical image stabilization system, and high-speed Dual Nano USM autofocus motors, the RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM will prove its superb optical performance, over and over again."

https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/details/lenses/ef/super-telephoto/rf100-500mm-f4-5-7-1-l-is-usm

With the addition of IBIS= Up to six stops.

Aug 02, 2020 at 10:02 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.10 #8Post your R5 Images Here
Sy Sez wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Sy Sez wrote
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.
From Canon Spec.: " With its built-in, 3-mode, and up-to 5-stop optical image stabilization system, and high-speed Dual Nano USM autofocus motors, the RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM will prove its superb optical performance, over and over again."

https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/details/lenses/ef/super-telephoto/rf100-500mm-f4-5-7-1-l-is-usm

With the addition of IBIS= Up to six stops.



Thanks fo the correction. I guess DPreview got it wrong. Now I know why it it costing me $3,500 CND
Aug 02, 2020 at 10:28 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.10 #9Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Sy Sez wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Sy Sez wrote
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.
From Canon Spec.: " With its built-in, 3-mode, and up-to 5-stop optical image stabilization system, and high-speed Dual Nano USM autofocus motors, the RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM will prove its superb optical performance, over and over again."

https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/details/lenses/ef/super-telephoto/rf100-500mm-f4-5-7-1-l-is-usm

With the addition of IBIS= Up to six stops.
Thanks fo the correction. I guess DPreview got it wrong. Now I know why it it costing me $3,500 CND


The head shot of the eagle is blown out, I hope the lens didn't do that....

Aug 02, 2020 at 10:30 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.10 #10Post your R5 Images Here
Zenon Char wrote:
Sy Sez wrote
Zenon Char wrote
Sy Sez wrote
armd wrote
Stoffer wroteMan, I’m really starting to wonder how well the R5 + RF 100-500mm combo will work and what impact the RF 1.4x will have.
While I appreciate the perspective, given that many of us own 100-400 is ii’s it’s hard to compel a switch from a fantastic and versatile lens which gives great IQ and works well with a tc for the 100-500. The 100-500 is nearly twice as expensive for an additional 100mm FL though it is a 1/2 lb lighter.
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Both the 100-400 II and 100-500 are rated a 4 stops.
From Canon Spec.: " With its built-in, 3-mode, and up-to 5-stop optical image stabilization system, and high-speed Dual Nano USM autofocus motors, the RF100-500mm F4.5-7.1 L IS USM will prove its superb optical performance, over and over again."

https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/details/lenses/ef/super-telephoto/rf100-500mm-f4-5-7-1-l-is-usm

With the addition of IBIS= Up to six stops.
Thanks fo the correction. I guess DPreview got it wrong. Now I know why it it costing me $3,500 CND


I reported the error to them. I have seen errors before so I should know better than to rely on them. I still find it very handy to find which out which year gear was released, etc. This was a good reminder.
Aug 02, 2020 at 10:34 AM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.10 #11Post your R5 Images Here
armd wrote:
RobAmy wrote
armd wroteRob and Dave, having used my 500 f/4 is ii +- tc’s for years on my 5dmkiv’s I never saw the level of sharpness or af accuracy (even when calibrated) that your images with the R5 are displaying. Can you comment on this?
Well I am spoiled with the 1dx Mark III in that regard, but yes the extenders work flawless in my opinion. Yesterday I used my 400mm strait, with the 1.4x and with the 2x and really did not notice any AF performance issues. I will have to say the EOS R did a really nice job in that regard also. I do not even think twice about using extenders with Canon's line up. I will be curious if the RF extenders will offer any performance advantage over the current EF extenders.
Your observations are appreciated and what I am still trying to gauge is whether the same lenses and tc’s applied to the R5 will deliver performance I am not accustomed to seeing from a 5dmkiv? Are you using your IS or turning it off at higher Tv?

With respect to the tc’s it’s a bit of a Frankenstein connection having an ef lens, an R adapter, then an R tc, no? If the ef lens, ef tc and R adapter work fine, why change?


I never used a 5dmark IV but I feel the R5 is better then the 1dx Mark II and Amy agrees with what we have done so far with the R5. The TC's and adapter work great. I do not believe the RF TC with work with the adapter. If using the RF TC then you will have a RF lens to so no need for the adapter. The RF TC will not work with EF lenses. The reason for the change is to migrate everything to RF mount. I leave my IS on all the time.

Aug 02, 2020 at 11:36 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.10 #12Post your R5 Images Here


Hathaway wrote:
RobAmy wrote@arbitrage@@@

Geoff here is one with the 400mm DO II + 2x

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50177927381_3a74496e1e_h.jpgGreat Egret (400mm DO II) by A & R Photography, on Flickr
I have never worked with a DO lens before. The background blur on this image looks a bit weird to my eye. Maybe it is my display. It does not look smooth/creamy at all. Almost like a paintbrush has been drug vertically across the OOF areas. Is that the lens, the background or my display?

Bob


I can’t speak for Rob but all I see in the egret image background is the rendering of OOF grass blades at a distance that is too close to render without some semblance of vertical definition left. Maybe Rob’s 400/2.8 would have rendered them more OOF.

That said, having owned and shot the 400DOII for many years and having shot the 300/2.8II and 600II alongside it, I never found any bokeh issues related to the DO optic that I could tell.
Aug 02, 2020 at 11:38 AM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.10 #13Post your R5 Images Here
Hathaway wrote:
RobAmy wrote@arbitrage@@@

Geoff here is one with the 400mm DO II + 2x

https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/50177927381_3a74496e1e_h.jpgGreat Egret (400mm DO II) by A & R Photography, on Flickr
I have never worked with a DO lens before. The background blur on this image looks a bit weird to my eye. Maybe it is my display. It does not look smooth/creamy at all. Almost like a paintbrush has been drug vertically across the OOF areas. Is that the lens, the background or my display?

Bob


I think it is more to do with the grasses moving due to wind in the background. I applied nothing to the background in PS.

Aug 02, 2020 at 11:38 AM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.10 #14Post your R5 Images Here
A couple from this morning, I did not have the light but fun to get out anyway.

2000 ISO

Whitetail Bucks by A & R Photography, on Flickr

5000 ISO

Belted Kingfisher by A & R Photography, on Flickr
Aug 02, 2020 at 12:52 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.10 #15Post your R5 Images Here
Some back yard action with rolling shutter. This is getting too easy...














Aug 02, 2020 at 01:02 PM
stanj
Offline
Details
p.10 #16Post your R5 Images Here
Hathaway wrote:
I have never worked with a DO lens before. The background blur on this image looks a bit weird to my eye.


I agree, the DO delivers oftentimes odd backgrounds. The mk1 was awful, the mk2 is much better - but it really depends on background distance and contrast, much more so than with a "normal" lens. I have some perfectly in focus photos from my "backyard safari" but I just can't use them because the grass behind the bunny or quail or whatever is inducing seizures in people.

I still love my DO
Aug 02, 2020 at 01:07 PM
dcmiller
Offline
Details
p.10 #17Post your R5 Images Here
Sy Sez wrote:
The RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?


Of IS yes, but that doesn't help with subject movement, of course. I expect a step up of real world IQ to the 100-500 from the 100-400. And I really like my 100-400.

As a rule when Canon adds substantially to the price, as with the 100-500, they are improving the lens for higher resolution cameras. A $2500 zoom is going to be a really nice lens, regardless of the variable aperture.

Aug 02, 2020 at 01:58 PM
Jonesy
Offline
Details
p.10 #18Post your R5 Images Here
First shots with the R5. Used the RF85









Aug 02, 2020 at 02:20 PM
cpe1991
Offline
Details
p.10 #19Post your R5 Images Here
dcmiller wrote:
Sy Sez wroteThe RF100-500 "should" provide an additional stop, or two of IS over the EF 100-400 ?
Of IS yes, but that doesn't help with subject movement, of course. I expect a step up of real world IQ to the 100-500 from the 100-400. And I really like my 100-400.

As a rule when Canon adds substantially to the price, as with the 100-500, they are improving the lens for higher resolution cameras. A $2500 zoom is going to be a really nice lens, regardless of the variable aperture.


Canon has posted the MTF curves of the 100-500 on the Japanese website, corrected for diffraction. The values at 500mm are a tad lower than those for the 100-400mm at 400mm, as expected for a lens of very similar IQ but smaller aperture. It seems most likely that the two lens have very similar IQ.

Aug 02, 2020 at 02:28 PM
RobAmy
Offline
Details
p.10 #20Post your R5 Images Here
Playing with crop mode again. 1/120th

Red Bellied up close by A & R Photography, on Flickr

Playing around how low of a shutter I can go at 800mm in crop mode handheld. This is 1/20th

Chipmunk @ 1/20th handheld by A & R Photography, on Flickr
Aug 02, 2020 at 02:30 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister