fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020R5/6 lag/blackout

  
 
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.20 #1R5/6 lag/blackout
I got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.
Aug 04, 2020 at 01:14 PM
Maxxus46
Offline
Details
p.20 #2R5/6 lag/blackout
If this is accurate then nowhere near an A9. Hmnnn

Zenon Char wrote:
I got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.

Aug 04, 2020 at 07:31 PM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.20 #3R5/6 lag/blackout
Maxxus46 wrote:
If this is accurate then nowhere near an A9. Hmnnn

Zenon Char wroteI got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.


Yeah I think it is pretty obvious now that the scan speed is no where near an A9. The A7SIII isn't even near an A9 and it has less rolling shutter in video than the R5.
Aug 04, 2020 at 09:42 PM
Chimping
Offline
Details
p.20 #4R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
Thang wrotethis may have been discussed already somewhere in this 19 pages thread, but at 5:55, the photographer talks about the lag and displays it with the KF in flight sample. Unless, their settings weren't correct, this is not going to work for me with Peregrine in flight (both fast and unpredictable). Did I miss something?
The issue with their test is they used an older 500/4 lens and that lens doesn't support the full 12FPS MS mode. So what you see in those examples is one of the slower FPS modes. From other videos I've seen the 12FPS mode looks a lot less laggy due to quick frame insertion but there must be lag still there being hidden by the frame insertion. It is hard to know how it will really be unless you get your hands on one. There are FM users now saying that it is not difficult to track BIF. Chimping mentioned
...Show more →

Yes, that’s true - I have no problem panning using either MS or ES. If there’s frame insertion going on it’s irrelevant to me; the pan looks fine, and I don’t lose my subject while tracking.

EDIT:

The lenses I’ve now used with no appreciable lag are:

RF 85 f/1.2L
EF 600mm f/4L II with & without the 2x III
EF 300mm f/2.8L II
EF 100-400 f/4.5-5.6L II
Aug 04, 2020 at 11:40 PM
AlphaPhotography
Offline
Details
p.20 #5R5/6 lag/blackout
Just found this showing hummingbirds shot with the R5 electronic shutter in crop mode: https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/64228089

Looks surprisingly good albeit not panning

arbitrage wrote:
Maxxus46 wroteIf this is accurate then nowhere near an A9. Hmnnn

Zenon Char wroteI got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.
Yeah I think it is pretty obvious now that the scan speed is no where near an A9. The A7SIII isn't even near an A9 and it has less rolling shutter in video than the R5.

Aug 05, 2020 at 01:37 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.20 #6R5/6 lag/blackout
AlphaPhotography wrote:
Just found this showing hummingbirds shot with the R5 electronic shutter in crop mode: https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/64228089

Looks surprisingly good albeit not panning

arbitrage wrote
Maxxus46 wroteIf this is accurate then nowhere near an A9. Hmnnn

Zenon Char wroteI got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.
Yeah I think it is pretty obvious now that the scan speed is no where near an A9. The A7SIII isn't even near an A9 and it has less rolling shutter in video than the R5.


You don't need to be panning to distort fast moving wings. Hummer wings will distort and even come apart at certain positions of their movement. That said, even on the slow scanning Z50 and RIV that position shown in those examples don't usually show any distortion because they have been captured at the furthest extension where the wings pause for a split second. It will be shots during the middle of the wing beat where one would see if there is significant distortion or not.

I'm going to post on that DPR thread and ask if he has any shots from the other wing positions.

It is also interesting that the Crop mode may be scanning faster than FF. If FF is 1/60 then crop mode may be fast enough to avoid distortion in most shots.
Aug 05, 2020 at 05:35 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.20 #7R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
AlphaPhotography wroteJust found this showing hummingbirds shot with the R5 electronic shutter in crop mode: https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/64228089

Looks surprisingly good albeit not panning

arbitrage wrote
Maxxus46 wroteIf this is accurate then nowhere near an A9. Hmnnn

Zenon Char wroteI got this math from another site.

19ms = 0.019 seconds. 1 divided by 0.019 = 52.63 so 53. (put this in the denominator with one in the numerator) = 1/53 sec

If the R5 is actually 1/60 that isn't bad for 45mp but most are assuming it will be slower than the R6. The R which is reportedly 80ms puts it at about 1/12.

30ms would be 1/33.
Yeah I think it is pretty obvious now that the scan speed is no where near an A9. The A7SIII isn't even near an A9 and it has less rolling shutter in video than the R5.
You don't need to be panning to distort fast moving wings. Hummer wings will distort and even come apart at certain positions of their movement. That said, even on the slow scanning Z50 and RIV that position shown in those examples don't usually show any distortion because they have been captured at the furthest extension where the wings pause for a split second. It will be shots during the middle of the wing beat where one would see if there is significant distortion or not.

I'm going to post on that DPR thread and ask if he has any shots from
...Show more →

Would be a nice option to show ES, EFCS and MS in the exif data.
Aug 05, 2020 at 06:06 AM
Dely
Offline
Details
p.20 #8R5/6 lag/blackout
mikmau wrote:
Could Canon get rid of the blackout/lag in the R5/6 viewfinder?
Any info?


This is a very good review of the Canon R5 where your question about blackout was addressed. According to the Reviewer’s comments:

“No Blackout. None!!!“…….“The R5’s autofocus system surpasses the A9II’s, especially the animal eye autofocus. It’s amazing. I was shocked...”

Note: The Reviewer was recently shooting with a Sony A9II. He also previously shot with 1DX MKII so he provides a very well rounded viewpoint.

Credit goes to @Tony5787 for originally posting this video





Edited on Aug 05, 2020 at 06:47 AM · View previous versions
Aug 05, 2020 at 06:39 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.20 #9R5/6 lag/blackout



Canon representative says the R5 has a brand new sensor with superior read speeds and the R6 has a sensor with excellent read speeds, based on the 1dx III's sensor but not totally the same. My understanding of that would be the R5 sensor is a higher read speed than 1dx III. Power point slide show 1:47 mark.
Aug 05, 2020 at 06:40 AM
arbitrage
Offline
Details
p.20 #10R5/6 lag/blackout
Once again if someone can just post a series of feeding hummers and not cherry pick the extended wing positions that would help a lot. Trying that in APS-C mode and FF mode would also help to see if APS-C does give a faster speed.

This is what I'm looking for. Notice that even on the 1/20s scan speed (FF compressed, 1/30 is possible in APS-C compressed) of the RIV that the full forward wing beat is mostly distortion free (other than some combing artifacts on the upper edge of the far wing).














Aug 05, 2020 at 07:27 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.20 #11R5/6 lag/blackout
Dely wrote:
mikmau wroteCould Canon get rid of the blackout/lag in the R5/6 viewfinder?
Any info?
This is a very good review of the Canon R5 where your question about blackout was addressed. According to the Reviewer’s comments:

“No Blackout. None!!!“…….“The R5’s autofocus system surpasses the A9II’s, especially the animal eye autofocus. It’s amazing. I was shocked...”

Note: The Reviewer was recently shooting with a Sony A9II. He also previously shot with 1DX MKII so he provides a very well rounded viewpoint.

Credit goes to @Tony5787@ for originally posting this video






Minute 30:20. EVF wake up time which I don't like about the R. Is he kinda contradicting himself? He mentions the EVF shutting off to save battery power is good. Later he says to leave the LCD on and it switches between it and the LCD. Is that not good for saving battery power?

Personally I don't care about battery power. I'll get a few spares if I need to. I'm more interested in the EVF wake up speed. Does anyone have a R to compare. Is the R5 better? Either way when I'm birding I'll just leave the time out speeds at the maximum settings for quick EVF response time.
Aug 05, 2020 at 08:42 AM
lighthound
Offline
Details
p.20 #12R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
This is what I'm looking for. Notice that even on the 1/20s scan speed (FF compressed, 1/30 is possible in APS-C compressed) of the RIV that the full forward wing beat is mostly distortion free (other than some combing artifacts on the upper edge of the far wing).


Well if that kind of distortion is what you're looking for, why not just stay with Sony then.
It does look kinda pretty in an abstract kind of way.

Seriously though. You say "not to cherry pick the extended wing position" and yet you are specifically looking to "cherry pick" for the worst. Is there something special about humming bird pictures with their wings pointed straight out that you find especially pleasing? My preference is to see them in the up or down position for more details and mass.

I think you need to step back and look at the big picture here Geoff. Don't get hung up on the A9II read speed and think it's some kind of gift of the gods and the only way ANY MILC can achieve fast action photos. The results and reports we are seeing from the R5 are proof that that is not the case at all.

From my first hand experiences with the R5, I can honestly say that if you can't track fast BIF and keep it in the frame due to it's slower than A9II read speed, the camera is not the problem.

I really wish you hadn't have gotten cold feet when you canceled your R5 order. I was looking forward to hearing your first hand thoughts on it in comparison to the vast collection of other bodies you have used. I know you'll be picking one up someday, but by then it'll be old news.
Aug 05, 2020 at 08:46 AM
orlandoom
Offline
Details
p.20 #13R5/6 lag/blackout
Agree. This is canon's 5 series and not the soon to come 1 series which can only get better.
Aug 05, 2020 at 08:59 AM
Pius Sullivan
★ Featured Winner
Offline
Details
p.20 #14R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Dely wrote
mikmau wroteCould Canon get rid of the blackout/lag in the R5/6 viewfinder?
Any info?
This is a very good review of the Canon R5 where your question about blackout was addressed. According to the Reviewer’s comments:

“No Blackout. None!!!“…….“The R5’s autofocus system surpasses the A9II’s, especially the animal eye autofocus. It’s amazing. I was shocked...”

Note: The Reviewer was recently shooting with a Sony A9II. He also previously shot with 1DX MKII so he provides a very well rounded viewpoint.

Credit goes to @Tony5787@@ for originally posting this video

Minute 30:20. EVF wake up time which I don't like about the R. Is he kinda contradicting himself? He mentions the EVF shutting off to save battery power is good. Later he says to leave the LCD on and it switches between it and the LCD. Is that not good for saving battery power?

Personally I don't care about battery power. I'll get a few spares if I need to. I'm more interested in the EVF wake up speed. Does anyone have a R to compare. Is the R5 better? Either way when I'm birding I'll just leave the
...Show more →

What I got from what he's saying, is you need the lcd screen active to have the evf come on instantly when you raise the camera to your eye. I took the eos R for several test drives and that was a huge issue for birds in flight or sports action. If you need to dissipate heat why would you not give users the option to turn things on and off.
If he wanted a quick response from the evf he had to leave the lcd on, hence a trade off for battery life...

Aug 05, 2020 at 09:08 AM
Maxxus46
Offline
Details
p.20 #15R5/6 lag/blackout
I think he has extensive experience shooting BIF and has used many many cameras. You have to realize the A9ii is still far more advanced from a sensor to EVF readout standpoint, and zero blackout is a BIG deal once you've used it you won't want to go backwards. So Canon has made a good camera...great. but dont think for a second that the tech is similar. It is not and readout speed, zero blackout and nearly zero EVF lag on A9 series does matter. The R5 may be a good camera but it is not in the same class as an A9ii....canon. will need a mirrorless 1DX to achieve this. I am not willing to sacrifice speed, acquisition and accuracy for more mpx or video features.

lighthound wrote:
arbitrage wroteThis is what I'm looking for. Notice that even on the 1/20s scan speed (FF compressed, 1/30 is possible in APS-C compressed) of the RIV that the full forward wing beat is mostly distortion free (other than some combing artifacts on the upper edge of the far wing).
Well if that kind of distortion is what you're looking for, why not just stay with Sony then.
It does look kinda pretty in an abstract kind of way.

Seriously though. You say "not to cherry pick the extended wing position" and yet you are specifically looking to "cherry pick" for the worst. Is there something special about humming bird pictures with their wings pointed straight out that you find especially pleasing? My preference is to see them in the up or down position for more details and mass.

I think you need to step back and look at the big
...Show more →
Aug 05, 2020 at 09:08 AM
Greg Schneider
Offline
Details
p.20 #16R5/6 lag/blackout
Zenon Char wrote:
Dely wrote
mikmau wroteCould Canon get rid of the blackout/lag in the R5/6 viewfinder?
Any info?
This is a very good review of the Canon R5 where your question about blackout was addressed. According to the Reviewer’s comments:

“No Blackout. None!!!“…….“The R5’s autofocus system surpasses the A9II’s, especially the animal eye autofocus. It’s amazing. I was shocked...”

Note: The Reviewer was recently shooting with a Sony A9II. He also previously shot with 1DX MKII so he provides a very well rounded viewpoint.

Credit goes to @Tony5787@@ for originally posting this video

Minute 30:20. EVF wake up time which I don't like about the R. Is he kinda contradicting himself? He mentions the EVF shutting off to save battery power is good. Later he says to leave the LCD on and it switches between it and the LCD. Is that not good for saving battery power?

Personally I don't care about battery power. I'll get a few spares if I need to. I'm more interested in the EVF wake up speed. Does anyone have a R to compare. Is the R5 better? Either way when I'm birding I'll just leave the
...Show more →

What I got out of that was that if you flip the LCD screen closed (reversed), then only the EVF is used and powered, and only when you put it up to your eye. He wants to avoid even the power use of having the LCD screen open and the camera switching to that output when you move your eye away from the EVF. What he's mentioning is the lag to switch or wake up the EVF is greater when the LCD is not being powered (stowed away) while almost instant when it's being used.

Aug 05, 2020 at 09:09 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.20 #17R5/6 lag/blackout
arbitrage wrote:
Once again if someone can just post a series of feeding hummers and not cherry pick the extended wing positions that would help a lot. Trying that in APS-C mode and FF mode would also help to see if APS-C does give a faster speed.

This is what I'm looking for. Notice that even on the 1/20s scan speed (FF compressed, 1/30 is possible in APS-C compressed) of the RIV that the full forward wing beat is mostly distortion free (other than some combing artifacts on the upper edge of the far wing).


https://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/64228089
Aug 05, 2020 at 09:09 AM
JaimitoFrog
Offline
Details
p.20 #18R5/6 lag/blackout
Here is rolling shutter fan test on R5 vs A9 and A7R4. Not far back of A9, significantly better than A7R4.

https://twitter.com/photostudio9/status/1290541057210347520?s=19
Aug 05, 2020 at 09:22 AM
Zenon Char
Offline
Details
p.20 #19R5/6 lag/blackout
Pius Sullivan wrote:
Zenon Char wrote
Dely wrote
mikmau wroteCould Canon get rid of the blackout/lag in the R5/6 viewfinder?
Any info?
This is a very good review of the Canon R5 where your question about blackout was addressed. According to the Reviewer’s comments:

“No Blackout. None!!!“…….“The R5’s autofocus system surpasses the A9II’s, especially the animal eye autofocus. It’s amazing. I was shocked...”

Note: The Reviewer was recently shooting with a Sony A9II. He also previously shot with 1DX MKII so he provides a very well rounded viewpoint.

Credit goes to @Tony5787@@@ for originally posting this video

Minute 30:20. EVF wake up time which I don't like about the R. Is he kinda contradicting himself? He mentions the EVF shutting off to save battery power is good. Later he says to leave the LCD on and it switches between it and the LCD. Is that not good for saving battery power?

Personally I don't care about battery power. I'll get a few spares if I need to. I'm more interested in the EVF wake up speed. Does anyone have a R to compare. Is the R5 better? Either way when I'm birding I'll just leave the time out speeds at the maximum settings for quick EVF response time.
What I got from what he's saying, is you need the lcd screen active to have the evf come on instantly when you raise the camera to your eye. I took the eos R for several test drives and that was a huge issue for birds in flight or sports action. If you need to dissipate heat why would you not give users the option to turn things on and off.
If he wanted a quick response from the evf he had to leave the lcd on, hence a trade off for battery life...



That is what I got out of it as well. In the R's power saving menu you can disable VF off. I disabled both the VF and Power Off and the LCD to shut off in 15 seconds. With the LCD active the VF woke up right away. After the LCD shut off there was a delay even with the VF off disabled. Looks like I'm getting extra batteries.
Aug 05, 2020 at 09:25 AM
Chimping
Offline
Details
p.20 #20R5/6 lag/blackout
JaimitoFrog wrote:
Here is rolling shutter fan test on R5 vs A9 and A7R4. Not far back of A9, significantly better than A7R4.

https://twitter.com/photostudio9/status/1290541057210347520?s=19




Although, that's a pretty cool effect from the A7RIV!
Aug 05, 2020 at 09:30 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister