I just got home from my local park and Barn Swallows in crappy late evening light. I’ve shot these birds fairly extensively with the A9/200-600 and 1DX3/600iii, where the A9/200-600 was the superior combo. I shot them with the R5/600iii tonight. I have not reviewed images on the computer yet. My initial impressions are the R5/600iii combo had a bit more difficulty actually getting on the bird than the Sony combo, particularly if the focus was nowhere near where the bird was when I put the camera up. If focus was fairly close, the camera did a very good job of picking the bird up and tracking it. It was just about as good as the Sony combo I have. Again, the lighting was really bad tonight so it’s not really a fair comparison. It seemed the R5/600iii has a harder time tracking very small in the frame birds, particularly dark birds against dark backgrounds, than the A9/200-600. However, I’d never really keep any of these photos, so it may be a moot point.
The other factor to consider is my shooting style with the A9/200-600 is to generally start at 200mm and zoom in quickly to 600mm once focus is acquired with the Sony, so that obviously affords a large advantage to the Sony combo. I have not used the Sony 600 with the A9, so I can’t make a comparison there.
Overall the R5/600iii seemed far superior to the 1DX3 both in picking up the birds against varied backgrounds and continuously tracking them. It seemed the Sony *might* track better, but I cannot be sure how much of that is the difference in lenses. I have to do more testing, but I was thoroughly impressed with the R5/600iii.
I tried some electronic shutter shots and felt that the experience was much improved over the EOS R, however it wasn’t quite the live feed of the A9. My experience with the A9 live feed is that it is extremely good cause but as the card starts to fill, it starts to have a nearly identical experience to the R5 where it gets a bit of the slight “stuttering” of the image.
Here’s to more shots this weekend!