fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2020 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2020Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?

  
 
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #1Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Steve Spencer wrote:
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
JadedWriter wroteMirrorless is so small...until you pop on a flash, 2.8 lens and a vertical grip, then it's just slightly skinnier than a DSLR. At some point I'm going to pick up my Nikon's again for some relaxed shooting, just need to find the time...and get some sort of 100-400 for them because I'm starting to realize how much I like shooting nature type stuff.
Yeh...you can make mirrorless big by putting big lenses and flash onto it...but the beauty of mirrorless is that you CAN keep it small by using small compact lenses...unlike if you start with a big heavy DSLR...no way of making it small.

I use an A7R with the Sony 35 2.8 lens which combined weigh in at 585gm...much less than most DSLR's weigh by themselves.
That's indeed one of the strong sides of mirrorless, particularly the early A7 models, but only if you can live with one battery and a slowish lens. I do this all the time with my m43 cameras and their fantastic primes. However, if I'm travelling or if I'm doing a commercial shoot, there's no way I will survive with one lens and one battery.

And of course nowadays, the current A7R IV is approaching 700g even without a lens. Its ergonomics have improved, as has the battery life. Still, I would be more than happy to carry the extra 200g of the D780 for the even better ergonomics, much better battery life and the optical viewfinder.

It's all a question of what compromise is easiest to live with for each individual.
I travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter.
...Show more →

A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.




Jan 13, 2020 at 09:54 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
being that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is anothers treasure.

Edited on Jan 14, 2020 at 09:21 AM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:10 AM
PhotoSteve134
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #3Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
I've just invested in my DSLR Nixon camera - how long do you think we've got. Do you think the top end models will go first
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:12 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Wasn't R. Nixon from my side of the pond? he had a career ending event too
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:19 AM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #5Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
sjms wrote:
being that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is another gold.


Being that you didn't bring it up, but have an interest in it, how would you define "snaps" vs "images"?
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:32 AM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #6Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
PhotoSteve134 wrote:
I've just invested in my DSLR Ni(k)on camera - how long do you think we've got. Do you think the top end models will go first[/quote


Likely as long as you need. And no.


Edited on Jan 13, 2020 at 12:31 PM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:35 AM
Jorgen Udvang
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
sjms wrote:
being that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is another gold.


His point is valid. The camera has little influence on the "artistic" value of the photo. To me, viewfinder, lens and responsiveness matter. My D2Xs has that in spades. If I had any brains, I should buy better lenses for that camera rather than wasting money on new bodies
Jan 13, 2020 at 10:44 AM
James Farrell
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
I must have some kind of malfunction in the software of my web browser. I click on my bookmark link for the Nikon Forum of Fred Miranda and I somehow get presented this childish, argumentative, trolling thread that resembles DPreview.
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:17 AM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
T-O Shooter wrote:
sjms wrotebeing that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is another gold.
Being that you didn't bring it up, but have an interest in it, how would you define "snaps" vs "images"?


I don’t. Each image has a value to someone at some level. Now that you have tried to turn my question around please answer it.

Jan 13, 2020 at 11:23 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
T-O Shooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wroteYeh...you can make mirrorless big by putting big lenses and flash onto it...but the beauty of mirrorless is that you CAN keep it small by using small compact lenses...unlike if you start with a big heavy DSLR...no way of making it small.

I use an A7R with the Sony 35 2.8 lens which combined weigh in at 585gm...much less than most DSLR's weigh by themselves.
That's indeed one of the strong sides of mirrorless, particularly the early A7 models, but only if you can live with one battery and a slowish lens. I do this all the time with my m43 cameras and their fantastic primes. However, if I'm travelling or if I'm doing a commercial shoot, there's no way I will survive with one lens and one battery.

And of course nowadays, the current A7R IV is approaching 700g even without a lens. Its ergonomics have improved, as has the battery life. Still, I would be more than happy to carry the extra 200g of the D780 for the even better ergonomics, much better battery life and the optical viewfinder.

It's all a question of what compromise is easiest to live with for each individual.
I travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may
...Show more →

Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong that the D780 looks good to me--it doesn't (although I can recognize why it looks good to others) and you are definitely wrong about what sort of DSLR would look good to me (as I explain below I don't think any DSLR would work for me personally, but I can appreciate why others would like one). For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want small manual focus lenses with excellent performance in addition to an AF lens or two and that is something that just can't be done well with DSLRs. There are two problems for this type of lens with DSLRs that are inherent to the design. First, DSLRs can't magnify the viewfinder and although I like an optical viewfinder for some types of shooting, I don't like an optical viewfinder for shooting manual focus and especially wide angle manual focus. The EVF is just tons better for manual focus glass. Second there is the issue of flange distance. A DSLR has to have a long flange distance and that means large wide angle lenses, whereas there is some phenomenal and small wide angle manual focus glass available for mirrorless that just could never be built for a DSLR because it requires a short flange distance. For example, the Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, the Voigtlander 21 f/3.4, the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4, and the Zeiss Loxia 25 f/2.4 are all phenomenal lenses and just could not be built for a DSLR. These sort of lenses are an integral part of any travel kit I put together. I am certainly not saying my way of designing a travel kit should set the agenda for what Nikon should do or even that my way of building a travel kit is common, but I am saying for me a DSLR would just never work for travel, and I do very much appreciate my high resolution Z7 with IBIS and I also very much appreciate that it is a mirrorless camera with a very short flange distance so I can use exactly the lenses I want to use with it.

Edited on Jan 13, 2020 at 11:41 AM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:25 AM
Brev00
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Speculation is akin to gossip: favorite activities that have little value especially in this case. Let's say the D6 and the D780 were the last DSLRs ever released by Nikon. We would still have magnificent DSLRs available to use and purchase for a long time to come. The only reason to make predictions about this is to blog/brag later how smart one is. It is also something of a self-fulfilling prophecy. If everyone believes DSLRs are dying out then they will.
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:31 AM
chez
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Steve Spencer wrote:
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
Jorgen Udvang wroteThat's indeed one of the strong sides of mirrorless, particularly the early A7 models, but only if you can live with one battery and a slowish lens. I do this all the time with my m43 cameras and their fantastic primes. However, if I'm travelling or if I'm doing a commercial shoot, there's no way I will survive with one lens and one battery.

And of course nowadays, the current A7R IV is approaching 700g even without a lens. Its ergonomics have improved, as has the battery life. Still, I would be more than happy to carry the extra 200g of the D780 for the even better ergonomics, much better battery life and the optical viewfinder.

It's all a question of what compromise is easiest to live with for each individual.
I travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.
Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong about that. For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want small manual focus lenses with excellent performance in addition to an AF lens or two and that is something that just can't be done well with DSLRs. There are two problems for this type of lens with DSLRs that are inherent to the design. First, DSLRs can't magnify the viewfinder and although I like
...Show more →

These are the exact reasons why for travel a kit built around a mirrorless camera can be much more compact and weigh much less than an equivalent kit built around a DSLR system. Much of my travel photography involves closeup wide angle images where the savings in lens size and weight is greatest going mirrorless. I also always travel with a spare camera, sometimes two and if you include a spare DSLR the bulk and weight differences grow. My pack is smaller with mirrorless as well as my tripod...again savings in bulk and weight.

Those that say there is no potential weight savings going mirrorless is just wrong.
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:39 AM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #13Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Steve Spencer wrote:
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
Jorgen Udvang wroteThat's indeed one of the strong sides of mirrorless, particularly the early A7 models, but only if you can live with one battery and a slowish lens. I do this all the time with my m43 cameras and their fantastic primes. However, if I'm travelling or if I'm doing a commercial shoot, there's no way I will survive with one lens and one battery.

And of course nowadays, the current A7R IV is approaching 700g even without a lens. Its ergonomics have improved, as has the battery life. Still, I would be more than happy to carry the extra 200g of the D780 for the even better ergonomics, much better battery life and the optical viewfinder.

It's all a question of what compromise is easiest to live with for each individual.
I travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.
Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong that the D780 looks good to me--it doesn't (although I can recognize why it looks good to others) and you are definitely wrong about what sort of DSLR would look good to me (as I explain below I don't think any DSLR would work for me personally, but I can appreciate why others would like one). For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want
...Show more →

Without reading the whole spiel of it, which I have no intention of doing, my point was that what we are choosing as options greatly depend on what Nikon is putting out there. I was neither suggesting that a D780 or a Z7 was the right choice for you. I was talking in general terms.

Someone shat in your corn flakes today??

Edited on Jan 13, 2020 at 11:55 AM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:53 AM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #14Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
sjms wrote:
T-O Shooter wrote
sjms wrotebeing that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is another gold.
Being that you didn't bring it up, but have an interest in it, how would you define "snaps" vs "images"?
I don’t. Each image has a value to someone at some level. Now that you have tried to turn my question around please answer it.



No.
Jan 13, 2020 at 11:54 AM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Steve Spencer wrote:
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wrote
JadedWriter wroteMirrorless is so small...until you pop on a flash, 2.8 lens and a vertical grip, then it's just slightly skinnier than a DSLR. At some point I'm going to pick up my Nikon's again for some relaxed shooting, just need to find the time...and get some sort of 100-400 for them because I'm starting to realize how much I like shooting nature type stuff.
Yeh...you can make mirrorless big by putting big lenses and flash onto it...but the beauty of mirrorless is that you CAN keep it small by using small compact lenses...unlike if you start with a big heavy DSLR...no way of making it small.

I use an A7R with the Sony 35 2.8 lens which combined weigh in at 585gm...much less than most DSLR's weigh by themselves.
That's indeed one of the strong sides of mirrorless, particularly the early A7 models, but only if you can live with one battery and a slowish lens. I do this all the time with my m43 cameras and their fantastic primes. However, if I'm travelling or if I'm doing a commercial shoot, there's no way I will survive with one lens and one battery.

And of course nowadays, the current A7R IV is approaching 700g even without a lens. Its ergonomics have improved, as has the battery life. Still, I would be more than happy to carry the extra 200g of the D780 for the even better ergonomics, much better battery life and the optical viewfinder.

It's all a question of what compromise is easiest to live with for each individual.
I travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter.
...Show more →

Totally agree Steve The argument for and against DSLR vs MLC becomes tiring. I love both systems and it just becomes a choice that we as photographers prefer to use. I love the Z6 because the 35/50/85 are outstanding lenses for their size/weight, value and this does not include the class leading 24-70/2.8S. I still have my stash of 28E, 58G, 105E and 70-200E which are all superb. I could easily opt for a D780 as I no longer need the high MP's for traveling. Problem with MP's for traveling is it eats into data storage very quickly and slows down your laptops regardless even if they are well spec'd. The D750 was excellent but started to become dated not having decent LV or video functionality. The D780 will be great for many but for now I prefer using the FTZ adapter with my lenses.

Jan 13, 2020 at 11:58 AM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
T-O Shooter wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wroteI travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.
Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong that the D780 looks good to me--it doesn't (although I can recognize why it looks good to others) and you are definitely wrong about what sort of DSLR would look good to me (as I explain below I don't think any DSLR would work for me personally, but I can appreciate why others would like one). For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want small manual focus lenses with excellent performance in addition to an AF lens or two and that is something that just can't be done well with DSLRs. There are two problems for this type of lens with DSLRs that are inherent to the design. First, DSLRs can't magnify the viewfinder and although I like an optical viewfinder for some types of shooting, I don't like an optical viewfinder for shooting manual focus and especially wide angle manual focus. The EVF is just tons better for manual focus glass. Second there is the issue of flange distance. A DSLR has to have a long flange distance and that means large wide angle lenses, whereas there is some phenomenal and small wide angle manual focus glass available for mirrorless that just could never be built for a DSLR because it requires a short flange distance. For example, the Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, the Voigtlander 21 f/3.4, the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4, and the Zeiss Loxia 25 f/2.4 are all phenomenal lenses and just could not be built for a DSLR. These sort of lenses are an integral part of any travel kit I put together. I am certainly not saying my way of designing a travel kit should set the agenda for what Nikon should do or even that my way of building a travel kit is common, but I am saying for me a DSLR would just never work for travel, and I do very much appreciate my high resolution Z7 with IBIS and I also very much appreciate that it is a mirrorless camera with a very short flange distance so I can use exactly the lenses I want to use with it.
Without reading the whole spiel of it, which I have no intention of doing, my point was that what we are choosing as options greatly depend on what Nikon is putting out there. I was neither suggesting that a D780 or a Z7 was the right choice for you. I was talking in general terms.

Someone shat in your corn flakes today??


Do you not have the decency to respect Steve's perspective and what he prefers. Your last line of commentary serious requires an apology to Steve or you should be banned from FM !!!



Edited on Jan 13, 2020 at 12:06 PM · View previous versions
Jan 13, 2020 at 12:05 PM
sjms
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
Jorgen Udvang wrote:
sjms wrotebeing that you have brought it up, how do you define "snaps" vs "images" and how do you "judge" other peoples work?

I believe one must be rather careful how one treads here as one mans trash is another gold.
His point is valid. The camera has little influence on the "artistic" value of the photo. To me, viewfinder, lens and responsiveness matter. My D2Xs has that in spades. If I had any brains, I should buy better lenses for that camera rather than wasting money on new bodies


Maybe technique and pov
Jan 13, 2020 at 12:05 PM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #18Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
charles.K wrote:
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wroteI don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.
Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong that the D780 looks good to me--it doesn't (although I can recognize why it looks good to others) and you are definitely wrong about what sort of DSLR would look good to me (as I explain below I don't think any DSLR would work for me personally, but I can appreciate why others would like one). For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want small manual focus lenses with excellent performance in addition to an AF lens or two and that is something that just can't be done well with DSLRs. There are two problems for this type of lens with DSLRs that are inherent to the design. First, DSLRs can't magnify the viewfinder and although I like an optical viewfinder for some types of shooting, I don't like an optical viewfinder for shooting manual focus and especially wide angle manual focus. The EVF is just tons better for manual focus glass. Second there is the issue of flange distance. A DSLR has to have a long flange distance and that means large wide angle lenses, whereas there is some phenomenal and small wide angle manual focus glass available for mirrorless that just could never be built for a DSLR because it requires a short flange distance. For example, the Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, the Voigtlander 21 f/3.4, the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4, and the Zeiss Loxia 25 f/2.4 are all phenomenal lenses and just could not be built for a DSLR. These sort of lenses are an integral part of any travel kit I put together. I am certainly not saying my way of designing a travel kit should set the agenda for what Nikon should do or even that my way of building a travel kit is common, but I am saying for me a DSLR would just never work for travel, and I do very much appreciate my high resolution Z7 with IBIS and I also very much appreciate that it is a mirrorless camera with a very short flange distance so I can use exactly the lenses I want to use with it.
Without reading the whole spiel of it, which I have no intention of doing, my point was that what we are choosing as options greatly depend on what Nikon is putting out there. I was neither suggesting that a D780 or a Z7 was the right choice for you. I was talking in general terms.

Someone shat in your corn flakes today??
Do you not have the decency to respect Steve's perspective and what he prefers. Your last line of commentary serious requires an apology to Steve or you should be banned from FM !!!



I wasn't challenging his point of view. Please re-read what I said, and if you cannot see that, let me know where you are having difficulty and I'll try to help you out.

And if he wants to be an ass with his reply (I've noticed several of you like to give a response to what was not said rather than what was said), expect a response.
Jan 13, 2020 at 12:11 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
chez wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
T-O Shooter wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Jorgen Udvang wrote
chez wroteI travel with an assortment of lenses all made for the mirrorless mount and lighter than the DSLR counterparts. I also carry 2 spare batteries...but I did that with mirrorless.

To me the weight that really counts is the one I carry in my hands...camera and lens. I can carry much more weight on my back...but my overall kit has gone down in weight by at least 60% compared to my DSLR outfit...and I believe the image quality has gone up at the same time.

I also have a very nice A6000 as a backup which weighs nothing, takes the same batteries and lenses as the A7R and takes up no room in my pack. I traveled enough with a DSLR based system to know how much lighter and smaller a mirrorless system can be. Weight is really key as many foreign airlines are now starting to enforce their 7kg carry on limits. I've been checked in India and Vietnam...was just under both times.
I don't understand what your point is. You are comparing a 7 year old Sony model with all its known limitations with the latest Nikon models. I wouldn't even dream of buying the original A7R.

The Nikon Z6 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 S is 1,145 grams
The Nikon D780 with one battery and the 85mm f/1.8 AF-S is 1,190 grams

For Sony fanboiz:
The Sony A7 III with one battery and the FE 85mm f/1.8 is 1,021 grams

The D780 is rated for 2,260 shots per charge, the Z6 is rated for 310 shots. (The Sony is rated for 710 shots). The Z6 is a fine camera, and I'm sure that the new lens is even better than the AF-S lens. But the older lens is very good, and few if any non-photographers will see the difference between images taken with the two.

As for airline limitations, I travel internationaly twice per month on average, mostly in Asia. So far, I have never had problems bringing my camera gear as hand-carry. If they check the weight and I'm over (I mostly am), I show them the content of the bag (which mostly is well within size limits), and they always say "please, go ahead". Few if any airlines in this part of the world want valuable camera gear with the checked in luggage. The risks are high, and they don't want to deal with possible claims. Some airlines in Southeast Asia have even raised their weight limits lately, Vietnam Airlines to as much as 12 kg if I remember correctly.

I would consider a mirrorless backup for a D780 though, like the Z6 or even the tiny Z50, since the lenses from the DSLR work fine, and the Z6 uses the same battery. The EVF of those camera are also great for video.
To add to this post if we compare the D780 to Z6 the D780 weighs 165g more, but all the f/1.8S lens are heavier than their f/1.8G counterparts. At 24mm it is 450g vs. 355g; at 35mm it is 370g vs. 200g; at 50mm it is 415g vs. 185g; and at 85mm it is 470g vs. 350g. This means that even with one lens the weight difference is minimal and goes back and forth. With 24mm and 85mm the Z6 with a lens is slightly lighter and at 35mm and 50mm the D780 with one lens is slightly lighter. If you put together any kit with even two lenses the D780 kit will be lighter (and I don't think this will change with the 20mm as the f/1.8G lens is at 355g is almost certainly going to be lighter than the f/1.8S lens).

So getting a Z6 kit to save weight (or even size) for travel doesn't really make much sense. Now, personally I use a Z7 kit for travel, so I am not saying there aren't other reasons to get a Z kit for travel but weight and size really aren't sensible reasons over the D780 and the small f/1.8G lenses. For me I can have a better set of lenses with my Z kit and I can have a high resolution camera and those things matter to me (I also really like IBIS for travel), but if one is happy with the f/1.8G lenses and 24 MP the D780 kit could be pretty compelling.
A lot of the "argument" of this only applies based on what Nikon decided to make and what they currently make. The Z7 kit looks good to you because Nikon made a small body, 46mp piece of gear. If Nikon had taken the Df or D750 as their model to design from and made a 46 mp "small" DSLR, added IBIS, and updated their 1.8 lenses to 2020 technology standards, it's very likely that would have been just as desirable a travel kit as the Z7. The D780 as it is, for those that are satisfied at 24mp, may very well be as desirable as the Z6.

I've went through about 20 pages of the Zee image thread, and it's a variety of what I'd call snaps, and then some very nice images. Give the same fellows equal mp DSLRs with IBIS (or without) and you'd still have the same fellows putting out snaps and the same fellows putting out images. The kit will not change that.

Same would hold true if Nikon built a Z9 that had the AF of the D6, but never made a D5 or D6. Then I might look at it and say I'd be buying a Z9. But that wound be a forced decision based on what Nikon decided to sell, the same as it would be now if I wanted a 46mp small body for travel.
Funny how you think you know exactly why the Z7 looks good to me and what sort of DSLR kit would look as good to me. You are actually wrong about that. For me a DSLR kit would never work for travel because I want small manual focus lenses with excellent performance in addition to an AF lens or two and that is something that just can't be done well with DSLRs. There are two problems for this type of lens with DSLRs that are inherent to the design. First, DSLRs can't magnify the viewfinder and although I like an optical viewfinder for some types of shooting, I don't like an optical viewfinder for shooting manual focus and especially wide angle manual focus. The EVF is just tons better for manual focus glass. Second there is the issue of flange distance. A DSLR has to have a long flange distance and that means large wide angle lenses, whereas there is some phenomenal and small wide angle manual focus glass available for mirrorless that just could never be built for a DSLR because it requires a short flange distance. For example, the Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, the Voigtlander 21 f/3.4, the Voigtlander 21 f/1.4, and the Zeiss Loxia 25 f/2.4 are all phenomenal lenses and just could not be built for a DSLR. These sort of lenses are an integral part of any travel kit I put together. I am certainly not saying my way of designing a travel kit should set the agenda for what Nikon should do or even that my way of building a travel kit is common, but I am saying for me a DSLR would just never work for travel, and I do very much appreciate my high resolution Z7 with IBIS and I also very much appreciate that it is a mirrorless camera with a very short flange distance so I can use exactly the lenses I want to use with it.
These are the exact reasons why for travel a kit built around a mirrorless camera can be much more compact and weigh much less than an equivalent kit built around a DSLR system. Much of my travel photography involves closeup wide angle images where the savings in lens size and weight is greatest going mirrorless. I also always travel with a spare camera, sometimes two and if you include a spare DSLR the bulk and weight differences grow. My pack is smaller with mirrorless as well as my tripod...again savings in bulk and weight.

Those that say there is no potential
...Show more →

Chez, if you actually do the math and stick to primes I think you will find the difference much smaller than you are suggesting. Nikon has long offered a fairly small and light DSLR kit for travel with their very light and quite small in size f/1.8G lenses. Those lenses make pretty much any D780 kit (compared to a Z6 kit) lighter even if you add a second camera (if you care about weight it probably makes sense to add the Df as your second DSLR, which I think is the lightest FF Nikon DSLR). But to demonstrate how these small lenses can even compare quite favorably to a two camera Sony mirrorless kit let's compare these two kits: Nikon D780 and Df, 20 f/1.8G, 28 f/1.8G, 50 f/1.8G, and 85 f/1.8G to the Sony A7 III X 2, Zeiss Loxia 21 f/2.8, Sony FE 28 f/2, Sony FE 55 f/1.8, and Sony FE 85 f/1.8. They are surprisingly close in weight. Yes, the Sony kit does weigh less at 2546g versus the Nikon kit at 2825g of 279g or about an 11% difference. Certainly no huge weight differences in these two kits, however (and if you swap out the 28mm lenses for the 35mm and even if you use the tiny Sony FE 35 f/2.8, the weight difference is even smaller--just 229g--and less than 10%).

So, I am not saying mirrorless doesn't offer you a small kit--it does--but you won't get lighter by going mirrorless in Nikon land and even if you go with Sony which offers the lightest mirrorless FF the weight savings over a light Nikon DSLR kit with their light f/1.8G primes will be minimal at best.
Jan 13, 2020 at 12:16 PM
T-O Shooter
Offline
[X]
Details
p.8 #20Hogan's article - The DSLR cash cow is alive for how long?
James Farrell wrote:
I must have some kind of malfunction in the software of my web browser. I click on my bookmark link for the Nikon Forum of Fred Miranda and I somehow get presented this childish, argumentative, trolling thread that resembles DPreview.


Only difference between here and there is that here, there's about 6 fellows everyone agrees with. Change that "everyone in agreement" thingy and you'll find those fellows no better than the worse of DPR.

Jan 13, 2020 at 12:17 PM
FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister