fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)

  
 
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #1Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
[...] The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.


The tree eater!!!! wasn't this supposed to happen with stars only?
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:22 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.25 #2Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nandadevieast wrote:
What if this guy comes back and tells you all the images were shot on FE


Then I want to know why some of the images look different and I want to know why he is trying to trick people on his site.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:22 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #3Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nandadevieast wrote:
What if this guy comes back and tells you all the images were shot on FE


Then he will have to admit that they weren't all shot at the same aperture from the same standing point. Which would make a fool out of him not me.

Aug 13, 2019 at 01:23 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #4Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.


On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:25 PM
smpetty
Offline
Details
p.25 #5Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Am I the only one who likes his images? I see that the bokeh is a bit busier on the FE shots, but he's comparing it to the best 35mm option that is on the Sony system. I'm keeping my pre-order (and I have an RX1R II).

Sky crapper, . It's a UPS truck...

I agree with Fred ^^^. I do not think that the missing trees are due to edit. I think that the different positions and angles and focal lengths account for the phantom trees.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:29 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #6Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
smpetty wrote:
Am I the only one who likes his images? I see that the bokeh is a bit busier on the FE shots, but he's comparing it to the best 35mm option that is on the Sony system. I'm keeping my pre-order (and I have an RX1R II).

Sky crapper, . It's a UPS truck...


Chad is a great photographer and I love his images. (Check out the samples from his CV 40/1.2 review when you have a chance)

I think he meant that both lenses are capable of similar sharpness and "blur". To me the main difference is the smoothness in the transition zone. The FE seems to have stronger SA correction and that affects rendering. (it's a bit harsh and higher in contrast, especially at mid-distance).
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:31 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.25 #7Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wroteYou have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.


As I said I think that is possible for the first pair of images, but I don't see how that is possible for the third pair of images. The trees are very distant and stick above the roof quite a bit in one shot and are just gone in the other. Doesn't make sense to me.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:39 PM
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.25 #8Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Looking at the stronger sources of light, like the reflections in the fish scales or people left of the scooter or the leaves in the left-centre background, makes it pretty clear which is which IMHO. Batis 40 does the same with those distinct "light circles".
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:40 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.25 #9Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.


not for bokeh rendition, and at close distance, one is a little bit better and typical shooting distance, seems to be a wash.

bad bokeh will show up in small images, bigger images amplify it more. There is no mistaking a Helios lens, and just recently, phillip reeve had a comparison on the Sigma 35 f1.2 vs 35 1.4 vs 40 1.4, and it was plain as day, I could see it on my phone.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:44 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #10Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
j4nu wrote:
Looking at the stronger sources of light, like the reflections in the fish scales or people left of the scooter or the leaves in the left-centre background, makes it pretty clear which is which IMHO. Batis 40 does the same with those distinct "light circles".


So finally the Batis 40 has a strong competitor...

Edited on Aug 13, 2019 at 01:57 PM · View previous versions
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:52 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #11Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
smpetty wroteAm I the only one who likes his images? I see that the bokeh is a bit busier on the FE shots, but he's comparing it to the best 35mm option that is on the Sony system. I'm keeping my pre-order (and I have an RX1R II).

Sky crapper, . It's a UPS truck...
Chad is a great photographer and I love his images. (Check out the samples from his CV 40/1.2 review when you have a chance)

I think he meant that both lenses are capable of similar sharpness and "blur". To me the main difference is the smoothness in the transition zone. The FE seems to have stronger SA correction and that affects rendering. (it's a bit harsh and higher in contrast, especially at mid-distance).


So how would the Sigma 45mm compare here.... We definitely need some more pics in the Sigma review thread
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:56 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #12Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wroteNot really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.
As I said I think that is possible for the first pair of images, but I don't see how that is possible for the third pair of images. The trees are very distant and stick above the roof quite a bit in one shot and are just gone in the other. Doesn't make sense to me.


I think it's more of the same on the third sample as well. The main culprit is the different FOV between them. (The Sonnar 35 is wider)
There is also some rotation and alignment issues between shots.

The new FE 35/1.8 seems slightly sharper and higher in contrast compared to RX1RII samples but I don't know which aperture were used and don't have access to 1:1 crops nor full size files.

I really appreciate that Chad posted some many comparison samples.




Difference is FOV, alignment and rotation is tricking the eyes...(Images from Chad Wadsworth's review)

Aug 13, 2019 at 02:01 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #13Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
vdo1 wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
smpetty wroteAm I the only one who likes his images? I see that the bokeh is a bit busier on the FE shots, but he's comparing it to the best 35mm option that is on the Sony system. I'm keeping my pre-order (and I have an RX1R II).

Sky crapper, . It's a UPS truck...
Chad is a great photographer and I love his images. (Check out the samples from his CV 40/1.2 review when you have a chance)

I think he meant that both lenses are capable of similar sharpness and "blur". To me the main difference is the smoothness in the transition zone. The FE seems to have stronger SA correction and that affects rendering. (it's a bit harsh and higher in contrast, especially at mid-distance).
So how would the Sigma 45mm compare here.... We definitely need some more pics in the Sigma review thread


I know! I started testing the CV 75/1.5 Nokton and neglected the Sigma 45/2.8.
Aug 13, 2019 at 02:07 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.25 #14Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wroteI don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.
As I said I think that is possible for the first pair of images, but I don't see how that is possible for the third pair of images. The trees are very distant and stick above the roof quite a bit in one shot and are just gone in the other. Doesn't make sense to me.
I think it's more of the same on the third sample as well. The main culprit is the different FOV between them. (The Sonnar 35 is wider)
There is also some rotation and alignment issues between shots.

The new FE 35/1.8 seems slightly sharper and higher in contrast compared to RX1RII samples but I don't know which aperture were used and don't have access to 1:1 crops nor full size files.

I really appreciate that Chad posted some many comparison samples.


Now I see it. These shots show quite clearly how the field of view is more different between these lenses than I would have expected, but I have never shot with the RX1. It is a substantially wider lens and on that third pair he must have taken a step forward to compensate and equalizes the parts of the image closer to the camera and that means you loose sight of those trees having a very different perspective on what is further away from the camera.
Aug 13, 2019 at 02:18 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.25 #15Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wroteYou can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.
As I said I think that is possible for the first pair of images, but I don't see how that is possible for the third pair of images. The trees are very distant and stick above the roof quite a bit in one shot and are just gone in the other. Doesn't make sense to me.
I think it's more of the same on the third sample as well. The main culprit is the different FOV between them. (The Sonnar 35 is wider)
There is also some rotation and alignment issues between shots.

The new FE 35/1.8 seems slightly sharper and higher in contrast compared to RX1RII samples but I don't know which aperture were used and don't have access to 1:1 crops nor full size files.

I really appreciate that Chad posted some many comparison samples.
Now I see it. These shots show quite clearly how the field of view is more different between these lenses than I would have expected, but I have never shot with the RX1. It is a substantially wider lens and on that third pair he must have taken a step forward to compensate and equalizes the parts of the image closer to the camera and that means you loose sight of those trees having a very different perspective on what is further away from the camera.


Yes, it's the same with the RX1R II vs FE 35/2.8. The latter has noticeable narrower FOV. The Sonnar 35/2 is closer to 32mm than 35mm.
Aug 13, 2019 at 03:39 PM
KarmaKramer
Offline
Details
p.25 #16Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Hopefully most will resist this “half assed” creation & force Sony to make a 35GM like the 24/1.4.
Aug 13, 2019 at 03:45 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #17Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
KarmaKramer wrote:
Hopefully most will resist this “half assed” creation & force Sony to make a 35GM like the 24/1.4.


Who cares, Sigma already has a 1.2 for those interested in shallow DOF.
Aug 13, 2019 at 04:50 PM
mudlake
Offline
Details
p.25 #18Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
It’s still too early to make serious judgements, but I sure wish they would have made a 35/2 with some special glass. I don’t know about the photographer population in general, but Sony could have sold a ton of 35mm lenses to FM members who wanted a sonnar 35 equivalent. The chanting has been loud and boisterous for years. Sony had a soft pitch and instead of hitting an easy home run chose to bunt. Well...maybe it’s not too early for serious judgment. 🙂
Aug 13, 2019 at 04:59 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.25 #19Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Hey guys.... fresh review, lots of pics:

https://www.mobile01.com/topicdetail.php?f=254&t=5869765

(copy and paste the link to your browser to make it work)
Aug 13, 2019 at 05:29 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.25 #20Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wroteWhat happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
On his first sample, the images are just not aligned and there is a slight rotation between shots. The Sonnar 35/2 is also wider in FOV compared to the new FE.
It does look odd that the tree foliage is not there for both images but it's due to the slight different FOV, alignment and rotation.
As I said I think that is possible for the first pair of images, but I don't see how that is possible for the third pair of images. The trees are very distant and stick above the roof quite a bit in one shot and are just gone in the other. Doesn't make sense to me.
I think it's more of the same on the third sample as well. The main culprit is the different FOV between them. (The Sonnar 35 is wider)
There is also some rotation and alignment issues between shots.

The new FE 35/1.8 seems slightly sharper and higher in contrast compared to RX1RII samples but I don't know which aperture were used and don't have access to 1:1 crops nor full size files.

I really appreciate that Chad posted some many comparison samples.
Now I see it. These shots show quite clearly how the field of view is more different between these lenses than I would have expected, but I have never shot with the RX1. It is a substantially wider lens and on that third pair he must have taken a step forward to compensate and equalizes the parts of the image closer to the camera and that means you loose sight of those trees having a very different perspective on what is further away from the camera.
Yes, it's the same with the RX1R II vs FE 35/2.8. The latter has noticeable narrower FOV. The Sonnar 35/2 is closer to 32mm than 35mm.


Interestingly, the Pentax 31 Ltd is slightly narrower than listed, and extremely similar to the wider than listed RX1. Enjoying both 28 and 35mm, I found these two lenses to be my absolute favorite FL. The difference is slight but very noticeable and I wish more manufactures would cater to this. Reminds me of the way 40mm is in vogue and splits the more traditional FL’s of 35 and 50.
Aug 13, 2019 at 06:00 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister