fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2019 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2019Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)

  
 
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #1Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
vdo1 wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wroteI agree, it won't be close to the Sonnar in the RX1 series of cameras. To me the bokeh reminds me of the Loxia 35 and the Zeiss Planar 50 f/1.4 lenses. Wide open it looks to have a bit of over corrected spherical aberrations, but stopped down and sometimes at close distances it can be pretty good. Some people really like the bokeh from those two lenses and I kind of like the bokeh from them stopped down to f/4 or narrower, but I am not a fan of the bokeh at wider apertures.

The lens won't have onion rings of course because it doesn't have any aspherical elements.
I thought the FE 35/1.8 has one aspherical element towards the rear. I will double check that.
Yeah, Fred you are right. I had misremembered. I was disappointed that it didn't have any ED or APD elements, but it does have one aspherical element at the back.
Yes, the FE 28/2 has more special glass but it's wider...Complete different optical designs.
Yeah, it is a completely different design from the FE 28 f/2, but I don't think Sony did a very good job here competing with Nikon and Canon. All three lenses (the Sony, Nikon, & Canon 35 f/1.8's) are 11 element 9 group designs. The similarly priced Nikon has 3 aspherical and 2 ED elements and seems to out perform the Sony lens by a fair bit (although personally I don't like the bokeh of either lens very much, but the Nikon has much better control of CA and is probably a bit sharper). The Canon is $300 less expensive, has a similar one aspherical element in its design, but focuses much closer down to .17m offering 1:2 magnification. It seems to be at least as sharp as the Sony as well. The Sony doesn't look very good with its mediocre CA control and bokeh that can best be described as distinctive. One clear positive for the Sony is that it is the smallest and weighs the least, but I can't help but be a bit disappointed in Sony's effort with this lens.
Dpreview just posted a review of the Nikon one where you can comparatively pixel peep it against Sony 1.8 and 1.4, and a Canon 1.4. Sony 1.4 is the worst of the bunch (soft and with high CA). The Nikon is not the sharpest - that is the Sony 1.8. Unfortunately the Sony 1.8 has high CA too. The most balanced is the Canon.

I guess Sony has to take this CA thing a little bit more seriously. Their non G(M) lenses have copious amounts of LoCA and stuff.


And if you look at the corners and edges at f/5.6 and f/8 the FE 35 f/1.8 does not look very good. Clearly not as sharp as the others in the edges and corners, and if you look at the corrugated roof in the lower mid right the CA does not even go away at f/4 and the Nikon clearly is way way better not even showing CA at f/1.8. The Nikon is far from perfect and especially the bokeh for my tastes is not as good as it should be, but it has very nice CA control and good across the frame sharpness stopped down. My take is neither the Nikon nor the FE 35 f/1.8 look all that good for portraits, but the Nikon could make a nice landscape lens and be pressed into service for portraits if you can avoid problems in the bokeh. The Canon lens is this test is the EF 35 f/1.4L II. I am interested in how the new Canon mirrorless lens performs as well.
Aug 12, 2019 at 05:58 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #2Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
There will always be compromises in price, size, rendering, aberration control and resolution/contrast.

For me personally, I like what Sigma did with their new 45/2.8 Contemporary. It's under-corrected for SA and highly corrected for CA. Resolution and contrast won't win any awards but but that's my prefered compromise.

I'd much prefer a Sigma 35/2 Contemporary with the the same 45/2.8 characteristics instead of sharper lenses capable of more blur in exchange for ugly rendering and high color error.
Aug 12, 2019 at 06:33 PM
frezeiss
Offline
Details
p.24 #3Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
I think Sony has done a good job in this lens, since this and the 55/1.8 are more of an"entry level" lens so compromising colour errors for sharpness make sense. Only a few people at Dpreview and FM that have worries for CA.

What I see in a lens in order of significance is rendering, sharpness, colours and CA/LoCA last. I do agree that the new Sigma 45/2.8 looks great and be tempted if I dont already own a dozen of lenses in the 35-50mm space.
Aug 12, 2019 at 10:54 PM
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #4Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
The 55/1.8 was never a Sony "entry level" lens In fact, it is a Zeiss lens made for the Sony system. It was $999 on its introduction in 2014. At that time (and maybe still is) it was the most expensive 50'ish/1.8 AF lens ever made for FF.
Aug 12, 2019 at 11:10 PM
pdmphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #5Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Fred Miranda wroteI thought the FE 35/1.8 has one aspherical element towards the rear. I will double check that.
Yeah, Fred you are right. I had misremembered. I was disappointed that it didn't have any ED or APD elements, but it does have one aspherical element at the back.
Yes, the FE 28/2 has more special glass but it's wider...Complete different optical designs.
Yeah, it is a completely different design from the FE 28 f/2, but I don't think Sony did a very good job here competing with Nikon and Canon. All three lenses (the Sony, Nikon, & Canon 35 f/1.8's) are 11 element 9 group designs. The similarly priced Nikon has 3 aspherical and 2 ED elements and seems to out perform the Sony lens by a fair bit (although personally I don't like the bokeh of either lens very much, but the Nikon has much better control of CA and is probably a bit sharper). The Canon is $300 less expensive, has a similar one aspherical element in its design, but focuses much closer down to .17m offering 1:2 magnification. It seems to be at least as sharp as the Sony as well. The Sony doesn't look very good with its mediocre CA control and bokeh that can best be described as distinctive. One clear positive for the Sony is that it is the smallest and weighs the least, but I can't help but be a bit disappointed in Sony's effort with this lens.
Dpreview just posted a review of the Nikon one where you can comparatively pixel peep it against Sony 1.8 and 1.4, and a Canon 1.4. Sony 1.4 is the worst of the bunch (soft and with high CA). The Nikon is not the sharpest - that is the Sony 1.8. Unfortunately the Sony 1.8 has high CA too. The most balanced is the Canon.

I guess Sony has to take this CA thing a little bit more seriously. Their non G(M) lenses have copious amounts of LoCA and stuff.
And if you look at the corners and edges at f/5.6 and f/8 the FE 35 f/1.8 does not look very good. Clearly not as sharp as the others in the edges and corners, and if you look at the corrugated roof in the lower mid right the CA does not even go away at f/4 and the Nikon clearly is way way better not even showing CA at f/1.8. The Nikon is far from perfect and especially the bokeh for my tastes is not as good as it should be, but it has very nice CA control and
...Show more →

My main issues with all the Sony non G/GM lenses are corner sharpness and color issues. The Sony 35/1.8 doesn't look to be any different.
Aug 12, 2019 at 11:15 PM
MayaTlab
Offline
Details
p.24 #6Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
I like what Sigma did with their new 45/2.8 Contemporary. It's under-corrected for SA and highly corrected for CA.


And it looks decently well corrected for field dependent aberrations as well. The Sony's 35 1.8 bokeh suffers not just from CA but also astigmatism (?) as well I believe.
Aug 13, 2019 at 12:25 AM
Jochenb
Offline
Details
p.24 #7Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
It must be a joke that someone thinks this lens is comparable to the RX1's 35/2 Sonnar. I've used both the RX1 and RX1RII for years and it renders much smoother than this harsh looking FE 35/1.8.

Aug 13, 2019 at 01:12 AM
frezeiss
Offline
Details
p.24 #8Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
pdmphoto wrote:
The 55/1.8 was never a Sony "entry level" lens In fact, it is a Zeiss lens made for the Sony system. It was $999 on its introduction in 2014. At that time (and maybe still is) it was the most expensive 50'ish/1.8 AF lens ever made for FF.


Its a bit tongue in cheek. I was thinking "entry level" due to the 1.8 aperture vs the Zony 50/1.4.

Yes, it was an expensive entry level 55 mm lens when Sony has no mirroless peers back then, like the Zony 35/2.8

Aug 13, 2019 at 01:14 AM
Donbioh
Offline
Details
p.24 #9Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
My local dealer said, this week the Sony 35/1.8 will be in stock. I preorder it...
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:53 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.24 #10Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
vdo1 wrote:
Ah, copy variation.... this is something else that Sony (not dpreview) has to address. If dpreview is most likely to get a dud, then I am also going to most likely get a dud. If it takes to buy and return 5-6 lenses to get a decent one, then I’ll just stay away from that particular model. Asking dpreview to cherry pick from 6 lenses while its readers are going to get the 5 ones left is a little bit disingenuous, isn’t it?


You are free to call me disingenous, if you please. I'm honestly really not into name calling. This isn't the dpreview forum after all. What I was trying to say was that we will never have a true evaluation of any given lens without keeping copy variation in mind. It just helps to get a better overall picture. I get that the average reviewer can't do it, hence Roger's tests are so extremely helpful. I merely dared to point out this fact.

There is no secret that several of the early e-mount lenses have been effected by copy variation, most notably the 35 1.4, but there seems to be comparatively little copy variation in recent releases. In other words, Sony has already addressed this issue. The problem is that 1) seeing all the complaints about QC around here, makes it seem as if this is a Sony exclusive issue, when it's not (early issues with the Nikon 200-500 and 300 PF's image stabilization, the oilspills on D600, the 7D2's AF issues, etc.) and 2) many seem to believe it's easy to increase the % of near perfect copies, when (according to Roger) it's unfortunately not.
Aug 13, 2019 at 05:14 AM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.24 #11Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
I saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/

Aug 13, 2019 at 10:29 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #12Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
nandadevieast wrote:
I saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/



You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Aug 13, 2019 at 12:03 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.24 #13Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.


Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
Aug 13, 2019 at 12:35 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #14Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
vdo1 wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.


I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
Aug 13, 2019 at 12:44 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.24 #15Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Steve Spencer wrote:
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.


You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/

Aug 13, 2019 at 12:49 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.24 #16Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
vdo1 wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
vdo1 wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
nandadevieast wroteI saw Chad’s review. There is an update today where he has posted exact same images taken with RX1 Sonnar and the new 35, without saying which is which.

How many of you can figure this. I find them similar to be honest

https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/
You have to keep in mind these are extremely small (maybe 200 X 300 pixel) images. Such downsizing hides many flaws, but I still think I can see differences in a number of images, but not all of them certainly.
Not really, if you have Firefox, you can right click on them, select View Image, then zoom.

The Vespa one for example is 2800 × 1867. Once there, you'll notice quite some differences, the most easily to notice being CA.

The only question here is whether you have previous experience with any of the lenses. If you don't, you will still be able to say which is the "better" image, but won't be able to decide whether it's the RX or the FE.
I don't have Firefox so I am stuck with the really small images. I would guess that it is a lot easier with images the size you are describing. Even at the small sizes I can see CA differences in a number of images.
You can try to save the images on your local disk (right click - save image - they should be saving at full size) and then inspect them separately. More cumbersome but should work.

Let me embed a pair of them here to see if it can be viewed at high res:

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-554.jpg

https://chadwadsworth.files.wordpress.com/2019/08/rx1-vs-fe-445.jpg

Images by Chad Wadsworth, https://chadwadsworth.com/2019/08/08/whip-smart-sonys-new-fe-35mm-f-1-8-is-the-lens-rx1-fans-have-been-waiting-for/



I did figure out how to open them in a new window, but there is some weird editing going on in these shots. Look at the lower left corner of the first two shots. What happened to the trees that were there in the first shot in the second. I thought that might have just been a slightly different angle of view. But then look at the third pair of images. The trees that extend above the roof on the first shot a third of the way to right aren't there in the second shot and there is no way that should have happened.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:03 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.24 #17Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Same aperture for both above?
Most of the his samples were at close distance where the FE will look ok.
Rendering between the two will be more distinctive at mid-distance where the transition zone blends with the OOF background.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:06 PM
nehemiahphoto
Offline
Details
p.24 #18Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
The bottom photo taken with the FE is worse bokeh wise—look at the sky crapper in the back right or the USPS truck lettering on the left. The FE photo USPS truck lettering has slight Nissen bokeh—harsher and doubled edged. Looks crappy. My 31 Ltd will do this, and my 35 Lux ASPH had this even worse.

Now look at that sky scrapper and USPS truck on rx1. Looks lovely.

Edited on Aug 13, 2019 at 01:21 PM · View previous versions
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:17 PM
vdo1
Offline
Details
p.24 #19Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Same aperture for both above?
Most of the his samples were at close distance where the FE will look ok.
Rendering between the two will be more distinctive at mid-distance where the transition zone blends with the OOF background.


Not sure but something is off. The turn light on the Vespa seems soo much more OOF in the first pic. Second pic has some double vision and weirdo bokeh balls, if it's true that the FE has the worse bokeh, then that's the one.
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:20 PM
nandadevieast
Offline
Details
p.24 #20Now in Stock: Sony FE 35mm f/1.8 ($748)
What if this guy comes back and tells you all the images were shot on FE
Aug 13, 2019 at 01:20 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister