Sigma ART 135/1.8 $1400; 82mm filter add $30 over 67mm; MC-11 add $250. Up to $1680, and you sign on to deal with dodgy firmware updates forever, don't forget to cost out your hourly rates doing that each year, the June one apparently caused trouble. Price difference over life of ownership (say 2-5 years), really a worry? It's chickenfeed.
philip_pj wrote:
Sigma ART 135/1.8 $1400; 82mm filter add $30 over 67mm; MC-11 add $250. Up to $1680, and you sign on to deal with dodgy firmware updates forever, don't forget to cost out your hourly rates doing that each year, the June one apparently caused trouble. Price difference over life of ownership (say 2-5 years), really a worry? It's chickenfeed.
First of all, a filter is NOT required nor everyone uses one so no need to throw it in automatically.
If I were to use your reasoning then lets add a 2 year protection plan from B&H and that is $164.99 for the Sigma and $235.99 for the Batis so a BIG difference there. But why assume people is adding stuff to the purchase just to manipulate the price difference one way or the other?
Second just because you get the MC-11 does not mean you are ONLY getting it for the one lens..and if you do and your firmware is working great then why bother upgrading?
I personally use it with the Metabones V and firmware 57 and it performs fantastic plus is not for one lens so I cannot add its cost just to the Sigma.
Hourly rates because of time doing firmware and issues..seriously now...Guess when someone wants to justify something so bad it does not matter how much things need to be stretched to reach the goal.
What is a fact is...the Batis is slower and from Guy's test, the Sigma is as sharp if not sharper, has better bokeh and more subject isolation as expected from a 1.8 vs 2.8 lens. On the Batis side you have faster AF and a smaller lens (for people that mind about size..not me).
So while I prefer to avoid conflicts like this because in the end, we all need to find the tool that fits our personal requirements, it does bother me when things are manipulated so much trying to prove a point.
If you prefer the Batis..great for you..no need to twist reality
With very sweet bokeh the price would be very okay for me - as i like Zeiss look & rendering... Anyway i like since 3 years rendering of my Sigma Art 18-35mm F1.8 too.
Personally for me the 135mm range is for events and portraits where the Sigma is king. I also shoot landscapes at times in this range where the 70-200 f4 is a much better match.
I like the size of the Batis, but it's pricing us totally out of whack.
Honestly the 70-200 in any flavor is not going to come close at 2.8 or F4. Its not just a event or portrait either. I love this focal length for landscapes as well. I think too many hang ups because of the price. I got over that after two days of owning it. The Sigma is wonderful but it's not native and Sigma has yet to fix it for the A9. Until they get that damn MC-11 working correctly it's a no go for A9 users. Still no updates. So in hindsight glad I returned it .
I updated the FW of my MC-11 to the latest version and the combo Sigma 135mm lens and MC-11 works just fine on my A7r II. Too bad, Guy sold his Sigma lens already and cannot try out that lens on the updated FW on his A9. Just recently, an FMer posted that his Sigma 135mm lens works on his A9; I believe after the last FW update of the MC-11. He also posted an image of a flying helicopter. Frankly, I don't remember who that was or which thread his findings were posted at.
Currently, I venture to say that the A9 is not widely used yet and that there are significantly more A7r II users out there. Plus, Sony users make up only a fairly small percentage. There are still a lot of photographers that use Canon and Nikon. There is a big world out there, in other words. So, I don't think that Sigma will loose sleep over this one. With that said though, I agree that they need to look into this matter if it is a real issue and that the MC-11 doesn't work well with several Sigma lenses in Canon mount, even if it is limited only to the A9. That it doesn't work well or only sporadically with Canon branded lenses, well, that's not their problem .
The size and weight won me over. I only shoot primes, so size matters since I'll typically carry around 3-5 lenses with me. I'm also a big fan of the Zeiss color/contrast (it's why I chose the Batis 85 over the 85 GM), and I'm guessing that the Sony 135 probably won't be a Zony. And, while f/2 would have been nice, the DOF is still pretty shallow at f/2.8 on a 135.
I haven't had time to take many pics, aside for the portrait below. Lighting wasn't great and bokeh isn't very interesting in this shot, but I haven't seen all that many portraits posted with this lens, so I thought I'd post it nonetheless.
One of the things I was curious about was how the Batis 85 in crop mode compared to the 135, so I've attached that comparison as well. DOF seems almost identical, which I guess is what you'd expect.
Of late, Zeiss are big on color consistency across lenses in their ranges, and Mr T, it looks like a strong family resemblance here. Sony will probably have to produce a GM to compete with these fabulous 135mm lenses out there all of a sudden - the bar is now set very high.
It's obviously personal but f2.8 separation at 135mm is the last thing many will worry about, a huge number of portraits (even at much shorter FLs) are shot stopped down a little/lot in any case - not every client prefers your fast lens's WO bokeh ahead of a more natural drawing of the subject.
What has happened to most Sony users will go on happening - they slowly drift from Canon, Sigma et al to 'these native lenses are not half bad', whether it be the slow burn appeal of Zeiss or the impact of the GM lenses and wide zooms (in particular). Each native lens targets the Sony sensors and color processing engine, no small thing.
The size and weight won me over. I only shoot primes, so size matters since I'll typically carry around 3-5 lenses with me. I'm also a big fan of the Zeiss color/contrast (it's why I chose the Batis 85 over the 85 GM), and I'm guessing that the Sony 135 probably won't be a Zony. And, while f/2 would have been nice, the DOF is still pretty shallow at f/2.8 on a 135.
I haven't had time to take many pics, aside for the portrait below. Lighting wasn't great and bokeh isn't very interesting in this shot, but I haven't seen all that many portraits posted with this lens, so I thought I'd post it nonetheless.
One of the things I was curious about was how the Batis 85 in crop mode compared to the 135, so I've attached that comparison as well. DOF seems almost identical, which I guess is what you'd expect. ...Show more →
Thanks for this comparison. I decided against the Batis 135 in favour of cropping my Batis 85 and this proves that's an equally valid solution if you don't need the full resolution.
I thought about that as well, but figured that the 135 can be cropped down to 200mm. So part of why I bought it is because it's now, effectively, my 135-200mm zoom.
MrTMan wrote:
I thought about that as well, but figured that the 135 can be cropped down to 200mm. So part of why I bought it is because it's now, effectively, my 135-200mm zoom.
Yea- I'm going through the same deliberation. With MP counts going up and up, cropping from 135-200 is reasonable, especially as I'll be using the lens in non-critical situations for indoors sports shots of my daughter etc. And really, in those situations a small black lens stands out less than a giant white one.
The other thing is cost...with some patience I'm pretty sure I can get a Batis 135 AND an FE 70-200 f/4 (for when I really need the zoom) used for only a few hundred more than a used FE 70-200 2.8.
...but on the other hand a 70-200 2.8 is pretty usable in a lot of situations. Need more time to decide.
philip_pj wrote:
It's obviously personal but f2.8 separation at 135mm is the last thing many will worry about, a huge number of portraits (even at much shorter FLs) are shot stopped down a little/lot in any case - not every client prefers your fast lens's WO bokeh ahead of a more natural drawing of the subject.
.
The nice thing with a 1.8 lens is you have the ability to stop it down to 2.8 or 4, but a 2.8 lens cannot be opened up anymore. The 1,8 lens just gives you more flexibility for subject isolation and more room to work in dim light, of course at the expense of weight.
virtualrain wrote: MrTMan wroteAlright, I bought the Batis 135.
The size and weight won me over. I only shoot primes, so size matters since I'll typically carry around 3-5 lenses with me. I'm also a big fan of the Zeiss color/contrast (it's why I chose the Batis 85 over the 85 GM), and I'm guessing that the Sony 135 probably won't be a Zony. And, while f/2 would have been nice, the DOF is still pretty shallow at f/2.8 on a 135.
I haven't had time to take many pics, aside for the portrait below. Lighting wasn't great and bokeh isn't very interesting in this shot, but I haven't seen all that many portraits posted with this lens, so I thought I'd post it nonetheless.
One of the things I was curious about was how the Batis 85 in crop mode compared to the 135, so I've attached that comparison as well. DOF seems almost identical, which I guess is what you'd expect.Thanks for this comparison. I decided against the Batis 135 in favour of cropping my Batis 85 and this proves that's an equally valid solution if you don't need the full resolution.
It's also one of the reasons why I didn't get the Batis 135. I prefer the bokeh and overall rendering of the 85/1.4 GM in crop mode at 135mm for portraits. Also bokeh balls are perfectly rounded to the edges in crop mode. Yes, it's only 18MP but it's enough for casual portraits. If Sony releases a 135/1.8 GM with similar rendering, I would be all over it.
BTW: I also have the Batis 85/1.8 and this it's a completely different lens. The look is so distinctive with very high micro-contrast and saturated colors. I mainly use it for travel and it's sharp to the edges even wide open.
Apologies for the paradigm-naivete; additional apologies for slight veer from designated topic.
Is there a difference between:
The file you would get from a shot using 85GM (or any other FF lens) on a FF body in the "normal"(on A9: APS-C/Super 35 set to "off") way, then cropping away the "edges" of the raw file in LR/C1 to match the field coverage as if the FF sensor had been an APS-C-size;
and
The file from otherwise same shot—same scene, same exposure triangle, same FF body, same lens—with the in-camera menu choice of APS-C/Super 35 set to "on"?
Or, "Are there relevant differences between files from the photographer's cropping the photo in the camera and from cropping it in the LR/C1 stage? Irrelevant ones?"
jacquesvroom wrote:
Apologies for the naivete; additional apologies for slight veer from designated topic.
Is there a difference between:
The file you would get from a shot using 85GM (or any other FF lens) on a FF body in the "normal"(on A9: APS-C/Super 35 set to "off") way, then cropping away the "edges" of the raw file in LR/C1 to match the field coverage as if the FF sensor had been an APS-C-size;
and
The file from otherwise same shot—same scene, same exposure triangle, same FF body, same lens—with the in-camera menu choice of APS-C/Super 35 set to "on"?
Or, "Are there relevant differences between files from the photographer's cropping the photo in the camera and from cropping it in the LR/C1 stage? Irrelevant ones?"
There's no difference between cropping in camera vs in post other than the obvious differences that in-camera you can potentially compose better (as you can clearly see the final result at the time) and have a ready JPEG right out of the camera while in post you have the advantage of cropping however much and wherever you want. I crop in post.
Fred Miranda wrote: virtualrain wroteMrTMan wroteAlright, I bought the Batis 135.
The size and weight won me over. I only shoot primes, so size matters since I'll typically carry around 3-5 lenses with me. I'm also a big fan of the Zeiss color/contrast (it's why I chose the Batis 85 over the 85 GM), and I'm guessing that the Sony 135 probably won't be a Zony. And, while f/2 would have been nice, the DOF is still pretty shallow at f/2.8 on a 135.
I haven't had time to take many pics, aside for the portrait below. Lighting wasn't great and bokeh isn't very interesting in this shot, but I haven't seen all that many portraits posted with this lens, so I thought I'd post it nonetheless.
One of the things I was curious about was how the Batis 85 in crop mode compared to the 135, so I've attached that comparison as well. DOF seems almost identical, which I guess is what you'd expect.Thanks for this comparison. I decided against the Batis 135 in favour of cropping my Batis 85 and this proves that's an equally valid solution if you don't need the full resolution.It's also one of the reasons why I didn't get the Batis 135. I prefer the bokeh and overall rendering of the 85/1.4 GM in crop mode at 135mm for portraits. Also bokeh balls are perfectly rounded to the edges in crop mode. Yes, it's only 18MP but it's enough for casual portraits. If Sony releases a 135/1.8 GM with similar rendering, I would be all over it.
BTW: I also have the Batis 85/1.8 and this it's a completely different lens. The look is so distinctive with very high micro-contrast and saturated colors. I mainly use it for travel and it's sharp to the edges even wide open....Show more →
Good to read someone else see the Batis 85 distinction too! I own and use both Batis 85 and GM 85 and agree with your description of both. Each with their own advantage. Of the two, the Batis is of course my travel 85. Took me some time to come to grips with the F2.8 on the Batis. I always wanted F2 for this lens, but never expected it would come about. However, once I started using the Batis @ 2.8, I have to say I quickly got over missing F2 for this FL, or maybe not missing F1.8 or F2 as much as I thought I would.
chez wrote: philip_pj wroteIt's obviously personal but f2.8 separation at 135mm is the last thing many will worry about, a huge number of portraits (even at much shorter FLs) are shot stopped down a little/lot in any case - not every client prefers your fast lens's WO bokeh ahead of a more natural drawing of the subject.
.The nice thing with a 1.8 lens is you have the ability to stop it down to 2.8 or 4, but a 2.8 lens cannot be opened up anymore. The 1,8 lens just gives you more flexibility for subject isolation and more room to work in dim light, of course at the expense of weight.
Can't argue the reality or F1.8, F2 and F2.8 and to my eyes the Sigma 135 is stunning at F1.8.
But like I wrote earlier I don't find myself missing F1.8 or F2 as much as I thought I would using the Batis 135 @ 2.8. Not sure if it's F2.8 at 135mm in general that I like, or the way the Batis does F2.8 at 135mm... je ne sais quoi ?