fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts

  
 
jacquesvroom
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
GM: Wonderful NY images. Couple of decades ago, I worked for several years at the Metropolitan Museum a bit north of that Essex House. Wasn't always so pretty to the naked eye! You should consider doing this professionally!
Jul 03, 2017 at 08:59 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
lol I'm going to see one of my all time favorites Irving Penn exhibit tommorrow.

Back in the day I went to School of Visual Arts in the late 70s. What a great school to attend

Oh I mailed your SD cards out today. Forgot to send you a PM
Jul 03, 2017 at 09:11 PM
VeniceBeach
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Any further thoughts on the 135 Batis?

I am about to go on a couple of trips (Disney World and Hawaii) with the A9. I'll take landscapes and family shots, including both candids and semi-posed images of the kids and short, handheld videos. The family shots are more important to me than the landscapes.

Typically, I travel with one or, at most, two lenses.

I will take the Sony 16-35/4 or the great Sony/Zeiss 35mm/1.4 FE as one lens.
And either the Sony 70-200/4 G or the Sony 85/1.4 GM or buy the 135/2.8 Batis and take it as a second lens.

And just the A9.

Weight is an issue for me.

Any thoughts on the Batis vs the Sony 70-200/4 G or even the 85/1.4 GM?

Thanks,

Bill
Jul 12, 2017 at 11:08 AM
scalanc2
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
This comparison would be interting as I well know the 70-200 4.0.
It sounds really strange to that there is no face to face comparison of Batis 135 and THE LENS (Sigma 135).
Is anyone informed of any?
Jul 12, 2017 at 11:45 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Bottom line . It's extremely sharp wide open. It's light and the size of a FE 35 1.4 without hoods. Fast Af like lightning, opens to focus closes to shoot. Superlative lens

Now the bad.
Hood is stupid. Will never use it
It's a 2.8
It's 300 too much
Bokeh can be swirly. Pick background with care

Eye AF makes this lens stand above anything else.

I'm keeping it. I forgot about the money and F stop
Jul 12, 2017 at 11:56 AM
gocolts
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
VeniceBeach wrote:
Any further thoughts on the 135 Batis?

I am about to go on a couple of trips (Disney World and Hawaii) with the A9. I'll take landscapes and family shots, including both candids and semi-posed images of the kids and short, handheld videos. The family shots are more important to me than the landscapes.

Typically, I travel with one or, at most, two lenses.

I will take the Sony 16-35/4 or the great Sony/Zeiss 35mm/1.4 FE as one lens.
And either the Sony 70-200/4 G or the Sony 85/1.4 GM or buy the 135/2.8 Batis and take it as a second
...Show more →

Funny you mention Disney World and Hawaii...you can look back through my posts and see pics I've posted in Maui (2 weeks every November) and we've been to Disney World twice already this year (long story...). Anyways, my A7R2 has been the perfect tool for both trips, I'm sure the A9 will be great as well. I would say that you could almost get by with only the 16-35 f/4 and a fast prime (28 or 55 depending on what you like to shoot) but then again I'm normally doing landscapes in Maui and close-proximity group shots in Disney World. Maybe you'll have more telephoto needs depending on what you plan to shoot. My Batis 18mm, 28mm f/2, 35 f/2.8, and either 24-70 f/4 or 55 1.8 are my combo for such trips. Yea- 4 lenses, but the primes weight next to nothing, and I prefer the 35 f/2.8 over the 28 f/2 assuming light allows it.

I would say that you need a fast prime....night time at both Disney and Hawaii can get dark....

Edited on Jul 12, 2017 at 12:27 PM · View previous versions
Jul 12, 2017 at 12:09 PM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I got mine from the FM buy/sell and am wowed by it. Agree that it is 300 too much (at least), but it's also amazing. For my needs the lighter weight of f/2.8 is ideal.
Jul 12, 2017 at 12:19 PM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.4 #8Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
darbo wrote:
I got mine from the FM buy/sell and am wowed by it. Agree that it is 300 too much (at least), but it's also amazing. For my needs the lighter weight of f/2.8 is ideal.


I saw that one and I'm glad you grabbed it before I did!
Jul 12, 2017 at 12:23 PM
nampramos
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
I really enjoy mine as well. Been using it a lot lately. Love the extra reach over the 85/90mm.
Jul 12, 2017 at 03:45 PM
VeniceBeach
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Wow. Nice replies!
Changing lenses has always been something I love to avoid.
Carrying more than one extra lens is not really possible and even then I am better off with just what is on the A9.

Maybe the 35/1.4 and the Batis 135/2.8 would be a great combo.

Would anyone here choose the 85/1.4 GM over the Batis 135 for nice shots of the kids and family?

-Bill
Jul 12, 2017 at 06:24 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
VeniceBeach wrote:
Wow. Nice replies!
Changing lenses has always been something I love to avoid.
Carrying more than one extra lens is not really possible and even then I am better off with just what is on the A9.

Maybe the 35/1.4 and the Batis 135/2.8 would be a great combo.

Would anyone here choose the 85/1.4 GM over the Batis 135 for nice shots of the kids and family?

-Bill


Sure I'd choose the 1.4/85 GM over the Batis 135 for the kids and family. In fact I'd choose the Batis 85 over either on simple ergo grounds for this purpose.

That's nothing against the Batis 135; I love it. It's just that 85 is a more appropriate focal length for a lot of work of this kind. A 135 is great to have, but for most people it'll be used much less often than 85.

Jul 12, 2017 at 07:21 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
What exactly do people mean when they say that a lens like this is, e.g. $300 too much?
(I'm not being a smartarse, I hope, It's just I suspect people mean many different things.)

One is : "I won't buy it would if it were 300 less". But you can't say that if you have bought it without discount.

Another is "The pricing formula is wrong: they would make more money if they priced it $300 less". Could be true, but how would any of us know what the sweet spot for volume versus margin is.

Another is "given the cost of manufacture, markup is too high". But first I doubt it's cheap to make (never have I seen a lens more densely packed with exotic stuff to make it great wide open). Second, that mistakes how pricing works -- see previous.

Another is "no-one would be rational to buy it given the peformance unless $300 less". But this ignores how much spare cash you have. For some it would be crazy to spend that kind of $$ on any lens, for (very few) others the cost is not something to worry about, and the rest - like most of us here - are somewhere in between.

Anther is like the above but insert "someone with my level of disposable income and desire for good optics" - but that's just a version of (1)

Maybe it's something like "My judgement is that given my available resources and desire for good glass, I oughtn't buy it unless it's $300 less, and if I have bought it it's because by GAS got the better of me"
Jul 12, 2017 at 07:30 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
Many lenses are based on speed. We have a very good Sigma 135 1.8 at 1400. A extra 600 dollars for a slower speed lens throws the balance off. I paid the 2 grand I'm not complaining but I feel given this it's about 300 too much given the market and competition.
That's all and the money does not mean that much too at the end of the day. I like the lens and end of day that's all that counts.
Jul 12, 2017 at 07:42 PM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
What exactly do people mean when they say that a lens like this is, e.g. $300 too much?
(I'm not being a smartarse, I hope, It's just I suspect people mean many different things.)

One is : "I won't buy it would if it were 300 less". But you can't say that if you have bought it without discount.

Another is "The pricing formula is wrong: they would make more money if they priced it $300 less". Could be true, but how would any of us know what the sweet spot for volume versus margin is.

Another is "given the cost of manufacture, markup
...Show more →

The 300 less thing is merely an appropriateness value judgment, that's all. I think the lens price would be more "appropriate" if it were priced in the 1500-1700 range. I don't think it is a contradiction to not be happy about how any particular thing is priced vs. having an ultimate willingness to buy the thing. If so, I suspect most everyone is a walking contradiction: willing to buy various things they regard as priced inappropriately high.

For my part, I was able to buy the lens in the range I am more comfortable by buying a mint used copy.
Jul 12, 2017 at 09:03 PM
chrisgibbs
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
GMPhotography wrote:
Many lenses are based on speed. We have a very good Sigma 135 1.8 at 1400. A extra 600 dollars for a slower speed lens throws the balance off. I paid the 2 grand I'm not complaining but I feel given this it's about 300 too much given the market and competition.
That's all and the money does not mean that much too at the end of the day. I like the lens and end of day that's all that counts.


I've never had a 70-200 that wows at 135mm, how would you say the Batis 135 and 70-200GM compare at 135mm?

Jul 12, 2017 at 11:47 PM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
darbo wrote:
DavidBM wroteWhat exactly do people mean when they say that a lens like this is, e.g. $300 too much?
(I'm not being a smartarse, I hope, It's just I suspect people mean many different things.)

One is : "I won't buy it would if it were 300 less". But you can't say that if you have bought it without discount.

Another is "The pricing formula is wrong: they would make more money if they priced it $300 less". Could be true, but how would any of us know what the sweet spot for volume versus margin is.

Another is "given the cost of manufacture, markup is too high". But first I doubt it's cheap to make (never have I seen a lens more densely packed with exotic stuff to make it great wide open). Second, that mistakes how pricing works -- see previous.

Another is "no-one would be rational to buy it given the peformance unless $300 less". But this ignores how much spare cash you have. For some it would be crazy to spend that kind of $$ on any lens, for (very few) others the cost is not something to worry about, and the rest - like most of us here - are somewhere in between.

Anther is like the above but insert "someone with my level of disposable income and desire for good optics" - but that's just a version of (1)

Maybe it's something like "My judgement is that given my available resources and desire for good glass, I oughtn't buy it unless it's $300 less, and if I have bought it it's because by GAS got the better of me"
The 300 less thing is merely an appropriateness value judgment, that's all. I think the lens price would be more "appropriate" if it were priced in the 1500-1700 range. I don't think it is a contradiction to not be happy about how any particular thing is priced vs. having an ultimate willingness to buy the thing. If so, I suspect most everyone is a walking contradiction: willing to buy various things they regard as priced inappropriately high.

For my part, I was able to buy the lens in the range I am more comfortable by buying a mint used copy.


I get that; my suggestions I suppose were for what "appropriate" might mean in the context of pricing.
Jul 13, 2017 at 01:47 AM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
DavidBM wrote:
Maybe it's something like "My judgement is that given my available resources and desire for good glass, I oughtn't buy it unless it's $300 less, and if I have bought it it's because by GAS got the better of me"

To me is about what I can get value/performance wise from other products. Like Guy mentioned, there is the fantastic Sigma 135mm art which is 1.8, razor sharp wide open, no CA and great bokeh, and is much cheaper. So one has to decide if paying more for a smaller lens that has native AF but is slower and the possibility of swirly bokeh (not a bad thing in itself since its a matter of preferences), is worth the extra $$$.
For me, I love my Sigma and with Metabones V firmware v57 I am in heaven but also at least with the MC-11 I know the performance is bad with A9 so that is another thing to consider.
So...for me if I were to put a value on the Batis, based on my needs and requirements for the lens, it would be even lower than the $300 mentioned.
All matter of points of view in the end.
Regards

Jul 17, 2017 at 09:19 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
GabrielPhoto wrote:
DavidBM wroteMaybe it's something like "My judgement is that given my available resources and desire for good glass, I oughtn't buy it unless it's $300 less, and if I have bought it it's because by GAS got the better of me"
To me is about what I can get value/performance wise from other products. Like Guy mentioned, there is the fantastic Sigma 135mm art which is 1.8, razor sharp wide open, no CA and great bokeh, and is much cheaper. So one has to decide if paying more for a smaller lens that has native AF but is slower and the possibility of swirly bokeh (not a bad thing in itself since its a matter of preferences), is worth the extra $$$.
For me, I love my Sigma and with Metabones V firmware v57 I am in heaven but also at least
...Show more →

Yep; that's the one and it of course makes complete sense: it's the price you are willing to pay given your resources, needs, and available alternatives. But I think many others meant something else, more "objective", and I was trying to figure out what it was.

Edited on Jul 17, 2017 at 07:14 PM · View previous versions
Jul 17, 2017 at 04:33 PM
gocolts
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
GMPhotography wrote:
Bottom line . It's extremely sharp wide open. It's light and the size of a FE 35 1.4 without hoods. Fast Af like lightning, opens to focus closes to shoot. Superlative lens

Now the bad.
Hood is stupid. Will never use it
It's a 2.8
It's 300 too much
Bokeh can be swirly. Pick background with care

Eye AF makes this lens stand above anything else.

I'm keeping it. I forgot about the money and F stop


$300 too much huh? I don't disagree. Well...eBay might be a friend for some as I'm seeing them new for $1,649 with free shipping. Don't know the seller but the reviews are good. Do a search for it and you can't miss it.

Jul 17, 2017 at 06:31 PM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Batis 135 F2.8 tests and thoughts
That's just a competitive price i think is fair but hell I dropped the 2 grand and don't regret it.
Jul 17, 2017 at 06:49 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister