chez, fast lenses made a lot of sense in low ambient conditions back when fast color film was ISO 400, and was best shot at ISO 250. We are just one stop down with the B135, and Sonys are excellent at ISO 1600-3200. For low light, it's now 'faster sensors enabling slower lenses'.
Zeiss used a lot of (costly) high end glass to get the same or better results compared with any faster lens at a common aperture. The lens speed is nothing new for Sony FE, all Batises and Loxias are f1.8-f2.8.
I shot a really big gig last week with both the Batis 135 and the 70-200 GM both in crop mode. We used the zoom more for the reach aka 300mm and the Batis at 202mm and ISO 2000. The results are great with very little noise both with the A9 and A7rII. We shot some at 2.8 and mostly F4 but on every occasion the Batis beat the zoom even at different focal lengths. Also Eye AF on every shot taken. We shot 23 thousand images in total. To be brutally honest I will not buy that 70-200 but will only rent for this gig I do twice a year. Give me a 200 2.8 anyday over the zoom. The Batis was simply outstanding on all levels. I was not happy with 2.8 and price at the start and I was very open about it being overpriced given the competition. After owning it I'll take back my comments.if you need fast AF and Eye AF there are no other options. Besides that you can't really put a price tag on IQ especially if your shooting for money.
philip_pj wrote:
chez, fast lenses made a lot of sense in low ambient conditions back when fast color film was ISO 400, and was best shot at ISO 250. We are just one stop down with the B135, and Sonys are excellent at ISO 1600-3200. For low light, it's now 'faster sensors enabling slower lenses'.
Zeiss used a lot of (costly) high end glass to get the same or better results compared with any faster lens at a common aperture. The lens speed is nothing new for Sony FE, all Batises and Loxias are f1.8-f2.8.
For me the 135 is a portrait and concert lens where at times i like the option of going to 1.8 for either the great subject isolation or the ability to shoot in very dim venues. I can live with extra weight when shooting under those conditions. Having a fast lens just opens up more opportunities and is more flexible. ISO 1600 is always better than ISO 3200 and when we are shooting with a lens costing $2,000 this is important. We analyze to death the sharpness of a lens but then we are ok throwing away that sharpness by needing to shoot at a high ISO?
chez wrote: philip_pj wrotechez, fast lenses made a lot of sense in low ambient conditions back when fast color film was ISO 400, and was best shot at ISO 250. We are just one stop down with the B135, and Sonys are excellent at ISO 1600-3200. For low light, it's now 'faster sensors enabling slower lenses'.
Zeiss used a lot of (costly) high end glass to get the same or better results compared with any faster lens at a common aperture. The lens speed is nothing new for Sony FE, all Batises and Loxias are f1.8-f2.8.
f1.8: 1; f2: 3; f2.4: 1; and f2.8: 3.For me the 135 is a portrait and concert lens where at times i like the option of going to 1.8 for either the great subject isolation or the ability to shoot in very dim venues. I can live with extra weight when shooting under those conditions. Having a fast lens just opens up more opportunities and is more flexible. ISO 1600 is always better than ISO 3200 and when we are shooting with a lens costing $2,000 this is important. We analyze to death the sharpness of a lens but then we are ok throwing away that sharpness by needing to shoot at a high ISO? ...Show more →
The tradeoff in f/2.8 vs. f/1.8 (or f/2) is size versus the subject isolation and low light ability. Many people shoot Sony at least partly because they appreciate the small size it allows and are willing to tradeoff the reduced subject isolation and low light ability for a smaller lens. Others will care more about subject isolation and low light ability than size. Neither is obviously the better choice. Different horse, etc.
I had the Sigma and now the Batis. Sure 1.8 is great but it's heavier, larger and does not even come close to AF speed or Eye AF but it is a great lens. I would love to have kept it But it's simply not native and that AF speed and accuracy not to mention AFC mode just won't work. The Batis has its negatives and speed is one of them but real world it's incredible right at 2.8 so no need to stop down which is a huge plus for it. Bokeh you just have to think a little harder on your choices of background for me that's a very easy task. Need to get to know the lens to adapt to that. Im reading a lot of talking here but very few actually buying either lens. Talk is cheap, sorry. I hate the armchair quarterbacking. Go spend the money on either. Frankly I thought about having both but decided I'll stick with the Batis it's so sharp wide open and focuses like a Cheetah . Outside all the speed weight and stuff like that. The Batis has far better color to it and micro contrast a Zeiss trait.
I do wish it was a F2 in a way but the higher ISO on both the A9 and A7rII are extremely good under 6400 and you can even use a noise program if you had to. I have not found that need yet. Pick your poison but go buy one of them.
Now in all honesty on paid gigs with real money on the line I would be very hard pressed to take a chance on a wide open lens to begin with. You miss your screwed. I have more confidence in doing that with the Batis it's deadly accurate wide open. I love the Sigmadont get me wrong but with money the deciding factor I'm going to stop it down. It's really just that simply. Sure maybe other work you will take that risk wide open and I would too but I'm not going to risk a high paying client like that. For a working Pro that's just not in the cards. You don't want to risk losing clients. I just blew up a wind mill shot to the highest resolution I can muster out of a A7rII shot last night for a client that I went 250 percent in raw processing the file. It's a 620 meg file. Luckily it's sharp as hell to begin with. I've been burned badly by this in the past with clients going way beyond the intended purpose when shooting it. So you really need to be careful about those risks. I know most will never run into this but I can only speak from a Pro seat on these matters and you may never run into this stuff but I have to let you know real world stuff outside the lab stuff. It's tough enough out here so you need to understand the pitfalls out here.
With the GM 16-35/2.8, GM 100-400 and G 12-24/4 shipping or about to ship, another Sony announcement can't be far off. Thus, I suppise that a native 135/1.8 and a a native 400mm can't be far away.
Or buy both! I started out with the Sigma and I am still enamored by that lens. According to Photozone, if this matters to anyone out there, it is the best lens they have ever tested. No, it is not a native FE lens in terms of AF. By the way, the most recent firmware improvement of both Metabones and Sigma MC-11 makes it close, really close even in AF-C. In this respect, the Metabones is better now since you can get the entire PDAF area for Eye-AF while that of MC-11 is still limited horizontally.
Yes, it is heavy and bulky but the results that it generates are something else. I like it better than the (sold) Zony 135mm f/1.8 in A-mount and (sold) Zeiss f/2 ZE APO in term of IQ and way, way better in terms of focusing speed compared to both, especially, the last one . All three lenses are big and heavy. Obviously, you cannot get away with certain physical requirements of having a fast lens of this focal length yet.
I would love to get the Batis 135mm where weight would be an issue but the price simply doesn't justify it....yet. And in the meantime, while biding my time, I will have to just put up with the Sigma .
Steve Spencer wrote:
The tradeoff in f/2.8 vs. f/1.8 (or f/2) is size versus the subject isolation and low light ability. Many people shoot Sony at least partly because they appreciate the small size it allows and are willing to tradeoff the reduced subject isolation and low light ability for a smaller lens. Others will care more about subject isolation and low light ability than size. Neither is obviously the better choice. Different horse, etc.
+1. Every lens is a tradeoff. Even an Otus has its tradeoffs (cost/size/lack of AF).
Unlike Guy, I'm not a pro, I mostly shoot pics of my family and the occasional landscape. I own the 35/1.4 and 50/1.4, so I can appreciate the tradeoff between weight and image quality and to some extent am willing to carry extra weight. But the Batis 135 weighs 1.4 pounds as it is -- do I really want a 2.5 pound lens like the Sigma if I plan to be taking it on vacation, family outings, etc.?
I love the fact that I now have a full set of primes (18/25/35/50/85/135) that can all fit in a relatively small bag like my Tenba Cooper Slim 13 (not that I would take them all out at the same time -- but hey, I could!)
Sony surprised us with the compact size and weight of the 16-35/2.8, so who knows, maybe they'll figure out a way to make a 135/2 GM at <2 lbs. But I don't think anyone really knows whether or not a 135 announcement is imminent, and I want to get out there and take pictures rather than keep waiting. I'm also a huge fan of Zeiss color/microcontrast, and Zeiss customer service & quality control, so those are other factors that swayed my decision.
All that said, I still have to actually do some shooting with this lens, so I can't yet speak to how much of an issue the f/2.8 is or isn't. But one thing I've already learned is that DOF is surprisingly shallow at f/2.8 on a 135mm.
GMPhotography wrote:
After owning it I'll take back my comments.if you need fast AF and Eye AF there are no other options. Besides that you can't really put a price tag on IQ especially if your shooting for money.
Steve Spencer wrote:
The tradeoff in f/2.8 vs. f/1.8 (or f/2) is size versus the subject isolation and low light ability. Many people shoot Sony at least partly because they appreciate the small size it allows and are willing to tradeoff the reduced subject isolation and low light ability for a smaller lens. Others will care more about subject isolation and low light ability than size. Neither is obviously the better choice. Different horse, etc.
Good stuff from Guy and Steve.
I've struggled to find much joy in using telephotos...they're usually too long or too heavy to carry them around along with other lenses. Even 70-200mm f/4s are too long (physical length of lens body and hood). So, for me, those go less-used and eventually get sold off. The Batis size/weight is perfect for me. Now I'm easily slipping it into my TT Urban Approach 5 and 10 bags along with other lenses. And there is the performance: the IQ is exceptional from f/2.8 and AF is great.
I do not shoot portraits. Not interested with the exception of the occasional one from the street. Instead my focus is landscapes and city/small town and street shooting. So, it annoys me, slightly, that 85mm and 135mm lenses are referred to and mostly discussed as "portrait lenses". I fully appreciate that those are coincidentally superb focal lengths for portraits, but for me they just happen to be generic focal lengths that permit me to find and frame subjects that I simply cannot with wider lenses. What native e-mount mid-telephoto lens could be more perfectly suited for my portability/performance needs than the Batis? Hard to put a price on that.
Side-note: if Zeiss would just make a Batis 35mm I'd be SO happy. It's the only major hole left to fill in the 18mm, 25mm, 85mm, 135mm range imo. Beyond that, a 15mm would be super cool too. I admit it: Batis fanboy here.
Having only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)
Fred Miranda wrote:
Having only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)...Show more →
What would makes things really interesting is if Sigma would release a native e mount version of the lens possibly reducing the weight and improving the autufocus. If they could do that, it would be a killer if a lens.
We'll have to wait on details of Sigma's full frame native mount plans.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Having only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)...Show more →
Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.
AGeoJO wrote: Fred Miranda wroteHaving only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here. ...Show more →
I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Having only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)...Show more →
The thing is with Metabones and firmware v57, Eye AF works fantatic with the Sigma so I dont think is fair to say "missing a shot" like its a hit or miss..is not, is accurate and pretty fast as well. Is it going to be as fast as native, of course not but portrait work it works amazing and I still get the better bokeh, 3Dish look of the subject isolation. Now this is on the A7Rii so not sure how the A9 is doing with that firmware.
Anyways, I just wanted to offer a different perspective of an owner that uses the Sigma on every outdoor shoot alongside the 85mm GM. If Eye AF was not good, I wouldnt have kept it.
Regards
GMPhotography wrote:
I had the Sigma and now the Batis. Sure 1.8 is great but it's heavier, larger and does not even come close to AF speed or Eye AF but it is a great lens. I would love to have kept it But it's simply not native and that AF speed and accuracy not to mention AFC mode just won't work.
You were very happy with the Sigma until the A9 issues with MC-11 so I am surprised to read this.
BTW, some people claim it works better with the latest firmware but for me still the Metabones is my choice since I get AF-C across the frame and can choose to go Green mode if I ever felt like it. Best of both worlds.
Regards
Fred Miranda wrote: AGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteHaving only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.
Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses.
AGeoJO wrote: Fred Miranda wroteAGeoJO wroteFred Miranda wroteHaving only tried both lenses for a short time, I think the difference between the Sigma vs Batis is not only size vs speed. I consider having accurate and reliable AF to be crucial in a 135mm lens when shooting portraits/events.
Eye AF is also a feature that changed how many portrait photographers shoot nowadays. That's reason alone to go with the native Batis. As Guy wrote above, missing a shot is not an option for many photographers.
However, a Sony 135/1.8 GM with fast and reliable AF will be a different story and would perhaps be a speed vs size decision...Similar to what we already have in the 85mm focal length. (Batis vs GM)Fred, you may not be aware of the progress of the firmware in both Metabones IV/V and Sigma MC-11. Both can deliver AF performance that is getting really close to native FE lenses, including Eye-AF in AF-C. I did several portrait sessions using both Sigma 135mm and GM 85mm and the keeper rate in terms of AF is excellent, better than 95% for both of them.
Still, if my livelihood depends on the way my gear performs, like in Guy's situation, I still would feel more comfortable using native FE lenses. Is this real or just perception? I don't know the answer to that but let me assure you, adapting Canon lenses and getting them to work well on Sony FE mount bodies has come a long, long way. And I am talking about using that setup on the A7r II and not A9 here.I've tried both about a month ago and it was a frustrating experience. I found that changing modes for the Metabones to get EyeAF is annoying and although it works ok in good light, I didn't find it reliable enough in low light or outside the center area. MC-11, not much better. It's frustrating when your subject is ready and your lens starts hunting!
Having said that, I agree that theses adapters have come a long way and it's great to have the option.Fred,
I agree that switching back and forth from the green mode (PDAF only) to advance mode (hybrid AF), where the Eye-AF is enabled is a pain. The switching method still remains in Version V that I am using right now. The idea behind that is they have to turn off the adapter completely to switch from one mode to the other. I wish we could do that on the fly. But again, my experience with the Eye-AF coming off the Metabones has been positive and they were able to expand the effective center area where MC-11 still struggles. However, I agree the performance is still not quite that of the native FE but close. BTW, even native FE lenses do struggle with Eye-AF if the lighting conditions get lower and lower.
Now, the next aspect, I wonder how the AF of native FE lenses but built by generic lens manufacturers, like Samyang (14mm and 50mm). Sigma does make FE lenses but in APS-C format. I have no idea about their AF performance. Do they perform as well as Sony FE lenses or do they perform slightly less. Any idea anyone? So far, most of the native FE lenses made by third-party manufacturers, like Voigtlander, Tokina Firin, are manual focus lenses....Show more →
It's just my personal experience and I thought it was important to point out that "size vs speed" is not the only consideration. There are many other aspects that come into play when deciding on these lenses. I for one, own three 85mm lenses for entirely different needs. (Batis, GM and ZM)
I have used smart adapters since they first came to market and they have definitely come a long way. The thing is, Sony keeps releasing lenses like crazy and pretty soon, adapting will turn from necessity to just individual preference.