I think a lot of the differences people are seeing in those shots comes from a difference in lighting. The Sigma got much better light. That's not a knock against you, Guy. I appreciate the tests, but shooting them in the same light would've better illustrated your point.
One thing that's very noticeable is the Sigma's distortion. Is that consistent throughout the focus range or does it get worse the closer you focus?
Thanks for the comparison and first impressions Guy. I too have just received the Batis and am very pleased with it especially with its amazing aberration control. I don't have the Sigma to compare it to, but for my needs the Sigma is just way too heavy.
Here's my first shot with the Batis, a cross-post from the FE images thread (vignetting wide open is a bit similar to Loxia 21mm though):
Doesn't look half bad, and in most instances looks pretty darn good
As I've said in other threads, if this was a $799 lens, I'd probably buy it as a lighter option to hauling a 70-200/2.8 around.
At the current price point though, I'm just not seeing any "wow", or even just "want".
When I view images from the 135/1.8, or previous the Nikon 105/1.4, I say "damn, I want that lens!". Price and size/weight be damned, the images are amazing.
I look at the Batis images though and my credit card doesn't seem to have the slightest risk of coming out of my wallet
Which I suppose is a good thing, so I shouldn't be complaining
Guy, thanks for your test photos. Have you had a chance yet to shoot any portraits with the Batis? I'd be curious as to how it compares with the 85 GM in crop mode... or, for that matter, if you have any other thoughts on the Batis now that you've had it for a few more days.
Have not had a chance to really get out and shoot. It's been extremely hot with temps hitting in the 116 degree mark for the last 5 days and no shoots scheduled. I start driving across country next Tuesday but I have it in my bag. I'll be shooting models in NY so I'll get a better idea than. Right now I'm hiding under a rock to stay cool. Lol
GMPhotography wrote:
Have not had a chance to really get out and shoot. It's been extremely hot with temps hitting in the 116 degree mark for the last 5 days and no shoots scheduled. I start driving across country next Tuesday but I have it in my bag. I'll be shooting models in NY so I'll get a better idea than. Right now I'm hiding under a rock to stay cool. Lol
Get out there and do that 4k video overheating test, you pansy!
GMPhotography wrote:
Have not had a chance to really get out and shoot. It's been extremely hot with temps hitting in the 116 degree mark for the last 5 days and no shoots scheduled. I start driving across country next Tuesday but I have it in my bag. I'll be shooting models in NY so I'll get a better idea than. Right now I'm hiding under a rock to stay cool. Lol
I'd offer to take you out to lunch when you get to NY but looks like I'm out of town about the time you're getting here! Enjoy the (somewhat) cooler weather and bring your scuba gear to swim through the humidity here! Been very muggy lately.
Well went out in the city with just the 135mm and touristy stuff but very very sharp. Eye AF not shown here was dead on the money. Im really starting to like this lens and I am keeping it.
Very nice Guy. The lens is certainly sharp and close to zero aberrations. The mid distance shots with a fairly close background, (e.g., the women's backside, the guy on the bike, the horse drawn carriage) all show bokeh that is a little busy to my eye, but that distance with close foliage is difficult for any lens and pretty much all modern lenses show that type of bokeh in that type of shot. In every other way the lens looks fantastic.
It seems that mid distance bokeh is at its worst. I agree it's not bad but could be smoother. The Sigma does handle that better. Infinity shots or distance let's say the bokeh in near foreground look good and close up as well. Just have to be aware of what your going to get. People stuff I would be fairly tight so it maybe just fine. Tracking is really good too
The problem and maybe we should not call it that is the optics made today are in the close to perfect arena and with that we are going to lose some of that bokeh look because lenses like this have no aberrations. Really tough to get around unless you have a 1.4 or so lens and even than getting buttery is not easy.