Fred Miranda wrote:
David,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?
I'm not sure if this helps and it would be very interesting to hear David's experience, but when I spoke with Zeiss last year about their digital scale, they told me that what is displayed on the OLED is the same as you'd see in the viewfinder, this is what they said:
"the AF distance metering as well as the DOF data displayed on the Batis´ OLED display are provided by the Sony camera body. They can also show the limited AF metering accuracy especially together with a super wide angle lens. The lens itself cannot do any distance metering."
With best regards
Kundensupport / Customer Support
Camera Lens Division
Carl Zeiss AG
ecarlino wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavid,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?I'm not sure if this helps and it would be very interesting to hear David's experience, but when I spoke with Zeiss last year about their digital scale, they told me that what is displayed on the OLED is the same as you'd see in the viewfinder, this is what they said:
"the AF distance metering as well as the DOF data displayed on the Batis´ OLED display are provided by the Sony camera body. They can also show the limited AF metering accuracy especially together with a super wide angle lens. The lens itself cannot do any distance metering."
With best regards
Kundensupport / Customer Support
Camera Lens Division
Carl Zeiss AG...Show more →
Thanks for the info. I have a Batis 85/1.8 here and the digital display shows decimals while the camera does not. Example: Camera shows 1...2m while the lens shows 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.4......2m
I wonder if there is more accuracy.
Matt Grum wrote: freaklikeme wroted) It's an AF lens
And, this time, it's not just my personal snobbery. My primary use for a 135 is in situations where silent operation is generally preferred. Manual focus lenses and silent shutter make shooting dress rehearsals in small venues or soloist recitals that are being recorded more comfortable for everyone involved, and it's typically the perfect back-of-house focal length for unobtrusively capturing more intimate moments on the stage.If you're happy with manual focus (or you require it) and you don't need f/2 then your cup runneth over with great 135mm options!
Agreed, but I do think there's a difference between "no AF" options and "no native AF" options (beyond the more expensive GM zoom). I'm guessing Zeiss is going to have an uphill battle selling much beyond the early adopters, even with native AF.
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteGMPhotography wroteFolks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them . Not sure it's deserved with the Rokinon135. I see no CA issues but just really nice sharpness across the frame even at the wider apertures. I think it deserves a lot more credit it's been given. You know I'm pretty good at knowing lenses and I think this generalizing sometimes is not the best way to describe it. Just sayin. I'm still thinking about this Batis but what NO ONE has brought up in the 3 or 4 threads here and I'm actually shocked no one brought up how this manually focuses and most users are landscape shooters. That's the first question I ask when buying a AF lens and especially Batis since I find the manual focus sucks really bad as it has no feel whatsoever. Yes I'm old school used REAL manual lenses my whole career but if it does not have any feel I run away. I had both the 25 and 85 nice lenses but they have no feel. Why I sold them. Is this lens any different. Forget price forget everything if it don't feel good in your hands it's worthless. Again it's about performance.Hi Guy
Yes you can get the Samyang branded version of the f2 135 in native FE mount; I've used it!
They all come out of the same factory - the Samyang factory - but in the US are imported by a company that calls them Rokinon because that was a historic name they used for off brand stuff. In Europe the same thing is done by a different company that brands them Bower. There are a couple of other brand labels on these lenses.
Which one you should buy depends on who your local distributer is that will honour the warranty. In the US that's Rokinon. But here in Australia, for example, you must buy the Samyang labelled one if you want good warranty service or repair (and also in most of Asia including Korea where they are made)
As for the QC there's some evidence the QC is better on these 135 lenses than on their other ones; you for example, contribute to that - but that's a sample of a few.
So I hope that it has improved a lot. But I, and others I know, have been BADLY burned on the Rokinon/Samyang quality, not just in getting a good one (where it makes the worse Sonys look good) but also on it *staying* good.
You are right that's on other lenses. But I don't think people can be blamed for being a bit cautious who have had that experience until and unless there's much more evidence that things have improved. Especially if they live in countries where returning lenses is much less easy than in the US.
That's not to say it's not worth the money, or that the lottery is not worth playing. It's a smoking bargain and an optically great lens. But I can see how some wouldn't want to play.
As for the manual focus experience, I know some people don't enjoy MF on the Batis series. I don't *enjoy* it either. It's not as fun as a well damped coupled helicoid. But in landscape situations I actually find the MF on Batis more accurate and quick than traditional MF. Once you get used to the variable speed you can get it roughly right really fast, and then can focus far more precisely as the effective travel increases for fine tuning. Now until your brain and fingers get used to variable speed focussing, it's a mess, and I can see some not wanting to mess up their finely tuned helicoid reflexes, but if you want to learn that kind of MF I think it's better. Practically better. I agree it's not as 'satisfying' somehow.David,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?
No; not really. It can be...but in other circumstance not so much. I think there's more variability than just the temperature variation you sometimes get with coupled focussing. The best result is when you move from closer than infinity to infinity and you have to stop the first time infinity appears on the scale. You can keep focusing. I got it very wrong on the top of Tindstindern in Norway once using the scale and I have focussed optically on infinity with batises ever since. But I think what happened then is that I focussed as far as it will go, which on by B85 is definately way past infinity.
Fred Miranda wrote: ecarlino wroteFred Miranda wroteDavid,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?I'm not sure if this helps and it would be very interesting to hear David's experience, but when I spoke with Zeiss last year about their digital scale, they told me that what is displayed on the OLED is the same as you'd see in the viewfinder, this is what they said:
"the AF distance metering as well as the DOF data displayed on the Batis´ OLED display are provided by the Sony camera body. They can also show the limited AF metering accuracy especially together with a super wide angle lens. The lens itself cannot do any distance metering."
With best regards
Kundensupport / Customer Support
Camera Lens Division
Carl Zeiss AGThanks for the info. I have a Batis 85/1.8 here and the digital display shows decimals while the camera does not. Example: Camera shows 1...2m while the lens shows 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.4......2m
I wonder if there is more accuracy.
I think this is consistent. What's displayed in the viewfinder might just be a rougher grained interpretation of the data the body is providing.
MY own feeling from using them (I use all three existing Batises) is that the finer grained information is likely a bit dubious, and the viewfinder is being sensibly conservative by making it coarser.
But that's only a feeling. I don't use the OLED thing really; I focus on what I want to focus on, and if I want a wide range and I'm on tripod I tend to focus stack rather than stop down beyond optimal aperture for DOF.
But I've got a laser tape measure somewhere so if I get a moment it'd be interesting to test the accuracy of the scale by focussing on a wall from a range of measured distances...
DavidBM wrote: Fred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteGMPhotography wroteFolks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them . Not sure it's deserved with the Rokinon135. I see no CA issues but just really nice sharpness across the frame even at the wider apertures. I think it deserves a lot more credit it's been given. You know I'm pretty good at knowing lenses and I think this generalizing sometimes is not the best way to describe it. Just sayin. I'm still thinking about this Batis but what NO ONE has brought up in the 3 or 4 threads here and I'm actually shocked no one brought up how this manually focuses and most users are landscape shooters. That's the first question I ask when buying a AF lens and especially Batis since I find the manual focus sucks really bad as it has no feel whatsoever. Yes I'm old school used REAL manual lenses my whole career but if it does not have any feel I run away. I had both the 25 and 85 nice lenses but they have no feel. Why I sold them. Is this lens any different. Forget price forget everything if it don't feel good in your hands it's worthless. Again it's about performance.Hi Guy
Yes you can get the Samyang branded version of the f2 135 in native FE mount; I've used it!
They all come out of the same factory - the Samyang factory - but in the US are imported by a company that calls them Rokinon because that was a historic name they used for off brand stuff. In Europe the same thing is done by a different company that brands them Bower. There are a couple of other brand labels on these lenses.
Which one you should buy depends on who your local distributer is that will honour the warranty. In the US that's Rokinon. But here in Australia, for example, you must buy the Samyang labelled one if you want good warranty service or repair (and also in most of Asia including Korea where they are made)
As for the QC there's some evidence the QC is better on these 135 lenses than on their other ones; you for example, contribute to that - but that's a sample of a few.
So I hope that it has improved a lot. But I, and others I know, have been BADLY burned on the Rokinon/Samyang quality, not just in getting a good one (where it makes the worse Sonys look good) but also on it *staying* good.
You are right that's on other lenses. But I don't think people can be blamed for being a bit cautious who have had that experience until and unless there's much more evidence that things have improved. Especially if they live in countries where returning lenses is much less easy than in the US.
That's not to say it's not worth the money, or that the lottery is not worth playing. It's a smoking bargain and an optically great lens. But I can see how some wouldn't want to play.
As for the manual focus experience, I know some people don't enjoy MF on the Batis series. I don't *enjoy* it either. It's not as fun as a well damped coupled helicoid. But in landscape situations I actually find the MF on Batis more accurate and quick than traditional MF. Once you get used to the variable speed you can get it roughly right really fast, and then can focus far more precisely as the effective travel increases for fine tuning. Now until your brain and fingers get used to variable speed focussing, it's a mess, and I can see some not wanting to mess up their finely tuned helicoid reflexes, but if you want to learn that kind of MF I think it's better. Practically better. I agree it's not as 'satisfying' somehow.David,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?No; not really. It can be...but in other circumstance not so much. I think there's more variability than just the temperature variation you sometimes get with coupled focussing. The best result is when you move from closer than infinity to infinity and you have to stop the first time infinity appears on the scale. You can keep focusing. I got it very wrong on the top of Tindstindern in Norway once using the scale and I have focussed optically on infinity with batises ever since. But I think what happened then is that I focussed as far as it will go, which on by B85 is definately way past infinity....Show more →
My 16-35/4 and 55/1.8 lenses focus at infinity, the way you described: "have to stop the first time infinity appears on the scale".
I will try the Batis 85 tomorrow. Thanks!
Fred Miranda wrote: DavidBM wroteFred Miranda wroteDavidBM wroteGMPhotography wroteFolks not sure why everyone keeps referring to Samyang 135 . They do not have a native FE mount. There is the Rokinon 135 that does, NO adapter needed. Secondly it's getting a little old hearing about lens construction and Constryction issues. I have had three of these and it's built very well and all three copies I have had where as sharp as the next. Sure Samyang may have a bad name on somelenses but I have yet to see a issue with the 135. Not that I really care but there is a shit load of whining here about them . Not sure it's deserved with the Rokinon135. I see no CA issues but just really nice sharpness across the frame even at the wider apertures. I think it deserves a lot more credit it's been given. You know I'm pretty good at knowing lenses and I think this generalizing sometimes is not the best way to describe it. Just sayin. I'm still thinking about this Batis but what NO ONE has brought up in the 3 or 4 threads here and I'm actually shocked no one brought up how this manually focuses and most users are landscape shooters. That's the first question I ask when buying a AF lens and especially Batis since I find the manual focus sucks really bad as it has no feel whatsoever. Yes I'm old school used REAL manual lenses my whole career but if it does not have any feel I run away. I had both the 25 and 85 nice lenses but they have no feel. Why I sold them. Is this lens any different. Forget price forget everything if it don't feel good in your hands it's worthless. Again it's about performance.Hi Guy
Yes you can get the Samyang branded version of the f2 135 in native FE mount; I've used it!
They all come out of the same factory - the Samyang factory - but in the US are imported by a company that calls them Rokinon because that was a historic name they used for off brand stuff. In Europe the same thing is done by a different company that brands them Bower. There are a couple of other brand labels on these lenses.
Which one you should buy depends on who your local distributer is that will honour the warranty. In the US that's Rokinon. But here in Australia, for example, you must buy the Samyang labelled one if you want good warranty service or repair (and also in most of Asia including Korea where they are made)
As for the QC there's some evidence the QC is better on these 135 lenses than on their other ones; you for example, contribute to that - but that's a sample of a few.
So I hope that it has improved a lot. But I, and others I know, have been BADLY burned on the Rokinon/Samyang quality, not just in getting a good one (where it makes the worse Sonys look good) but also on it *staying* good.
You are right that's on other lenses. But I don't think people can be blamed for being a bit cautious who have had that experience until and unless there's much more evidence that things have improved. Especially if they live in countries where returning lenses is much less easy than in the US.
That's not to say it's not worth the money, or that the lottery is not worth playing. It's a smoking bargain and an optically great lens. But I can see how some wouldn't want to play.
As for the manual focus experience, I know some people don't enjoy MF on the Batis series. I don't *enjoy* it either. It's not as fun as a well damped coupled helicoid. But in landscape situations I actually find the MF on Batis more accurate and quick than traditional MF. Once you get used to the variable speed you can get it roughly right really fast, and then can focus far more precisely as the effective travel increases for fine tuning. Now until your brain and fingers get used to variable speed focussing, it's a mess, and I can see some not wanting to mess up their finely tuned helicoid reflexes, but if you want to learn that kind of MF I think it's better. Practically better. I agree it's not as 'satisfying' somehow.David,
In your experience using the Batis 'digital scale'...when you hit the infinity symbol, is it accurate?No; not really. It can be...but in other circumstance not so much. I think there's more variability than just the temperature variation you sometimes get with coupled focussing. The best result is when you move from closer than infinity to infinity and you have to stop the first time infinity appears on the scale. You can keep focusing. I got it very wrong on the top of Tindstindern in Norway once using the scale and I have focussed optically on infinity with batises ever since. But I think what happened then is that I focussed as far as it will go, which on by B85 is definately way past infinity.My 16-35/4 and 55/1.8 lenses focus at infinity, the way you described: "have to stop the first time infinity appears on the scale".
I will try it out tomorrow. Thanks!
I'm guessing that means you have carefully tested that that's repeatably so, rather than just a pretty good impression which is all I can bring to the table?
If so that's great news for people who want to use the scales, because on the assumption that the Batises are using the same data (which I think is right - I saw it form some Zeiss source as well, an interview I think) then it will likely be repeatably the case there as well. If you get promising results I'll check in different conditions too. It'd be handy to be able to trust scale focussed infinity.
GMPhotography wrote:
Thanks David. Yes I know the names fall under the same company. I guess I never saw a Samyang listed here in the states as a FE mount. Maybe why I was wondering which one was being talked about. I had a Samyang 14 which looked like a fisheye with distortion. Was cheaply made but worse the focusing was really weird.
I've got the Samyang 12mm diagonal fisheye for FE mount myself branded as Samyang, which is cheap enough justify (I would never use a diagonal fisheye enough to pay top prices). It's OK; but not as good as their fisheyes for APS unfortunately. My sample is a bit decentred, but I think less so than average so I'm not playing change-o
I went through five 14s. I had a Samyang branded one for Canon that was amazing. Better than the Canon 14 by far before you applied a distortion profile, and just as good afterwards despite being 20% of the price. I was in heaven.
Then I switched to Sony when the first A7r came out -- and I did something dumb. I replaced my canon mount Samyang with an FE mount Rokinon labelled version. It was **terrible** - SA all over the field! I got rid of that for a pittance, and got another Samyang. Dreadful. Another Rokinon. Another Samyang. All hopeless (and infinity was at 1 metre or two randomly on these) I gave up.
I also tried the 100mm macro, thinking it might be optically great (which a good sample likely is) and that MF for macro is all you need, which is true at least given my tastes. Well maybe i could have forgiven the magnification scale being horribly out (1:2 was closer to 1:4) and the distance with it, but it just couldn't get sharp beyond a couple of metres, and was tilted in the macro range. Tried one more - flared crazy in a way that the other didn't! Gave up.
But as people have said, they do seem to be getting better - the premium line would interest me a lot if I was shooting DSLR. I really hope they extend it to mirrorless models. Maybe what's going on is that your 135 is like the APO SOnnar - remember they said it was Otus before Otus? Maybe the 135 is Samyang Premium before Samyang Premium! But it does look like it's the old build from the outside...
The results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8.
This could change once we get 'trusted' reviews or perhaps the f/2.8 aperture was a deal breaker for many shooters.
I think this lens looks like it could be an excellent tool for pros, but there's no spec in there to get my prosumer heart pounding
I'll stick with my pocket rocket Minolta 135/2.8, or my APO 80-200/2.8 when I care about CA and don't mind the size. Looks like I just "found" another $2k for that A99II budget...
farfisa wrote:
I think this lens looks like it could be an excellent tool for pros, but there's no spec in there to get my prosumer heart pounding
I'll stick with my pocket rocket Minolta 135/2.8, or my APO 80-200/2.8 when I care about CA and don't mind the size. Looks like I just "found" another $2k for that A99II budget...
Are you using the MD or AF and do you have any samples I can look at? Thinking of getting one of those to hold me for a year or so while waiting to see what happens with used Batis prices.
For three years I've used the 135mm ƒ1.8 on my Sonys, always assuming that eventually they'd release a 'modern' replacement and I'd need to have it.
But given the price of the new one, and the great performance of the SAL135F18Z, I feel no need to replace it now. (yes, I realize the new one is 'better', but not enough to matter, for me.)
Fred Miranda wrote:
The results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8.
This could change once we get 'trusted' reviews or perhaps the f/2.8 aperture was a deal breaker for many shooters.
You are correct, Fred. Out of the 3 main groups (sorry for repeating it):
1) YES: I will buy the lens right away
2) MAYBE: I am interested in the lens but I will wait until the reviews are available and/or the price (used/new) is more reasonable
3) NO: I am not interested in the lens for various reasons; like owning other lens(es), not using this FL, etc.
And the 3rd group (including the last option to just view the result) makes up more than 60% in contrast to only 3% of the 1st and seemingly enthusiastic group. The indecisive 2nd group may still be swayed into one of the other camps but still, it doesn't look good, at least for now.
AGeoJO wrote:
You are correct, Fred. Out of the 3 main groups (sorry for repeating it):
1) YES: I will buy it right away
2) MAYBE: I am interested in buying but I will wait until either the reviews are superb or the price (used/new) is more reasonable
3) NO: I am not interested in the lens for various reasons; like owning other lens(es), not using this FL, etc.
And the 3rd group (including the last option to just view the result) makes up more than 60% in contrast to only 3% of the 1st and seemingly enthusiastic group. The indecisive 2nd group may still be swayed into one of the other camps but still, it doesn't look good, at least for now....Show more →
Joshua, I think the poll/results actually lead to more questions for all of us marketing novices - for example - in other systems, what percentage of users even have a 135 prime? And for those that do, is that one of their lenses they allocated an above/below average amount for a lens? 3% in your poll may exceed Zeiss' expectations given the premium optic/price. It probably suits their manufacturing schedule better as well that they can have regular production runs without being behind on initial demand. From observing numerous rants (my own included) over the past years re: the Sony (and 3rd party) rollout of lenses, it seems like everyone has "their favorite" focal length or two but is it any wonder that some of the focal lengths received a lot of attention and only in year 4 of the FE mount is there the first 135mm - probably because camera manufacturers know how many lenses they sell at each focal length. It seems like with this announcement and Sony's 100 STF, they decided to go with low volume offerings. Let's hope the rest of 2017 is a bit more mainstream as there still is a lot of low hanging fruit for them.
Also, given that 135 is probably not 'the lenscap' for very many people, seeing the price being what it is and knowing (having been through the Batis 85 already) that there will be faster and cheaper alternatives within a year or two, the lack of initial commitment seems reasonable and I'd hardly (not that anyone has) call it a failure on Zeiss' part.
For as many people have spoken out that they want a 'fast' 135 - i can't wait for when that is released and 10x people come out of the woodwork saying 'look at how ridiculously big that is on the a7 body'.
I suspect that over time, once the alternatives are available, there will be a steady trickle, certainly never a rush, of people interested in this lens.
I think it's nice to have a relatively smaller option with fantastic IQ. Even though I've never been afraid of relatively big, fast lenses, the 85GM is sort of the limit for me on the a7 bodies and the Batis 135 is just inside the leather - so i'm glad to have a high IQ option at that focal length (though i am still undecided myself - sadly for me it's more about my schedule/availability to shoot/travel this year and how much i'll use any of my gear, let alone this focal length).
virtualrain wrote: ecarlino wroteFor those "not interested regardless or price"
is it because of
a) the focal length doesn't interest you
b) the aperture is too 'slow' because of available light concerns
c) the aperture is too 'slow' because of Depth of Field / background separation/blur concernsI chose this option because there was no option to select for not buying because the price is too high.
But, even if the price was in line with the Batis 85, the max aperture is not appealing. I would use it to shoot full body at 40' away and at that distance you need wide apertures to blur the background. .
I think they really screwed up here. The worst part is that this may do so poorly in the market that Zeiss gives up developing any more Batis lenses. Although maybe a $2000 50 f/2.8 is just around the corner!
This lens probably has a very limited life and perhaps Zeiss knows that and has factored that in. As soon as Sony brings an FE 135 to market this lens won't move at all. I expect the Batis 85 is already starting to suffer this fate at the hands of the FE 85.
I was a real fan of the Batis lenses until now. They offered a great mix of optical performance, max aperture, and size/weight at a reasonable (for me) premium that was perfect for a traveler. But this lens throws that value prop out the window. It's zoom speed at an insane premium. And as I said elsewhere, edge sharpness and correction in a lens that is going to have edges and corners rendering blurred bokeh in nearly every shot, is the wrong priority for this lens. Those shooting landscapes at 135mm will enjoy that edge sharpness I guess, but few others will. ...Show more →
I agree with this. Zeiss likely knew that this lens was not going to be popular, hence the Instagram campaign that was all shrouded in secrecy.
If this lens had been a 135mm f2, it would have flown off the shelves at $2000 MSRP. But at f2.8, it will likely sit for a lot of people. I understand that f2 would have made the lens heavier, but they could have done some things to mitigate that, such as sacrificing corner performance. Most people use these types of lenses for long portraits and background blurring, not for corner-to-corner sharpness.
As it stands, we have the Batis 85mm f1.8 which has similar background blurring to 135mm f2.8, and we can always crop to 135mm with 42mp. It's lighter, cheaper, with similar sharpness and CA performance, and offers OSS. The existence of the Batis 85 is what really makes the Batis 135 redundant, in my opinion.
You are exactly right, corner sharpness on a portrait lens is not high on the priority list. As far as landscapes go where corner sharpness is important, there are many other options at 135mm that are excellent and much cheaper.
RoseandCharles wrote: virtualrain wroteecarlino wroteFor those "not interested regardless or price"
is it because of
a) the focal length doesn't interest you
b) the aperture is too 'slow' because of available light concerns
c) the aperture is too 'slow' because of Depth of Field / background separation/blur concernsI chose this option because there was no option to select for not buying because the price is too high.
But, even if the price was in line with the Batis 85, the max aperture is not appealing. I would use it to shoot full body at 40' away and at that distance you need wide apertures to blur the background. .
I think they really screwed up here. The worst part is that this may do so poorly in the market that Zeiss gives up developing any more Batis lenses. Although maybe a $2000 50 f/2.8 is just around the corner!
This lens probably has a very limited life and perhaps Zeiss knows that and has factored that in. As soon as Sony brings an FE 135 to market this lens won't move at all. I expect the Batis 85 is already starting to suffer this fate at the hands of the FE 85.
I was a real fan of the Batis lenses until now. They offered a great mix of optical performance, max aperture, and size/weight at a reasonable (for me) premium that was perfect for a traveler. But this lens throws that value prop out the window. It's zoom speed at an insane premium. And as I said elsewhere, edge sharpness and correction in a lens that is going to have edges and corners rendering blurred bokeh in nearly every shot, is the wrong priority for this lens. Those shooting landscapes at 135mm will enjoy that edge sharpness I guess, but few others will.I agree with this. Zeiss likely knew that this lens was not going to be popular, hence the Instagram campaign that was all shrouded in secrecy.
If this lens had been a 135mm f2, it would have flown off the shelves at $2000 MSRP. But at f2.8, it will likely sit for a lot of people. I understand that f2 would have made the lens heavier, but they could have done some things to mitigate that, such as sacrificing corner performance. Most people use these types of lenses for long portraits and background blurring, not for corner-to-corner sharpness.
As it stands, we have the Batis 85mm f1.8 which has similar background blurring to 135mm f2.8, and we can always crop to 135mm with 42mp. It's lighter, cheaper, with similar sharpness and CA performance, and offers OSS. The existence of the Batis 85 is what really makes the Batis 135 redundant, in my opinion.
Exactly. Cropping my Batis 85 is exactly what I have been doing since switching to Sony. And I will continue to do that. This new Batis offers no noticeable advantage in terms of subject isolation. In fact, I find shooting candid street with the 85 and cropping offers a lot more flexibility and I can shoot at lower ISOs in low light. I don't need 42Mpx resolution for my street photos so this works ok for me.
And if you own the 85 f/1.4 GM, this lens is even less compelling than cropping unless you really need all that resolution.
I'm actually glad this lens is unattractive in price and aperture, otherwise I probably would have purchased it and then flip-flopped between it and the 85 and now I don't need to think about that.
I've voted for the first option. I've ordered the lens (and will probably get it already end of this month) but it's definitetly not my dream lens (that would be a 15mm Loxia with similar performance as the 21mm Loxia).
I own at the moment two 135mm lenses, the Zeiss 2.0/135mm Apo ZF.2 and the Leica 3.4/135mm Apo and enjoy using the 135mm focal length more and more for landscape images and the occasional wildlife and people images.
The Zeiss 2.0/135mm Apo ZF.2 is extremely good, even wide open, but large and heavy and needs an adapter to be used on the A7RII. The Leica is very small but needs to be stopped down to f/4 for perfect corner sharpness. My idea is to sell both lenses and just keep the Batis. If it is as good as the 2.0/135mm.
Getting Exif info is another advantage of the Batis. And, although I shoot all my landscape images with MF, for the occasional wildlife and people shots AF could also be useful.
Fred Miranda wrote:
The results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8.
I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little bit lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!
Matt Grum wrote: Fred Miranda wroteThe results from this poll do not look good for the new Batis 135/2.8. I think it's worth stating again that this forum is not a representative sample of potential customers - people here are exacting with very specific requirements, I'd probably buy the lens if it were a little be lighter or a little bit cheaper or a little bit faster, or if the timing was different, but as it is it falls just outside my very narrow criteria!
It's also worth pointing out that FM members do not shy from expensive gear so price is not what's really driving these numbers. I believe the slower a aperture is a deal breaker for a lot of shooters.