fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2017 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2017Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?

  
 
Mark_EL
Offline
Details
p.2 #1Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Jman13 wrote:
There needs to be a fifth option, "I might have been interested, but it's too expensive." Option 3 is too specific....

I have no desire to wait until it shows up on B&S, but I might have been interested at a more reasonable price. As it is now, I can't see myself ever owning it. I could possibly see spending $1200 on one eventually, new...but I'm not paying that used, and I sure as heck am not paying $2K. Honestly, that price for a lens like this, it might as well be an Otus or a Leica APO Summicron...totally beyond what
...Show more →

This!
Apr 06, 2017 at 12:04 AM
twoeye
Offline
Details
p.2 #2Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
At half the price it could make sense to replace my Apo-Sonnar 2/135ZF and Canon 135L with the Batis, I would then have Apo-Sonnar quality and AF in one lighter package, but no f2.

These two lenses have cost me much less (used) than one Batis 135.
Apr 06, 2017 at 12:05 AM
Matt Grum
Offline
Details
p.2 #3Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
freaklikeme wrote:
d) It's an AF lens

And, this time, it's not just my personal snobbery. My primary use for a 135 is in situations where silent operation is generally preferred. Manual focus lenses and silent shutter make shooting dress rehearsals in small venues or soloist recitals that are being recorded more comfortable for everyone involved, and it's typically the perfect back-of-house focal length for unobtrusively capturing more intimate moments on the stage.


If you're happy with manual focus (or you require it) and you don't need f/2 then your cup runneth over with great 135mm options!


Edited on Apr 06, 2017 at 08:59 AM · View previous versions
Apr 06, 2017 at 03:09 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.2 #4Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
If picked option 4. I'm not really interested in a 135 2.8 lens, APO or not, and certainly not at that price point.

With prices having come down on the APO Sonnar and the Sony 135 1.8 recently, the introduction of the affordable Samyang, and various other alt options, and the competition from Sony's 70-200 zooms, I wonder how many people are willing to bite the blue bullet this time.

You would think that Sony now has one incentive more to make that "no holds barred" 135mm f1.8 or f2 GM or Sony Zeiss, that lives up to or improves upon what has remained arguably its most critically acclaimed a-mount lens to date.
Apr 06, 2017 at 05:29 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.2 #5Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I put seriously considering. I do have a need but it's pricey for me for a 2.8 which makes it a little tough for some of my needs. But I'm not ruling anything out yet. Like to hear what camera is next first.
Apr 06, 2017 at 06:22 AM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.2 #6Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Jman13 wrote:
There needs to be a fifth option, "I might have been interested, but it's too expensive." Option 3 is too specific....

I have no desire to wait until it shows up on B&S, but I might have been interested at a more reasonable price. As it is now, I can't see myself ever owning it. I could possibly see spending $1200 on one eventually, new...but I'm not paying that used, and I sure as heck am not paying $2K. Honestly, that price for a lens like this, it might as well be an Otus or a Leica APO Summicron...totally beyond what
...Show more →

Please take a look at the second part of the third option that says (not verbatim) "until...the price is more reasonable". You meant, Option 3 is too specific or is not specific enough? I should have put in "and/or" rather than just "and" to separate the two subgroups of Option 3.

There are basically 3 main groups of folks:
1) I will buy the lens whenever it becomes available or I will pre-order or I have pre-ordered.
2) I will buy the lens only after certain conditions are met - this has a few subgroups, such as, after excellent review, after available on the B&S forum, after the price is more reasonable. Even the last subgroup is subjective, since the term "reasonable" to some may still be "excessive" to others. And definitely, there is no need to break it down further.
3) I will not buy the lens regardless of its price based on a few possible reasons, not my FL I use/prefer, I have other lens(es) I use and love, etc.

The more options there are in the poll, the more diluted and distorted the results. Just adding the "Just view the result" option will shift and skew the end result already. And, again, this is not a scientific poll and we cannot break it down further to accommodate minor variations than what those options are.

FYI, the retail price of Zeiss Batis 85mm f/1.8 still remains at $1,199 as of today. I believe that's the same price at its introduction, which was approximately 18 months ago. A mint one can be had for approximately $900 or maybe even slightly less on the B&S Board. Yes, eventually Zeiss will reduce the official price of this lens based on the market demand and that's due to the pressure coming from the used market.
Apr 06, 2017 at 07:01 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.2 #7Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Maybe it's me but I can't wait for new lens prices to drop 6 months from now. I need to shoot to make money. I'm glad some folks can wait. I'm talking newly released lenses

AGeoJO wrote:
Jman13 wroteThere needs to be a fifth option, "I might have been interested, but it's too expensive." Option 3 is too specific....

I have no desire to wait until it shows up on B&S, but I might have been interested at a more reasonable price. As it is now, I can't see myself ever owning it. I could possibly see spending $1200 on one eventually, new...but I'm not paying that used, and I sure as heck am not paying $2K. Honestly, that price for a lens like this, it might as well be an Otus or a Leica APO Summicron...totally beyond what I'm willing to pay for a lens that does what it does, though I acknowledge that it's a very high-end lens.

To be honest, one of the biggest reasons I'd never get this lens at this price is that I can get the Fuji 90mm f/2 for $950 brand new, and while it lacks IS, it is about as optically flawless a lens as I've ever used. It is tack sharp at f/2, has beautiful bokeh, essentially zero CA, zero distortion....and it even has the same ability for shallow DOF as the Batis (and it can focus closer!).
Please take a look at the second part of the third option that says (not verbatim) "until...the price is more reasonable". You meant, Option 3 is too specific or is not specific enough? I should have put in "and/or" rather than just "and" to separate the two subgroups of Option 3.

There are basically 3 main groups of folks:
1) I will buy the lens whenever it becomes available or I will pre-order or I have pre-ordered.
2) I will buy the lens only after certain conditions are met - this has a few subgroups, such as, after excellent review, after available on
...Show more →
Apr 06, 2017 at 07:05 AM
AGeoJO
Offline
Details
p.2 #8Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
GMPhotography wrote:
Maybe it's me but I can't wait for new lens prices to drop 6 months from now. I need to shoot to make money. I'm glad some folks can wait. I'm talking newly released lenses

AGeoJO wrote
Jman13 wroteThere needs to be a fifth option, "I might have been interested, but it's too expensive." Option 3 is too specific....

I have no desire to wait until it shows up on B&S, but I might have been interested at a more reasonable price. As it is now, I can't see myself ever owning it. I could possibly see spending $1200 on one eventually, new...but I'm not paying that used, and I sure as heck am not paying $2K. Honestly, that price for a lens like this, it might as well be an Otus or a Leica APO Summicron...totally beyond what I'm willing to pay for a lens that does what it does, though I acknowledge that it's a very high-end lens.

To be honest, one of the biggest reasons I'd never get this lens at this price is that I can get the Fuji 90mm f/2 for $950 brand new, and while it lacks IS, it is about as optically flawless a lens as I've ever used. It is tack sharp at f/2, has beautiful bokeh, essentially zero CA, zero distortion....and it even has the same ability for shallow DOF as the Batis (and it can focus closer!).
Please take a look at the second part of the third option that says (not verbatim) "until...the price is more reasonable". You meant, Option 3 is too specific or is not specific enough? I should have put in "and/or" rather than just "and" to separate the two subgroups of Option 3.

There are basically 3 main groups of folks:
1) I will buy the lens whenever it becomes available or I will pre-order or I have pre-ordered.
2) I will buy the lens only after certain conditions are met - this has a few subgroups, such as, after excellent review, after available on the B&S forum, after the price is more reasonable. Even the last subgroup is subjective, since the term "reasonable" to some may still be "excessive" to others. And definitely, there is no need to break it down further.
3) I will not buy the lens regardless of its price based on a few possible reasons, not my FL I use/prefer, I have other lens(es) I use and love, etc.

The more options there are in the poll, the more diluted and distorted the results. Just adding the "Just view the result" option will shift and skew the end result already. And, again, this is not a scientific poll and we cannot break it down further to accommodate minor variations than what those options are.

FYI, the retail price of Zeiss Batis 85mm f/1.8 still remains at $1,199 as of today. I believe that's the same price at its introduction, which was approximately 18 months ago. A mint one can be had for approximately $900 or maybe even slightly less on the B&S Board. Yes, eventually Zeiss will reduce the official price of this lens based on the market demand and that's due to the pressure coming from the used market.


If past or current conditions are giving us some kind of indication, Zeiss hasn't reduced the price of the existing 85mm and 25mm lens after 18 months or so. Chances are, they won't reduce the original price of $1,999 until at least the approximately same period has elapsed. So, I am afraid that you have to pay the full price or you wait until it shows up on the B&S board for less. When and for how much less? Who knows....
Apr 06, 2017 at 07:17 AM
Justin Stone
Offline
Details
p.2 #9Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
This lens rumor and release has been good for
me because it's helped me figure out I am really only willing to use a prime if it offers me a more useful tool than a zoom. Usefulness for a prime usually means faster aperture, uniform performance, flatter field, sharper corners, less CA, less distortion, smaller package. In fact, I generally shoot with primes. I'm willing to trade a few of those for the remarkable utility of a zoom which obviously is capable of the trick of resembling numerous different lens focal lengths with a twist of a ring.

The Batis ticks a lot of those boxes for utility for sure. But it misses a big one and that's max aperture. 2.8 can be slow for getting the optimal indoor shot. Coupled with the perceived value or lack thereof due to the much higher than expected msrp this lens seems far too niche for most users to recommend for many shooting situations let alone to realize the value stored in $2000 US.


shaolin95 wrote:
I am in the 4th option, I dont see any price that will make it interesting for me personally.
Of course, we are all different.

Apr 06, 2017 at 08:01 AM
iammikie
Offline
Details
p.2 #10Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I preordered right out of the box.
1. I don't have a 135 except by using a zoom
2. I love everything about Batis Lenses and have three now
3. At my age MF is not an option
4. Waiting for used is not an option for the same reason
5. Paying for Nikon & Canon big glass has somewhat hardened me over price point decisions
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:28 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.2 #11Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I will continue using my 135/2 EF lens if I need a prime lens in this focal length. I don't need anything else here - voted #4.
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:38 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.2 #12Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
Jannik Peters wrote:
I have voted " I am not interested in that lens regardless of the price " although I miss the option "I would have been interested if it would have been half the price".

I honestly don't care if the lens has got 4 or 11 ED lenses - I can't really ask for more than the Rokinon 2/135's performance and I would have maybe paid double it's price for a 1 stop slower and almost equally heavy lens with AF and better build quality... But 4 times the price? Does this lens also cook coffee and make fire?

Sorry,
...Show more →

Exactly this-- except even at half the price I'd pass.

At Batis 18 price, and 135L size, at f/2, I'm in, regardless of APO or corner-to-corner sharpness w/o.

If Samyang can team up with someone who does AF right, I'd be thrilled if they took their current 135 f/2 (spectacular-- nearly perfect) and added whatever basic size needed to AF-ize it. Double the price, sell a boatload.
Apr 06, 2017 at 08:49 AM
GabrielPhoto
Offline
Details
p.2 #13Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?

Now THAT would be a dream lens for me! The Samyang with good AF.
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:01 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.2 #14Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
shaolin95 wrote:
Now THAT would be a dream lens for me! The Samyang with good AF.


Zeiss could have taken that lens, added AF, maybe added their coatings (not even sure if it's needed, honestly), and sold a quite a few at $2K. Samyang could do it and clean house at $1K.
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:24 AM
Fred Miranda
Offline
Admin
Upload & Sell: On
Details
p.2 #15Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
justruss wrote:
shaolin95 wroteNow THAT would be a dream lens for me! The Samyang with good AF.
Zeiss could have taken that lens, added AF, maybe added their coatings (not even sure if it's needed, honestly), and sold a quite a few at $2K. Samyang could do it and clean house at $1K.


It seems that what makes the Samyang 135/2 perform so well is its length. With an adapter, it's more than 2 inches bigger than the new Batis 135/2.8. It's also longer than any other fast 135mm lens (even f/1.8 lenses).
With AF, it could get even bigger and heavier but perhaps it's possible for Samyang to develop a slight smaller version for the E-mount.
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:49 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.2 #16Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I don't have a adapter it's built in is there a Samyang version. I have a Rokinon in FE mount

I have this one at 550 new

https://www.adorama.com/rk1352msoe.html#source=productOptions

Construction7 groups /11 elementsAngle of view12.4°F stop range2.0-22Closest Focusing Distance0.8m / 2.62 ft.Filter Size77mmLength5.83" / 148.1mmWeight29.6oz / 840g

Edited on Apr 06, 2017 at 09:57 AM · View previous versions
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:52 AM
artur5
Offline
Details
p.2 #17Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
If Techart made an AF adapter for Canon/Nikon mount lenses directly to Sony-E you'd get AF with the current Samyang 135 (albeit not with E native AF features).
As is, the TAP adapter for Leica.M to Sony-E is too short to allow for full range AF with lenses above 50mm. and it seems also that the mechanical quality leaves something to be desired.

Anyway, my five cents on the 135 Batis are :
1- Too big for travel-landscape lens.
2- Too slow for portraits.
3- Too expensive for a general purpose 135mm, specially for amateur and/or occasional use.
No doubt it will be stellar from an optical point of view, but it seems to sit in the middle of nowhere. I'd expect that the potential market will be quite small but, being no fortune teller, maybe I'm totally wrong and people will kill each other for get a copy as fast as possible.
Finally, with a max.diameter of 98mm (even bigger than the Sigma 135/1.8 ART -and that's saying a lot !) I claim my right to nickname it Fatis 135.
Apr 06, 2017 at 09:53 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.2 #18Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
.moved to other thread / didnt mean to post in the 'poll' thread.

Edited on Apr 06, 2017 at 10:34 AM · View previous versions
Apr 06, 2017 at 10:08 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.2 #19Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
I voted for the fourth option, not interested at any price. Reasons:

1) 135mm is one of my least used and least favorite focal lengths -- I use it in zooms perhaps twice a year.
2) The price is stupendously high and out of my reach.
3) If I were to buy a 135mm lens, it would be a used Canon 135/2L via Sigma MC-11 adapter.

I will certainly buy a Loxia 21 and 50 (and perhaps even a CV 12/5.6) long before I consider a 135mm lens. I would likely buy a used Canon 200/2.8L II before the 135L.
Apr 06, 2017 at 10:28 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.2 #20Are you falling for the new Zeiss Batis?
artur5 wrote:
If Techart made an AF adapter for Canon/Nikon mount lenses directly to Sony-E you'd get AF with the current Samyang 135 (albeit not with E native AF features).
As is, the TAP adapter for Leica.M to Sony-E is too short to allow for full range AF with lenses above 50mm. and it seems also that the mechanical quality leaves something to be desired.

Anyway, my five cents on the 135 Batis are :
1- Too big for travel-landscape lens.
2- Too slow for portraits.
3- Too expensive for a general purpose 135mm, specially for amateur and/or occasional use.
No doubt it will be stellar
...Show more →

A couple points of clarification: first, the 98 diameter is of the hood not the lens, so it isn't nearly as bad as that may seem at first; second, too big for travel-landscapes is in my view a pretty tough characterization. No it isn't as small as the Leica M 135 f/3.4 APO, but it isn't that much heavier and it may be a bit better in performance and quite a bit cheaper. It is smaller than pretty much any other 135mm (some older and much inferior options are just a bit smaller as well, but to me that is apples and oranges), so if you want this focal length for travel and landscapes if you can't handle this size then you are not going to have many options; third, I disagree with the too slow for portraits. At their respective minimum focus distances and with wide open aperture this lens actually has just a bit less depth of field than the Sony/Zeiss 50 f/1.4. Is that lens too slow for portraits too? Many people think only of aperture when considering depth of field and what makes a nice portrait. In my view focal length at least as important and with the high ISO capabilities of the A7rII and the A7s this lens will do just fine for portraits indoors and out; fourth, not everyone wants to compromise on a general purpose lens and if you don't want to compromise (or make as few compromises as possible) on a general purpose lens then you can't expect a cheap price. I personally, like what Zeiss (and Sony) has done but building somewhat slower aperture lenses at a very high quality and charging more than lenses at these focal lengths and apertures have cost in the past. A good example of that is the Sony/Zeiss 55 f/1.8. People complained endlessly when that lens came out about a $1,000 price tag on a 50ish f/1.8 lens. These had typically cost about $100 in the past. Now, I think many people see the Sony/Zeiss 55 f/1.8 as a wonderful all purpose lens. To me this Zeiss Batis is a similar sort of lens and although people are complaining endlessly about the price, if you want a 135mm all purpose lens I think in time people will appreciate what this lens has to offer just as in time they appreciated what the 55 f/1.8 had to offer.
Apr 06, 2017 at 10:47 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister