navmannz wrote:
Picked up mine yesterday from Auckland, NZ - very impressed with the optical performance, particularly at close to middle distances, and it even works very well closer in with a Nikon No. 3 T. However, mine appears to have faulty signalling of the aperture, with some positions at the wide open end initiating a jiggle between F/22 and say F/2.8. Yet another experience of poor quality control with a Loxia - currently awaiting instructions from the NZ Zeiss agent.
-John
John,
I experienced a similar electronic aperture glitch with my Loxia 50/2. Zeiss could not fix it and I ended up getting a replacement.
Fred
Fred asked if I'd do a centre, mid, and edge comparison of the Loxia and Tele-Tessar 85s. It's my first attempt at doing this kind of comparison. Consequently, it's by no means perfect but I hope it is useful. I ran into an exposure problem similar to the one Stephen (Luvwine) reported, with the Tele-Tessar shots being underexposed compared to the Loxia. I've tried to even out the exposures but next time I'll use manual rather than aperture priority exposure. All shots taken on a tripod using a remote control.
First the full scene, which shows that the Tele-Tessar 85mm has a slightly wider field of view than the Loxia 85mm.
I also have left, centre, and right crops for both the top and bottom of the frame but didn't include them because it would have doubled the number of pictures in an already long post. I can do another post if that's of interest.
@genji
Thank you so much! It helps a lot!
This is what I was expecting. The Loxia would be noticeably better at f/4 since the ZM is wide-open but at f/5.6 they would be somewhat similar with an edge still for the Loxia. (Better resolution and micro-contrast)
I wonder if there is much difference at f/6.3 or f/7.1. (My mostly used apertures for the ZM 85)
Thank you,
Fred
At first blush, looks like Loxia is better on fine details--leaves on trees, fine fence lines on the bottom of the right images, etc. 85/4 has lots of contrast and does very well, however, just not quite as well as Loxia.
navmannz wrote:
Picked up mine yesterday from Auckland, NZ - very impressed with the optical performance, particularly at close to middle distances, and it even works very well closer in with a Nikon No. 3 T. However, mine appears to have faulty signalling of the aperture, with some positions at the wide open end initiating a jiggle between F/22 and say F/2.8. Yet another experience of poor quality control with a Loxia - currently awaiting instructions from the NZ Zeiss agent.
-John
Sorry to hear about the fault with your lens. Hopefully Zeiss in NZ will provide you with a replacement. Your pictures are indeed lovely and demonstrate the close to middle distance performance that convinced me to get a Loxia 85.
Thanks so much for these, I grew up in the Big Smoke and know this area very well.
You could take a look at the f8 set as that is where the ZM85 is best, and the L85 will be on the way down, in the center at least. That would help the landscape users. Another to do for interest: f2.4 L85 -vs- f4 ZM85. This is a good demo of MTF in fact - the L85 will be stronger in/near the focal plane in the midfield, outside the very center, where the ZM should be almost as good.
Notes: everything looks good until you see something better, which is why comparisons are so valuable. A lot of CA even in the centre of the ZM (see 'Tele-Tessar F4 centre'), the L85 is moire-ing even where you don't expect it, see last image fence in foreground. Much cleaner color and much stronger contrast > greater 3D (image depth perception, not everyone notices this). It's a micro-contrast monster. Color palette fabulous in L85, clean neutrals and far better separation between close tones, some contamination in ZM images - reflections etc. cheers.
genji wrote: navmannz wrotePicked up mine yesterday from Auckland, NZ - very impressed with the optical performance, particularly at close to middle distances, and it even works very well closer in with a Nikon No. 3 T. However, mine appears to have faulty signalling of the aperture, with some positions at the wide open end initiating a jiggle between F/22 and say F/2.8. Yet another experience of poor quality control with a Loxia - currently awaiting instructions from the NZ Zeiss agent.
-JohnSorry to hear about the fault with your lens. Hopefully Zeiss in NZ will provide you with a replacement. Your pictures are indeed lovely and demonstrate the close to middle distance performance that convinced me to get a Loxia 85.
Thanks Genji - it's with the courier on its way back up to Auckland. It seems there are none spare to be had in Australasia at the moment, so if they can't either replace or repair it, I'll be asking for it back for a week-long alpine trip that I have planned for the first week in Feb. I compared it with my Emarit-M, and while the Elmarit held its ground in the centre, it never really caught up with the Loxia in the outer parts of the image, even stopped down to F/8.
philip_pj wrote:
Notes: everything looks good until you see something better, which is why comparisons are so valuable.
I totally agree. Without the side-by-side it's hard to judge these top lenses. Without a direct comparison, I didn't think the ZM 85 would be so much better than the Batis and the Leica 90AA would render fine detail so much better than the ZM at infinity.
From the MTF, I knew the Loxia would do better than the ZM but the real test for me is at f/6.3-8 where I mostly use this little lens.
philip_pj wrote:
You could take a look at the f8 set as that is where the ZM85 is best, and the L85 will be on the way down, in the center at least. That would help the landscape users. Another to do for interest: f2.4 L85 -vs- f4 ZM85. This is a good demo of MTF in fact - the L85 will be stronger in/near the focal plane in the midfield, outside the very center, where the ZM should be almost as good.
...
The F2.4 Loxia vs F4 Tele-Tessar set was easy to do because I already had the F4 TT crops. The F8 set will have to wait until tomorrow (hopefully).
Heres a quick raw shot of my pup. Its a close, wide open/bokeh shot for those wanting to add to the mix. FWIW, I find manual focus relatively easy with this lens. The focus throw seems just about perfect.
photomadnz wrote:
Heres a quick raw shot of my pup. Its a close, wide open/bokeh shot for those wanting to add to the mix. FWIW, I find manual focus relatively easy with this lens. The focus throw seems just about perfect.
I also compared the Loxia with my Contax Zeiss 85/2,8. I don't currently have the time to post such extensive tests, but roughly said, in the center the Contax is about equal (97%) to the Loxia, in the outer regions however it gets much softer than the Loxia which mainly looses contrast towards the outer parts of the file, but still holds quite good detail.
Surprisingly, at close (= portrait) distance, the Canon EF 85/1,8 is even slightly better than the Loxia (clarity and sharpness), but at longer distances Loxia easily wins. MF is also quite difficult on the Canon - when you manage to hit the focus exactly, it can be amazingly sharp (that goes also for the EF100mm f2.0).
Therefore my summary so far would be: The Loxia is - apart from it's lack of AF and apterture being a bit on the dark side for low light situations - the most consistent of all 85mm lenses I have seen so far. Moderate specs but excellent performance in virtually all situations. Not necessarily a "leader" in any, but a very constant performance at a very high level. It also has quite a gentle way of rendering a scene, more subtle than bold.
kin2son wrote:
Just to confirm - The L85 is optically superior compared to the ZM85 and 90 Summarit right?
Not sure as I got better results with my two copies of the ZM 85. There could be copy variance here. Like to see some more folks also doing the comparisons to confirm this. Not that the results posted are bad but we all have been through copy variance before so I'm still on the fence. I appreciate the hard work don't get me wrong but I had two ZMs that where stellar and Fred has my last one in hand.