Not to argue with Philip's good points above, but just putting in my two cents for an opposite viewpoint.
I used 4x5 (and 617) as my primary formats for decades until switching to digital about 18 months ago. I'm the first to admit that I'm not your typical landscape photographer in that I rarely used wide lenses in 4x5. My most-used was 300 (rough equivalent = 90 in 35mm format), and I frequently used 450 and even 720 lenses. When I first got the latter, I thought originally that I'd use it for such things as isolating distant ridgelines, etc. and perhaps not much more, but I was surprised by how often I actually did use it, even at close range. A good example of that was doing an isolated shot of the "Z" at Bond Falls, a well-known location to those of us who frequent Upper Michigan. I suppose I was about 20-25 feet from the "Z" and wanted it to fill the frame; the camera (Ebony SV45U2, which I got specifically for its very long bellows) had its bellows stretched nearly to breaking to get enough extension at such close range!
I used 72-210 lenses in 4x5 a fair amount, but not as much as the longer lengths. I've always been fond of composing by isolation; now that I'm doing digital, I've been mixing things up and have learned to like wide lenses much more than I did in the past. I do, however, like using my 135/2 for landscape quite often; it relates nicely to my old 450 in 4x5 format.
When I was shooting Canon, if I planned to shoot landscape, I always brought my Canon 70-200 f/2.8L II. 135mm was my go-to FL with that lens, especially with super panoramas.
When I shot 4x5 my favorite lens was the 400/8 T - I rarely used super wides.
In fact I find the typical landscape images with typical lenses quite boring. Give me great compression or give me incredibly wide - I'm not one for the in-betweens.
My point still stands - any lens can be used to make a great landscape image when used in the best situation for the image intended. Who cares what's been typically or traditionally used by anyone in the past or present.
For my own personal preferences and what I like to shoot for the most part 15mm and wider or ~135mm (FX format) or longer suit me and my subjects best for landscapes.
The Loxia 85/2.4 is on the edge for my use for landscapes, but it's perfect for a travel lens (which I have used 85mm for on-the-go landscapes) when I feel f/2.4 will be worth the weight and size over my 85/4 ZM.
As Phillip said - it's all down to personal taste and style, which is a good thing for variety.
jhinkey wrote:
...
The Loxia 85/2.4 is on the edge for my use for landscapes, but it's perfect for a travel lens (which I have used 85mm for on-the-go landscapes) when I feel f/2.4 will be worth the weight and size over my 85/4 ZM.
...
After a week's use, I've concluded that f/2.4 is definitely worth the weight and size over my 85/4 ZM.
genji wrote: jhinkey wrote...
The Loxia 85/2.4 is on the edge for my use for landscapes, but it's perfect for a travel lens (which I have used 85mm for on-the-go landscapes) when I feel f/2.4 will be worth the weight and size over my 85/4 ZM.
...After a week's use, I've concluded that f/2.4 is definitely worth the weight and size over my 85/4 ZM.
Could you post a comparison between the two lenses at infinity (or near infinity) at f/4 and f/5.6? It would be nice to see how the center, mid and edges look side by side.
I mainly would use the Loxia at these two apertures as it would not be my main portrait or any other type of application requiring a larger aperture.
I'm having a hard time justifying the extra weight and bulk for landscape usage as the ZM is stellar at f/5.6.
Sorry not to be able to help with the Zeiss ZM 85 comparison. I did take some more pics today with my Loxia 85 and did another brief series (it was cold in Atlanta today!) with my Leica 90/2 AA. First, I did a pic shooting a tree in the yard with sun in the frame trying to get some ice coated branches. This is the only shot I got this, but there is some purple in the upper left. Is this flare?
Anyway, I then went to my favorite nearby cityscape location on a bridge. Light was tough as Sun was just to the left of the buildings so there was a bit of veiling effect. Still, I worked quickly (it was cold). I did the series of F2-F8 twice and when I looked at the files, strangely, it seems the Leica shots were underexposed compared to the Loxia by about 1/4 stop. I did this comparison and then I did it again all images +1. If I used the second set, I would likely have to underexpose the Loxia by a similar amount. Not sure what this says. In presenting the images below, I have added .25 to the exposure and all are "dayllight" in lightroom. No other processing--no sharpening, etc. My remote release ran out of battery juice, so i did these pressing the shutter, but shutter speeds were high enough that I don't think that affected anything.
Any thoughts on a winner? To me, they are very evenly matched in infinity testing once stopped down to F4 or F5.6. The Loxia does better in the corners until about F5.6 at infinity. I am not sure what to make of why when metering on aperture priority the Loxia has a slightly slower shutter speed and thus exposes more to the right than the Leica. I guess I should have done this on manual settings. Live and learn....
Fred Miranda wrote:
Could you post a comparison between the two lenses at infinity (or near infinity) at f/4 and f/5.6? It would be nice to see how the center, mid and edges look side by side.
I mainly would use the Loxia at these two apertures as it would not be my main portrait or any other type of application requiring a larger aperture.
I'm having a hard time justifying the extra weight and bulk for landscape usage as the ZM is stellar at f/5.6.
I realize that perhaps I should have qualified that statement because I haven't done any direct comparisons between the Loxia 85 and the Tele-Tessar 85 ZM. What I meant was that, for me, the extra weight and bulk of the Loxia fade into insignificance, partly because I always felt constrained by the ZM's f/4 maximum aperture but mainly because, in terms of handling, the Loxia 85 is just heaven on a stick, even better than the Leica R lenses that have previously been my benchmark in that regard.
I have a free day tomorrow so I have the time to do a comparison between the two. Am I correct in assuming that a cityscape similar to that in Stephen's (luvwine's) previous post would be most useful?
Before thoughts, a note that Amazon won't have stock until Jan 30 - Feb 4, B&H 'don't have an estimate'. And a shout out to Robert White, perhaps better people / prompt email responses (and cheaper for Australians by several hundred).
Thoughts occur: f2.4: 90AA perhaps a little better centers but close; lower right: other factors arise (different distance from focal plane; but very close, however note dirt pattern on (nearer) light post and edge of light - L85 is neat and clean; upper left: a straight out win fr L85, and look at edging in 90AA.
Mid Upper: a clear win for micro-contrast of L85 on building, 90AA perhaps better on lit side; 90AA has more magenta fringing on roof line, less sharp elsewhere;
f4: center confirms 90AA is best in center, and little better than L85 shaping and 3D, main sign contrast; Lower Right: 90AA improves on f2.4, little stronger in background, 'same' for near light post; Upper Left: 90AA stronger than f2.4 but still lags in depth, fringing; Mid Upper: very close, L85 in front still little better here, better m/c, less color in highlights; f5.6: 90AA still little stronger but take your pick almost; Lower right: test of DOF and contrast really, 90AA little better overall; Upper Mid: still prefer L85 here, better shaping, small advantage in fine detail, remnant fringing. Two great lenses - Zeiss should market L85 as APO? A heck of a color performance, IMO.
Agreed on Robert White in the comments. In most every image I look at I find parts of the image that I like for each lens. I could post five more crops from just these images and there would be positives for each lens. Due to the filter thread consistency with my other two Loxia, I just put the Leica on B&S. I might regret it and buy it back some day. It just makes really nice images.
Only very bad light these days here, I just made a few snaps today - an overview and 2 crops. The street in the 1st crop is hundreds of meters away actually, 1/60s handheld, hazy weather and ISO320. This was f4,5.
alba63 wrote:
Only very bad light these days here, I just made a few snaps today - an overview and 2 crops. The street in the 1st crop is hundreds of meters away actually, 1/60s handheld, hazy weather and ISO320. This was f4,5.
My personal question is do I sell the most-excellent 135/2 APO ZF.2 to fund this?
I use it once per year and usually need to stop down to f/2.8 for my portraits to get the required DOF to keep both eyes in focus, etc. and use the also most-excellent 135/3.4 APO instead (with extra DOF . . .). I can also take one step more toward my subjects with the 85/2.4 and use it WO for similar effect while also being able to use it for other purposes that the 135/2 Zeiss is way too heavy for.
jhinkey wrote:
My personal question is do I sell the most-excellent 135/2 APO ZF.2 to fund this?
I use it once per year and usually need to stop down to f/2.8 for my portraits to get the required DOF to keep both eyes in focus, etc. and use the also most-excellent 135/3.4 APO instead (with extra DOF . . .). I can also take one step more toward my subjects with the 85/2.4 and use it WO for similar effect while also being able to use it for other purposes that the 135/2 Zeiss is way too heavy for.
These are difficult decisions. I just sold my Leica 90/2 (in about three hours, I think!) as I thought it was too close to justify keeping it and the Loxia 85/2.4, tho if the filter size had not matched my other two Loxia lenses, I might have made the opposite call. To me, I would not keep both the 135/2 and the 135/3.4. I understand that the Zeiss 135/2 is likely a better lens optically and it is faster, but it is enough bigger that I would not use it much. Unless there are applications where you really need the speed, I would sell the Zeiss 135/2, but that is me. I keep all my lenses insured on an inland marine policy and don't want to pay to insure expensive lenses if I am not using them.
Whether 85 or 135 is better for portrait is a personal thing. For me, it depends on whether you are inside or outside and how tight you want to be. Inside, I like 85, outside, 135, broadly speaking, tho either will work.
I'd do the opposite with the 135s.....I love using the 135/2 wide open for flower closeups and such, and wouldn't get the same effect at 3.4. If you never use it wide open, though, that would be a reason to keep the 3.4 instead...
Got my demo one today. I can confirm its definitely up there with the very best lenses. I went out and did a quick sequence this morning and came back and printed off a 30x20 inch print on the ZBE Chromira printer. I cant fault it..... Sublime. I wish it had slightly more bokeh wide open but thats what you get for a comprise in size. Speaking of which.... It feels terrific on the A7RII.
Day off tomorrow so Ill have some more raws if anyones interested...
Picked up mine yesterday from Auckland, NZ - very impressed with the optical performance, particularly at close to middle distances, and it even works very well closer in with a Nikon No. 3 T. However, mine appears to have faulty signalling of the aperture, with some positions at the wide open end initiating a jiggle between F/22 and say F/2.8. Yet another experience of poor quality control with a Loxia - currently awaiting instructions from the NZ Zeiss agent.