Also the red went more yellow biased. Even in post yellow is a little tough to correct on skin tone. In a lot of cases you over correct. The only thing that I see as a negative on the Zeiss is the specular highlights are a little bright but highlight control works well with Zeiss lenses with a bump of correction. I'm also looking at contrast and clarity which to me the Zeiss has a nicer balance to it along with a little pop. Portraits are tough because it really tests our eyesight and our own color bias that we see as humans. Judging a landscape image is easy almost anything works. People are much harder to judge, correct and view because of our bias towards the qualities of our vision.
The Leica is a fine lens don't get me wrong but I tend to like a more Zeiss looking file. I should I shoot mostly all Zeiss
Which brings up a whole topic in itself is your whole kit of glass do you want a consistent look or lenses that are all different. I prefer a more consistent look to my whole kit. Maybe a good thread topic here.
Very interesting to see the comments here on the portraits. I am leaning toward selling the Leica, but mainly for the compatible filter size in my lineup. Skin tones are hard for me not being a portrait photographer and, of course, in this case the subject is of Chinese descent. Leica has always seemed to have a bit warmer colors with vibrant red tones and Zeiss a bit cooler with great blues. Ironically, the picture she chose for her profile was one of the Leica 90 AA shots. It is below tho a bit more processed than the ones above. I include the eye crop (but eye crop is not any more processed than the ones above). All of these used "Adobe" colors. Camera neutral yields a different look as does Camera portrait or standard (the latter two more yellow still). Whlch color profile I like depends upon the light--outdoors I usually prefer the camera profiles to Adobe. In this case, she chose the color profile, tho I did not disagree. I think this image was at F 2.8:
Also, for the skin color issue, I would note that I processed this image at a bit cooler color temp rather than the "daylight" 5500 +10. I think this is a more realistic skin tone for her than what the daylight setting produced.
Just for fun, and since I am happy playing wth new lenses, here is another try with the Loxia 85. This was the first pic I took of her in the session and I like how it came out. It is wide open at F 2.4. It is slightly cropped and I did some processing on the image.
For the past few years I've been going to Circular Quay in Sydney to photograph the crowd on New Year's Eve. Since I'd picked up the Loxia 85/2.4 the day before, I thought I'd restrict myself to using just that lens. On the previous New Year's Eve (in 2015) I used mainly the Zony FE 55/1.8, which nailed focus almost perfectly. Last night was different and I struggled to get accurate focus with subjects who were on the move so the pictures that worked were of static subjects. In retrospect, since I was shooting at f/4 to give myself a bit more depth of field, I might have done better by using the Tele-Tessar ZM 85/4 with the TAP. But I really wanted to give the Loxia 85 a workout.
Looks great but truly it comes down to a comfort level . If you feel good about that lens you shoot that really is all the bat counts. Trust me on this
Looks great but truly it comes down to a comfort level . If you feel good about that lens you shoot that really is all the that counts. Trust me on this
One final follow up (I think) about the portrait comparison I posted where the Leica looked more yellow than the Loxia. I got some tips from the people forum (I really am a novice at portraits) and used the eyedropper tool on the white of the subject's eye. This is not fool proof as the color temp varies a fair bit depending upon where in the white one clicks (yes, I am beginning to see the importance of using a gray card or color checker passport for portraits!). Anyway, I did the eyedropper tool a few times on the Loxia and Leica shots. The color temp was ultimately the same (4550). However, the Loxia was tint -1 and the Leica tint +8. Here they are for your edification. These are completely unprocessed straight out of camera except the color temp. No crop, no nothing. Adobe Standard color (default).
Stephen, very nice! The 90 Cron appears more appealing to my eye, as you have more magenta. If you were to look at each image alone, both are excellent. I do prefer the 90 Cron for portraits as there is less micro contrast, but for landscapes the 85 Loxia is better for the Zeiss look with the high micro contrast. The difference with the 90 Cron is you still have f/2 for separation the and the look when you need it for portraits.
That said I love the Loxia MF implementation and you would have not issues in fast accurate focusing for portraits.
Anyone have any thoughts as to how the Loxia 85 compares to the GM 85 at infinity? My thought is that since Guy tested the ZM 85 as essentially the equal of the GM and since the ZM is slightly inferior to the Leica 90/AA there, and since I find the Loxia about equal to the Leica, that the GM is likely slightly inferior to the Loxia at infinity. This logic may have flaws, but there is a fellow over at DP Review who has done some short range comparisons and claims the GM blows awaynthe Loxia. I doubt it and don't see a sharpness difference in his examples (bokeh, yes), but thought I would inquire here if anyone has any thoughts/info.
On center I would say it is equal. Its the corners where the advantage of the ZM over the GM. The GM is damn good on center but blows the Loxia 85 away I would question that statement. Maybe equal too but I don't think blow away would be accurate. But worth a test from someone here like Fred or Myself. Now if I was pushed to shoot landscape with the GM i would not baulk about the IQ but about the weight and size more than anything else. But if want very good corners F8 I would say it would do well. Again the ZM is better here in corners.
This Loxia from all that I have seen posted here looks very very nice.
Thanks Guy. This confirms my suspicions. I certainly would agree that the GM is the better choice as a specialist portrait lens due to larger apertures and eye autofocus. However, for corner to corner sharpness at infinity, I would be skeptical. The same guy at DP review says he thinks the 135/3.4 apo from Leica has a better MTF than the Loxia and provided a composite MTF to "prove" his assertion. Of course, he was comparing the MTF graphs at 2.4 for Loxia with 3.4 for the Leica. Now I love the Leica 135/3.4 apo, but facts are facts and the Loxia MTF is a bit better (slightly) at comparable apertures and equal to or slightly better even than the 90/2 apo. I was only over there because Fred's forum was on the fritz the other night....
I am currently at Yomesite and the 85 ZM is getting a workout. It's so small, I keep it in my jacket sometimes and I am mostly shooting at f/6.3 or f/7.1 where it is absolutely outstanding. I could never do that with my GM.
I don't have the Loxia yet but since I use the GM for portraits, I am struggling justifying the Loxia over the ZM. I will still put these three lenses to test though.
GMPhotography wrote:
On center I would say it is equal. Its the corners where the advantage of the ZM over the GM. The GM is damn good on center but blows the Loxia 85 away I would question that statement. Maybe equal too but I don't think blow away would be accurate. But worth a test from someone here like Fred or Myself. Now if I was pushed to shoot landscape with the GM i would not baulk about the IQ but about the weight and size more than anything else. But if want very good corners F8 I would say it would do well. Again the ZM is better here in corners.
This Loxia from all that I have seen posted here looks very very nice. ...Show more →
Luvwine wrote:
Thanks Guy. This confirms my suspicions. I certainly would agree that the GM is the better choice as a specialist portrait lens due to larger apertures and eye autofocus. However, for corner to corner sharpness at infinity, I would be skeptical. The same guy at DP review says he thinks the 135/3.4 apo from Leica has a better MTF than the Loxia and provided a composite MTF to "prove" his assertion. Of course, he was comparing the MTF graphs at 2.4 for Loxia with 3.4 for the Leica. Now I love the Leica 135/3.4 apo, but facts are facts and the Loxia MTF is a bit better (slightly) at comparable apertures and equal to or slightly better even than the 90/2 apo. I was only over there because Fred's forum was on the fritz the other night.......Show more →
Yep I saw that post at DPR and the "proof" ..... gah.
Fred Miranda wrote:
I am currently at Yomesite and the 85 ZM is getting a workout. It's so small, I keep it in my jacket sometimes and I am mostly shooting at f/6.3 or f/7.1 where it is absolutely outstanding. I could never do that with my GM.
I don't have the Loxia yet but since I use the GM for portraits, I am struggling justifying the Loxia over the ZM. I will still put these three lenses to test though.
GMPhotography wroteOn center I would say it is equal. Its the corners where the advantage of the ZM over the GM. The GM is damn good on center but blows the Loxia 85 away I would question that statement. Maybe equal too but I don't think blow away would be accurate. But worth a test from someone here like Fred or Myself. Now if I was pushed to shoot landscape with the GM i would not baulk about the IQ but about the weight and size more than anything else. But if want very good corners F8 I would say it would do well. Again the ZM is better here in corners.
This Loxia from all that I have seen posted here looks very very nice.
Agree I would not be taking the GM out for landscape work. This is where the second lens like the ZM and Loxia would excel on our poor aging backs.
GMPhotography wrote: Fred Miranda wroteI am currently at Yomesite and the 85 ZM is getting a workout. It's so small, I keep it in my jacket sometimes and I am mostly shooting at f/6.3 or f/7.1 where it is absolutely outstanding. I could never do that with my GM.
I don't have the Loxia yet but since I use the GM for portraits, I am struggling justifying the Loxia over the ZM. I will still put these three lenses to test though.
GMPhotography wroteOn center I would say it is equal. Its the corners where the advantage of the ZM over the GM. The GM is damn good on center but blows the Loxia 85 away I would question that statement. Maybe equal too but I don't think blow away would be accurate. But worth a test from someone here like Fred or Myself. Now if I was pushed to shoot landscape with the GM i would not baulk about the IQ but about the weight and size more than anything else. But if want very good corners F8 I would say it would do well. Again the ZM is better here in corners.
This Loxia from all that I have seen posted here looks very very nice.Agree I would not be taking the GM out for landscape work. This is where the second lens like the ZM and Loxia would excel on our poor aging backs.
My aging back just carted the ZM 35 and Elmarit-M 90 on a three day back-packing trip climbing up to 1500m on NZ's central North Island volcanoes. The ZM 35 blows me away, but the Elmarit, while great for plant closeups (sometimes with Nikkor 3T), seems a bit lacking in that Zeiss micro-contrast for landscapes - I'll be checking the Loxia once it arrives in the antipodes, but that could be a while
Fred Miranda wrote:
I am currently at Yomesite and the 85 ZM is getting a workout. It's so small, I keep it in my jacket sometimes and I am mostly shooting at f/6.3 or f/7.1 where it is absolutely outstanding. I could never do that with my GM.
I don't have the Loxia yet but since I use the GM for portraits, I am struggling justifying the Loxia over the ZM. I will still put these three lenses to test though.
GMPhotography wroteOn center I would say it is equal. Its the corners where the advantage of the ZM over the GM. The GM is damn good on center but blows the Loxia 85 away I would question that statement. Maybe equal too but I don't think blow away would be accurate. But worth a test from someone here like Fred or Myself. Now if I was pushed to shoot landscape with the GM i would not baulk about the IQ but about the weight and size more than anything else. But if want very good corners F8 I would say it would do well. Again the ZM is better here in corners.
This Loxia from all that I have seen posted here looks very very nice.
If you were willing to let the Leica 90 AA go and keep the ZM 85 due to size, then it may well be that you pass on the Loxia. The Loxia does have a more contrasty rendering than the Leica, but not sure it is any sharper or more detailed overall than the Leica--they seem really close in that department to me. I am back home and not on my laptop anymore so will have another look at the test images I did. I suspect the Loxia will end up being a hair better than the ZM at infinity with similar rendering but with a size penalty.
As far as the comparisons for landscape shooters . I would tend to leave the GM out of the equation and one reason I say that is most folks here are good with 2 lenses in this focal length and the GM clearly is not the best hiking lens. I really think its between the 3 like the ZM. Leica and Loxia. I also question if it is a a landscape type lens does F2.4 really buy you anything as a advantage. I just think given a lot of good 85's out there we have to narrow this down.
So I have come back from a few days of traveling, with my new Loxia. I was in the german countryside, so virtually I did only nature photography. I didn't own any Zeiss longer than my 35-70mm so far, and no Leica at all. I saw 2 reviews and had a brief hands- on in a store, then I wanted the Loxia.
Basically the reviews as virtually everybody has already said the Loxia 85 is most excellent in what it does. I never had a lens of such optical quality, when shooting I was amazed how the lens can subtly graduate tonal depth and sharpness and thus create dimension and depth. A true precision instrument. Contrast is very high, sometimes almost too much, in C1 I found that it can be better to pull back sharpening in order to not overenhance details. Focussing with the EVF loupe is quite easy, despite the moderate speed the EVF clearly shows what's in focus and what is not (quite). It is still too early to make a final judgement, but so far I am quite pleased. I count to use the Loxia for everything not portrait, where I prefer AF lenses with eye AF or so...
I did not always carry a tripod, and found out that that with the a7rII's resolution I get very sharp images out of the Loxia at 1/60s almost all the time (with IBIS) and when careful also at 1/30s. Below that very unreliably.
Here are some samples:First a shot with 100% crop. I only saw the cat inside the caravan on the table later....
And a few landscape shots: I cropped away some sky or (uniform) forground on some for composition.