Steve Spencer wrote: Andrew Gough wroteIt is interesting to hear that it will do "video really well". I can tell you that pulling focus at F2.4 on this lens will require a follow focus and a monitor. Sure it will be easy to focus on a tripod, fixed image shooting, but for any kind of movement... The basis 85mm will do a pretty good job of AF in video on the A7RII - Just sayin'Andrew for video work it can be useful at times to control the speed of focus. An autofocus lens can never do that, so if this matters to you--it does to me--then an AF lens will never do for video. Yes, you need a follow focus to do this, but Zeiss now makes some very nice attachable gears that fit the Loxia lenses beautifully and allow for easy use of a follow focus. So, for some of us who shot video this lens is simply capable of things that a Batis is not (note the declickable aperture takes on a similar function--at times I want to control the speed of an aperture change to create the image I want in video--you can't do that unless you have a ceclicked aperture)....Show more →
Yes we do do the same, but the loxia is just too specialized vs say the Milvus. The New Sigma's look pretty cool.
Staring at the MTF of the Otus and the new Loxia I can see why some people would buy the Loxia; you really are splitting hairs between them. At some points Loxia is better, at others Otus is better. Of course it's hard because you are comparing charts at 2.4 and 5.6 with 1.4 and 4. But Lox at f5.6 seems to outperform Otus at f4, which suggests similar quality.
So here's what you might think: for a third of the price I can get a much smaller Otus level prime that's only 1.5 stops slower. Sold.
Of course two caveats: what's most amazing about Otus is it's wide open performance. And the best short teles at stopped down apertures are all amazingly good, and certainly many are indiscernibly different (at least to me) even if measurably different. So we await real world tests.
freaklikeme wrote:
Thanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.
It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.
It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.
Argh, the weight is a killer for me and my applications. If it were 400-500 grams I might overlook it, but lugging this guy around the mountains would be a problem.
I think I'll stick with the 85/4 ZM. Can someone please make an M to FE mount adapter that has a programmable chip in it to communicate the lens focal length to my A7RII!!! That would make life so much easier during fast lens changes.
Fred Miranda wrote:
Let's not forget that Zeiss wants to address the video market with the Loxia line.
The shared 52mm filter thread (barrel diameter), mechanical MF and aperture de-clicking may not make any difference for still shooters but it could be crucial for video work when matching lenses.
It's irrelevant to discuss AF vs MF as a preference. If you don't want MF, the Loxia line is not for you regardless of the IQ, price or size.
And there it is really. The Loxia seems to want to kill 2 birds with one stone and with the growing interest in video this has covered Zeiss nicely. The Zeiss MP 100/2 I own is heavy for my needs (though still only less than 100g more than this Loxia) but until there is a smaller/lighter option, that is equally as sharp (corner to corner) and almost as fast, for my travel/hiking and portrait requirements, then that stays in the bag.
philip_pj wrote:
CZ don't talk much about APD. Perhaps one of the first mentions I recall was in relation to the CY 100-300 (it has three such elements), and we all know how that one works.
They use anomalous dispersion elements quite a bit. The new Milvus 85 has seven, the Touit 50 had two, the APO-Sonnar 135 has three, the Milvus 50 has four and an aspherical. Those are the ones I remember reading about recently, but there are likely more. It just doesn't look to me like they're getting the level of correction out of the design they get with other implementations. It looks like they intentionally went a little old school with the lens to me.
jhinkey wrote:
Argh, the weight is a killer for me and my applications. If it were 400-500 grams I might overlook it, but lugging this guy around the mountains would be a problem.
I think I'll stick with the 85/4 ZM. Can someone please make an M to FE mount adapter that has a programmable chip in it to communicate the lens focal length to my A7RII!!! That would make life so much easier during fast lens changes.
I think there is one that will read six-bit coding. Would that help?
Fred Miranda wrote: freaklikeme wroteThanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.
It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.
Cool. Do you want to throw my Summicron 90 in to that test? It would likely save me a rental. I'd be happy to send it out once you get your Sonnar.
jhinkey wrote:
Argh, the weight is a killer for me and my applications. If it were 400-500 grams I might overlook it, but lugging this guy around the mountains would be a problem.
I think I'll stick with the 85/4 ZM. Can someone please make an M to FE mount adapter that has a programmable chip in it to communicate the lens focal length to my A7RII!!! That would make life so much easier during fast lens changes.
You can do that with the Techart pro and as a bonus gain AF when needed. The only downside is that it's 133 grams, which is about 3 times heavier than a regular dumb M to E-mount adapter.
freaklikeme wrote: Fred Miranda wrotefreaklikeme wroteThanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.
It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.Cool. Do you want to throw my Summicron 90 in to that test? It would likely save me a rental. I'd be happy to send it out once you get your Sonnar.
I am curious about the 90AA and never tested it. Let's just say my Summarit is not optimized for long distances and that was surprising to me. It just can't compare to the 85ZM, Batis 85 or 85GM even at stop-down apertures.
freaklikeme wrote: philip_pj wroteCZ don't talk much about APD. Perhaps one of the first mentions I recall was in relation to the CY 100-300 (it has three such elements), and we all know how that one works.It just doesn't look to me like they're getting the level of correction out of the design they get with other implementations. It looks like they intentionally went a little old school with the lens to me.
Based on the samples? The MTFs look like it's got amazing correction....
Fred Miranda wrote: freaklikeme wroteThanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.
It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.
Do you still have a C/Y 3.5/100? It's be great to compare it against that too, to figure out whether the only big difference (aside for a FL difference) between it and the ZM and Lox is the sunstar/bokeh ball shape...
pdmphoto wrote:
The MTF's are impressive, but the the samples from the DearSusan review don't inspire me at all.
They do inspire me. The landscape shots vs. the Otus look pretty spectacular and I am a huge fan of what I have seen of the bokeh in those samples. The bokeh is of course subjective, but the landscape test is very consistent with the MTFs.
Fred Miranda wrote: Holger wroteMaybe it is better than many other 85s. But what can we really say regarding the MTFs. Can we be sure, all MTFs are fully comparable, that the measurement procedure didn't change over the last one or two decades? If not, comparing MTFs is pointless. Will we be able to spot the sharpness difference other than by printing A0 or at 200%? Much I read here is pure speculation, in my opinion. And if it indeed shows a tiny sharpness advantage at 100%, this doesn't help at all if you don't have the skill to get the most out of it. And with MF it is not easy to use in a faster paced environment.
Personally, I see this lens as a collectors toy, in light of other cheaper and more lightweight options. Regarding the quality my 85/1.8g delivers stopped down at 300Euros and 300something gramms and it is no match to the Batis I own. The market will be small too, SAR shows about 9% of the readers interested. If some people are happy, however, why not.Let's not forget that Zeiss wants to address the video market with the Loxia line.
The shared 52mm filter thread (barrel diameter), mechanical MF and aperture de-clicking may not make any difference for still shooters but it could be crucial for video work when matching lenses.
It's irrelevant to discuss AF vs MF as a preference. If you don't want MF, the Loxia line is not for you regardless of the IQ, price or size.
DavidBM wrote: freaklikeme wrotephilip_pj wroteCZ don't talk much about APD. Perhaps one of the first mentions I recall was in relation to the CY 100-300 (it has three such elements), and we all know how that one works.It just doesn't look to me like they're getting the level of correction out of the design they get with other implementations. It looks like they intentionally went a little old school with the lens to me.Based on the samples? The MTFs look like it's got amazing correction....
Definitely the samples, which look good, they're just not what I expected after having seen the MTFs.
So for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.
I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).
I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
tzhang4284 wrote:
So for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.
I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).
I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now). ...Show more →
It looks like a winner optically, but the Batis and GM are also excellent. I think the only way this new lens makes sense is if you shoot video and need this focal length to augment other Loxia lenses you own. I see no significant advantage and a few disadvantages of this vs the Batis or GM for stills.
tzhang4284 wrote:
So for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.
I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).
I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now). ...Show more →
It looks like a winner optically, but the Batis and GM are also excellent. I think the only way this new lens makes sense is if you shoot video and need this focal length to augment other Loxia lenses you own. I see no significant advantage and a few disadvantages of this vs the Batis or GM for stills.
tzhang4284 wrote:
So for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.
I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).
I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now). ...Show more →
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.