fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar

  
 
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.13 #1Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteThanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.
It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.

It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.
Cool. Do you want to throw my Summicron 90 in to that test? It would likely save me a rental. I'd be happy to send it out once you get your Sonnar.
I am curious about the 90AA and never tested it. Let's just say my Summarit is not optimized for long distances and that was surprising to me. It just can't compare to the 85ZM, Batis 85 or 85GM even at stop-down apertures.


Yeah, I don't have the AA, just the pre-A, and I don't expect it to keep up with the Loxia at landscape distances. The center could at like apertures, mid-frame would catch up at f/5.6, corners at f/11 (though they're not terrible at f/8). It's mid-range to close focus where I think the two would be much more comparable, from the looks of the sample.

The AA at landscape distances is much more like the APO-Elmarit 100. Excellent across the frame resolution at f/2.8 that peaks at f/5.6 with lots of crisp, well-defined detail. That lens could probably make the Loxia struggle a bit to keep up. I've thought about replacing the 100 with an 90 AA, but the 100's a much better close-focuser, being a macro lens and all, so it ends up being worth it's bag weight as a excellent all-arounder.

For what it's worth, all three of my Leica APO teles (100, 180, 280/2.8) hold their resolution well over long distances. The 280 really needs f/5.6 to get there, the 100 starts to shine at f/4, and the 180 truly only needs to be stopped down to gain depth. If you think about adding a mid-tele to your landscape line-up, it's worth a look. It's got resolution to spare.

Landscape distance, wide open...

a7rII_APO-E180_Suburban_Noir by Bradley Clemens, on Flickr

From the back of the amphitheater, wide open, holding the camera above my head, cropped to about 20MP...

a7rII_APOElmarit180_Decemberists by Bradley Clemens, on Flickr

Close (2m), on the a7II, and I think at f/4...

a7II_APOElmarit180_AtHome by Bradley Clemens, on Flickr

If this lens has a weakness, I haven't found it.
Sep 16, 2016 at 01:49 AM
Viramati
Offline
Details
p.13 #2Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tn1krr wrote:
tzhang4284 wroteSo for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).

I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.

I have to say that I disagree with this analysis of the FE90 macro for landscape work. My copy on the A7rII just gives stunning sharpness and micro detail across the frame and into the extreme corners by f5.6 at infinity. It's only downsize is it's size but IMO it has the best implementation of manual focussing of any of the Sony and Zony lenses and is just so versatile and one of Sony's best lenses. I'm sure the Loxia's IQ will be stunning (as is my Loxia 21) but it's not a lens for me
Sep 16, 2016 at 02:11 AM
tn1krr
Offline
Details
p.13 #3Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Viramati wrote:
tn1krr wrote
tzhang4284 wroteSo for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).

I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.
I have to say that I disagree with this analysis of the FE90 macro for landscape work. My copy on the A7rII just gives stunning sharpness and micro detail across the frame and into the extreme corners by f5.6 at infinity. It's only downsize is it's size but IMO it has the best implementation of manual focussing of any of the Sony and Zony lenses and is just so versatile and one of Sony's best lenses. I'm sure the Loxia's IQ will be stunning (as is my Loxia 21) but it's not a lens for me


I'm only telling what some very respected testers have found out and what my own comparative testing has shown. In context I have no doubt that A7R II + FE 90/2.8 can accomplish resolution unattainable just a few years ago (even at infinity), but today, according to several sources there are better options available to long distances

Lensrentals OLAF test at infinity shows Canon 100/2.8L and Macro Planar 100 beating the FE 90/2.8 clearly

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2015/10/sony-e-mount-lens-sharpness-bench-tests/

Yet at macro distance tables turn, Sony is best

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2016/08/more-photogeekery-finite-conjugate-mtf-bench-tests-for-macro-lenses/

Jim Kasson's test at longer distances, conclusions. Contains link to start of the test.

http://blog.kasson.com/?p=13717

Jim has also demonstrated how stellar the FE 90/2.8 is at macro distance before diffraction limits. Interestingly the Coastal Optics 60 seems to handle diffraction better than others

http://blog.kasson.com/?p=14871

dxomark also test on rather short distances, again FE 90/2.8 is stunningly good. To me these start to show a pattern and I can comparatively see it with my own lenses too.
Sep 16, 2016 at 02:49 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.13 #4Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tn1krr wrote:
Viramati wrote
tn1krr wrote
tzhang4284 wroteSo for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).

I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.
I have to say that I disagree with this analysis of the FE90 macro for landscape work. My copy on the A7rII just gives stunning sharpness and micro detail across the frame and into the extreme corners by f5.6 at infinity. It's only downsize is it's size but IMO it has the best implementation of manual focussing of any of the Sony and Zony lenses and is just so versatile and one of Sony's best lenses. I'm sure the Loxia's IQ will be stunning (as is my Loxia 21) but it's not a lens for me
I'm only telling what some very respected testers have found out and what my own comparative testing has shown. In context I have no doubt that A7R II + FE 90/2.8 can accomplish resolution unattainable just a few years ago (even at infinity), but today, according to several sources there are better options available to long distances

Lensrentals OLAF test at infinity shows Canon 100/2.8L and Macro Planar 100 beating the FE 90/2.8 clearly

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2015/10/sony-e-mount-lens-sharpness-bench-tests/

Yet at macro distance tables turn, Sony is best

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2016/08/more-photogeekery-finite-conjugate-mtf-bench-tests-for-macro-lenses/

Jim Kasson's test at longer distances, conclusions. Contains link to start of the test.

http://blog.kasson.com/?p=13717

Jim has also demonstrated how stellar
...Show more →

I think it is easy to reconcile these two views. The 90 2.8 does indeed give stunning detail at infinity for landscapes, or at least mine does. But unlike at macro distances where it's class leading, there are even slightly better lenses around for infinity use. But not so much better that, if you were a macro enthusiast, you should race out and buy a dedicated infinity use short tele as well, unless you can totally afford it and don't imagine you'll be making better images as a consequence. Of course you might have other reasons for a second short tele that happens to be better (not everyone would pack the 2.8/90 macro on a long hiking trip for instance. But if you are buying another lens so you can have the best possible infinity performance as well as best possible macro performance, then it's probably with your gear enthusiasts hat on rather than your artists hat on given how good they all are. Nothing wrong with that, but it's good to distinguish what you need for techically excellent images from what you'd like because it's state of the art.
Sep 16, 2016 at 03:38 AM
Viramati
Offline
Details
p.13 #5Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tn1krr wrote:
Viramati wrote
tn1krr wrote
tzhang4284 wroteSo for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).

I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.
I have to say that I disagree with this analysis of the FE90 macro for landscape work. My copy on the A7rII just gives stunning sharpness and micro detail across the frame and into the extreme corners by f5.6 at infinity. It's only downsize is it's size but IMO it has the best implementation of manual focussing of any of the Sony and Zony lenses and is just so versatile and one of Sony's best lenses. I'm sure the Loxia's IQ will be stunning (as is my Loxia 21) but it's not a lens for me
I'm only telling what some very respected testers have found out and what my own comparative testing has shown. In context I have no doubt that A7R II + FE 90/2.8 can accomplish resolution unattainable just a few years ago (even at infinity), but today, according to several sources there are better options available to long distances

Lensrentals OLAF test at infinity shows Canon 100/2.8L and Macro Planar 100 beating the FE 90/2.8 clearly

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2015/10/sony-e-mount-lens-sharpness-bench-tests/

Yet at macro distance tables turn, Sony is best

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2016/08/more-photogeekery-finite-conjugate-mtf-bench-tests-for-macro-lenses/

Jim Kasson's test at longer distances, conclusions. Contains link to start of the test.

http://blog.kasson.com/?p=13717

Jim has also demonstrated how stellar
...Show more →
I don't doubt that there will be lenses that are marginally better than the FE 90 G for landscape work but I was really trying to say that for versatility this is a lens that is hard to beat

Sep 16, 2016 at 03:46 AM
bjornthun
Offline
Details
p.13 #6Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
The Sony 90/2.8 G has some curvature of field at infinity distances, so some care is needed when focusing the lens to ensure edge to edge sharpness. Maybe there is some correlation to the MTF there?

Edited on Sep 16, 2016 at 04:06 AM · View previous versions
Sep 16, 2016 at 04:05 AM
tn1krr
Offline
Details
p.13 #7Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
I think it is easy to reconcile these two views. The 90 2.8 does indeed give stunning detail at infinity for landscapes, or at least mine does. But unlike at macro distances where it's class leading, there are even slightly better lenses around for infinity use. But not so much better that, if you were a macro enthusiast, you should race out and buy a dedicated infinity use short tele as well, unless you can totally afford it and don't imagine you'll be making better images as a consequence. Of course you might have other reasons for a second short
...Show more →

True, though this originated from user who said 85% of shooting is landscape, street etc. I have Batis 85 and FE 90/2.8, because I cannot live without a macro lens, yet I do not find the macro fast, fast focusing or small/light enough for my other uses on that focal length. Just carried a small sports/camera backpack with A7R II with FE 16-35, FE 35/2.8, FE 55/1.8 and Batis 85 (50 miles in 4 days). The FE 90/2.8 would have been too big to conveniently fit into that bag, so sometimes even the size difference plays a part.

And since this is a gear forum/discussion I think sharing even somewhat nuanced, if real/measurable, differences should be encouraged.

Edited on Sep 16, 2016 at 04:32 AM · View previous versions
Sep 16, 2016 at 04:06 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.13 #8Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
I had a fairly long tryout of the FE90 Macro, and I really loved that lens. While it is not an in-your-face type of rendering, like some other macros (Zeiss 50Mp and 100 Mp, CV 125, for example), it does bring out the detail more than the Loxia 85. The Loxia 85 is exceptionally good at reproducing the ambiance, the atmosphere of a scene. In this respect, my forum-pal Pascal says it is as good as the Otus 85 which he owns. He brought back pics from Australia with delightful restitution of mist, clouds, dust, smoke. This sort of rendering is the purview of really excellent lenses, and not what the FE90 macro was designed for as a priority. As said before, this doesn't mean that the FE90 is weak in this respect, not at all, just that the Loxia is startlingly good at that, unspectacular though it is.
Sep 16, 2016 at 04:14 AM
Viramati
Offline
Details
p.13 #9Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tn1krr wrote:
Viramati wrote
tn1krr wrote
tzhang4284 wroteSo for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15% of the time for causal portraits with a generally patient subject (the girlfriend).

I've ruled out both the Sony 90mm f2.8 (which seems superb on sharpness) and the Sony 85mm GM on size and the 85mm f4 on not being native (i'm done playing with adapted lenses for now).
Ruling out the FE 90/2.8 Macro for heavy landscape is a good idea and makes a lot of sense. While it is stellar for macro range it loses sharpness significantly on longer focus distances and lands clearly behind Batis 85 near infinity. This has been demonstrated for example by Jim Kasson's and lensrentals testing and having both lenses it is really not that hard to see by oneself if similar frames from both lenses are compared.
I have to say that I disagree with this analysis of the FE90 macro for landscape work. My copy on the A7rII just gives stunning sharpness and micro detail across the frame and into the extreme corners by f5.6 at infinity. It's only downsize is it's size but IMO it has the best implementation of manual focussing of any of the Sony and Zony lenses and is just so versatile and one of Sony's best lenses. I'm sure the Loxia's IQ will be stunning (as is my Loxia 21) but it's not a lens for me
I'm only telling what some very respected testers have found out and what my own comparative testing has shown. In context I have no doubt that A7R II + FE 90/2.8 can accomplish resolution unattainable just a few years ago (even at infinity), but today, according to several sources there are better options available to long distances

Lensrentals OLAF test at infinity shows Canon 100/2.8L and Macro Planar 100 beating the FE 90/2.8 clearly

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2015/10/sony-e-mount-lens-sharpness-bench-tests/

Yet at macro distance tables turn, Sony is best

https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2016/08/more-photogeekery-finite-conjugate-mtf-bench-tests-for-macro-lenses/

Jim Kasson's test at longer distances, conclusions. Contains link to start of the test.

http://blog.kasson.com/?p=13717

Jim has also demonstrated how stellar
...Show more →

I rather like Jim's way of concluding his view of the FE90 "I found it merely excellent". Not often you hear 'merely' and 'excellent' in the same sentence. Anyway If I wanted a 90mm lens for landscape only I'm sure the Loxia will be hard to better
Sep 16, 2016 at 04:27 AM
Jannik Peters
Offline
Details
p.13 #10Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
philber wrote:
it does bring out the detail more than the Loxia 85. .


That's what I've always thought about that lens. I'd describe it as a transparent look.. I often know that a picture as been taken with the 2.8/90 Macro before I read the EXIF/description.
Sep 16, 2016 at 04:31 AM
DavidBM
Offline
Details
p.13 #11Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tn1krr wrote:
DavidBM wroteI think it is easy to reconcile these two views. The 90 2.8 does indeed give stunning detail at infinity for landscapes, or at least mine does. But unlike at macro distances where it's class leading, there are even slightly better lenses around for infinity use. But not so much better that, if you were a macro enthusiast, you should race out and buy a dedicated infinity use short tele as well, unless you can totally afford it and don't imagine you'll be making better images as a consequence. Of course you might have other reasons for a second short tele that happens to be better (not everyone would pack the 2.8/90 macro on a long hiking trip for instance. But if you are buying another lens so you can have the best possible infinity performance as well as best possible macro performance, then it's probably with your gear enthusiasts hat on rather than your artists hat on given how good they all are. Nothing wrong with that, but it's good to distinguish what you need for techically excellent images from what you'd like because it's state of the art.
True, though this originated from user who said 85% of shooting is landscape, street etc. I have Batis 85 and FE 90/2.8, because I cannot live without a macro lens, yet I do not find the macro fast, fast focusing or small/light enough for my other uses on that focal length. Just carried a small sports/camera backpack with A7R II with FE 16-35, FE 35/2.8, FE 55/1.8 and Batis 85 (50 miles in 4 days). The FE 90/2.8 would have been too big to conveniently fit into that bag, so sometimes even the size difference plays a part.

And since this
...Show more →

Sure, I don't disagree: if did mainly non-Macro I wouldn't choose the 90, however good it is. Mainly for ergonomic reasons, although I think I get just perceptibly better results at infinity with Batis. And it is a great, great macro - good enough that I find myself using it when I really would prefer a 50mm FOV just because my own 50 is not as good.

And I agree that in a gear forum it's fine to talk about both merely measurable and just perceptible as well as measurable differneces. It's fun, and I certainly do it all the time. For example a question that has me *very* interested at the moment iis whether the slight measured advantage of the new Loxia 85 is perceptible against the ZM 85, for instance.

But I also think that in a gear forum it's good to sometimes address the issue - which is a gear issue - of which level of gear will give (for example) sufficiently good results for a technically excellent, largish print with detail from edge to edge. At one end the answer is clear: not a kit zoom. At the other end the answer is also clear: any of these fine short teles we have been talking about. But there is an interesting (and legitimately gear rather than artistic) question where the cutoff is (and of course that cutoff will depend on various factors)

So in reminding anyone that needs reminding (maybe it's no-one, and I wasn't assuming that you did) that likely all these lenses are above that cutoff, I didn't take myself to be making one of those "the gear doesn't matter its all your vision" posts, but rather answering a gear question - but a different gear question from the nonetheless fascinating "which is best" or "what are the subtle rendering differences" questions.
Sep 16, 2016 at 05:06 AM
Chris_88
Offline
Details
p.13 #12Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
DavidBM wrote:
Sure, I don't disagree: if did mainly non-Macro I wouldn't choose the 90, however good it is. Mainly for ergonomic reasons, although I think I get just perceptibly better results at infinity with Batis. And it is a great, great macro - good enough that I find myself using it when I really would prefer a 50mm FOV just because my own 50 is not as good.

And I agree that in a gear forum it's fine to talk about both merely measurable and just perceptible as well as measurable differneces. It's fun, and I certainly do it all the time.
...Show more →

I do think it's indeed worth pointing out the issue of diminishing returns (and the highly individual financial/performance-based cut off line) from time to time. Thanks for that, David. Unless you print very large, I would think that other factors (support, wind, haze, heat waves, technique, whatever) would influence the quality of the picture far more than whatever very good/excellent 85/90mm lenses you're using. I know this is probably an unpopular opinion in a gear forum, but having an extraordinary talented group of regular participants here helps in making many lenses discussed here, look very good. Often these are expensive lenses, but lesser photographers would get far less out of them.

Philippe has proven that point with the Loxia review on DearSusan. Except that he and Pascal still manage to make lenses they like less than the Loxia look good through the pictures that accompany their great reviews. Same goes for Phillip, Jannik and Bastian, Fred and Guy's reviews here, and many others here who don't do reviews, but "just" keep posting excellent pictures in the big thread (Joshua, Charles, Werner, Helena, Ronny, Greggf and many more).
Sep 16, 2016 at 05:33 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.13 #13Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
tzhang4284 wrote:
So for those with the Batis 85, if given the choice between the Batis 85 and the new Loxia 85, who would be willing to take their chances with the Loxia instead of the Batis assuming the claims about the image quality is consistent with reviews + MTF charts + sample photos.

I'm in the market for one of these two lenses - was hoping the Loxia tele would be a slam dunk, which it isn't but it seems to be a very sharp lens. I would use this 85% of the time for landscapes, street and travel photography and 15%
...Show more →

I think that decision comes down to whether you would prefer AF or MF. Based on the MTFs, I think the Loxia will have slightly better IQ for landscapes, but you won't notice it unless you print very big and look close. I think the bokeh of the Loxia will be a bit cleaner too--the Batis shows some onion rings in the bokeh balls. On the other hand, the faster aperture of the Batis is likely to be useful to many people. So, personally I would rather have the Loxia, but I much prefer manual focus. For someone who prefers AF, I think the Batis is an excellent choice.
Sep 16, 2016 at 06:20 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.13 #14Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
From testing the Batis and owning it on center wide open it's extremely good even a good portion on center. Where the Batis is less of a landscape lens is the corners are good but it takes to at least F8 for that ultimate coverage across the frame maybe even 6.3 and it may have some odd bokeh for a lot of folks and not exactly round bokeh balls , why some folks like the GM better because the bokeh balls are rounder and onion rings are less, also I like the bokeh better on the GM. Now really this is being pretty critical since the Batis 85 is a really good lens and I would say it's really the big brother to the 55 in many ways. They are more a generalist type of lens with fast AF good aperture speed but not so great manual focusing ( that's a human feel factor ) . Now this new Loxia looks promising it still would be hard for a Batis owner to give it up. Batis is faster, cheaper, lighter and more designed for wide open use. The Loxia advantages are across the set is just flat out better focusing feel , very good stopped down for landscape use and a better build. But even the 50 takes a little bit in the corners but they have a nice look to them , more a smoother tonal range in look or character if you will. The one issue with this new 85 is weight , size and speed . This is a video lens with a still lens sidebar. Just a lot of very good 85 out there or 90 if you will. Now we are assuming it might have a better look to it with nice bokeh and some folks will gravitate to that more . Most of us know how nice the 21 and 50 are for instance. So there is a lot of hope it will follow that pattern.

The real question you have to ask yourself is speed important or not, is bokeh win out or not , how about your corners where do you want excellent to be at 5.6 or at f8 as part of this buying process. Obviously money plays a roll. For me it's smack in the middle of two lenses I have and does not replace either one of them or both. So I'll stick with two lenses that serve me better overal for many types of shooting,the GM 85 and ZM 85. Now that's two lenses in the same focal length. If you wanted only one than I say the Batis offers the best balance over the Loxia but you gotta like the results and that should come first before anything. If you hate it than the money is not spent correctly. Tough choices here since there are many options. The length of this thread proofs that as we read each other's responses and choices . Not the easiest choices but you have to decide what's the best balance for you. Not one lens in 85/90 does it all well. Okay need another espresso. Lol
Sep 16, 2016 at 07:29 AM
ecarlino
Offline
Details
p.13 #15Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Guy, good analysis (although it sounds like you might be leaning towards dating the Loxia 85, the other girls should be starting to get jealous about now),

one Q: regarding the 85GM and 85/4ZM - optically, is the 85GM close enough to the ZM at landscape distances stopped down that if it were not such a big thing to lug around it could be your landscape lens as well? in other words, if weight/size were not a factor, could the 85GM be the 1 lens for you at that foc len? i was surprised when i compared the Batis 85 and 85GM at landscape distances at f/5.8 and f/8 how sharp the GM was into the corners - i mean, REALLY sharp.
Sep 16, 2016 at 08:18 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.13 #16Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
The GM could very well do landscape it does have the corners and distance for it, bring a sherpa though. Lol
Sep 16, 2016 at 08:47 AM
Steve Spencer
Online
Details
p.13 #17Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
It is true there are many good choices at 85mm. Just taking the current Zeiss and Sony line up. You have the Sony GM 85 f/1.4, the Otus 85 f/1.4, the Milvus 85 f/1.4, the Batis 85 f/1.8, the Loxia 85 f/1.4, and the ZM 85 f/4. These are all excellent lenses in their own right and there are compelling arguments for each of them. Then there are a boatload of legacy lenses and other third party lenses. There is a ton of choice and many excellent options.

I have the Milvus 85 f/1.4 which is a very large and heavy but wonderful lens. For me it will just get use in the studio and for video. I will add this Loxia 85 which will get some video use and be a nice all arounder. I also have the Leica M 90 cron AA, which will probably get more use than the Loxia as it is smaller, faster, and lighter. I will probably typically take the Leica M 90 AA, but if I planned to do a lot of portraits then the Loxia. Then I have the Leica M 90 f/4 Macro when I really want to go small and lighter. It is smaller and lighter than the ZM 85 f/4 and does macro to boot. Those are my personal decisions, but there are so many good ways to set up this focal length it becomes a very personal decision very fast.
Sep 16, 2016 at 09:10 AM
GMPhotography
Offline
Details
p.13 #18Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
geez and I thought I was bad with two 85s. Lol

It really is tough there are a lot of choices here. I honestly feel Zeiss just wanted to fill the Loxia line up more than anything and a lot of video folks will gladly pay 1400 for a lens in this focal length. Bottom line it just gives us more options. For still shooters even more choices. I honestly don't think there is a bad choices amongst all these 85 and 90. I shot a lot of them in the old days all very very good and for lens designers a easy lens to build as well.
Sep 16, 2016 at 09:15 AM
naturephoto1
Offline
Details
p.13 #19Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Fred Miranda wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
Fred Miranda wrote
freaklikeme wroteThanks, and I wish you cooler weather. It's been in the 70's here this week- a very nice change.
It's much cooler here in San Clemente right now.

It would be helpful to test the new Loxia 85/2.4 side-by-side with the ZM version at several apertures. I will do that when I get mine and also throw the 85GM in the mix.
Cool. Do you want to throw my Summicron 90 in to that test? It would likely save me a rental. I'd be happy to send it out once you get your Sonnar.
I am curious about the 90AA and never tested it. Let's just say my Summarit is not optimized for long distances and that was surprising to me. It just can't compare to the 85ZM, Batis 85 or 85GM even at stop-down apertures.


Hi Fred,

The Leica M 90mm f2.5 or f2.4 Summarit lens may not be as good as the 85ZM,Batis 85 or 85GM even stoped down at distance, but the lens may be much better at this than you think.

Below is image taken with my tripod mounted A7rM V3 and my 90mm f2.5 Summarit at ISO 100, f11 with the second image at 100%. These are straight out of the camera with all of the LR defaults with focusing on the chimneys on houses hundreds of feet away and taken out my rear Kitchen door.

Additionally, the next 2 images were taken with my stock A7r on my Cambo Actus with my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N Enlarger lens that were taken a different day from the same location also focused on the same chimneys with the camera and lens set to ISO 100 at f11.

Rich






A7rM V3 and my 90mm f2.5 Summarit at ISO 100, f11







A7rM V3 and my 90mm f2.5 Summarit at ISO 100, f11- 100% Crop







Stock A7r on my Cambo Actus with my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N Enlarger lens, ISO 100 at f11







Stock A7r on my Cambo Actus with my Rodenstock 80mm f4 Apo Rodagon N Enlarger lens, ISO 100 at f11-100% Crop



Edited on Sep 16, 2016 at 10:42 AM · View previous versions
Sep 16, 2016 at 10:36 AM
philber
Offline
Details
p.13 #20Official: Loxia 85mm f/2.4 Sonnar
Steve Spencer wrote:
the Loxia 85 f/1.4,


Haha, nice Freudian slip, Steve!


As I wrote earlier, I never owned a Cron 90AA, but did try one out, and owned a 75. I'd be very interested to see how yours compares to a Loxia 85. I was surprised how little it concedes to the Otus, so...
Sep 16, 2016 at 10:37 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister