fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016IDXII with corrupted RAW files

  
 
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #1IDXII with corrupted RAW files
charlyw wrote:
HKFEVER wroteCanon is waiting for its own firmware to save its repetition
If I were you I would shut up about Canon - they are doing more than can be expected to fix someone else problem!


This is not fair, Canon should fully test their share before releasing this 1DXII.

This is not fair, Sandisk should full refund or replace its not up to spec. CFast card.

This is not fair, without speaking out and putting pressure on Canon in internet, do you thing Canon nor Sandisk will care, ..


Jul 04, 2016 at 07:49 AM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.6 #2IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
This is not fair, Canon should fully test their share before releasing this 1DXII.

And you are prepared to spend $20k for the 1DxII when it is fully tested against all available memory cards? I'd bet you aren't willing to spend more money just for those tests to be made. And how would you test for hardware that at the time of the tests isn't even available yet - you have to rely on the specification. Nobody with a sane mind would expect a manufacturer to test all combinations of third party devices to work...

HKFEVER wrote:
This is not fair, Sandisk should full refund or replace its not up to spec. CFast card.

Assuming that they have something to replace them with - at the moment. A fix for such a problem isn't easily done and for the fix to be propagated to the point of sale takes time.

HKFEVER wrote:
This is not fair, without speaking out and putting pressure on Canon in internet, do you thing Canon nor Sandisk will care, ..

Canon already issued a fix for someone elses problem (already cameras have been shipped with firmware 1.0.2 which uses a workaround), again it takes time to test the update process (it's different to ship a product with new firmware against having the user - who will make mistakes - upgrade it, so additional tests and thus delays are inevitable) - so Canon went far beyond what anyone can expect!

Jul 04, 2016 at 08:05 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #3IDXII with corrupted RAW files
charlyw wrote:
HKFEVER wroteThis is not fair, Canon should fully test their share before releasing this 1DXII.
And you are prepared to spend $20k for the 1DxII when it is fully tested against all available memory cards? I'd bet you aren't willing to spend more money just for those tests to be made. And how would you test for hardware that at the time of the tests isn't even available yet - you have to rely on the specification. Nobody with a sane mind would expect a manufacturer to test all combinations of third party devices to work...

HKFEVER wroteThis is not fair, Sandisk should full refund or replace its not up to spec. CFast card.
Assuming that they have something to replace them with - at the moment. A fix for such a problem
...Show more →
HKFEVER wroteThis is not fair, without speaking out and putting pressure on Canon in internet, do you thing Canon nor Sandisk will care, ..


Wish I was in USA, then I will ask for full refund of the CFast card.

Unfortunately, I only have 7-10 days to ask for replacement for product has failure.

In other terms, that mean Canon should replace the not up to spec. Sandisk CFast card that came in the premium pack. Not asking users to swallow the not up to spec. Sandisk CFast card that Canon sell together with their camera.
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:25 AM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.6 #4IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
Unfortunately, I only have 7-10 days to ask for replacement for product has failure.


Is it Canon's fault that your area has no consumer protection to speak of? Maybe that's why products are increasingly more expensive the better the area's consumer protection is...

Besides that the CFast isn't defective - it's just buggy and Canon issued a fix to work around that bug...
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:28 AM
kosin
Offline
Details
p.6 #5IDXII with corrupted RAW files

charlyw wrote:
And how would you test for hardware that at the time of the tests isn't even available yet - you have to rely on the specification. Nobody with a sane mind would expect a manufacturer to test all combinations of third party devices to work...



I would assume that Canon at least thoroughly tested CFast cards that they sold with cameras around the world. Not like these cards were just introduced to the market. These were available way before the 1DxII hit the shelves. And I bet, the same cards were supplied to beta testers as well.

I believe that problem is on Canon's side because file corruption exist also on Lexar cards...
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:32 AM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.6 #6IDXII with corrupted RAW files
kosin wrote:
I would assume that Canon at least thoroughly tested CFast cards that they sold with cameras around the world.

And if those CFast that they tested with came with a different firmware revision that didn't yet use the 16Mb cache - nobody could have ever found the error...

Jul 04, 2016 at 08:38 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #7IDXII with corrupted RAW files
charlyw wrote:
HKFEVER wroteUnfortunately, I only have 7-10 days to ask for replacement for product has failure.
Is it Canon's fault that your area has no consumer protection to speak of? Maybe that's why products are increasingly more expensive the better the area's consumer protection is...

Besides that the CFast isn't defective - it's just buggy and Canon issued a fix to work around that bug...



I really can't understand your POV, .
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:38 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #8IDXII with corrupted RAW files
charlyw wrote:
kosin wroteI would assume that Canon at least thoroughly tested CFast cards that they sold with cameras around the world.
And if those CFast that they tested with came with a different firmware revision that didn't yet use the 16Mb cache - nobody could have ever found the error...



What is the average raw file size in 1DXII?
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:42 AM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.6 #9IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
charlyw wrote
kosin wroteI would assume that Canon at least thoroughly tested CFast cards that they sold with cameras around the world.
And if those CFast that they tested with came with a different firmware revision that didn't yet use the 16Mb cache - nobody could have ever found the error...
What is the average raw file size in 1DXII?


Irrelevant, the way the bug in the cache management on the card manifests itself points clearly to a cache flush problem - to ensure that all relevant data has been written the new firmware seems to fill the cache fully with data for the imagesave.bin (or whatever it's called) file...
Jul 04, 2016 at 08:51 AM
ross.thomas
Offline
Details
p.6 #10IDXII with corrupted RAW files
Just got my first corrupted file!
Jul 04, 2016 at 02:06 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #11IDXII with corrupted RAW files
ross.thomas wrote:
Just got my first corrupted file!


My Lexar 3600X has been working fine since the first day.

The 128GB Sandisk cames with the premium pack, has corrupted Raw consistently.

The 128GB Sandisk that I bought from camera store, is back to Sandisk HK and waiting for their verdict,
Jul 05, 2016 at 06:46 AM
kosin
Offline
Details
p.6 #12IDXII with corrupted RAW files


ross.thomas wrote:
Just got my first corrupted file!


Which card?
Jul 05, 2016 at 07:25 AM
ross.thomas
Offline
Details
p.6 #13IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
ross.thomas wroteJust got my first corrupted file!
My Lexar 3600X has been working fine since the first day.

The 128GB Sandisk cames with the premium pack, has corrupted Raw consistently.

The 128GB Sandisk that I bought from camera store, is back to Sandisk HK and waiting for their verdict,


kosin wrote:
ross.thomas wroteJust got my first corrupted file!
Which card?


It was on the Sandisk 64 GB card that came with the camera. I'm currently using the Lexar 128gb 3500 and haven't had any issues with it yet.
Jul 05, 2016 at 12:48 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #14IDXII with corrupted RAW files
I have owned 4 Sandisk CFast, 2 were replaced either by Canon or by Sandisk dealer.

Form their corruption count, some cards are worst that others, ie. it is the quality or spec. issues.
Jul 05, 2016 at 08:27 PM
Fern Trujillo
Offline
Details
p.6 #15IDXII with corrupted RAW files
KKFung wrote:
I got my 1Dx2 yesterday and have a flyer as below. Mine already have firmware ver. 1.0.2, seem I can use Sandisk but I don't have either Lexar or Sandisk CFast on hand now

https://c6.staticflickr.com/8/7299/27439506813_786f9b9f98_b.jpg無標題 by KK Fung, 於 Flickr


I received my 1DxII finally yesterday, and saw this as well.

There is one problem however, I downloaded Sanitize from Sandisk as per the instruction but the program does not recognize that there is a Sandisk card inserted in the computer.

A call to Sandisk was less than fruitful they at least the ones I spoke with had no idea what's going on or how to get their program to recognize their cards.

Frustrating.

I have to honest however all cards eventually go bad but my rate so far has been

Sandisk 3 Lexar 0

Jul 06, 2016 at 07:02 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.6 #16IDXII with corrupted RAW files
What OS did you install the Sandisk software on? For Apple OSX systems, Sandisk states the requirement for 10.10 or 10.11. I'm still on 10.9, not having found a compelling reason to upgrade to the newer versions...
Jul 06, 2016 at 02:30 PM
KKFung
Offline
Details
p.6 #17IDXII with corrupted RAW files
Fern Trujillo wrote:
KKFung wroteI got my 1Dx2 yesterday and have a flyer as below. Mine already have firmware ver. 1.0.2, seem I can use Sandisk but I don't have either Lexar or Sandisk CFast on hand now

https://c6.staticflickr.com/8/7299/27439506813_786f9b9f98_b.jpg無標題 by KK Fung, 於 Flickr
I received my 1DxII finally yesterday, and saw this as well.

There is one problem however, I downloaded Sanitize from Sandisk as per the instruction but the program does not recognize that there is a Sandisk card inserted in the computer.

A call to Sandisk was less than fruitful they at least the ones I spoke with had no idea what's going on or how to get their program to recognize their cards.

Frustrating.

I have to honest however all cards eventually go bad but my rate so far has been

Sandisk 3 Lexar 0



Thanks for share Fern, I think I should borrow some Sandisk cards and reader from my friend to have a test.
Jul 06, 2016 at 08:06 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #18IDXII with corrupted RAW files
KKFung wrote:
Fern Trujillo wrote
KKFung wroteI got my 1Dx2 yesterday and have a flyer as below. Mine already have firmware ver. 1.0.2, seem I can use Sandisk but I don't have either Lexar or Sandisk CFast on hand now

https://c6.staticflickr.com/8/7299/27439506813_786f9b9f98_b.jpg無標題 by KK Fung, 於 Flickr
I received my 1DxII finally yesterday, and saw this as well.

There is one problem however, I downloaded Sanitize from Sandisk as per the instruction but the program does not recognize that there is a Sandisk card inserted in the computer.

A call to Sandisk was less than fruitful they at least the ones I spoke with had no idea what's going on or how to get their program to recognize their cards.

Frustrating.

I have to honest however all cards eventually go bad but my rate so far has been

Sandisk 3 Lexar 0
Thanks for share Fern, I think I should borrow some Sandisk cards and reader from my friend to have a test.


The Sanitize only works with Sandisk reader not Lexar.
Jul 06, 2016 at 08:10 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.6 #19IDXII with corrupted RAW files

CPS called, the new firmware will be posted later on today in their website.
Jul 07, 2016 at 04:21 AM
RonLander
Offline
Details
p.6 #20IDXII with corrupted RAW files
The 1.02 firmware is on the Canon USA support website
Here - Under the "Firmware" tab.

I have installed it on my 1Dx2 and it seems OK. The instructions state to switch the camera OFF after installing the update and then remove the battery for at least 2 seconds. The CF/CFAST card which the update was installed from should be reformatted before using again. The Cfast card should be reformatted also.


Jul 07, 2016 at 04:59 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister