fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2016 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2016IDXII with corrupted RAW files

  
 
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #1IDXII with corrupted RAW files
mogud wrote:
Just a long shot but are the Cfast cards ejected properly from the Mac once copied to the HDD? The reason why I ask is that once files are copied to the Mac and then copied again to another Mac, the corruption seems to occur. If the Cfast card is just removed from the reader and not ejected properly by dragging the CFast icon to the trash, data could be lost and could be the cause of the corruption problem.


Been there done that, tried ejected and tried just pulled out from card reader. No different. Also, according to Canon once finished the read or copy or whatever just pull out the card makes no different ?

Most of the time I eject it
Jun 11, 2016 at 08:40 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #2IDXII with corrupted RAW files
kosin wrote:
HKFEVER wrote
kosin wrote
HKFEVER wroteI am using Lexar 3600X 128GB with Lexar reader, so far so good after 100 pictures,

I don't have fingers to cross any more

kosin wrote
Shutterbug2006 wroteTry a different Cfast card reader?
I was under impression that the OP used different card readers...

If not, it would be the obvious next step. Different card reader or simply connecting connecting the camera via USB.
Are you using just one card reader for all your tests?
I have 3 different CFast card readers:
http://www.pbase.com/hkfever/image/163429045/large.jpg

All the previous random corrupted files were read by Sandisk reader with Sandisk CFast card.

Transcend, did not use it yet.

Lexar 3600X + its thunderbolt reader is the fastest, no issue yet, finger crossed
Keep us posted if you encounter any problems.

Did you have any corrupted files, question marked images, in camera before downloading them to the computer?


Yes, will update whatever I found.

In the first CFast that came with the 1DXII has question marked images. But I was not aware that until download to Mac. I don't preview on camera normally, as a PRO, wakakaka
Jun 11, 2016 at 08:43 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #3IDXII with corrupted RAW files
ggreene wrote:
There is a thread on DPR that lists a Canon phone number to call for 1DX2 problems especially with freeze ups and hanging. You might want to call to report your issues with corrupt files. It's in the 1D forum. I'd post the link but I'm not sure about forum etiquette here at FM.com on such cross links to competitors. I'm sure you can find it.

It has definitely made me glad that I was not an early adopter of the 1DX2. Hopefully Canon can sort it out in time for the Olympics as that would be pretty bad publicity
...Show more →

Will try to dip it out. Or you can PM me.

Canon has no problem, as their factory doesn't affected by nature like Nikon's does
Jun 11, 2016 at 08:45 PM
mogud
Offline
Details
p.3 #4IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
mogud wroteJust a long shot but are the Cfast cards ejected properly from the Mac once copied to the HDD? The reason why I ask is that once files are copied to the Mac and then copied again to another Mac, the corruption seems to occur. If the Cfast card is just removed from the reader and not ejected properly by dragging the CFast icon to the trash, data could be lost and could be the cause of the corruption problem.
Been there done that, tried ejected and tried just pulled out from card reader. No different. Also, according to Canon once finished the read or copy or whatever just pull out the card makes no different ?

Most of the time I eject it


I don't think it's a camera thing IMHO. Given the number of variables being, CFast disk maker, Mac operating system, card reader, all will be pointing to each other as the cause of the problem.

Hope you find the answer.
Jun 11, 2016 at 10:23 PM
melcat
Online
Details
p.3 #5IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wroteBeen there done that, tried ejected and tried just pulled out from card reader. No different. Also, according to Canon once finished the read or copy or whatever just pull out the card makes no different ?

This is absolutely incorrect advice from Canon. A removable volume on Mac (as on all Unix systems) must always be properly dismounted using the operating system before being physcially removed. You may get away with it if nothing has been written to the volume, and OS X may even notice and put up a a dialogue asking you to put the card back, but it's incorrect procedure. It works this way because Unix systems write to the "file buffer cache" in memory and only later, in the background, actually copy stuff from there to the volume.

You may think you didn't write to the card, but if you opened a Finder window on it that will usually write hidden .DS_Store files in those folders.

You should test the suspect card by formatting it on the Mac, then copying a large file onto the card and back off again, and comparing the round-tripped copy of the file with the original one on the Mac using the diff or cmp utilities. If it has changed, you know the card is faulty independent of the camera.
Jun 12, 2016 at 01:09 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #6IDXII with corrupted RAW files
melcat wrote:
HKFEVER wroteBeen there done that, tried ejected and tried just pulled out from card reader. No different. Also, according to Canon once finished the read or copy or whatever just pull out the card makes no different ?
This is absolutely incorrect advice from Canon. A removable volume on Mac (as on all Unix systems) must always be properly dismounted using the operating system before being physcially removed. You may get away with it if nothing has been written to the volume, and OS X may even notice and put up a a dialogue asking you to put the card back, but it's incorrect procedure. It works this way because Unix systems write to the "file buffer cache" in memory and only later, in the background, actually copy stuff from there to the volume.

You may think you didn't
...Show more →

Well understood your points, but the corruption happens in either condition.


Jun 12, 2016 at 01:52 AM
melcat
Online
Details
p.3 #7IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
Well understood your points, but the corruption happens in either condition.


Yes, but did you reformat the card again after removing it the wrong way? If even once removed wrongly in the past, the volume cannot be trusted again until it's been reformatted. (FAT or EXFAT - actually EXFAT has a worse reputation.)
Jun 12, 2016 at 02:32 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #8IDXII with corrupted RAW files


melcat wrote:
HKFEVER wroteWell understood your points, but the corruption happens in either condition.
Yes, but did you reformat the card again after removing it the wrong way? If even once removed wrongly in the past, the volume cannot be trusted again until it's been reformatted. (FAT or EXFAT - actually EXFAT has a worse reputation.)


I think I have never format so many time in my whole life
Jun 12, 2016 at 04:46 AM
brian_sp
Offline
[X]
Details
p.3 #9IDXII with corrupted RAW files
HKFEVER wrote:
I think I have never format so many time in my whole life

check this thread


https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/600984/4806
Jun 12, 2016 at 09:48 PM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #10IDXII with corrupted RAW files
The dues we pay for being on the cutting edge. Worrisome when you can't trust your gear though, isn't it?! Two out of 300 from yesterday..... And, I was incorrect, the corruption is in the same locale on the files.









Jun 13, 2016 at 06:42 AM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #11IDXII with corrupted RAW files
My work flow is the same as HK's, but through Adobe CC. Notice that the corruption we are experiencing is in the same spot on all of our images. Just went back to my folder from yesterday and I don't see any new corruption at this point.
Jun 13, 2016 at 06:51 AM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #12IDXII with corrupted RAW files
I have received advice from the manufacturer of the cards telling me to format the card in a computer/and from the same manufacturers telling me never to do that and only format them in the camera. How would you ever determine who actually knows what they are talking about. I flipped a coin and only format in camera. As far as the "ejecting" routine, don't know about windows, but you should never eject a drive of any kind without dismounting it first on a Mac.
Jun 13, 2016 at 08:18 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #13IDXII with corrupted RAW files
JWilsonphoto wrote:
My work flow is the same as HK's, but through Adobe CC. Notice that the corruption we are experiencing is in the same spot on all of our images. Just went back to my folder from yesterday and I don't see any new corruption at this point.


The corruption happens in the CFast card not the raw file in computer's folder. And it doesn't happen every time you re-visit the CFast card.



Edited on Jun 13, 2016 at 09:21 AM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2016 at 09:12 AM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #14IDXII with corrupted RAW files
JWilsonphoto wrote:
I have received advice from the manufacturer of the cards telling me to format the card in a computer/and from the same manufacturers telling me never to do that and only format them in the camera. How would you ever determine who actually knows what they are talking about. I flipped a coin and only format in camera. As far as the "ejecting" routine, don't know about windows, but you should never eject a drive of any kind without dismounting it first on a Mac.


I only format the card in camera, as computer has so many different format, I can't figure out which format to format, so always use camera to format the cards.

I use CF, SD, ... since the first date they out in the market. And have been pulling them out without ejecting them for so many time on the road, never has problem.

For this CFast new thing, I obey the rule, eject before pull out. But corruption still happens.

Lately, I use Lexar 3600X 128GB, I found out Br will only cache new files.

But with Sandisk, Br will cache files again whenever you plug in.
Jun 13, 2016 at 09:19 AM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #15IDXII with corrupted RAW files
OK HK, I have an official word from the manufacturer (Canon) that CFast cards need to be formatted on a Windows machine prior to use. As I said before I have been advised by memory manufacturers to do that/not do that to their cards so I'm confused. Add to that the fact that I have 30 CF/SDXC/Micro SDXC cards in my arsenal, none have been formatted in anything but the camera they will be shooting in, and none of them have exhibited this problem. Color me doubtful that a computer reformat will solve our problem.

That said, I guess I'll seek out a Windows boat anchor and try it, what have I got to lose? I can't trust the camera until this is fixed and that is not an option for me.
Jun 13, 2016 at 02:09 PM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #16IDXII with corrupted RAW files
Shouldn't we be getting paid big bucks for R&D here HK?
Jun 13, 2016 at 02:11 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #17IDXII with corrupted RAW files
JWilsonphoto wrote:
OK HK, I have an official word from the manufacturer (Canon) that CFast cards need to be formatted on a Windows machine prior to use. As I said before I have been advised by memory manufacturers to do that/not do that to their cards so I'm confused. Add to that the fact that I have 30 CF/SDXC/Micro SDXC cards in my arsenal, none have been formatted in anything but the camera they will be shooting in, and none of them have exhibited this problem. Color me doubtful that a computer reformat will solve our problem.

That said, I guess I'll seek
...Show more →

No way Jose

What happen, a lot of pros don't use Win machine

What should I do this these?
Jun 13, 2016 at 09:29 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #18IDXII with corrupted RAW files
JWilsonphoto wrote:
OK HK, I have an official word from the manufacturer (Canon) that CFast cards need to be formatted on a Windows machine prior to use.


Which format:
- NTFS
- HFS
- UFS
- FAT12, 16, 32
- OS Extended
- exFAT
- Whatelse



Edited on Jun 13, 2016 at 09:54 PM · View previous versions
Jun 13, 2016 at 09:49 PM
HKFEVER
Offline
Details
p.3 #19IDXII with corrupted RAW files
Just got call from CPS HK. Asked me don't bother to find out what is the cause.

- Hold on to your invoice
- Canon will announce in next week or so for the cause of corrupted file.
Jun 13, 2016 at 09:52 PM
JWilsonphoto
Offline
Details
p.3 #20IDXII with corrupted RAW files
I had my son format my 64 and 128 CFast Cards on his Windows machine. The format was NTFS. I put the 128 in my MarkII this evening and shot 500 files, not a single corruption. Any connection? Who knows.
Jun 14, 2016 at 08:45 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister