From what I have tested, I am sure is Sandisk CFast quality issue. My new Lexar 3600X 128GB is fine with 3 different readers and so far 1000+ raw, no issue at all in multi iMacs. I pull the card out from camera and iMac without turn off the camera nor eject, all A OK like previous CFs in my 1DX
dehowie wrote:
Has anyone had a corrupt file with a standard compact flash or only CFast?
Whenever I had RAW files corrupted on a CFast card, they were perfectly fine on a CF card. And this is in the camera, before copying to a computer. So far, no corrupted video files.
Also, after "deep" format on my Mac and another format in the camera, I had no problems with this specific CFast card yet.
And just to remind my situation, my files were showing up as a black screen with a question mark in the camera. They couldn't be copied via computer. They didn't show up as partially corrupted as for OP.
kosin wrote: dehowie wroteHas anyone had a corrupt file with a standard compact flash or only CFast?Whenever I had RAW files corrupted on a CFast card, they were perfectly fine on a CF card. And this is in the camera, before copying to a computer. So far, no corrupted video files.
Also, after "deep" format on my Mac and another format in the camera, I had no problems with this specific CFast card yet.
And just to remind my situation, my files were showing up as a black screen with a question mark in the camera. They couldn't be copied via computer. They didn't show up as partially corrupted as for OP.
From the original CFast card, it has some files show black thumbnail with yellow question mark. Which can't be copy to HD nor open by Br, PS, Lr & DPP4.
HKFEVER wrote: JWilsonphoto wroteAnother 1,000 shots on the same 128GB CFast, but now PC formatted, no sign of a hiccup. Color me skeptical, but so far so good.Did you just preview or open the raw file?
Which program you use to preview or open?
I previewed while shooting, but my analysis is based upon images downloaded to my MacBook Pro an backed up to my RAID. Adobe CC is my preferred post processing tool. Another couple thousand exposures on the 128 GB card with nary a hiccup. Seems like it might be over for me but we'll see. I'll be shooting critical stuff with a back up CF being written to as well.
I have had this same exact issue, using the CFast card and reader, on a 128gb card. My dealer just replaced the card but I haven't tested it yet. I'm going to record to both the CF and CFast card until I can determine if the problem is resolved. 1DX mark II.
Hopefully the potential FW update addresses the need for taking extra shots before powering off. How is that missed in testing? That's not exactly a rare case.
HKFEVER wrote: kosin wroteI just had my first video file corruption on a Lexar card... What sucks is that videos are not written to both cards!
I wonder what CFast cards beta testers used that this issue didn't come up before the camera release?3400, 3500 or 3600?
3400x bought on eBay.
Interestingly, the seller asked me to send this card to Lexar for evaluation and eventual repair/exchange. I guess these cards are in fact original Lexar products.
Canon says it's a Sandisk problem... to me it sounds like files are being cached in volatile memory on the card and then transferred to 'permanent' flash memory, but the last file isn't properly written to flash...
I got a SanDisk 64GB card with the camera and it's probably one of the affected ones (store put their own barcode sticker over the box's barcode sticker, which when I pull off the store's destroyed the original one, making it very difficult to read the product number), but I only used it as an overflow for a CF card during a recent shoot and probably only put about 400 images on it. None appeared to be corrupted, though I haven't inspected them closely. Will wait for the firmware update before using the card extensively.
In the meantime, if shooting CFast cards, it sounds like it might be a good idea to disable the camera's sleep function. I.e. to never power down.