fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

  
 
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.8 #1Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
telyt wrote:
Luvwine wrote
zhangyue wroteHere is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Well, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
...Show more →

How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with R lenses than the SL. I personally would have liked to see higher resolution as well and I do t have a need for 5 frames per second let alone 11, but for some reason, they did not design the camera for me!

By the way, the lossy compression problem is being fixed and only affects a tiny percentage of files. I certainly have not seen it in my images, tho perhaps it is there and I have just not recognized it.
Oct 21, 2015 at 07:41 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.8 #2Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
To be correct, Sony has fixed the lossy RAW compression issue on the A7RII, the 2.0 firmware with the fix came out Monday.
Oct 21, 2015 at 08:01 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #3Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
telyt wrote
Luvwine wrote
zhangyue wroteHere is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Well, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with
...Show more →

I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.
Oct 21, 2015 at 08:04 AM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.8 #4Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
hiepphotog wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
hiepphotog wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
hiepphotog wroteA lot to criticize and a lot to like might work with a $2000 camera. But for a $7k+, I'm not sure I would be willing to make too much compromises. I admit I really like the 50 ISO thing, big EVF, dual slot (mainly because of UHS-II support). I'm not sure about its responsiveness yet, but the GUI does seem to get more complicated. I read most of the reviews out there right now and some said because of the amount of customization, the menu system is similar to Sony's now. However, the lens system is what really kills it for me; too big and heavy.

Again, I thought Leica is the master of making small lenses with high IQ. I guess Karbe is not in the team. Paying this much a camera would require a viable ecosystem into the future, not just to adapt stuff. Sony is already excellent at this, big lens can always be used with a gripped A7. And the future of SL system is medium format size and weight with a competitive FF IQ (but not the top). To me, the look of the camera is irrelevant. I can put up with the ergonomics for light lens, but for big lens, I don't know if that grip (contour-less) is going to be comfortable. In the end, I would consider buying it if it's not for what Jono Black said in his review that its M compatibility is good but not as good as the M240. Again, sound to me like a modded Sony cam (for less than half the price). If anything, the next M with this same tech would be a big hit for Leica.

Sony only gets dethroned when this camera is adopted more by the mass. The difference is academic when Leica can only sell this to a few individuals.
I think you are mischaracterizing Jono Black's review. He said he thought the edges and corners were *slightly* better on the M240, but that was without side by side testing. He also said he shot tons with the a number of M lenses and that, "Results have been excellent, and compare well with those from My Leica M240." So, from this review there is no indication of problems with M lenses. They seem to work well.

This camera seems to work well with Leica lenses that the Sony cameras do not and it works with Leica S lenses that the Sony camera cannot use. So for alt lenses it does seem to work with more lenses that the Sony A7 series. In my book that makes it the champ for alt lenses, but YMMV.
Let me quote that whole paragraph to see if I mischaracterized it:

"For me then, the $64,000 dollar question was whether the Leica SL would perform well enough with Leica M lenses. To that end I dusted down my tripod and headed to the Suffolk coast with my Leica M240, the Leica SL, and my son Silas’s Sony A7 mark 2, together with a selection of Leica lenses which have proved problematic. I took a leaf out of Sean Reid’s book, and did this properly, shooting at f2.8, f4, f5.6 and f8 with each lens, with focus bracketing for each set. I am intending to post the original files and the comparison between the Sony A7 mark 2 and the Leica SL in a later article, but suffice to say, that although the edges and corners of the M240 were slightly better than the SL, the results for the SL were hugely better than those from the Sony A7 mark 2. Sadly, I didn’t have a Sony A7r mark 2, but the cover glass is the same thickness as that on the A7, and there is no reason to suppose that the results will be any better than the A7 mark 2."

He actually used his tripod to do an aperture test, instead of the usual Steve Huff's "non technical" opinion. I think that is pretty conclusive there. I just paraphrased what he said really.

So the champ of Alt lenses? If we actually list all the non-native platforms each camera can actually work with (in the case, you will see. We have working AF adapters for Contax N, Canon EF, Nikon F (prototype), Contax G, Contax 645.

As soon as Leica releases their working Leica S to L adapter, we would no doubt have one for Sony soon by reverse engineering. Sony will be, at least in the near future, a much more popular platform that third party adapter makers would spend more R&D on it. It's hasty at this point to say Leica SL can do more. We're not even sure if it's going to last long. The difference is again academic at best since this Leica is not going to dominate the market by any measure.
So, he says it is hugely better than the stock Sony and the M240 is slightly better in the edges and corners here and later he says the SL is excellent with M lenses and compares well with his M240, and you paraphrase that as the M240 is better than the SL. Sorry, IMO, that paraphrase is a mischaracterization and doesn't paint the full picture of what he is saying. The SL is much better than the Sony A7 II and very close to the performance of the M240 would be a much fairly characterization. And this characterization is important, IMO, because it strongly suggests that the SL has thin cover glass. Your paraphrase can and I think did lead some to believe the SL has thick cover glass.

As far as whether what makes something a king of alt lenses, it is clear we have very different ideas. You seem to be suggesting that wide spread adoption is what will make something the king of alt lenses. From my perspective alt lenses has never been and will never be about wide spread adoption.

Instead for the king of alt lenses I just mean the system that can use the widest array of non-native lenses. I think it is clear that the Leica SL will be that system. It can use M lenses more effectively--to use Juno Black's words it is hugely better. It can use S lenses, and I have some serious doubts that there will ever be third party adapters for the Sony to Leica S. Is there really enough money in S adapters to bother with reverse engineering an adapter for Sony? I kind of doubt it given how many of these lenses are on the market, but I guess we will see. So, IMO, the SL is the most adaptable system out there. The Sony is great for alts and the IBIS is very nice, but being able to use all the wide Ms well, IMO, certainly tips the crown to the SL. A win on points to be sure and not a knock out, but still a win in my book.
Let me re-quote myself then: "In the end, I would consider buying it if it's not for what Jono Black said in his review that its M compatibility is good but not as good as the M240." His later assessment is more like practical shooting, a little smearing with normal shooting would not be as noticeable. A modded Sony would give similar result as well.

As for adaptation, I think you conveniently left out what I have mentioned above. Sony system can currently AF with Canon EF, Nikon F, Contax G, Contax N, Contax 645. Nope, Leica SL can mount Leica S, which can mount Contax 645 (I think), and that's it. That is the here and now. As soon as third party figures out the protocol for Leica L mount to make Canon EF, Nikon F, Contax G, Contax N available for the L mount, they can just reverse engineer what Leica has done with their S-to-L right there. It's just part of the R&D process. Without those third party adapter makers, I doubt Leica (or Sony) would ever have so much adaptability.
Well it still find your original quote to be seriously misleading in how you describe Juno's assessment, but your decision is your decision and I won't belabour the difference in our assessments any more.

With regard to alt, this post makes it even more clear how we have different views of Alt. For me third party AF is not a real criteria for Alt. When I think Alt, I think manual focus and can you use a lens not whether it is AF and that has historically been a common view on this board. I realize that is a very
...Show more →

Agree to disagree then . Whoever is set on buying this camera is not going to be dissuaded by a little more smearing with the M. This camera has a lot more to offer. Personally, I will stick with Sony and possibly get the next iteration of the M.
Oct 21, 2015 at 08:05 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.8 #5Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.


Panasonic certainly does do IBIS, albeit not the better 5-axis kind. The GX7 and GX8 both feature IBIS.

Oct 21, 2015 at 08:05 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.8 #6Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
mawz wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteI would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.
Panasonic certainly does do IBIS, albeit not the better 5-axis kind. The GX7 and GX8 both feature IBIS.



I hadn't realized that, (thanks for the correction) but M 4/3rds IBIS and FF IBIS are likely very different in terms of requirements, so there is reason to hope it might be added by Leica in the future, but it was probably beyond what was possible with this release.
Oct 21, 2015 at 08:09 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.8 #7Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
Luvwine wrote
telyt wrote
Luvwine wrote
zhangyue wroteHere is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Well, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with R lenses than the SL. I personally would have liked to see higher resolution as well and I do t have a need for 5 frames per second let alone 11, but for some reason, they did not design the camera for me!

By the way, the lossy compression problem is being fixed and only affects a tiny percentage of files. I certainly have not seen it in my images, tho perhaps it is there and I have just not recognized it.
I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.


What you say makes total sense. I suspect sourcing and costs and quality of available products affect many design decisions. Lack of available IBIS made a lens based IS system mandatory and this contributes to the size/weight of the lenses and so on.

I am confident that the SL will be a great camera. Whether it is the right camera for me, I doubt due to lack of IBIS, cost, and resolution. Still, it has many lovely features including weather sealing, ISO 50, a great EVF, fast autofocus, good to excellent M wide compatibility, et al.

The fact that the SL raises the bar in some areas is a good thing. A rising tide lifts all boats, after all, and other manufacturers will doubtless see what Leica is doing. It is an exciting, albeit expensive, time to be a photographer. The changes and options are dizzying. We all have to decide for ourselves what the right tool is for us, and for how long. To the extent that new toys, er, tools, inspire us to go out and shoot and make better images, they are successful.

Oct 21, 2015 at 08:23 AM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.8 #8Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
Luvwine wrote
telyt wrote
Luvwine wrote
zhangyue wroteHere is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Well, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with R lenses than the SL. I personally would have liked to see higher resolution as well and I do t have a need for 5 frames per second let alone 11, but for some reason, they did not design the camera for me!

By the way, the lossy compression problem is being fixed and only affects a tiny percentage of files. I certainly have not seen it in my images, tho perhaps it is there and I have just not recognized it.
I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.
...To the extent that new toys, er, tools, inspire us to go out and shoot and make better images, they are successful.



Are we out? . Since yesterday, I have been glued to my computer reading reviews and discussions on this damn Leica SL. I love Leica (and Zeiss) glass, but I don't see this one fits into my style. I already move away from the big DSLR game, don't want to go back.
Oct 21, 2015 at 08:28 AM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.8 #9Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
hiepphotog wrote:
Luvwine wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Luvwine wrote
telyt wrote
Luvwine wroteWell, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with R lenses than the SL. I personally would have liked to see higher resolution as well and I do t have a need for 5 frames per second let alone 11, but for some reason, they did not design the camera for me!

By the way, the lossy compression problem is being fixed and only affects a tiny percentage of files. I certainly have not seen it in my images, tho perhaps it is there and I have just not recognized it.
I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.
...To the extent that new toys, er, tools, inspire us to go out and shoot and make better images, they are successful.
Are we out? . Since yesterday, I have been glued to my computer reading reviews and discussions on this damn Leica SL. I love Leica (and Zeiss) glass, but I don't see this one fits into my style. I already move away from the big DSLR game, don't want to go back.


Agreed! We should all be out taking pics rather than endlessly debating the minutiae of the merits of each new (or even rumored!) camera or lens. Of course, that would make these boards less interesting. We all seem to want the "best" camera, whether that makes a difference in our photography or not. I suspect we would all be better off spending 1/2 of what we do on gear and applying that money to travel expenses for photography....
Oct 21, 2015 at 09:09 AM
johnvanr
Offline
Details
p.8 #10Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
The changes and options are dizzying. We all have to decide for ourselves what the right tool is for us, and for how long. To the extent that new toys, er, tools, inspire us to go out and shoot and make better images, they are successful.




I actually don't think the changes or options mean much anymore. We've reached a plateau where basically every camera north of about $600 will do a good to great job for most applications.

This Leica just tweaks the edges a bit, as do most cameras nowadays from the perspective of going out, shooting and making better images.
Oct 21, 2015 at 09:24 AM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.8 #11Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
hiepphotog wrote
Luvwine wrote
Steve Spencer wrote
Luvwine wrote
telyt wroteI find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL.

As for what you have written, obviously these are different cameras and different features will appeal differently to different users. The SL has a lot to like, but some will not like it's size, some will find the price too high, and some will love it. I personally think perhaps the biggest omission is IBIS and that omission will likely make the Sony A7r2 and A72 better as a practical matter with R lenses than the SL. I personally would have liked to see higher resolution as well and I do t have a need for 5 frames per second let alone 11, but for some reason, they did not design the camera for me!

By the way, the lossy compression problem is being fixed and only affects a tiny percentage of files. I certainly have not seen it in my images, tho perhaps it is there and I have just not recognized it.
I would love IBIS too, but you have to keep in mind that Leica's obvious tech partner in this camera has been Panasonic and they don't do IBIS, so it isn't too surprising that it did not end up this camera. I think it is likely that Panasonic brought many nice things to this camera, (e.g., likely the AF system), but I don't think they have IBIS (ready at least) to contribute.
...To the extent that new toys, er, tools, inspire us to go out and shoot and make better images, they are successful.
Are we out? . Since yesterday, I have been glued to my computer reading reviews and discussions on this damn Leica SL. I love Leica (and Zeiss) glass, but I don't see this one fits into my style. I already move away from the big DSLR game, don't want to go back.
Agreed! We should all be out taking pics rather than endlessly debating the minutiae of the merits of each new (or even rumored!) camera or lens. Of course, that would make these boards less interesting. We all seem to want the "best" camera, whether that makes a difference in our photography or not. I suspect we would all be better off spending 1/2 of what we do on gear and applying that money to travel expenses for photography....


True . I mean the last couple of weeks has not been good for me, and I don't think it's going to get better any time soon. As a Zeiss/Leica shooter on a Sony platform, all the recent announcements from Zeiss and Leica (even Sigma, Canon and that Mitakon) just flooded in right before PhotoPlus. Then now we have Sony's announcement after Photoplus . I'm telling myself I only need 4 lenses after my major cut down last year, but interesting things keep popping up. This is probably my last post in this SL thread (or I hope so).
Oct 21, 2015 at 09:27 AM
miguel_13
Offline
Details
p.8 #12Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Lee Saxon wrote:
Okay, I just noticed this can output 10-bit 4:2:2 over HDMI. The price seems less outlandish when you look at other devices with that feature.

I'm not saying I believe that's fair, or that I have any interest in that feature; just an observation.


This is Panasonic technology, I think what most intrigues me about this SL is what it portends for Panasonic, there can't be a FF mirrorless Panasonic too far around the corner. . .competitively priced . The question is whether it would share the T mount, I don't think Leica has ever done that before (shared a mount with another manufacturer).

re: my original post about prices. Back when I was in the Leica system-mid 80s to mid 90s I never bought a Leica body, R or M mount brand new in a sealed box (except maybe the CLE), like a lot of people I trolled the local used market (which was substantial) and did the occasional Shutterbug deal. The last M body I owned, an M4P was purchased absolutely mint in the box for $850, that was the going price $800 to $900 for a clean one, my R's were less, about the same as an F3 with a motor. Leica lenses were always more than Nikon for the good stuff.

Of course in those days you could buy a pre-owned camera body and unless it had gone scuba diving you could drop it off at your local service shop and get it back a week later freshly tuned. A concept lost in the dust of history.

Another potential advantage to the new SL system that I hadn't considered in my first post is the association with Leica's geomatics division. The only files I touch these days that say "Leica" anywhere in the metadata have originated in Leica laser scanners, they are still a big player in geomatics, arguably in the top echelon. 3D photogrammetry would be way way easier if you had an up-to-date camera with decent GPS built in or a workpath for tagging shots with output from your portable dgps. I can see a technical version of this camera that shares the same mount. Then I could write it into a grant proposal
Oct 21, 2015 at 09:49 AM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.8 #13Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
hiepphotog wrote:
Are we out? . Since yesterday, I have been glued to my computer reading reviews and discussions on this damn Leica SL. I love Leica (and Zeiss) glass, but I don't see this one fits into my style. I already move away from the big DSLR game, don't want to go back.


Yeah, certainly was a great way to kill a day!

I can now better appreciate how the SL might appeal to some who don't mind DSLR size and handling, but would prefer an EVF experience. It's got me wondering if Leica will release an 'ML' or 'QL' iteration. EVF only M-sized body with L mount... which I guess many here were hoping the SL would be.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:26 AM
michael49
Offline
Details
p.8 #14Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
edwardkaraa wrote:
http://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/


Seems like everyone is blaming the dpreview product shots for making the SL look huge, but it is huge - look at it vs the A7 here!!
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:54 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.8 #15Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...


michael49 wrote:
edwardkaraa wrotehttp://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/
Seems like everyone is blaming the dpreview product shots for making the SL look huge, but it is huge - look at it vs the A7 here!!


Or maybe is the A7 too tiny? Is it a miniaturization contest?
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:07 AM
LightShow
Offline
Details
p.8 #16Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
michael49 wrote:
edwardkaraa wrotehttp://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/
Seems like everyone is blaming the dpreview product shots for making the SL look huge, but it is huge - look at it vs the A7 here!!

I was wondering if they went looking for the smallest employee to hold the camera...
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:21 AM
mbphoto_2.8
Offline
Details
p.8 #17Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
the Sony indeed is tiny..
I can't imagine using this for "serious" work, as in actually carrying the camera and shooting photos with a fast / long (or even a fast tele!) lens attached to it.

On a tripod, the camera surely performes very nicely with great resolution and DR and what not, but not in my medium sized hands..

While I find the Leica ridiculous (it looks like a "prototype" made by a kid) I'm pretty sure that it will balance better with larger lenses.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:25 AM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.8 #18Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
As one of the local Leica haters, my take on the SL is pretty ambivalent.

They got some stuff definitely wrong. No articulated LCD, the grip design is somewhere between lousy and utterly terrible and too much of the S UI is in here (I have a serious dislike for the S's controls, it's the worst of classic and modern UI's IMHO). They're also overselling the speed, This is a 6fps camera, not an 11fps camera (since 6 is max with full AF and AE).

They got some stuff right. Fast CDAF, a great EVF by all reports, a solid mount design, and really snappy electronics (a major issue for them prior to the Q). Also probably best in class 4k support.

Would I buy one? Not now for sure. one giant lens, no real adapter support today, much higher IQ options out there for a fraction of the cost.

In a year? That's another story. I view the SL as more of E mount to the S's A mount. It's the smaller, lighter option for S shooters. But that needs a fully-coupled S adapter. If a fully coupled R adapter comes it will be a big deal for R shooters too.

It's fugly and overpriced for sure (at the price it is, it should be more than 24MP), but not nearly as much as people make out. For a low-production, 4k capable body from Leica, I'd say $6k is where it probably should be. The 24-90 however looks terrible for the cost and size, it's decidedly weak at the long end from the samples I'm seeing. Hopefully Ming got a weak sample, but the MTF doesn't impress either.

Right now I don't see a real reason to worry about it either way. Unless the 90-280 is a real stunner I'd suggest skipping the SL until you can get S and R adapters and the Lux. If you need M compatibility, an M240 is cheaper and I'm sure a new M with this sensor and processing chain will be along for photokina.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:41 AM
Lee Saxon
Offline
Details
p.8 #19Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
It may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.


Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.

Oct 21, 2015 at 11:46 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.8 #20Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...


Lee Saxon wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.



Is it impossible for them to introduce at a later stage a smaller prosumer model with the same mount? I don't see why not?
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:53 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister