fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

  
 
ken.vs.ryu
Offline
Details
p.9 #1Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
But you'll be using the big lenses.

edwardkaraa wrote:
Lee Saxon wrote
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.
Is it impossible for them to introduce at a later stage a smaller prosumer model with the same mount? I don't see why not?

Oct 21, 2015 at 11:57 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.9 #2Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
People are using big lenses on the Sony already. Maybe not all lenses will be DSLR size, who knows. There are always the M lenses as well.

ken.vs.ryu wrote:
But you'll be using the big lenses.

edwardkaraa wrote
Lee Saxon wrote
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.
Is it impossible for them to introduce at a later stage a smaller prosumer model with the same mount? I don't see why not?

Oct 21, 2015 at 12:01 PM
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.9 #3Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Lee Saxon wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.



This is ridiculous. The M240 is Leica's bread and butter camera. It is absurd to suggest that it is a non selling product.

Oct 21, 2015 at 12:13 PM
Jorgen Udvang
Offline
Details
p.9 #4Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
edwardkaraa wrote:
Lee Saxon wrote
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.
Is it impossible for them to introduce at a later stage a smaller prosumer model with the same mount? I don't see why not?


The Leica T already has the same mount.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:31 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.9 #5Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...


Jorgen Udvang wrote:
edwardkaraa wrote
Lee Saxon wrote
Steve Spencer wroteIt may well be a mistake, but its how Leica has always operated so hardly a surprise. They would be a very different company if they went for volume sales at lower prices.
Not always though. I'd say the Q is quite competitive with the RX1r II.

I don't think anyone expected Leica to build a mass market product, but building the SL as a luxury product for the 17 people who buy the M240 when there definitely seemed to be real interest (actual sales) to be had in an interchangeable-mount Q, is just shooting themselves in the foot.
Is it impossible for them to introduce at a later stage a smaller prosumer model with the same mount? I don't see why not?
The Leica T already has the same mount.


I meant FF, Jorgen. I think the next logical step is a smaller FF body.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:41 PM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.9 #6Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
telyt wrote
Luvwine wrote
zhangyue wroteHere is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Well, that remains to be seen (on both accounts), but assuming you are correct, even though Leica might have lost less in a percentage basis, the person who bought the Leica would lose $3,000 where person who bought Sony would lose $1800.
I find direct cost comparison ludicrous at best. There are numerous areas where the Sony a7-series camera leave much room for improvement and unless the SL has the same problems price comparisons are apples/oranges.

For example (using my a7II for comparison):


  1. The a7II's first viewfinder magnification step is too big; I'd prefer the SL's 3x/10x steps
  2. The a7II's RAW bit depth drops in multi-shot mode and the RAW file compression is lossy, compromising file quality
  3. The a7II's EFC feature makes the camera more responsive and quieter but with my adapted lesns it's useless at shutter speeds faster than 1/1000 sec and switching EFC on or off requires menu-diving


The a7-series cameras leave a lot of room for improvement and I'd like to see how the SL compares in these problem areas before drawing any conclusions. BTW, how do the a7-series cameras do at 11 frames/sec?
How are any of your points relevant to the post I made? I was simply providing a counterpoint to the resale value argument. I did not bash the SL..


Chill. I didn't attack you.

mawz wrote:
To be correct, Sony has fixed the lossy RAW compression issue on the A7RII, the 2.0 firmware with the fix came out Monday.


They haven't fixed it for my a7II and as far as I know the loss of bit depth in multi-shot mode persists.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:45 PM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.9 #7Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
I am fine with A7's viewfinder magnification. You get used to it easily.

It's too much magnification for active subjects.

About menu diving: can't you assign enabling EFC to a custom button on the A7II? I don't own A7II so can't test this one.

Not that I've found.

Oct 21, 2015 at 12:50 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.9 #8Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
edwardkaraa wrote:
michael49 wrote
edwardkaraa wrotehttp://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/
Seems like everyone is blaming the dpreview product shots for making the SL look huge, but it is huge - look at it vs the A7 here!!
Or maybe is the A7 too tiny? Is it a miniaturization contest?


for some people (me and at least 2 other guys) it is a miniaturization contest. the a7 is too damn big already.

the size of the SL is fine for what it is (an R solution/continuation), but it's lame for people like me who were hoping for an evf based m lens platform.

Oct 21, 2015 at 01:05 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.9 #9Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
mawz wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
TMaG82 wroteOut if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you can get a couple of spares for $20. A spare Leica batteries gotta be what... $100?
Battery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.
That's sourced from Ming originally from what I've read, his shooting style tends to much better life than CIPA standard. Little chimping, no flash. $250 is ridiculous though, 1st party batteries are already wildly marked up at 1/3 that cost.

Earlier quoteI was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.
No flip screen is a deal-ender for me. Absolute design fail in a mirrorless body, and moderate fail in a DSLR. Articulated screens are simply such a massive improvement for tripod and non-eyelevel handheld work that I wouldn't buy a body without one today. For those who don't like them, high-end ones are thin and tuck away readily (like on my
...Show more →
Earlier quoteKeep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.



Yeah but what you all fail to realised is that Leica believes that everyone owns a smart phone. So if they make an app that works well, why do you need a flip up screen?

The battery IS unreasonable, but not the only brand to do it. If you consider 1 series batteries from the 1Ds3 days. But It's Leica, they're gonna gouge you as much as they can.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:07 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.9 #10Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
mawz wrote
adamdewilde wrote
TMaG82 wroteOut if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you can get a couple of spares for $20. A spare Leica batteries gotta be what... $100?
Battery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.
That's sourced from Ming originally from what I've read, his shooting style tends to much better life than CIPA standard. Little chimping, no flash. $250 is ridiculous though, 1st party batteries are already wildly marked up at 1/3 that cost.

Earlier quoteI was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.
No flip screen is a deal-ender for me. Absolute design fail in a mirrorless body, and moderate fail in a DSLR. Articulated screens are simply such a massive improvement for tripod and non-eyelevel handheld work that I wouldn't buy a body without one today. For those who don't like them, high-end ones are thin and tuck away readily (like on my E-M1)

Earlier quoteKeep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.
Sony does not cover themselves in glory with the battery for the A7. They should have used the A99 battery rather than the low-capacity battery from the smaller NEX series. The issue here isn't so much power management as it is a tiny battery with inadequate capacity for the camera's needs.
Yeah but what you all fail to realised is that Leica believes that everyone owns a smart phone. So if they make an app that works well, why do you need a flip up screen?


have you ever tried to shoot TLR style using your phone as the viewfinder? the flip screen is great for people who enjoy waist level shooting.

Oct 21, 2015 at 01:10 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.9 #11Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
helimat wrote:
mawz wrote
helimat wroteIs it just me, or does Leica have more product lines than Canon, Nikon and Sony.... Combined?
Well, it's only 3 mounts (Same as Ricoh)...

But yes, and Leica seems to have 2 teams.

1. The guys who designed the S, Q, M
2. The guys who designed the X, SL, T

And they don't seem to talk much. One set is doing great work, the other seems to prefer cool designs over usability.
That is 6 product lines, no?


If you're going to sort it out that way, then Canon has EF, EF-S, M, GX, and PowerShot, Nikon has FX, DX, 1, A, and Coolpix, Sony has the original Alpha mount FF and APS-C, E FF and APS-C, 3 flavors of RX, whatever they call the cell-phone lensors, and the action cam.

So, no, Leica doesn't even come close to their total, and doesn't even beat just Sony.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:12 PM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.9 #12Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

sebboh wrote:
edwardkaraa wrote
michael49 wrote
edwardkaraa wrotehttp://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/
Seems like everyone is blaming the dpreview product shots for making the SL look huge, but it is huge - look at it vs the A7 here!!
Or maybe is the A7 too tiny? Is it a miniaturization contest?
for some people (me and at least 2 other guys) it is a miniaturization contest. the a7 is too damn big already.

the size of the SL is fine for what it is (an R solution/continuation), but it's lame for people like me who were hoping for an evf based m lens platform.



No argument here. We all have different tastes. I found the A7 way too small to hold comfortably.

I find the SL slightly too tall but the other dimensions are fine with me.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:13 PM
DoubleNegative
Offline
Details
p.9 #13Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:23 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.9 #14Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
Regarding adopting R glass to this body, I fail to see what advantage it will have over adapting the same lenses to a Sony. They will still need an adapter and there would appear to be no advantage sensor compatibility wise (unlike with M wides). On the other hand, using R glass on recent Sony bodies allows the use of IBIS, which nets a significant advantage to the Sony quite apart from arguably superior sensor options in resolution and high ISO performance. What am I missing?


A deep bias against Sony and some possible corner and edge performance improvements with some R lenses.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:24 PM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.9 #15Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
mawz wrote
adamdewilde wrote
TMaG82 wroteOut if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you can get a couple of spares for $20. A spare Leica batteries gotta be what... $100?
Battery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.
That's sourced from Ming originally from what I've read, his shooting style tends to much better life than CIPA standard. Little chimping, no flash. $250 is ridiculous though, 1st party batteries are already wildly marked up at 1/3 that cost.

Earlier quoteI was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.
No flip screen is a deal-ender for me. Absolute design fail in a mirrorless body, and moderate fail in a DSLR. Articulated screens are simply such a massive improvement for tripod and non-eyelevel handheld work that I wouldn't buy a body without one today. For those who don't like them, high-end ones are thin and tuck away readily (like on my E-M1)

Earlier quoteKeep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.
Sony does not cover themselves in glory with the battery for the A7. They should have used the A99 battery rather than the low-capacity battery from the smaller NEX series. The issue here isn't so much power management as it is a tiny battery with inadequate capacity for the camera's needs.
Yeah but what you all fail to realised is that Leica believes that everyone owns a smart phone. So if they make an app that works well, why do you need a flip up screen?
have you ever tried to shoot TLR style using your phone as the viewfinder? the flip screen is great for people who enjoy waist level shooting.



Hahaha... I was being semi sarcastic. Since that's what a Leica rep would tell you to do (download the app).
I don't need/like flip out screens.. I never have.

But since you asked. Yes I have with the Q. Just for fun. And it wasn't bad, but it's not something I'd want to do without a tripod obviously. So waste level shooting is out.

But I shoot my M without a flip out screen. And waste level. And I use the DOF scales..
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:26 PM
Jman13
Offline
Details
p.9 #16Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
When I went to pick up my press badge today at Photo Plus, I took a quick peek at the vendors setting up their booths. I didn't want to bother those working hard to put everything together today, so I just stole a glance, but I saw the rear o the SL with the 24-90 on it. It's definitely big. They had it sitting next to the S007, and it's definitely smaller than that, but not majorly so. I'll have hands on tomorrow or Friday.

As a side note, the show floor for PhotoPlus is SO much smaller than for that of Photokina. My guess is that the Koelnmesse is about 5-6x larger than the Javits center. Maybe even more. The Samsung booth at Photokina was about 3-4x the size of the combined floor space at PhotoPlus for Nikon, Sony, Canon and Olympus. I hope the crowds are correspondingly smaller, or it's going to be a nightmare to see anything.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:30 PM
Luvwine
Offline
Details
p.9 #17Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
freaklikeme wrote:
Luvwine wroteRegarding adopting R glass to this body, I fail to see what advantage it will have over adapting the same lenses to a Sony. They will still need an adapter and there would appear to be no advantage sensor compatibility wise (unlike with M wides). On the other hand, using R glass on recent Sony bodies allows the use of IBIS, which nets a significant advantage to the Sony quite apart from arguably superior sensor options in resolution and high ISO performance. What am I missing?
A deep bias against Sony and some possible corner and edge performance improvements with some R lenses.


I get the deep bias against Sony, but is there any evidence of problems with edge and corner performance with R lenses? I am not arguing, just genuinely curious. I have only had a few R lenses. I had the 28 v. II, which worked well, but was a bit soft in the absolute corners until stopped down. However, it seemed to match the MTF, so I did not infer it was a problem with any compatibility. The other two I have used are R telephotos--180/2.8 apo and 280/4 apo both of which seem to work exceedingly well.

I know about issues with some M glass on Sony, but never read there was an issue with R glass on Sony.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:30 PM
mawz
Offline
Details
p.9 #18Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
Yeah but what you all fail to realised is that Leica believes that everyone owns a smart phone. So if they make an app that works well, why do you need a flip up screen?

The battery IS unreasonable, but not the only brand to do it. If you consider 1 series batteries from the 1Ds3 days. But It's Leica, they're gonna gouge you as much as they can.


Really hard to shoot waist level with a smartphone in one hand and an SL in the other. Do that all the time with my E-M1 and my G3.

I've got Wifi on the E-M1 and a very good app for it (OI.Share), rarely use it even on a tripod, it's too awkward to use even when its easy (gotta setup, pull out the phone, fire up the app, use it, shoot, put it back in the pocket. Vs stick camera on tripod, flip out screen, shoot, take camera off tripod). The wifi apps only become useful in the studio or when taking multiple shots in the field on one setup (or when the camera position becomes really awkward).
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:40 PM
k-h.a.w
Offline
Details
p.9 #19Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
BTW it is Jono Slack, with an S, not with a B!
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:56 PM
Arka
Offline
Details
p.9 #20Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote:
Not sure about Leica, but I just saw a Sears photo catalog from ~1953 posted somewhere (maybe petapixel?). In it the Contax IIa with 50/2 Sonnar was listed for $444. The 85/2 was $292. In 2015 dollars, that's $3950 and $2600 respectively. I would expect Leica's offerings to have been similarly priced, which I wouldn't exactly consider within reach of many at that time. Just like now, there would be a dedicated few who would make sacrifices to buy that gear, or simply have the disposable income to do so...

Anyway, I don't think Leica has been a relevant force
...Show more →

A $444 camera + lens in 1953 was a longer-term play than a $12,500 digital camera today + lens today (e.g., SL + kit lens). A mechanical camera and lens would not be rendered obsolete in one or two subsequent years, become unserviceable in a decade or less, or be missing key features available in the competition. This longevity is not true of digital camera bodies, which explains why their resale value sinks like a rock. I suppose none of that matters if you are the type of shooter who is satisfied with what he/she has in hand (I mostly am, though I sometimes yearn for the latest and greatest). Digital cameras also obviate the ongoing costs of film/processing inhering in the old mechanical cameras of yore. But I think they are differences worth noting.
Oct 21, 2015 at 02:33 PM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell