fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

  
 
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.6 #1Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Here is another photo Looks pretty good in size.

2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:27 AM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.6 #2Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
hiepphotog wrote:
Steve Spencer wroteOK, I will make a case for the Camera.

Advantages over the Sony A7r II:

Better EVF: high magnification and the reviews suggest it is excellent
Faster frames per second: 11 fps vs. 5 fps
Deeper buffer: 30 shots vs. 23
Dual card slots
Better compatibility with Leica M wide lenses
Compatibility with Leica S lenses
Perhaps auto aperture with Leica R lenses
Lower base ISO--50 instead of 100 but probably won't translate to better base ISO performance
Perhaps faster operation.
Touch sensitive LCD
Longer shutter speed available -- will this translate into better long exposure?
Better weather sealing

Advantages of the A7r II over the Leica SL

More resolution; better high ISO signal to noise ratio (overall better sensor)
IBIS
Better AF with phase detect
Smaller size
Tiltable LCD
Probably better video
Less than half the price

My best guess is that the Leica may have a better shooting experience, but the Sony has a better sensor and IBIS. Both will be very nice cameras and for price performance the Leica will not stand up (since when does Leica ever stand up to a value proposition). Still I think people could like this camera with the right glass and I think they will like the responsiveness and the EVF, and many people will like the interface.

Here are some excellent lenses that will work much better on the Leica: Leica M 18 SEM; Zeiss ZM 18 f/4; Leica M 21 SEM; Leica M 24 Elmar; Leica 28 Summicron ASPH; Zeiss ZM 35 f/1.4; Leica M 50 lux ASPH; Leica M 50 cron AA. These Leica M wide and normal lenses should all work well on the Leica SL, and all have trouble on a stock A7r II, and on the modified camera you will have colour balance issues (that can be fixed with a profile in processing) and you sacrifice the dust shaker.

Leica S 100 f/2; Leica S 120 f/2.5 Macro APO. These excellent S lenses are not useable on the A7r II and they are exceptional and for the speed and focal length (even though they cover a MF image circle) are not ridiculously big. The macro is quite special and really has no peer, IMO.

Leica R 180 f/2 APO; Leica R 180 f/2.8 APO; Leica 180 f/3.4 APO; Leica R 280 f/4 APO; Leica R 400 f/2.8 APO; Leica R 70-180 f/2.8 APO. These longer R lenses are fantastic and although you can shoot them on the A7r II, the bigger size of the Leica SL will be a bonus for these lenses and they may come with auto aperture on the SL when the new adapter is ready.

So in my mind the king of alternative lenses (the Sony A7r II) has been dethroned. The Leica SL will allow you to shoot more lenses and more lenses better and some are pretty unique and special ones even if they are pricey.
A lot to criticize and a lot to like might work with a $2000 camera. But for a $7k+, I'm not sure I would be willing to make too much compromises. I admit I really like the 50 ISO thing, big EVF, dual slot (mainly because of UHS-II support). I'm not sure about its responsiveness yet, but the GUI does seem to get more complicated. I read most of the reviews out there right now and some said because of the amount of customization, the menu system is similar to Sony's now. However, the lens system is what really kills
...Show more →

I think you are mischaracterizing Jono Black's review. He said he thought the edges and corners were *slightly* better on the M240, but that was without side by side testing. He also said he shot tons with the a number of M lenses and that, "Results have been excellent, and compare well with those from My Leica M240." So, from this review there is no indication of problems with M lenses. They seem to work well.

This camera seems to work well with Leica lenses that the Sony cameras do not and it works with Leica S lenses that the Sony camera cannot use. So for alt lenses it does seem to work with more lenses that the Sony A7 series. In my book that makes it the champ for alt lenses, but YMMV.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:54 AM
Spyro P.
Offline
Details
p.6 #3Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
zhangyue wrote:
2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.

Ah, so you lose $1.7k on the Sony and $3k on the Leica.
Oct 21, 2015 at 12:59 AM
zhangyue
Offline
Details
p.6 #4Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Spyro P. wrote:
zhangyue wrote2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
Ah, so you lose $1.7k on the Sony and $3k on the Leica.


Yeh, it is not bad, Always work with ratio in my mind. (because of at the time of buying, they are worth retail to me)
My half year old Sony A7 sold at 55% loss at the time, it is painful.
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:13 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.6 #5Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
zhangyue wrote:
2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.


that's why you should buy the sony 1-2 years down the road, huge discount while the tech is still ahead of most of the competition. anybody looking to get rid of an a7rII cheap to fund a purchase of the new SL please hit me up.

in any event i'm not interested in this due to size, but maybe they'll come out with a smaller body later. the evf looks sweet though. i want to see some real tests with troublesome m lenses too.

Oct 21, 2015 at 01:24 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.6 #6Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
zhangyue wrote2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
that's why you should buy the sony 1-2 years down the road, huge discount while the tech is still ahead of most of the competition. anybody looking to get rid of an a7rII cheap to fund a purchase of the new SL please hit me up.

in any event i'm not interested in this due to size, but maybe they'll come out with a smaller body later. the evf looks sweet though. i want to see some real tests with troublesome m lenses too.



Ask Leica to send me an SL for review. I'll review almost all the M-lenses. Also the S-lenses and while I'm at it some R-lenses for fun. I'll even shoot a wedding with it if they can get it to me fast enough
Oct 21, 2015 at 01:39 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.6 #7Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
sebboh wrote
zhangyue wrote2 year down to the road, your A7RII may be worth $1500, this thing might be still $4500, resell value wise, Sony camera is worst of bunch so far.
that's why you should buy the sony 1-2 years down the road, huge discount while the tech is still ahead of most of the competition. anybody looking to get rid of an a7rII cheap to fund a purchase of the new SL please hit me up.

in any event i'm not interested in this due to size, but maybe they'll come out with a smaller body later. the evf looks sweet though. i want to see some real tests with troublesome m lenses too.
Ask Leica to send me an SL for review. I'll review almost all the M-lenses. Also the S-lenses and while I'm at it some R-lenses for fun. I'll even shoot a wedding with it if they can get it to me fast enough


i'm fairly certain leica isn't listening to my requests.

Oct 21, 2015 at 01:43 AM
TMaG82
Offline
Details
p.6 #8Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Out if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you can get a couple of spares for $20. A spare Leica batteries gotta be what... $100?
Oct 21, 2015 at 02:04 AM
Tmuussoni
Offline
Details
p.6 #9Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Well... I must say I am so disappointed. No other way to say it. That thing is just MASSIVE. Size wise its much closer to Nikon D600/D750 and Canon 6D, than Sony A7 -series (or A7R II). I think this was a huge mistake. Now it seems Leica is going head to head against CaNikon, a potential suicide already there. They should have tried to keep the size small. And yes, A7r II still does have size advantage compared to full frame DSLRs. But compared to SL body and lenses I've seen, Leica does not have the same advantage. And the body does not even have IBIS yet it still weights 847 g. I'm wondering if this thing will have a bulb mode. And I mean a real bulb mode, not same as Q/M 240 limited to 1 minute exposures. That is not a real bulb mode.


Oct 21, 2015 at 02:46 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.6 #10Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
TMaG82 wrote:
Out if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you
...Show more →

Battery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.

I was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.


Keep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.
Oct 21, 2015 at 02:58 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.6 #11Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Tmuussoni wrote:
Well... I must say I am so disappointed. No other way to say it. That thing is just MASSIVE. Size wise its much closer to Nikon D600/D750 and Canon 6D, than Sony A7 -series (or A7R II). I think this was a huge mistake. Now it seems Leica is going head to head against CaNikon, a potential suicide already there. They should have tried to keep the size small. And yes, A7r II still does have size advantage compared to full frame DSLRs. But compared to SL body and lenses I've seen, Leica does not have the same advantage. And
...Show more →

▶ Shutter speed from 30min (bulb) – 1/8.000s (mechanical) – X-Sync: 1/250s

NO DIGITAL CAMERA can technically have real bulb mode.. Period. 30 minutes is a pretty long time if you ask me. I usually get bit by mosquitoes after about 2 minutes.. And I usually lose my patience and kick my tripod after about 5 or 6 minutes.

BTW 8000th mechanical shutter is good enough for me.

Edited on Oct 21, 2015 at 03:51 AM · View previous versions
Oct 21, 2015 at 03:00 AM
Tmuussoni
Offline
Details
p.6 #12Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
Tmuussoni wroteWell... I must say I am so disappointed. No other way to say it. That thing is just MASSIVE. Size wise its much closer to Nikon D600/D750 and Canon 6D, than Sony A7 -series (or A7R II). I think this was a huge mistake. Now it seems Leica is going head to head against CaNikon, a potential suicide already there. They should have tried to keep the size small. And yes, A7r II still does have size advantage compared to full frame DSLRs. But compared to SL body and lenses I've seen, Leica does not have the same advantage. And the body does not even have IBIS yet it still weights 847 g. I'm wondering if this thing will have a bulb mode. And I mean a real bulb mode, not same as Q/M 240 limited to 1 minute exposures. That is not a real bulb mode.
▶ Shutter speed from 30min (bulb) – 1/8.000s (mechanical) – X-Sync: 1/250s

NO DIGITAL CAMERA can technically have real bulb mode.. Period. 30 minutes is a pretty long time if you ask me. I usually get bit by misquotes after about 2 minutes.. And I usually lose my patients and kick my tripod after about 5 or 6 minutes.

BTW 8000th mechanical shutter is good enough for me.


Ah, thank you. 30 mins sounds great. So finally a Leica body with long exposures! But I am going to disagree here. Leica remained the only body manufacturer for a very long time with such restrictions regarding using bulb mode. M 240: 1 min. Q Type 116: 1 min (note: with higher ISO its restricted to just 8 seconds). No other CMOS body I am aware of has such restrictions.. I had no problems doing long exposures with A7r/5D II/5D III/D700, up to 30 mins easily. Especially if you turned on long exposure noise reduction. Anyway, I am glad they finally got it right!

Oct 21, 2015 at 03:14 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
Oct 21, 2015 at 03:35 AM
Matt Grum
Offline
Details
p.6 #14Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
TMaG82 wrote:
I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony


No flip out screen on the Leica, but I don't see how that helps prevent overheating...

adamdewilde wrote:
Keep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.


I just got back from a five day trip to Lisbon where I took an A7RII and 4 batteries. I had to change battery once the entire trip, and that was at the very end of one of the days. It depends on how you use the camera of course (when I hear of people taking 10 batteries I can't help but wonder what they're doing), but I know for me that two batteries is all I need for a day of casual shooting, which is more than manageable.


adamdewilde wrote:
I usually get bit by misquotes after about 2 minutes..


Misquotes don't bother me so much but when I get bitten by an improperly used apostrophe, that really hurts!

Oct 21, 2015 at 03:46 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.6 #15Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Matt Grum wrote:
TMaG82 wroteI didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony
No flip out screen on the Leica, but I don't see how that helps prevent overheating...

adamdewilde wroteKeep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.
I just got back from a five day trip to Lisbon where I took an A7RII and 4 batteries. I had to change battery once the entire trip, and that was at the very end of one of the days. It depends on how you use the camera of course (when I hear of people taking 10 batteries I can't help but wonder what they're doing), but I know for me that two batteries is all I need for a day of casual shooting,
...Show more →
adamdewilde wroteI usually get bit by misquotes after about 2 minutes..


damn auto-correct!!
I was using the A7 series cameras for weddings. I don't machine gun it, but Asian weddings can be long.. Around 15-17 hours long. That's what I consider a full day
Oct 21, 2015 at 03:50 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.6 #16Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote:
retrofocus wroteI disagree - I know several people who own an A7 series camera, and the main reason for all of them getting it is the smaller body size, followed by FF sensor. Tele lenses of course will always be longer - your examples of 300 mm FL lenses are no comparison to my point to make regular FL lenses smaller. It is funny that always tele lenses are used as example when defending bigger sized lenses made for smaller camera bodies. Do you think that this SL camera body is predominantly used with long tele lenses - I don't think so.
Well, we don't know yet how it will predominantly be used. But if a fair number of former R system users adopt it, then I think the SL's size makes sense relative to R lens sizing and the availability of some very desirable telephoto lenses.

Considering the trend in modern optical design is towards considerably larger, high performance lenses, then I do feel a somewhat larger body is logical. Some of the smaller lenses we've seen from Sony, such as the 28/2, like the Q's 28/1.7, and a number from Fuji (and probably others, too) rely a lot on in-camera processing
...Show more →

The industry has for many years focused and improved in DSLR lens systems, it is hard to turn the spinning wheels around by making high quality, smaller sized lenses which fit better to mirrorless cameras in focal lengths below 135 mm. Sony itself was surprised two years ago by the success with the A7 series, and had to push out lenses quickly to satisfy the growing market with the disruptive mirrorless technology. It sounds to me that blueprints of DSLR lenses were and are still used to make lenses which fit to the mirrorless E-mount and now here in the Leica SL case. That lenses can be made smaller show recent examples with Batis and manual focus Loxia lenses, also Voigtlander seems to be in demand with their M-series lenses (including the recent announcement to produce E-mount rangefinder-based lenses in 2016). I see this as a growing trend - I wouldn't be surprised to see more smaller, AF-based lenses for mirrorless cameras in the future replacing the bulkier current ones for wide and normal/small tele focal lengths.
Oct 21, 2015 at 05:20 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.6 #17Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
edwardkaraa wrote:
http://www.photographyblog.com/news/leica_sl_vs_sony_a7r_ii_side_by_side_comparison/


Matter of personal preference (ignoring the difference in price now) - but I would go for sure with the smaller camera body (okay, I admit that I prefer to have smaller lenses, too).
Oct 21, 2015 at 05:24 AM
mawz
Online
Details
p.6 #18Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
adamdewilde wrote:
TMaG82 wroteOut if my price range, but first glance shows some tech that I wouldn't mind Sony using. Dual card slots, more resolution in the EVF, touch screen. Also didn't see it mentioned but it's has wifi and GPS as well. Which begs the questions.

- Since it's also a full frame sensor and records 4K, will it overheat? I didn't pay attention to see if it has a flip screen, which helps with overheating with the Sony,

- with GPS, etc, how is battery life compared to Sony? The most common complaint against the Sony is the battery life, which you can get a couple of spares for $20. A spare Leica batteries gotta be what... $100?
Battery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.


That's sourced from Ming originally from what I've read, his shooting style tends to much better life than CIPA standard. Little chimping, no flash. $250 is ridiculous though, 1st party batteries are already wildly marked up at 1/3 that cost.


I was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.


No flip screen is a deal-ender for me. Absolute design fail in a mirrorless body, and moderate fail in a DSLR. Articulated screens are simply such a massive improvement for tripod and non-eyelevel handheld work that I wouldn't buy a body without one today. For those who don't like them, high-end ones are thin and tuck away readily (like on my E-M1)


Keep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.


Sony does not cover themselves in glory with the battery for the A7. They should have used the A99 battery rather than the low-capacity battery from the smaller NEX series. The issue here isn't so much power management as it is a tiny battery with inadequate capacity for the camera's needs.



Edited on Oct 21, 2015 at 05:26 AM · View previous versions
Oct 21, 2015 at 05:24 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.6 #19Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Matt Grum wrote:
No flip out screen on the Leica, but I don't see how that helps prevent overheating...


The LCD screen both generates heat in addition to the heat from the sensor, and it insulates the body. Flipping out the screen solves both of these problems, as the heat from the LCD does not enter the body, and the heat from the sensor can be freely radiated and convected away from the back of the body.
Oct 21, 2015 at 05:25 AM
edwardkaraa
Offline
Details
p.6 #20Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
The battery is 107 € by the way.

I'm not sure why I'm starting to change my mind about this camera. I was really in shock yesterday but now many aspects of it are starting to make sense. Even the design isn't as bad as I initially thought. That doesn't mean I'm going to rush and buy one. Being a prime person, I will wait at least until the 50 lux is released. My interest in this camera is for AF, and I use my M mount glass on my M240,so in the long term I would definitely consider it.
Oct 21, 2015 at 05:31 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister