fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

  
 
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #1Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Luvwine wrote:
Interesting. I had read about the hope for auto aperture but don't find that a big deal. Metadata is also not a big deal to me. However, I had not previously considered corrective profiles. Will they be "baked in"'to the raw or simply applied after the fact? Lightroom profiles already cover most R lenses for distortion correction. Think there will be a quality advantage or is this another nice convenience but that ultimately does not improve what is already available?

freaklikeme wrote:
You'll have to get confirmation from an M-shooter, but I believe they're side-car'd on to the DNGs and picked up by LR.


When an M is set to detect the lens and apply lens profile corrections, it bakes those corrections into the DNG. But the corrections are for color shift and partial vignetting. Not for distortion.
Oct 21, 2015 at 09:59 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #2Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
i never used any of the maxxums but i'll take your word for it. my UI demands are pretty minimal for a camera the way i shoot. i just need shutter speed, EC, iso, and some kinda shutter (AE lock is nice too, but not necessary). the m controls seem pretty good for me. if only they'd slim the m240 down a bit and put this evf where the rangefinder is... the a7 controls i need are all right under my finger tips, so my only real complaint is the terrible shutter feel.


As someone who has shot Canon 1-series cameras since the original EOS-1, I found the M a very easy transition, and shoot both side by side without problem, despite the massive difference in control layout. I agree, it would be great to see a slimmed M, but the problem is the lens mount to sensor depth combined with the rear LCD package. I don't see how Leica can make the M considerably slimmer, unless they do something like with the Q with cutouts as grip surfaces, rather than the typical raised grip style. That said, a future 'ML' would allow them to slim down the body a fair amount, given the shallower lens mount to sensor depth. But I also have to say that the M shutter release feel needs some work. My M9's release always felt gritty. The M240 is better, but could be improved a fair amount.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:06 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.12 #3Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
davewolfs wrote:
Just read the manual. Odd that you can't control exposure compensation when in aperture priority or shutter priority modes.


You can see page 224.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:07 PM
davewolfs
Offline
Details
p.12 #4Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
davewolfs wroteJust read the manual. Odd that you can't control exposure compensation when in aperture priority or shutter priority modes.
You can see page 224.


Yes it can only be controlled through a menu. That's a mistake.

"Some subjects are made up predominantly of excessively light or dark surfaces, for example large areas of snow or a frame-filling black steam locomotive. In P, S, and A exposure modes, it may be more useful in such cases to set an appropriate exposure compensation instead of using metering memory lock each time. The same applies if you want to ensure an identical exposure for several pictures."

By the time you go to the menu the locomotive is gone.

Edited on Oct 21, 2015 at 10:35 PM · View previous versions
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:32 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.12 #5Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
charles.K wrote:
Leica have some of the best lens designers, and really should be producing in parallel Leica FE mount lenses. The market for the A7 series is growing, and having high end Leica FE mount lenses would over shadow most of the Loxia lenses even at a higher cost. You don't need to compete with AF, but have small/light lenses that would bring out the best in the latest A7's.


Stop it, Charles. You're making me drool.

But if you ever convince them to do it, please work on Rodenstock next.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:33 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.12 #6Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
telyt wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
telyt wrote
naturephoto1 wroteI just got back from Shenandoah NP for Autumn color several hours ago. But, providing the camera is at the Leica Booth tomorrow, I expect to handle the camera with an assortment of lenses, both R and M. As Doug (telyt) has mentioned, if the R adapter will not be available until the end of 2016 as far as I am concerned Leica has shot themselves in the foot and I will voice that opinion. At present I am not looking for AF lenses and I have 3 M mount, 17 R mount (including telephoto and Zoom lenses (plus Bellows system), plus 1 Canon FD lens that should work on the camera. So, right now, if I purchased the camera, I would have 17 orphans until the adapter is available.

Rich
Novoflex makes adapters for the T (now L) mount for Leica-R and Canon FD lenses.
So the important ones are covered.

My first thought when I saw the initial pics and specs was, "Doug's going to be very excited about this."
The viewfinder sounds very enticing but I don't see it as a 'must-have' until the R adapter L becomes available, and then only if there's more to it than a dumb tube. I have to believe that if this adapter won't be available for another year there has to be more to it than just a dumb tube. I figure I can save enough $$$$ for it in a year.

However I reserve the right to contradict myself once I have the camera in my hands and peer into the viewfinder.


Yes, no one should ever have that right taken away from them.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:35 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.12 #7Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
sebboh wrotefor some people (me and at least 2 other guys) it is a miniaturization contest. the a7 is too damn big already.
I'll go on that list now. I'm very happy with the a7II's body-style for hand-held, but if someone came up with a way to pop the lens off the RX1II and replace it with an e-mount, it would make a near-perfect mini-DB. Flat and small, so no interference in movements, an EVF when you need it, an AA filter when you need it. The only way they could improve that is to get rid of the mount completely and make the front an open interface. And maybe slap their big-boy 50MP sensor in there.
i'm down for that. i need to start scouring ebay for brokeh rx1s again so i can make my own camera.


Won't you need a doner shutter as well?
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:40 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.12 #8Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
davewolfs wrote:
Just read the manual. Odd that you can't control exposure compensation when in aperture priority or shutter priority modes.


Push the bottom left button to activate exposure comp. Needs a firmware update to make use of the 2nd dial though.

Gordon
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:41 PM
flash
Offline
Details
p.12 #9Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote:
This is another factor about the a7 series that frustrates me. Menu diving to move the AF point around, IIRC. There isn't a dedicated, fluid, easy way to do it, such as with a joystick. Yet for an AF dependent camera, you'd think this would be a fundamental design requirement! It's one of the first things I felt was missing when I tried the first a7 way back when...


Push the C1 button (which is right next to the shutter button) and you get direct access to move the focus point using either the direction pad or the wheels. What's so hard about that? It takes maybe a 1/4 of a second to activate. Then tap the C1 button again to magnify. No menu required.

Gordon
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:45 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.12 #10Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote:
I don't see how Leica can make the M considerably slimmer, unless they do something like with the Q with cutouts as grip surfaces, rather than the typical raised grip style.


they could try what sony did with the rx1 to get the sensor much closer to the back of the camera. my recollections is that the m9 and m240 both have quite a bit larger distance from lcd surface to the sensor plane than the rx1 (the a7 also has about 1cm greater distance than the rx1). it would almost certainly require a more expensive lcd and a complete redesign of how the camera is assembled, but i feel like that is doable for $6-7k camera. it would improve the ergonomics quite a bit for me (i like the cutouts too).

Oct 21, 2015 at 10:50 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.12 #11Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
freaklikeme wrote:
sebboh wrote
freaklikeme wrote
sebboh wrotefor some people (me and at least 2 other guys) it is a miniaturization contest. the a7 is too damn big already.
I'll go on that list now. I'm very happy with the a7II's body-style for hand-held, but if someone came up with a way to pop the lens off the RX1II and replace it with an e-mount, it would make a near-perfect mini-DB. Flat and small, so no interference in movements, an EVF when you need it, an AA filter when you need it. The only way they could improve that is to get rid of the mount completely and make the front an open interface. And maybe slap their big-boy 50MP sensor in there.
i'm down for that. i need to start scouring ebay for brokeh rx1s again so i can make my own camera.
Won't you need a doner shutter as well?


maybe all those broken rx1s will have functional shutters that i can stick in all my lenses, maybe i can figure out a way to stick an fm2 shutter in there, or maybe if you take apart enough cameras you'll free a genie that can magic you the perfect camera...

Oct 21, 2015 at 10:55 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.12 #12Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
rscheffler wrote:
Luvwine wroteInteresting. I had read about the hope for auto aperture but don't find that a big deal. Metadata is also not a big deal to me. However, I had not previously considered corrective profiles. Will they be "baked in"'to the raw or simply applied after the fact? Lightroom profiles already cover most R lenses for distortion correction. Think there will be a quality advantage or is this another nice convenience but that ultimately does not improve what is already available?
freaklikeme wroteYou'll have to get confirmation from an M-shooter, but I believe they're side-car'd on to the DNGs and picked up by LR.
When an M is set to detect the lens and apply lens profile corrections, it bakes those corrections into the DNG. But the corrections are for color shift and partial vignetting. Not for distortion.


And there's a real answer. So it must be the sensor toppings that give the M240 a slight edge with those lenses over an a7II with a stock filter, but it isn't as though the a7II made the lenses unusable.
Oct 21, 2015 at 10:56 PM
freaklikeme
Offline
Details
p.12 #13Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
freaklikeme wrote
sebboh wrote
freaklikeme wrote
sebboh wrotefor some people (me and at least 2 other guys) it is a miniaturization contest. the a7 is too damn big already.
I'll go on that list now. I'm very happy with the a7II's body-style for hand-held, but if someone came up with a way to pop the lens off the RX1II and replace it with an e-mount, it would make a near-perfect mini-DB. Flat and small, so no interference in movements, an EVF when you need it, an AA filter when you need it. The only way they could improve that is to get rid of the mount completely and make the front an open interface. And maybe slap their big-boy 50MP sensor in there.
i'm down for that. i need to start scouring ebay for brokeh rx1s again so i can make my own camera.
Won't you need a doner shutter as well?
maybe all those broken rx1s will have functional shutters that i can stick in all my lenses, maybe i can figure out a way to stick an fm2 shutter in there, or maybe if you take apart enough cameras you'll free a genie that can magic you the perfect camera...



Uh-huh. Interesting plan. One I may have to use at work, though there he will be a Cisco genie.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:13 PM
telyt
Offline
Details
p.12 #14Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
naturephoto1 wrote:
I hope that Leica Reps can fill me in somewhat about the performance of M lenses on the camera tomorrow. I doubt that I will be able to get any usable files out of the camera to review after the show.


I'm looking forward to reading your impressions.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:36 PM
rscheffler
Offline
Details
p.12 #15Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...

rscheffler wrote:
This is another factor about the a7 series that frustrates me. Menu diving to move the AF point around, IIRC. There isn't a dedicated, fluid, easy way to do it, such as with a joystick. Yet for an AF dependent camera, you'd think this would be a fundamental design requirement! It's one of the first things I felt was missing when I tried the first a7 way back when...

flash wrote:
Push the C1 button (which is right next to the shutter button) and you get direct access to move the focus point using either the direction pad or the wheels. What's so hard about that? It takes maybe a 1/4 of a second to activate. Then tap the C1 button again to magnify. No menu required.

Gordon

Thanks. It has been some time since I've used an a7, so memory might be a bit foggy. But remember I didn't find it to be intuitive. A dedicated interface would be preferred, but considering that the a7 series also has the option for face/eye AF, etc., users may be less inclined to select focus point manually? The direction pad is IMO a UI disaster. It requires too light of a touch.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:48 PM
Steve Spencer
Offline
Details
p.12 #16Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
davewolfs wrote:
Steve Spencer wrote
davewolfs wroteJust read the manual. Odd that you can't control exposure compensation when in aperture priority or shutter priority modes.
You can see page 224.
Yes it can only be controlled through a menu. That's a mistake.

"Some subjects are made up predominantly of excessively light or dark surfaces, for example large areas of snow or a frame-filling black steam locomotive. In P, S, and A exposure modes, it may be more useful in such cases to set an appropriate exposure compensation instead of using metering memory lock each time. The same applies if you want to ensure an identical exposure for several pictures."

By the time you go to the menu the locomotive is gone.


If you read there are three ways to control it. The menu which may work if you are shooting interiors with bright light outside or something like that.I wouldn't use the general menu, but you can put it on your favourites menu. i will probably have it there and use it for some situations. You can also map it to one of the soft keys--which is what I will be doing. You can also use the gesture thing on the touch screen--I have no clue if that is a reasonable thing to do or not.
Oct 21, 2015 at 11:52 PM
charles.K
Offline
Details
p.12 #17Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
Steve Spencer wrote:
charles.K wroteThe more I read and compare the specs of the SL 601, the more I feel Leica has missed the target.

For the size of this beast, there are many better options for FF, cost effective and a large range of lenses available. The SL 601 does not have the best sensor, it is large/heavy and it does not really do anything better than what is available. There is only one lens available for now and of course you can use M mount lenses. The M lenses do not even perform as well as on the M240!

Leica have some of the best lens designers, and really should be producing in parallel Leica FE mount lenses. The market for the A7 series is growing, and having high end Leica FE mount lenses would over shadow most of the Loxia lenses even at a higher cost. You don't need to compete with AF, but have small/light lenses that would bring out the best in the latest A7's.

Maybe the target are the professionals, but most pros I speak to are cost conscious and very mindful of what equipment they invest in. Knowing there is basically only one AF lens available for now, most will not take the plunge.

I have loved the M9/MM and M240 as these cameras are seriously "cool" and unique and fun to use.

I am just puzzled...??
My take is that as usual for Leica, shooting this Leica creates a unique and enjoyable shooting experience. This camera compared to any other mirrorless camera has a much better EVF, a much faster responsiveness, and a much simpler interface. it brings a nice view of the scene, a snappy responsiveness, and it is simple to operate. You may not like the size, but there will be people that prefer this to a smaller camera. it can use all the lenses that Leica makes right now. Together the shooting experience plus the range of lenses that can be used
...Show more →

Steve, I have loved the M9/MM and M240 and lenses have just been amazing! It slowed my process of taking shots and made me think the lighting/design and composition of my images. I joined on the first page when Paul initiated the Leica thread in 2010 and it has been a fantastic journey.

The Leica experience will continue, and I feel most will stick to their M9, MM and M240's for now. But Leica really need to bring out an updated M240 body style camera. I would like see the best in the class sensor/electronics and ergonomics in the body, as the lenses already exist and they are truly awesome.

They don't need to reinvent the wheel as they have a huge inventory of amazing lenses out there. Leica has done decades of work in bringing these lenses to the market and I just don't see the logic of alternative system that has one lens to offer!!

If Leica truly redesigned best in its class M body without the RF this would reduce the cost both in manufacturing and the massive ongoing maintenance needed for re-calibrating the lenses and M bodies. This is a major issue for Leica both in cost and implementation. Of course Leica would need to still have the maintenance for the existing M bodies.

I really think Leica has put the "cart in front of horse" this time..?

Oct 22, 2015 at 01:53 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.12 #18Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
sebboh wrote:
adamdewilde wrote
sebboh wrote
adamdewilde wrote
mawz wrote
adamdewilde wroteBattery is $250
They're saying 400 shots. But I'm hearing 800.. These people seem like they would chimp. Simply because it's a review and a new camera to them.
That's sourced from Ming originally from what I've read, his shooting style tends to much better life than CIPA standard. Little chimping, no flash. $250 is ridiculous though, 1st party batteries are already wildly marked up at 1/3 that cost.

Earlier quoteI was hearing the same battery stats for the Q, but I don't chimp EVER. So I get 4 times that easily. Leica just has very good power management (thanks Panasonic).

I'd still get a spare battery though!

No flip screen (i hate that feature and I don't even know why I hate it).
GPS would be the first thing I turn off. I don't think the Q has it. I also keep the wifi off on the Q.
No flip screen is a deal-ender for me. Absolute design fail in a mirrorless body, and moderate fail in a DSLR. Articulated screens are simply such a massive improvement for tripod and non-eyelevel handheld work that I wouldn't buy a body without one today. For those who don't like them, high-end ones are thin and tuck away readily (like on my E-M1)

Earlier quoteKeep in mind I would hate to have to manage 5-10 batteries. Which I had to do with the A7, A7s, A7r, A7II, A7rII. I had 10 batteries between two bodies that I used simultaneously and it was a pain.

I'd much rather 3 batteries between 2 cameras that cost more money, but last longer. But that's just me.
Sony does not cover themselves in glory with the battery for the A7. They should have used the A99 battery rather than the low-capacity battery from the smaller NEX series. The issue here isn't so much power management as it is a tiny battery with inadequate capacity for the camera's needs.
Yeah but what you all fail to realised is that Leica believes that everyone owns a smart phone. So if they make an app that works well, why do you need a flip up screen?
have you ever tried to shoot TLR style using your phone as the viewfinder? the flip screen is great for people who enjoy waist level shooting.
Hahaha... I was being semi sarcastic. Since that's what a Leica rep would tell you to do (download the app).
I don't need/like flip out screens.. I never have.

But since you asked. Yes I have with the Q. Just for fun. And it wasn't bad, but it's not something I'd want to do without a tripod obviously. So waste level shooting is out.

But I shoot my M without a flip out screen. And waste level. And I use the DOF scales..
yeah, i can hear that coming from a leica rep...

waist level shooting and just guessing the framing is not fun for me, definitely prefer the reverse image of a TLR to that.

i guess you're used to just guessing framing though shooting an m and all though.

i quite like handheld waist level shooting (one of my big complaints about the original rx1 was you couldn't do this), not sure how or why you'd use a tripod for that?




I was just thinking of the odd time I like to shoot macro or product shots on weird angles with the tripod. And that a flip-out screen would be nice. But again, I don't mind the idea of using the phone or iPad if the software works seamlessly. The Q needs improvements (though they did update the app recently.. I will have to check now that I've remembered).
Oct 22, 2015 at 03:47 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.12 #19Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
freaklikeme wrote:
Luvwine wrote
freaklikeme wrote
Luvwine wroteRegarding adopting R glass to this body, I fail to see what advantage it will have over adapting the same lenses to a Sony. They will still need an adapter and there would appear to be no advantage sensor compatibility wise (unlike with M wides). On the other hand, using R glass on recent Sony bodies allows the use of IBIS, which nets a significant advantage to the Sony quite apart from arguably superior sensor options in resolution and high ISO performance. What am I missing?
A deep bias against Sony and some possible corner and edge performance improvements with some R lenses.
I get the deep bias against Sony, but is there any evidence of problems with edge and corner performance with R lenses? I am not arguing, just genuinely curious. I have only had a few R lenses. I had the 28 v. II, which worked well, but was a bit soft in the absolute corners until stopped down. However, it seemed to match the MTF, so I did not infer it was a problem with any compatibility. The other two I have used are R telephotos--180/2.8 apo and 280/4 apo both of which seem to work exceedingly well.

I know about issues with some M glass on Sony, but never read there was an issue with R glass on Sony.
Assuming they follow through with the M's corrective profiles for the last-model ROM'd R's, then you'll get native corrective profiles based on performance with the sensor. From what I've been shown, this is particularly helpful for lenses like the vII 19, the UWA zoom, and the Summilux 35.

There's also the hope the adapter will allow for ROM reading and auto-aperture, both of which are on the wish list for many R shooters.


Almost 100% that this will be the case.
The estimated times for adapters make me believe this is so. The R adapter will take longer then the S adapter to arrive. It's not going to be a dumb adapter.

Oct 22, 2015 at 03:49 AM
adamdewilde
Offline
Details
p.12 #20Leica SL images and specs. Looks somehow familiar...
naturephoto1 wrote:
I just got back from Shenandoah NP for Autumn color several hours ago. But, providing the camera is at the Leica Booth tomorrow, I expect to handle the camera with an assortment of lenses, both R and M. As Doug (telyt) has mentioned, if the R adapter will not be available until the end of 2016 as far as I am concerned Leica has shot themselves in the foot and I will voice that opinion. At present I am not looking for AF lenses and I have 3 M mount, 17 R mount (including telephoto and Zoom lenses (plus Bellows
...Show more →

You can buy me a coffee sometime. And name one of your orphans after me:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Leica-R-LR-lens-to-Leica-T-018-180-018-181-Mirrorless-Digital-Camera-Adapter-/221822448753?hash=item33a5a5f471:g:9pMAAOSwLVZVoGq0
Oct 22, 2015 at 03:54 AM
FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister