p.11 #1What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
By the way, do you mean TSMC from Taiwan that does most of the imager and semiconductor packaging for Philips instead of ASML that build equipments for the semiconductor industry? If it is I have worked with TSMC in Taiwan and their partner EPIN in Zhuhai China that also build imager for Philips. By the way EPIN also build lenses for Canon both in China and Malaysia.
Like I said is a small, small world if we work in this industry no matter which part of the world we are operating from.
technic wrote:
I did a few projects with Phillips imaging devices many years ago, but most (maybe even all) of their development in this area has moved outside the country. I have some friends working at ASML and one of the EM manufacturers to keep me informed of semicon technology etc. ;-) I no longer work in digital imaging, back in my official field which is biochemistry ;-)
p.11 #3What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
mogul wrote:
For someone so versed in military spending, I find it incredulous that you bought that $1000 dollar hammer story (or the $600 toilet seat); this is how the US funds its Black Ops without giving out costs of such endeavours.
I did have a good laugh on what you wrote because I was thinking about the US government always asking countries like China and Russia to be more transparent about their military spendings, but never mentioned about their black ops like the CIA, Navy Seals, NASA, National Geographic, NGOs and NSA, that can use these black pools of cash to purchase whatever they want or sells arms to countries that they themselves have black listed like the Iran Contra incident.
p.11 #4What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote: mogul wroteFor someone so versed in military spending, I find it incredulous that you bought that $1000 dollar hammer story (or the $600 toilet seat); this is how the US funds its Black Ops without giving out costs of such endeavours.I did have a good laugh on what you wrote because I was thinking about the US government always asking countries like China and Russia to be more transparent about their military spendings, but never mentioned about their black ops like the CIA, Navy Seals, NASA, National Geographic, NGOs and NSA, that can use these black pools of cash to purchase whatever they want or sells arms to countries that they themselves have black listed like the Iran Contra incident.
You sound like a fellow that a little knowledge goes a long ways.
p.11 #5What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
mogul wrote:
You sound like a fellow that a little knowledge goes a long ways.
A lot of times information that are placed in front of us are not as important as those that requires a little more efforts or in other words requires to go a long way to get it.
A lot of people knew what organizations like National Geographic and NGOs do. But not many knew about the projects that they sponsored can be use for espionage, national security, propaganda or toppling of elected governments.
That is a fact.
p.11 #6What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote:
By the way, do you mean TSMC from Taiwan that does most of the imager and semiconductor packaging for Philips instead of ASML that build equipments for the semiconductor industry? If it is I have worked with TSMC in Taiwan and their partner EPIN in Zhuhai China that also build imager for Philips. By the way EPIN also build lenses for Canon both in China and Malaysia.
Like I said is a small, small world if we work in this industry no matter which part of the world we are operating from.
technic wroteI did a few projects with Phillips imaging devices many years ago, but most (maybe even all) of their development in this area has moved outside the country. I have some friends working at ASML and one of the EM manufacturers to keep me informed of semicon technology etc. ;-) I no longer work in digital imaging, back in my official field which is biochemistry ;-)
The project was for a subsidiary of Dutch Phillips around 25 years ago. I was told by someone else that the imaging hardware came from Asia and not from the Netherlands but I don't know any details. Anyway, they seem to be mostly an Asian company nowadays that uses the Netherlands for research subsidies and tax evasion ;-)
p.11 #7What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
hans98ko wrote: mogul wroteYou sound like a fellow that a little knowledge goes a long ways. A lot of times information that are placed in front of us are not as important as those that requires a little more efforts or in other words requires to go a long way to get it.
Agree ... in my country the military is not as popular as e.g. in the US, so most companies and researchers try to hide military ties. At the same time, Dutch arms sales have a long history - in the early Middle Ages they already sold the best steel to the Vikings (for good money, probably) who used that to kill them. Later on they sold advanced navy ships and technology to some countries they were at war with ;-)
And you don't always know who you are dealing with. I once sold some image processing equipment to the biggest EU military customer; only found out later who I was dealing with (hiding behind acronyms and strange address). Sometimes they use consumer gear because it is more advanced due to shorter development cycles, or more practical to use ;-)
Even in my current field there is quite some research with military background, if you look a bit better at what people are really doing. Some research into dragonflies - one of my photography subjects - is military as well ...
p.11 #10What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
jhinkey wrote:
What it does mean is that I can hand-hold my 400/5.6 ED AI Nikkor at pretty respectfully low shutter speeds . . .
and hopefully Nikon will jump on board the IBIS bandwagon . . .
Some day it might even fully cure the vibration problem with the 4/300PF at 1/100-1/200s or so ;-)
I would also be interested in having IBIS for my non-IS Canon tele lenses. But as long as there is no good AF with (most) CaNikon lenses the A7RII use with such lenses is limited to 'slow' subjects like landscape, architecture etc.
For owners of Canon lenses the A7RII is a big (promising) step up, but the AF problem definitely isn't solved yet. Canon lenses that AF well with full functionality (like IS etc.) are more the exception than the rule and there are many reports about spurious problems (maybe more due to the adapters than the camera but still ...).
p.11 #14What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
What does it mean? Whatever people want it to mean. I've been between Sony and Nikon for the past few years (since the original a7) and have come to the conclusion that for me the a7xxx cameras serve a totally different purpose than my Nikon DSLR gear. I'm sticking to both till Nikon decides to create a digital FM2 or a digital F3HP with IBIS and video capabilities, or till such time that Sony actually produces a camera that's as responsive and intuitive as my dinosaur of a D700.
p.11 #15What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
After using the A7RII for a bit here's an update of what it means from my view.
I have no idea what it will mean to Nikon, but here's what I hope it will mean:
- It will kick Nikon to finally get a full-frame mirrorless model going - not as a replacement for any of their current high end DSLR models, but as a complement. Unless Nikon has found technological solutions to some of the mirrorless shortcomings relative to DSLRs, there is no way a direct A7RII-like camera by Nikon can begin to replace anything in their DSLR offerings - yet.
- Sony's inadequacies in camera design are primarily in integration, ergonomics, sensor output electronics, and software. Clearly they are superior in sensor design. Nikon needs to take advantage of this using what sensors Sony will give them and run with making a camera that is superior to the A7 series by making it very similar in integration, ergonomics, user interface, and sensor processing to their current DSLRs so as not to alienate their current user base and stop the present and future leakage of customers to the A7 series (people like me, though I may be a small minority).
- Figure out their lens strategy - do they want to have a specialized FX mirrorless mount + lenses or do they just want to use an adapter to be able to use AFS (E or G) lenses? E lenses (no mechanical aperture coupling) are clearly the future.
- Personally I'd love to have a short mount distance to the sensor, but I'd take the current F-mount in a mirroless body, even though it would be larger than otherwise it could be just to get the other mirrorless advantages for what I shoot.
- If Nikon does make a new short-registration distance mirrorless mount will they decide to make it such that it's usable for adaptation with other glass? It would be a shame if they chose a design that was not adaptable to M glass and such. I can see Nikon doing that . . .
Yesterday I used my D800 and A7RII side-by-side while out hiking. Sometimes using the same Nikkors between them. I must admit that even with the issues I have with the exterior ergonomics, UI, etc. the A7RII was still very nice to use and having the smaller size and weight strapped around my waist or in hand was very welcome indeed. I will say that it does seem more work to get an equivalent high quality image with the Sony (even using the same lens) than with my D800, but perhaps that's due to ACR or my processing skills. Still evaluating if the lack of 14bit RAW or compression artifacts are going to bother me.
I'm not an AF shooter, so for landscapes and such the A7RII is really really good.
I wonder if Nikon can make this sensor brake the 100 point barrier if they get there hands on it.
To me there is a question of which sensor, if any, Nikon will get from Sony.
Is Nikon ready to use the exact same sensor that's in the A7RII - it has PDAF built into the sensor - would Nikon use that in a DSLR? Would that allow using PDAF in LiveView - if so would anybody use it that way?
Does Sony have a version of this sensor for DSLRs that don't need PDAF on the sensor? Does BSI technology make any sense for a Nikon DSLR?
Is Nikon developing a similar sensor technology with someone besides Sony (Aptina?)? Will Sony ever share this sensor with Nikon? If so, when?
I don't have answers to the above, but some things to think about.
p.11 #18What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
Hardcore wrote:
Someone mentioned it before and it makes sense. Maybe sony won't allow nikon to use their sensors in a mirrorless full frame camera.
I can totally see why. Who knows what convoluted agreements they have. Sony wants to sell sensors (they make a lot of $$ doing it) to Nikon, but they also want to compete in the FX camera market. I'm sure there are interesting strategy meetings inside Sony regarding this (and Nikon as well).
I wonder if Nikon can make this sensor brake the 100 point barrier if they get there hands on it.To me there is a question of which sensor, if any, Nikon will get from Sony.
Is Nikon ready to use the exact same sensor that's in the A7RII - it has PDAF built into the sensor - would Nikon use that in a DSLR? Would that allow using PDAF in LiveView - if so would anybody use it that way?
Does Sony have a version of this sensor for DSLRs that don't need PDAF on the sensor? Does BSI technology make any sense for a Nikon DSLR?
Is Nikon developing a similar sensor technology with someone besides Sony (Aptina?)? Will Sony ever share this sensor with Nikon? If so, when?
I don't have answers to the above, but some things to think about. ...Show more →
I can't see Nikon releasing a D810 successor with "only" 42 mp's.
A 6 mp bump would be pretty small.
p.11 #20What does the new Sony A7R II mean for us Nikonions?
I'd like to see a digital version of Nikon's rangefinder SP, with an EVF replacing the rangefinder. That type of camera could be a niche product allowing Nikon to put a FF MILC camera on the market without competing directly with Sony or the Dx series. Allow it to use some native lenses as well as Batis, Loxia, and all of Nikon's range of lenses. Even some Leica M, perhaps.
While Sony, Nikon, and Canon appear to be competing with each other, I think it is a more of an orchestrated process of distributing income among family members of Japan, Inc. Nikon's turn upcoming I think.