fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.64 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
One thing I wish sony would do on the next camera is have better weather sealing. I think I mentioned this before, but some more gaskets etc would make me feel more comfortable with its protection.

Chris
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:42 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.64 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?


3. Native on Native ... Imo, the AF on the Sony is certainly quite sufficient. Sure, I think it's just fine. Even the little A58 with a 70-400 G did fine enough in a dimly lit store. It's when we start trying to think of the Sony as an extension of Canon that things start going south. I've not had the luxury of trying the native A-mount glass on the E mount with the "native" Sony adapter, but most report that to be satisfactory, iirc.

1. Manual lenses, the shorter registration distance affords more options to include the M mount Leica's. If you are a fan of that camp, then it's really a no-brainer that the Sony becomes the "poor man's Leica" of sorts. The EVF vs. OVF may still be preferential for some, but the ability to add in the M mount glass is a point of distinction that the Canon EF mount can't touch. If the rangefinder glass isn't your cup of tea, then the EF mount still affords quite a lot of options for alt glass use, sans the Minolta / Sony stuff.

2. This is the area that likely causes the most angst and debate. The key point @ "some applications" and I think the answer is clearly, sure, why not. But, when you extend that to a broader context, it goes south if folks are genuinely honest about it. I mean, until it is your first choice to put the popular 100-400L (et al) on a Sony for an important shoot over a 5D, 7D, 6D or 1D ... well, that (imo) says it isn't ready for prime time as a full replacement body ... back to "some applications" as the qualifier of the question at hand. I mean, even as a zoo lens ... are you going to enjoy lens hunting @ 400mm?



Oct 13, 2015 at 10:42 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.64 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
If the rangefinder glass isn't your cup of tea, then the EF mount still affords quite a lot of options for alt glass use, sans the Minolta / Sony stuff.



Problem with the newer Canon DSLR cameras is the lack of using the preferred manual focus matt screen instead of the standard one. In the 5D MkII this screen could still be easily exchanged, but since the 5D MkIII this is a drawback for using it with MF lenses. Focus peaking might work with the MagicLantern software (never tried it myself). Magnification has to be done using LiveView on the LCD screen instead of looking through the OVF.
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:57 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.64 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?


With the A7R II, I would give the edge to Sony on this one, although not by as big a margin as some might claim. Being able to zoom in 14x in the viewfinder is handy if your subject isn't moving, but then if your subject isn't moving you can do the same thing on the rear LCD of the Canon 5DsR. I feel the Sony's EVF still suffers from too much compression/line skipping and too little contrast to let you see if your subject is critically sharp or not, but if you're trying to work fast, it's probably good enough.

If you're working from a tripod and can use Live View, I find the rear LCD display of the Canon a bit easier to focus on than the Sony's LCD - I think it's another case of less compression and line skipping.

I would still fall back into my old habits and try using the Canon OVF for lenses like the Otus, but since the 5DsR lacks interchangeable focusing screens, one might have better luck with a 6D or even a 1Ds III for that.



2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.


The A7R II is good enough for short and moderately fast lenses - where virtually every system performs well. As you get into longer and slower lenses, the Sony AF begins to falter, and ultimately stops working much beyond f4 and/or 400mm. Where it does work well, there are native Sony lenses that might be a better choice, but at this point, not enough to replace anything beyond a minimalist Canon system.



3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?


Within its own limited range of native focal lengths, the A7R II works very well, and can certainly stand on its own - assuming you can live withing these limits photographically (and I'm sure Dan will wax poetic on that philosophical argument...)

In responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?
Oct 13, 2015 at 11:17 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.64 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Schlotkins wrote:
One thing I wish sony would do on the next camera is have better weather sealing. I think I mentioned this before, but some more gaskets etc would make me feel more comfortable with its protection.

Chris


The Sony Mark II cameras are supposed to be weather-sealed, but I haven't been brave enough to test this for myself yet.
Oct 13, 2015 at 11:19 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.64 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?


1. No question: Sony. In this case though, I'd take any halfway decent EVF over having to shoot off an LCD in liveview, or through an OVF (even with a fast lens and the precision focusing screen-- which I have installed in my 5D2). Punching in to max magnification for critical focus is fool proof and quick.

2. Hit or miss, with, as mentioned above, more hit than miss with fast lenses up to mid-tele or moderate tele. The thing is that i) there's always that x-factor of the adapter and its firmware (and possible need to turn the camera on/off; I haven't had this issue myself), ii) each lens really needs to be evaluated on its own, and iii) keep in mind that every lens will be a little bigger and bulkier with 1+ inches of adapter cantilevering off the camera. Some lenses might even work better (my 35L is about as fast, perhaps faster in some scenarios-- and focuses far more accurately on the Sony). Personally, I still see Canon lenses on Sony as a temporary solution (until one can afford the first-party lens, or Sony makes one available).

3. Yes, without question. It may well replace my Canon. I shoot mainly feature photojournalism. Like travel or adventure travel (skiing in Kashmir, rock climbing), or science/environment features (climate change and nomadic lifestyle in Mongolia; archeology and conservation in South Africa; wildlife trafficking in Southeast Asia). I don't see this as particularly demanding on AF systems though. Hell, I've been making due with a 5D2, which isn't an AF superstar by any measure (but is totally enough for me). It's surely not field sports (this camera doesn't have the lenses, and even if it did I'm not sure it is up to the task). I used to shoot weddings, I think I could comfortably do weddings with two A7rIIs-- but I wouldn't right off the bat (I'd use the A7rII as a second camera until it proved itself). Battery life isn't a major issue for what I do because I can carry multiples, have plenty of time to switch/plan my switches, power off of USB-bank or solar, etc. I also shoot almost exclusively with center-point AF in one-shot mode.

The biggest thing holding back #3 is lens choice. If the lenses you need are there-- the camera is solid (and IQ/resolution is outstanding). But there are some big holes remaining, and if the lenses aren't there for your needs... you're going to struggle with partial solutions or compromises you may not want to make.


Oct 13, 2015 at 11:58 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.64 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
RustyBug wroteIf the rangefinder glass isn't your cup of tea, then the EF mount still affords quite a lot of options for alt glass use, sans the Minolta / Sony stuff.
Problem with the newer Canon DSLR cameras is the lack of using the preferred manual focus matt screen instead of the standard one. In the 5D MkII this screen could still be easily exchanged, but since the 5D MkIII this is a drawback for using it with MF lenses.


+1 @ the reduced screen options = Aftermarket options = Whether I go with a 5D MK III or the 5Ds(R), I'd still like to know what screen options might be available. Not the end of the world with just the standard screen, but +1 @ screens are part of the equation.

Magnification can still be done with an angle finder through the OVF. Granted, it is only 2.5X, but if you need more than that, you can still switch to Live View.

molson wrote:
In responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?


+1 @ hmmm, as to why the problems with the longer stuff?

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 12:18 PM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:05 PM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.64 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
molson wroteIn responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?
+1 @ hmmm, as to why the problems with the longer stuff?


My guess would be that the sensor needs some minimum light or contrast level to function properly - a hurdle that SLR cameras overcame about two decades ago with cameras like the EOS 3 and 1V
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:17 PM
charlyw
Offline
Details
p.64 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
In responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?


There is reason to believe so: As the phase detection via the main sensor has a severe drawback: it is depending on the angle of incidence of the incoming light to produce the phase difference - and for long lenses this is as near as makes no difference perpendicular. This means that for long, well corrected lenses the phase detection cells on the sensor are inefficient. The other problem is the amount of movement (camera and subject) during the video frame captured - which isn't helped by the aperture and ISO limits of the camera... So the camera has a weak, blurred signal to work with. On a traditional phasedetection system the AF sensor has large cells that can operate at ISO of up to 5 million (for a focusing point working to -1 EV) and the secondary beam splitter and focusing lens in the AF module enlarge the phase difference.
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:19 PM
Schlotkins
Offline
Details
p.64 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Schlotkins wroteOne thing I wish sony would do on the next camera is have better weather sealing. I think I mentioned this before, but some more gaskets etc would make me feel more comfortable with its protection.

Chris
The Sony Mark II cameras are supposed to be weather-sealed, but I haven't been brave enough to test this for myself yet.


well, the A7r is also supposed to be weather sealed...
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:20 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.64 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
RustyBug wrote
molson wroteIn responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?
+1 @ hmmm, as to why the problems with the longer stuff?
My guess would be that the sensor needs some minimum light or contrast level to function properly - a hurdle that SLR cameras overcame about two decades ago with the EOS 3 and 1V


Oh, and I thought you were going to mention something about Sony's innovation.


charlyw wrote:
There is reason to believe so: As the phase detection via the main sensor has a severe drawback: it is depending on the angle of incidence of the incoming light to produce the phase difference - and for long lenses this is as near as makes no difference perpendicular.


Gotcha @ AI vs. collimated light.

How odd that the very thing that produces the greatest transfer of energy (AI = 90 degrees vector force impingement) would be counter productive to achieving focus. In that regard, it would suggest that the PD is a preferred AF means for WA / UWA projections. Interesting ... that could explain why the landscapers / street shooters find so much love for it.

Hmmm, now at how / why the Sony adapter from A mount to E mount factors in. It would seem that the LA-EA3 is contrast rather than phase ... and useful only with SAM/SSM lenses and not AF'ing with video.

https://us.en.kb.sony.com/app/answers/detail/a_id/37304/~/what-is-the-difference-between-the-la-ea1,-la-ea2,-la-ea3,-and-la-ea4-lens

Seems like we have a bit of a double-edged sword conundrum with the pro's / con's of PD vs. contrast for AF.

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 01:31 PM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:20 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.64 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
charlyw wrote:
molson wroteIn responding to this last point, it make me wonder if Sony doesn't have any long lenses for the FE system yet because of the same AF problems that limit their ability to AF with similar Canon and other third-party lenses?
There is reason to believe so: As the phase detection via the main sensor has a severe drawback: it is depending on the angle of incidence of the incoming light to produce the phase difference - and for long lenses this is as near as makes no difference perpendicular. This means that for long, well corrected lenses the phase detection cells on the sensor are inefficient. The other problem is the amount of movement (camera and subject) during the video frame captured - which isn't helped by the aperture and ISO limits of the camera... So the camera has a
...Show more →

This can be an issue on other brands of mirrorless systems as well. My non-Sony mirrorless system generally AFs relatively quickly and very accurately with short lenses up to "normal" or "short telephoto" length, but it bogs down in low contrast situations with, for example, a long zoom. It works. Most of the time. Slowly. But eventually...
Oct 13, 2015 at 12:53 PM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.64 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Yup, even my 100-400L II + TC will AF in Live View on the little T5i in low light ... eventually. Which is technically an improvement over not AF'ing at all. The other upside is that it will give you enough time to set your sundial before it does finally get there.
Oct 13, 2015 at 01:07 PM
RobDickinson
Offline
Details
p.64 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Schlotkins wrote:
well, the A7r is also supposed to be weather sealed...


Nope, sony never mentioned that, somebody did when it launched and it got taken up parrot style and splashed across the internet but the a7/a7r's have no sealing at all
Oct 13, 2015 at 01:17 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.64 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?


Sony A7rii

1. Sony, you're a sony shooter right? MF just works better.
2,3 is like the same, and IMO, the A7rii is good to stand on it's own. It's very brisk, and with fast primes, will AF in really low light. I was able to lock AF with street lighting, 12K iso, 1/60, F1.8 type settings.

about the only long lens I had concern about was the 70-400g, and it's good on the A7rii. With native shorter lenses, quite frankly, I find that eye AF is the ultimate in accuracy, where DSLR's may be a hair quicker. To me, the AF advantage goes to the A7rii by far since I prefer accuracy to super speed.
Oct 13, 2015 at 01:57 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.64 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Charlie N wrote:
I prefer accuracy to super speed.


What if you can get both?
Oct 13, 2015 at 01:58 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.64 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
It's funny, after some 10 people give different opinions and alternative views, somebody answers the "consensus" question definitely
Oct 13, 2015 at 02:07 PM
Charlie N
Offline
Details
p.64 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Charlie N wroteI prefer accuracy to super speed.
What if you can get both?


Sorry, I've never shot a DSLR as accurate as the Sony A7rii and eye focus. Are you claiming DSLR's are that accurate?
Oct 13, 2015 at 02:12 PM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.64 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Charlie N wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
Charlie N wroteI prefer accuracy to super speed.
What if you can get both?
Sorry, I've never shot a DSLR as accurate as the Sony A7rii and eye focus. Are you claiming DSLR's are that accurate?


The 5DS / R is not just any DSLR. It is the most accurate DSLR, more than the 1DX, because Canon has tuned the AF algorithms for accuracy for the 50MP resolution and not speed for the 12 FPS of the 1D X. Nobody I have seen have had accuracy issues with the 5DS AF, but I have seen many reports of Sony A7rII missing focus with Canon lenses.
Oct 13, 2015 at 02:16 PM
chez
Offline
Details
p.64 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII


alundeb wrote:
Charlie N wrote
gdanmitchell wrote
Charlie N wroteI prefer accuracy to super speed.
What if you can get both?
Sorry, I've never shot a DSLR as accurate as the Sony A7rii and eye focus. Are you claiming DSLR's are that accurate?
The 5DS / R is not just any DSLR. It is the most accurate DSLR, more than the 1DX, because Canon has tuned the AF algorithms for accuracy for the 50MP resolution and not speed for the 12 FPS of the 1D X. Nobody I have seen have had accuracy issues with the 5DS AF, but I have seen many reports of Sony A7rII missing focus with Canon lenses.


Are you saying there are no front / back focus issues with the 5ds cameras? No need to focus adjust your lens...and at what distance do you focus adjust at and what focal length do you focus adjust zooms at?

This merry-go-round of focus adjustments is not needed anymore?
Oct 13, 2015 at 02:28 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister