hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:
1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?
2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.
3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?
1. No question: Sony. In this case though, I'd take any halfway decent EVF over having to shoot off an LCD in liveview, or through an OVF (even with a fast lens and the precision focusing screen-- which I have installed in my 5D2). Punching in to max magnification for critical focus is fool proof and quick.
2. Hit or miss, with, as mentioned above, more hit than miss with fast lenses up to mid-tele or moderate tele. The thing is that i) there's always that x-factor of the adapter and its firmware (and possible need to turn the camera on/off; I haven't had this issue myself), ii) each lens really needs to be evaluated on its own, and iii) keep in mind that every lens will be a little bigger and bulkier with 1+ inches of adapter cantilevering off the camera. Some lenses might even work better (my 35L is about as fast, perhaps faster in some scenarios-- and focuses far more accurately on the Sony). Personally, I still see Canon lenses on Sony as a temporary solution (until one can afford the first-party lens, or Sony makes one available).
3. Yes, without question. It may well replace my Canon. I shoot mainly feature photojournalism. Like travel or adventure travel (skiing in Kashmir, rock climbing), or science/environment features (climate change and nomadic lifestyle in Mongolia; archeology and conservation in South Africa; wildlife trafficking in Southeast Asia). I don't see this as particularly demanding on AF systems though. Hell, I've been making due with a 5D2, which isn't an AF superstar by any measure (but is totally enough for me). It's surely not field sports (this camera doesn't have the lenses, and even if it did I'm not sure it is up to the task). I used to shoot weddings, I think I could comfortably do weddings with two A7rIIs-- but I wouldn't right off the bat (I'd use the A7rII as a second camera until it proved itself). Battery life isn't a major issue for what I do because I can carry multiples, have plenty of time to switch/plan my switches, power off of USB-bank or solar, etc. I also shoot almost exclusively with center-point AF in one-shot mode.
The biggest thing holding back #3 is lens choice. If the lenses you need are there-- the camera is solid (and IQ/resolution is outstanding). But there are some big holes remaining, and if the lenses aren't there for your needs... you're going to struggle with partial solutions or compromises you may not want to make.