fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.63 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote
Show me explicitly where someone...anyone ever said you are not "photographer enough" if you can't use multiple systems at the same time.


There have been a multitude of responses that have been a direct / indirect / implied effort to minimize the responses given by various members who have raised the issue of system compatibility preference toward a unified interface as not that big of a deal. You yourself have repeatedly flaunted your use of multiple systems as a response to others who indicated their preference toward a single platform. The fact that you, nor anyone else didn't use the exact same verbiage is moot. The fact remains that folks have expressed their preference toward a single platform, yet it's validity continually gets assaulted / refuted / minimized as invalid rationale.

It's not like it receives a response of "Gee, okay I see where you might prefer that ... but it's not a big deal to me." No, instead it gets met with "Look at me. I'm so great that I can shoot with anything and you should be able to also." Others can shoot cross platform also, they just prefer not to for reasons of their own choosing.


+1 @ a 1D2N vs. a 5D isn't the exact same layout / control. But, the similarities are conceptually much closer together than the A7 series. Where a person's threshold for preference in that regard varies. That same threshold applies to ergonomics as well. Everyone has their own preference / threshold ... it is subjective.

Most multi-system configurations are used independently in specific shooting situations. Many people have a mirrorless camera for travel or walk around and a DSLR for landscapes or sports. Most likely these two types of cameras won't be used at the same time. My 7d is used for sports whereas my A7R is used for steet and landscape...those paths don't cross.

Which is understood that you may have a separate system for a separate purpose. I have a mirrorless bridge camera for travel pics with the family.

BUT ... that is a far different thing from saying that I have a second body that is compatible with my existing system. The question for some isn't whether or not they have the wherewithal to use a second platform / system ... RATHER, it is trying to ascertain just how compatible is compatible with their existing Canon system.

The Sony is compatible with the Canon system via an adapter (to varying degrees of effectiveness). That compatibility is duly noted. The incompatibilities of ergonomics, menu, layout, controls, AF performance, etc are thus also noted. Even the issue of no CF card is another area of incompatibility. In order to have dual card setups, you're now talking about using SD card and Sony's proprietary card in one camera, while using CF's in the other. That's extending your system to managing three sets of cards (one of which is proprietary), rather than staying within the realm of one or two. That is even further divergent from the concept of compatibility.

Yet, when those incompatibilities ... to the Canon system ... are noted, they repeatedly get minimized in the name of dual platform, when the dialogue for the Sony (in the Canon Forum) is largely about it being compatible with Canon lenses (i.e. compatible with the Canon system).

Well, the issue of compatibility for some doesn't stop at the lens mount. For some, their objectives / goals for compatibility extend beyond that.

The Sony gets touted as being this "no brainer" for its compatibility with Canon glass via adaptation. But, the more some folks look into it, they realize that the Sony's compatibility with the larger concept of system compatibility, they come to realize that the more they think it through, the more it isn't nearly as compatible in various regards as touted in the realm of it being a "no brainer" upon first glance.

In that regard, it remains (imo) relegated to a niche use, or a dual / split platform ... particularly given it's ineffective performance with Canon long glass. That's fine if that is what a person is trying to achieve. However, some folks are not looking for that niche / split aspect. For them, the aforementioned aspects remain valid.

It just strikes me that the issue of Sony being compatible with Canon is wrought full of double-speak in the area of compatibility. When it is to Sony's favor for being compatible, it is a holy grail / no brainer. Where the incompatibilities exist and are presented by others ... well, those incompatibilities don't really matter according to some. Cake & eat it too.

It is either a compatible system, a partially compatible system, or a non-compatible system.

All I'm saying is that the Sony is only partially compatible. So, when folks present those incompatibilities, they should be honestly acknowledged as the incompatibilities, such as they are. Whether or not another person owns multiple different brands / platforms has no bearing on the compatibility of Sony with Canon. The most salient reason for discussing Sony in the Canon forum is predicated upon its compatibility through adaptation to render a degree of compatibility. Thus, it is likewise salient to discuss the incompatibilities such that Canon shooters can discern the degree of compatibility it affords and / or does not afford.

Some folks are merely pointing out ... it has incompatibilities. Honest, rational and objective review of such warrants an acknowledgement of the existence of those incompatibilities. Minimizing your fellow FM'ers for extolling those incompatibilities doesn't mitigate their existence. It only attempts to sweep them under the rug.

How compatible is Sony with Canon ... well, once adapted to Canon glass, that'll be somewhere greater than 0% and less than 100%. Depending on a person's individual attributes of concern, the assessment for that degree of compatibility will be highly variable. How willing a person is to plunk down $$$$ on a camera that is ancillary, partially compatible (albeit improved from its predecessor if we're being honest) with their existing system (which can be perceived radically different, depending on your existing glass lineup) compared to how willing they are to invest $$$$ into a camera that can be the class leading hub of their system ... well, that's an individual call also.



Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 07:37 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 06:21 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
Why do people always feel they need to interject comments about "brand


Because the subject is so clearly an underlying issue for a number of people in gear discussions, particularly in a thread like this one that compares two brands.

RustyBug wrote:
It just strikes me that the issue of Sony being compatible with Canon is wrought full of double-speak in the area of compatibility. When it is to Sony's favor for being compatible, it is a holy grail / no brainer. Where the incompatibilities exist and are presented by others ... well, those incompatibilities don't really matter according to some. Cake & eat it too.

It is either a compatible system, a partially compatible system, or a non-compatible system.

All I'm saying is that the Sony is only partially compatible....Some folks are merely pointing out ... it has incompatibilities. Honest, rational and objective
...Show more →

Well said. There is, from the perspective that many of us have, a kind of double-standard here. While one can go cherry-pick bits and pieces of this and that quote to try to construct the appearance of a more reasonable point of view, those who have watched this unfold since the introduction of the interesting mirrorless systems from Sony don't have any problem reading the actual underlying messages.

At the beginning the virtues of the A7r-series cameras were described by some as being so compelling that it often almost seemed that those doing the describing felt that photographers who didn't fall head-over-heels in love with this new system must be Luddites, unable or unwilling to recognize is superiority in all ways.

- Not so sure you needed to spend money on a second body? You get to keep using your Canon lenses!

- Confident that your current system works very well for you? You must not be pushing the limits of your gear enough?

- Not interested in adding a second, different system? You must live a boring life that doesn't embrace change and variation.

- Not so sure that the additional dynamic range of the Sony sensor would be worth all that much too you? More dynamic range is always good!

- Not so enthusiastic about Sony as a brand being that much different or better? Your camera company is "falling behind," using ten year old technology, unable to innovate, likely on the downward slide.

- Willing to wait to see what your existing camera company will come up with? Why wait? You might miss something now.

In the end, how does this play out? From what I've seen, the Sony camera technology is quite viable and for some people in some circumstances is a fine or even a superior choice. For example, if you want a full frame street photography system, and especially if you like using manual focus lenses, it is arguably the best option right now. For some things its initial advantages were real, but were (as predicted) soon largely negated: 36MP is no longer the highest FF sensor resolution, the vaunted dynamic range advantages (as seen in actual photographs) diminish. In other cases the initial promises turned out to be overblown or at least not yet fully effective — the idea that you could just port your existing lenses over to the Sony system turns out to be not nearly so simple, as anyone following the Sony forum fully understands.

For one object lesson, take a look at Sony boards and the user discussions of lens compatibility. I'll stipulate that there are many reports that certain lenses work quite well — particularly some of the native Sony lenses and also certain adapted lenses from manufacturers including Canon. For the subset of photographers who are happy to work entirely with manual focus lenses, the Sony platform seems like a fine way to use many (though not all) vintage and similar MF lenses. But look a bit closer. Sony users themselves report that a number of lenses are (to use the common phrase) accurate but slow to focus on their bodies. Or others will work well at short focal lengths but not at longer lengths. Or they seem to work for those with adapter X but not adapter Y, or perhaps work better with Y with software version X.x, but hopefully will get better with software v. X.x+1.

Can you imagine how Canon users would respond if it turned out that, say, the 100-400mm L lens only worked consistently up to 300mm? Of if the 200mm prime focused "slowly but accurately?" Or if you favorite wildlife lenses was really sharp... as long as the bird is not moving too fast?

It is interesting to go back and read some of the posts from the time of that initial flush of enthusiasm as the Sony A7r first became available, including posts by some who participate in this forum and this very thread. What kinds of verbiage were used to describe the (obvious!) superiority of the Sony camera? What language was used to refer to and describe those who, while acknowledging the virtues of what Sony has done, rated somewhat lower on the true believer scale? What elements of the original barrel thumping have now quieted down as the reality of using the system has made them seem a bit over-blown?

This could take me back to several things. One, which I won't go into right now in any depth, has to do with the nature of the contributions of certain posters — their need, it seems, to couch so many points about cameras in terms of the personal shortcomings of the people who don't hold their viewpoint, and their inclination to insult those holding a different point of view. Another, which seems more directly related to this discussion, is that this whole affair provides a wonderful lesson in the value of slowing down just a bit, being cautious about marketing hype (for companies or those who are fans of the companies), and about having unrealistic expectations regarding what new tools will do for you.

Sony provided us with the best sensor to date — higher resolution that anything else when it was released, and with the highest available dynamic range, hence excellent noise characteristics. All of that is good — as many of us have repeatedly said and written — and we understand the appeal. But in retrospect it becomes clearer that these pluses come (as is the case with any system) with their own set of compensatory minuses. That doesn't make the Sony option a bad one, but it does explain why even those who are impressed with what Sony has been doing get more than a bit tired of the constant Sony fanboyism...

Dan

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 07:19 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 06:21 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.63 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteShow me explicitly where someone...anyone ever said you are not "photographer enough" if you can't use multiple systems at the same time.
There have been a multitude of responses that have been a direct / indirect / implied effort to minimize the responses given by various members who have raised the issue of system compatibility preference toward a unified interface as not that big of a deal. You yourself have repeatedly flaunted your use of multiple systems as a response to others who indicated their preference toward a single platform. The fact that you, nor anyone else didn't use the exact same verbiage is moot. The fact remains that folks have expressed their preference toward a single platform, yet it's validity continually
...Show more →
Earlier quoteMost multi-system configurations are used independently in specific shooting situations. Many people have a mirrorless camera for travel or walk around and a DSLR for landscapes or sports. Most likely these two types of cameras won't be used at the same time. My 7d is used for sports whereas my A7R is used for steet and landscape...those paths don't cross.


+1 always best to see both sides of a discussion and not marginalize others opinions. Especially in these types of discussions which contain very few facts and are mostly matters of personal preference.

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 06:58 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 06:33 AM
Cliff L.
Online
Details
p.63 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
molson wroteWhy do people always feel they need to interject comments about "brand
Because the subject is so clearly an underlying issue for a number of people in gear discussions, particularly in a thread like this one that compares two brands.


I thought this discussion was about two cameras, not two brands... why do you always try to make it into something else with your long-winded armchair lectures?
Oct 13, 2015 at 06:35 AM
justruss
Offline
Details
p.63 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
I am using in parallel both Canon and Sony - the 5D MkII and the A7R. I have two 5D MkII bodies, one of them is converted to infrared with 715 nm cutoff filter inside the camera. In situations where I combine both infrared with color photography, I take my IR-converted 5D MkII body and often the A7R with me at the same time. Since I have gotten very much used to the A7R, my 5D MkII feels a lot bigger and heavier now than in the past when I only shot with this camera body before getting the A7R.
...Show more →

Funny... I've been fumbling with mounting lenses a whole lot more now that I have Fuji, Canon, Sony. And I have lenses that I use (via adapters) on 2 or 3 of those systems. Simplification is surely in order at some future point!
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:01 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.63 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wroteWhy do people always feel they need to interject comments about "brand
Because the subject is so clearly an underlying issue for a number of people in gear discussions, particularly in a thread like this one that compares two brands.
I thought this discussion was about two cameras, not two brands... why do you always try to make it into something else with your long-winded armchair lectures?


I see it as a discussion on two cameras as stated in the initial post of this thread. The fact that many people that use the Sony system in this thread also use a Canon camera sort of tells me it's not about brand fan boyism but instead a discussion about the use of these two cameras.

I fully agree about the long winded lectures which I fall asleep part way through and move onto the next post wondering what the actual point is of the winded post.
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:09 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
molson wroteWhy do people always feel they need to interject comments about "brand
Because the subject is so clearly an underlying issue for a number of people in gear discussions, particularly in a thread like this one that compares two brands.
I thought this discussion was about two cameras, not two brands... why do you always try to make it into something else with your long-winded armchair lectures?


Feel free to not read my "long winded armchair lectures." Or, take a moment to read them and to comment on my actual points rather than dismissing my points of view because too many words. Your choice.

Taking time to write a comment that is more than a few sentences long reflects a recognition that things are not always subject to one-liner come-backs, that nuance is appropriate... and it might also reflect respect for the intellects of some participating in the dialog.

For those who only want combative one-liners, holding out for a clear cut win for Team A or Team B, consider that possibility that I'm not writing to you.

Sometimes short is good. Sometimes it is insufficient. ;-)

Dan

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 09:21 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:15 AM
TeamSpeed
Offline
Details
p.63 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
The responses really aren't that long, it takes a minute or less to read it. I could see how somebody would ignore the reply, especially if it were directed at them for something they said prior.

I think the single point that I see in these discussions I agree with is having a complete system that works well together. For me, I would either be all Canon, or all Sony. I wouldn't mix and match. I want to know that my batteries, lenses, and accessories (for the most part, like wireless remotes, intervalometers, etc) all work on my bodies. If this means I give up other things like a bit less DR, etc, that is fine with me.

Even having 2 different generations Canon bodies is a bit difficult, the menu structures in a linear format vs tabs can be frustrating, or where one has CF settings and others have dedicated menus for what used to be CF settings.
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:18 AM
jcolwell
Offline
Details
p.63 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Meh. I shoot three types of contemporary Canon bodies, with three different types of batteries, and three vastly different user interfaces (1DX, 6D, and SL1). I also shoot Fujifilm X-E2 and X100S (two more types of batteries), and a Sony RX100 (another battery type). I often travel with three different types of batteries and chargers. It's all good.
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:30 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.63 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Some folks ^ are just better super-jugglers than others.
Sorry, I tapped out @ 5 different alt adapters, despite being an ardent understudy.
But, I am looking forward to mounting my M645 (et al) glass on a 5Ds(R) to see how it renders.

Some of us are only mere mortals ... please have pity on our poor souls.




Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 07:50 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:44 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Some folks ^ are just better super-jugglers than others.
Sorry, I tapped out @ 5 different alt adapters.

Some of us are only mere mortals ... please have pity on our poor souls.


Like so many things, I think it may be a subjective and conditional issue.

Some, including some truly excellent photographers, prefer to keep things simple when it comes to photography. Others like gear a bunch. Many are somewhere in between.

Another factor is the extent to which the photographer might compartmentalize her/his photography. If most of what you do is one sort of thing — say landscape, or portraits, or street, or wildlife, or sports, or whatever — you might not see much advantage in using more than one system. Or perhaps one simply prefers to adapt one system than to use something more specialized. On the other hand, for those of us who work in several rather different photographic genres, and tend to keep them somewhat separate during a particular shoot, the mental gear shift to move from one approach to another is quite natural, and the advantages of different kinds of systems are real for us.

YMMV,

Dan, who photographs from here, with one sort of system...

http://gallery.gdanmitchell.com/gallery/var/resizes/HumanWorld/Cities/UnitedStates/SanFrancisco/SanFranciscoatNight/AsianStylesShopPeopleNight20150725.jpg

... to here, with something else entirely:

http://gallery.gdanmitchell.com/gallery/var/resizes/NaturalWorld/TheLandscape/California/SierraNevada/EasternSierra/Color/BasaltColumnsLichenFallPlants20151009.jpg

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 09:03 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 07:50 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.63 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Thanks for the link Dan ... good stuff, timeless @ 100 years ago, or 100 years from now.

http://www.huntingtonwitherill.com/resources/articles_progress.php

Combined with this one ^ (contained within yours), it still rings true today for those who understand what is being said. The short of it is that I don't want to be on the Hamster Wheel of chasing variety and latest iterations. I want a stable platform that I can meld into oblivion without thought, so I can be as the author has more eloquently indicated than I could ever do.

Split platforms (imo) are the anti-thesis of such a concept. For me, that knocks the Sony out of the running (until Sony develops a completely unified platform of their own) for now when using the Canon platform as ... well, the platform. I'm not opposed to retooling and re-investing in a new learning curve ... I'm just not interested in a perpetual bouncing back & forth any more. So, if I'm gonna re-tool / re-learn (hey relearning is a tough gig for TBI) ... it's gotta be "all in" and for the "long haul". I just don't see current Sony utilization as being convergent to such philosophy as the author presents.

Sometimes it can be hard to discern between being a dinosaur headed for extinction and a sage elder allowing the Hamster Wheel to pass on by. I try to avoid the former, but the Hamster Wheel isn't my gig these days. Who knows, there may even be others who prefer to stay off it as well.
Oct 13, 2015 at 08:18 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
Thanks for the link Dan ... good stuff, timeless @ 100 years ago, or 100 years from now.

http://www.huntingtonwitherill.com/resources/articles_progress.php

Combined with this one ^ (contained within yours), it still rings true today for those who understand what is being said. The short of it is that I don't want to be on the Hamster Wheel of chasing variety and latest iterations. I want a stable platform that I can meld into oblivion without thought, so I can be as the author has more eloquently indicated than I could ever do.

Split platforms (imo) are the anti-thesis of such a concept. For me, that
...Show more →

From the Irony Department: Witherall, whose photography I love and whose ideas often make a lot of sense to me, contrary to the perspective in that article was actually one of the first to do truly creative and original work that relied on digital processes, even though his primary background is in what might be termed the "West Coast Black and White Large Format Landscape School."

I love irony. ;-)

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 09:18 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 08:59 AM
helimat
Offline
Details
p.63 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
For the record, I personally don't mind different platforms, and switching between them. That is not my beef here. I have over the last few years used different Sigma, Ricoh, Fuji and Sony kits alongside my Canon kit. In fact, the Ricoh remains, and I absolutely love it. The fact is I managed to get used to of all of their interfaces right away, except Sony's, as it sucks ballz.
Oct 13, 2015 at 09:01 AM
Imagemaster
Offline
Details
p.63 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Or, take a moment to read them and to comment on my actual points rather than dismissing my points of view because too many words.


Well I might if there were not always too many unnecessary words. And your images are always posted too small.

Maybe larger images and smaller dialogues

Taking time to write a comment that is more than a few sentences long reflects a recognition that things are not always subject to one-liner come-backs, that nuance is appropriate... and it might also reflect respect for the intellects of some participating in the dialog.

Nuance can be oh-so-boring. Perhaps the more intellectual can understand fewer words.
Oct 13, 2015 at 09:13 AM
Monito
Offline
Details
p.63 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
"If I had more time I would have written it shorter." -- Mark Twain
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:21 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Monito wrote:
"If I had more time I would have written it shorter." -- Mark Twain


Time I don't have for forum posts.

On the other hand, I do have a book. I know about real editing and writing, too.

Dan

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 10:25 AM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:25 AM
hiepphotog
Offline
Details
p.63 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:25 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.63 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?


Between Sony A7r/A7rII and Canon DSLRs (and excluding other choices) within that context probably the Sony. In fact, some will prefer the Sony MF system with its focusing aids in the EVF. However, if you work from the tripod the difference is less significant.

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

For "some applications" there is no doubt that it could do so. I refer you to the discussions in the Sony forum for a wide variety of direct user reports and discussions.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?

In the vast majority of cases in which AF is critical to the user, Canon is almost universally reported to be still ahead, though Sony will apparently work decently or even very well depending on the lenses and the nature of your shooting. But see that Sony forum, and consider what you read in the light of your own expectations.

Edited on Oct 13, 2015 at 12:50 PM · View previous versions
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:27 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.63 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
hiepphotog wrote:
So what is the consensus so far? Say if I split it into three scenarios:

1. Manual focus lenses that can be used on both (say the Otus). Which platform would make more sense and why?

2. Auto-focus Canon: Is Sony good enough for some applications that it can replace the Canon system? In the near future, Sony can use Nikon AF-S as well.

3. Auto-focus Canon vs. Auto-Focus Sony: Is the speed of native Sony good enough already to stand on its own?


I can only comment on 1 as I don't have first hand experience with the new AF and the picture changes rapidly regarding 2 and 3.

The consensus regarding 1 seems to be that it boils down to individual preference and usage.

For tripod work, the 5DS R has the advantages of the highest resolution and the possibility to avoid adapters. They can be tricky, and adapter thickness micrometers matter for corner performance on wide angle lenses. I have first hand experience with that and the Zeiss Distagon 21/2.8

For handheld work, the Sony mirrorless have the advantage of magnified focus view in the EVF. That advantage cannot be overstated for this kind of usage.
Oct 13, 2015 at 10:38 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister