I have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.
The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?
If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
I have a 5D2. I pre-ordered the 5DS about a month ago. The new Sony looks to be a good camera but it has not altered my plans one bit. It would have to be revolutionary and "blow away" the 5DS for me to bother with adapters, different ergonomics, a new workflow, battery life, repair support, and all the other issues. It isn't and it doesn't. The incremental advantage of the extra DR would be nice but does not overcome the negatives for me.
Between the two, I would summarize by: either you need DR, or AF !
If you can not rely on AF, go for A7RII. If you really need AF, go for 5DsR !
Having switched entirely to A7R for more than a year, I would not go back. But I keep a Canon bodie just for my personal photos which requires AF ...
Anyway, I use only Canon lenses, Canon flashes, same radio triggers, haven't changed my workflow at all (shoot raw and lightroom). It's just another tool to put on the back of my lenses with still a shutter button ... and amazing IQ...
matejphoto wrote:
I have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.
The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?
If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
Pick what works for you. Keep in mind the reports of AF improvements on the A7rII are totally untested and seem a little suspect. Also keep in mind that the new Sony is the same price or more compared to the new canon, assuming you are already a canon user. Add in the metabones, extra batteries and gadgets, maybe a native FE lens or two. I would suspect the cost to add a Sony to my gear would be upwards of 5k (in CAN $)
jctriguy wrote:
... I would suspect the cost to add a Sony to my gear would be upwards of 5k (in CAN $)
The current Henry's price for a new A7R and new Metabones IV is $2825 (incl. 15% HST). I estimate the new A7RII + Metabones IV will cost about $3800, tax in.
Update: make that $4600 CA (incl. 15% HST).
Wow, it's initial retail price is way higher than I expected. If you throw in a Metabones IV, it's $400 CA more expensive than a Canon 5DS (before sales tax).
KiboOst wrote:
Between the two, I would summarize by: either you need DR, or AF !
For the op if this is case or you need both af and dr. You're only option there is nikon lol.
For the people that ordered the 5ds/r they know canons limitations in the dr area and probably bracketed previously and will continue bracketin so it's a non issue for most of them.
matejphoto wrote:
I have a Canon 5D mark II (since Jan 2009) and have been patiently waiting for a significant upgrade in sensor tech. 5D mark III looks great but for my work I don't need the speed.
The 5Ds looked like the answer but the lack of increase in dynamic range is disappointing to me. Are any of you who were gonna buy the 5Ds are now considering the Sony A7rII?
If the 5Ds had the dynamic range of the Sony sensors, I would not look any further. It just seems silly to buy old sensor tech at nearly $4000.
+1. Exactly. Canon is by far not there with its own sensor tech compared to Sony (still 0.5 micrometer process generation based as for the FF sensors made in 2008). The only advantage I can see going for Canon is the better AF reliability with EF lenses. Even if the A7R II has improved the AF capability with third party lenses, it likely won't work exactly 1:1, and the precision is unknown so far. If AF and high resolution are equally important for somebody, then the 5Ds series might be still the best but compromising in DR and other options which the Sony camera provides. Clearly $4K is too much now compared to the competition.
If I personally didn't add an A7R already over a year ago, I would add to an A7R II now for sure.
For a moment I considered the 5Ds. And if it had come in at $2,700 and had a magical DR improvement... I might have been swayed. I decided not to buy one shortly after it was officially announced.
Before the A7r2 was announced I nearly bought an A7r to run alongside my 5D2 and Fuji X-E1, but I knew a replacement was coming, and I didn't want to go through the hassle of buying and selling, so I held off.
I'm going to be picking up the A7r2 if the AF really is a dramatic improvement-- A72-level for one-shot AF or better. I'm almost positive it will easily hit my expectations. I will probably be saying goodbye to the camera combo that has made incredible images and put food on my plate for many years now: Canon 5D2 and 35L. If Rokinon ever comes out with an 18mm f/2 or f/2.8 manual focus prime with great coma control for FE-mount... I'll drop my Fuji too.
I'm pretty excited since I've been in a camera holding pattern for the last two years.
I care much less about the size of the fab process or the supposed age of the technology than I do about the images.
For what I will be getting, and the way the end-of-the-day price of the new Sony is about the same as the new Canon, it is simply wrong to say "clearly $4K is too much now compared to the competition". There is no "clearly" about it. I'm paying for the 5DS and I am confident that overall when everything is considered I am getting the better system and I'll be able to make better images my way more easily.
Those who see this as an AF versus DR issue seem to have clouded vision that misses dozens of issues that factor in to the decision of which to purchase.
In this thread, many people are going to say something negative about a camera that many other like and are going to buy. I encourage all to not get defensive when some negative aspect of "your" or "my" camera is mentioned, but rather keep this open minded thinking. It is good times when we have so good tools to select from
If I should name one thing against A7R II, then 290 shots per battery seems a bit low. Like Sigma low.
Plus native Canon lens will most likely perform better on 5Ds. Now matter how good they are with on sensor AF, its not dSLR but mirrorless. And if you add poor battery life to mix, it wont AF for long..
Monito wrote:
I care much less about the size of the fab process or the supposed age of the technology than I do about the images.
For what I will be getting, and the way the end-of-the-day price of the new Sony is about the same as the new Canon, it is simply wrong to say "clearly $4K is too much now compared to the competition". There is no "clearly" about it. I'm paying for the 5DS and I am confident that overall when everything is considered I am getting the better system and I'll be able to make better images my way more easily.
Those who see this as an AF versus DR issue seem to have clouded vision that misses dozens of issues that factor in to the decision of which to purchase. ...Show more →
I agree, except for this: For some people it really does boil down to autofocus vs. dynamic range when comparing these two cameras/systems for their specific needs..
That doesn't mean there aren't a host of other considerations, from lenses and flash systems, to camera responsiveness, to battery life, weight, size, shape, workflow-- hell, even the hassle of switching one way or another! It just means that for some people both systems pass all thresholds except for AF and DR... and at that point those folks need to choose between those two features.
The flip side is this: For some people both AF and DR are non-issues with either camera. For them it obviously boils down to different things altogether.
I don't think either scenario means that the person in question has clouded vision. The only clouded vision is the perspective that one's own vision (wants, needs, measuring points for purchase) must necessarily apply in total, or even part, to all others.
KiboOst wrote:
Between the two, I would summarize by: either you need DR, or AF !
If you can not rely on AF, go for A7RII. If you really need AF, go for 5DsR !
Having switched entirely to A7R for more than a year, I would not go back. But I keep a Canon bodie just for my personal photos which requires AF ...
Anyway, I use only Canon lenses, Canon flashes, same radio triggers, haven't changed my workflow at all (shoot raw and lightroom). It's just another tool to put on the back of my lenses with still a shutter button ... and amazing IQ......Show more →
The A7rii is reported to support PDAF on Canon lenses via the Metabones adapter and has been observed to be nearly as fast as PDAF on a native Canon camera (source):
"PDAF works with Canon lenses via Metabones adapter, and A-mount lenses via the LA-E3. We're checking to see if you actually get the full AF coverage with subject tracking, but for now, consider our minds blown"
jcolwell wrote:
I'll probably pick up a used A7R in near mint condition, for peanuts.
mogud wrote:
In a year or so, you would then be able to pickup a near mint A7r II for the same peanuts. Gotta get the latest and greatest shiny new thing...
I have been using the a7r since it was introduced. I got frustrated that canon did not have a high mpx camera, and jumped to a7r.
The a7r has a great sensor. 36mpx and higher dynamic range. The dynamic range for me was not significant - I have not noticed a big advantage - sure you have more but pushing exposures just looked not great. It was not high enough to avoid AEB/Blending. The sony system was not versatile enough for wildlife for me to go to one system, so I have two sets of batteries, lens, etc.
The downsides of the a7r for me have been - very poor battery life (almost unusable for me for multiday hiking), two different systems (two different 24-70's for example, multple batteries, chargers...), and the pain of the adapters, a menu system that is not as polished as the canon (and unfamiliar because of the swithing back and forth between wildlife and landscape) and the a7x system is just not small enough to be worth the extra effort because he sensor is too close to the flange to permit small range finder ultra wide lens without color shifting on edges..
On a couple of occasions I have used my 5diii for landscape since and it has been liking coming home. I know where everything is, the fussing is reduced and the battery just keeps on going....
The new a7rii camera is not going to change much. It will still cause two different systems.... I feel more comfortable spending $12000 on a canon lens than a sony because sony might change there mind on mounts, and canon will keep up.
So I am going to buy the 5dsr and sell the adapters/a7r/chargers/lens/ batteries. It was a nice experiment but I need to simplify and canon has great lens and system for landscape and wildlife combined.
Scott Stoness wrote:
The new a7rii camera is not going to change much. It will still cause two different systems.... I feel more comfortable spending $12000 on a canon lens than a sony because sony might change there mind on mounts, and canon will keep up.
You mean like Canon changing from FD mount to EF mount?