fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.30 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Jon Tainton wrote:
Although the Nikonians don't seem to be afflicted with Sony acolytes to the same extent that the Canon forum suffers from.


I've noticed that, too. There are many possible explanations, though one is the fact that the D800/D810 use the same sensor as the A7r, making that comparison less, uh, "interesting." :-)

I was also a bit surprised at the intensity of Ming Thien's negative comments on the A7rII. In some ways I think he is perhaps a bit more willing to point out invisible clothing on emperors, but in this case he might have made the same points in a slightly less inflammatory manner. (Though this approach probably gets more clicks... ;-) I don't regard his review as the "last word" on this camera at all, but it is one more interesting data point in a range of reviews.

Dan
Aug 29, 2015 at 04:57 PM
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.30 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Jon Tainton wrote Although the Nikonians don't seem to be afflicted with Sony acolytes to the same extent that the Canon forum suffers from.
I've noticed that, too. There are many possible explanations, though one is the fact that the D800/D810 use the same sensor as the A7r, making that comparison less, uh, "interesting." :-)

I was also a bit surprised at the intensity of Ming Thien's negative comments on the A7rII. In some ways I think he is perhaps a bit more willing to point out invisible clothing on emperors, but in this case he might have made the same points in a slightly less inflammatory manner. (Though this approach probably gets more clicks... ;-) I don't regard his review as the "last word"
...Show more →

MT is no stranger to the emotional response generated by his candid reviews of the A7 series, probably why he took the approach of being hung for a sheep than a lamb for the A7r2 review.

The great pity is that there just aren't many reviewers of photography gear that can tick the boxes of; professional photographer, real world usage, technical knowledge, awareness of other camera systems capabilities and integrity.
Aug 31, 2015 at 03:55 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.30 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Jon Tainton wrote Although the Nikonians don't seem to be afflicted with Sony acolytes to the same extent that the Canon forum suffers from.
I've noticed that, too. There are many possible explanations, though one is the fact that the D800/D810 use the same sensor as the A7r, making that comparison less, uh, "interesting." :-)


The reason why this is brought up here in a much bigger extent than in the Nikon forum is exactly because Nikon had the sensor since 2012 in the D800 series cameras. It was a big mistake of Canon to ignore demand for improved FF high MP/high DR sensors for many years. It remains the Achilles heel of Canon in their FF cameras even the 5Ds(R) is finally a long overdue response of Canon in the FF market. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
Aug 31, 2015 at 05:58 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.30 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
gdanmitchell wrote
Jon Tainton wrote Although the Nikonians don't seem to be afflicted with Sony acolytes to the same extent that the Canon forum suffers from.
I've noticed that, too. There are many possible explanations, though one is the fact that the D800/D810 use the same sensor as the A7r, making that comparison less, uh, "interesting." :-)
The reason why this is brought up here in a much bigger extent than in the Nikon forum is exactly because Nikon had the sensor since 2012 in the D800 series cameras. It was a big mistake of Canon to ignore demand for improved FF high MP/high DR sensors for many years. It remains the Achilles heel of Canon in their FF cameras even the 5Ds(R) is finally a long overdue response of Canon in the FF market. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.


I agree, except that sometime during 2013 or even early 2014 would have been an appropriate response time for Canon to release the 5DS / 5DS R. Here in 2015, it seems like we are in a strange time warp where Canon is re-learning the same thing Nikon already learned with the 2012 D800 and D800E before finally moving to an sensor with no OLP filter in the 2014 D810.

The impression I begin to get, when I see new products like the XC10, is that Canon is an out-of-touch no-longer-innovative company (XC10 is one of the worst cringe-inducing new products I can remember seeing in years). However, the new glass in the upcoming EF 35mm f/1.4L II looks very cutting edge, so I am excited about that. Hopefully the 5D IV will wow us.

Regarding DR, I'll say this: Canon is making modest gains at base ISO while Sony has made none since 2012 (although the D810 got a nice boost by making ISO 64 the base). In fact the a7R II takes a small step backward at base ISO. So, the DR gap is closing.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:28 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.30 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.


The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:40 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.30 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.


+1...Thank you for very eloquently knocking down this tired and reparative comment.
Aug 31, 2015 at 06:57 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.30 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.


You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
Aug 31, 2015 at 07:12 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.30 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking
...Show more →

I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.


Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 07:23 AM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 07:22 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.30 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.


^+2
Yes, well said alundeb. I always appreciate responses like that that show good historical perspective.

Perhaps my greatest frustration with arguing about these products is that it is an argument over which phenomenal camera is better. Weighing it all out I felt the 5DS / R serves me a little better, but I would have been extremely pleased with either. I just needed a high-resolution image capturing device that can serve me for many years to come.

When it comes to making images, the choice of camera model does not appear to have a significant impact on the quality of the final results. In my book both cameras have incredible capabilities ideally suited to my type of work and I don't think my results will be either negatively or positively impacted by either.
Aug 31, 2015 at 07:23 AM
ggreene
Offline
Details
p.30 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
This may be a terrible attitude but I just don't care about how a camera system gets the IQ that it has. If a 5D4/1DX2 has better high ISO because of other methods deployed beyond the sensor then that's the bottom line for me.

That said, the Sony A7RII high ISO looks pretty solid to me. If Sony ever decides to build a decent body to surround it with I would be tempted. It would be great to have some flagship competition as the Canon/Nikon entries are getting really expensive to justify.
Aug 31, 2015 at 07:49 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.30 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
It was the lack of progress with the sensor from the 5d2 to the 5d3 that led me to look at Sony which not only increased quite substantially the pixels, but also the dynamic range of their sensor. I rented the A7R and have never looked back.

If the 5d3 had an improved sensor, I would not looked elsewhere...but that did not occur. The 5d3 had no improvements over the 5d2 for me.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:05 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.30 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
+1...Thank you for very eloquently knocking down this tired and reparative comment.


It would be fun to make a small list of such "arguments." It wouldn't be hard, since we hear them so often. ;-)

I wonder why the Sony Über Alles gang finds it sooooo important to reassure themselves by arguing incessantly in Canon forums? It seems to me that they could do the same thing in the Sony forum. Why not? One can hardly find a thread here on, say, neck straps or lens caps or pictures of my kids that does not soon get taken over by Serial Sony-istas beating everyone over the head with the Marvelous Wonders of Sony, and further harassing those whose point of view might fall short of abject worship of the Sony God.

Heaven forbid that one might think that Sony is fine but isn't necessarily the ne plus ultra in all ways for all people at all times. How dare a person think that they might choose something else and still be credited with intelligence above the level of a sea urchin!

Something tells me that the motives here are not limited to just questions of camera functionality or photography, but that for some these "brand wars" are a place to act out some other non-photographic issues. And when that happens, imagining that a respectful discussion of the purported question (cameras) will lead somewhere useful starts to look more and more unpromising.

Also, I've noticed that aside from a very few posts, there seems to be a much lower number of Nikon, Fuji, Pentax, Olympus users doing this stuff in the Canon forum, and a much lower number of Canon, Nikon, Fuji, Pentax, Olympus users doing this in Sony forums. Hmmmm...

Dan

(As always, Sony makes some very fine cameras. Among my friends and fellow photographers are several who use Sony A7r and A7rII cameras to make beautiful photographs. I have nothing against Sony as a brand or these cameras as products and we never get into these bizarre, endless arguments about our cameras. As to the Sony Gang in this forum, my Sony-using and other friends find their antics just as bizarre and inexplicable and annoying as the rest of us do – their reaction alternates between laughter and embarrassment.)

Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 02:20 PM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:25 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.30 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
It was the lack of progress with the sensor from the 5d2 to the 5d3 that led me to look at Sony which not only increased quite substantially the pixels, but also the dynamic range of their sensor. I rented the A7R and have never looked back.

If the 5d3 had an improved sensor, I would not looked elsewhere...but that did not occur. The 5d3 had no improvements over the 5d2 for me.


I felt the same way you did at that time and bought the A7r instead of upgrading the 5DII to the 5DIII for exactly the same reasons. The A7r is a great camera, but the shutter shock at 1/30 - 1/120 seconds exposure time is real, and the AF left a lot to be desired. The 5DS (R) feels like a nice upgrade from the A7r in many ways, and I am more happy with it than I was with the A7r.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:30 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.30 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology.


I guess for those who need groundbreaking technology to advance their photography, that makes the 5Ds a colossal failure.

Still shooting SLR/C ... that was groundbreaking in 2004 ... and it still can handle its own at base ISO just fine. Feed it some light and it does very well. Starve it of light and not so much.

I dig that new technology can now see a fart in the wind ... but, that doesn't do much for teaching folks that still don't understand how to draw with light (i.e. photo + graph).

For some folks who use their cameras as merely light recorders, the ability to PP everything to the nth degree from near nothingness is ever more critical for them. For those folks who have a better understanding of their light (ummm, Studio designator), it just isn't as critical to them to have "groundbreaking" technology to achieve their photographic goals.

Sure, the adage of "more is better" can be slung around all day long. But, that doesn't always mean that "more is necessary". That can pertain to anything from MP to DR.

I've got an old axe that my grandfather used. The handle on it is "sweeeeet". Sure, I can get a groundbreaking composite handled axe ... but it just doesn't feel the same in my hands and isn't a joy to swing. With the old handle, I can chop wood all day long.

Put that little Sony in some folks hands, and they just don't find it works the same way as their "old" technology does. Technology always marches on ... wait 5 seconds and your latest gizmo will be "old". In the meantime, there are those who continue to use "old" technology ... umm, I believe the A7R II still uses USB 2.0 whereas the 5Ds uses USB 3.0 ... and still get the job done, predicated on their knowledge and experience that can still exceed the benefits of a given technological advancement.

Technology advancements are often a cool thing ... but, it doesn't necessarily mean it is a better tool for a given task, nor that one needs it for their given purposes or preferences. If that's the case, then you should have been shooting with the cell phone when it hit the 40+ MP .... ooooh, that was groundbreaking too. Big whoop. As to the A7R II ... it still is limited in what it can do with long glass AF. Hmmmm, how groundbreaking is that, when it is actually a reversion from existing "old" technology's capabilities.

The short of it is that the A7R II is a trade-off of "this" for "that". If the "this" is up your alley ... super, duper Cooper. If the "that" is your thing, then not so much.

BTW, Sony could have already put all that technology into the A77 II, or an A99 II ... but, they haven't. So, they should be bashed for being behind where they could have already been too. What, you say ... they've been working on the E-mount because of the market. Hmmmm, you mean like Canon has been working on glass because of the market. You want to bash on Canon for being behind in "technological" advances, then you should be bashing Sony for being behind in optical offering advances or FF body offering advances.

Hey, what's good for the goose, is good for the gander. Just sayin'.


ggreene wrote:
That said, the Sony A7RII high ISO looks pretty solid to me. If Sony ever decides to build a decent body to surround it with I would be tempted.


This ^

... and add some glass to the lineup.


Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 08:51 AM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:35 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.30 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
I felt the same way you did at that time and bought the A7r instead of upgrading the 5DII to the 5DIII for exactly the same reasons. The A7r is a great camera, but the shutter shock at 1/30 - 1/120 seconds exposure time is real, and the AF left a lot to be desired. The 5DS (R) feels like a nice upgrade from the A7r in many ways, and I am more happy with it than I was with the A7r.


The a7R shutter is the only thing I really hate about that camera, otherwise I really like it. And I am keeping it for two reasons:
1. The a7R gives me the ability to use an ND filter (a 1-10 stop variable ND no less!) with my 11-24mm. The 1-10 stop variable filter is built into the Fotodiox ND Throttle adapter. Super cool. Even if Lee or Fotodiox eventually make a front filter bracket for the 11-24mm I'll want no part of that monstrosity!

2. Love the EVF and tiltable screen for better handheld manual focus experience and for getting the camera into otherwise awkward positions (like down low).

To me the a7R is nothing more than an off-brand Canon accessory.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:40 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.30 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
To me the a7R is nothing more than an off-brand Canon accessory.


Priceless, and sage perspective.

Edited on Aug 31, 2015 at 08:44 AM · View previous versions
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:43 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.30 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
alundeb wroteI felt the same way you did at that time and bought the A7r instead of upgrading the 5DII to the 5DIII for exactly the same reasons. The A7r is a great camera, but the shutter shock at 1/30 - 1/120 seconds exposure time is real, and the AF left a lot to be desired. The 5DS (R) feels like a nice upgrade from the A7r in many ways, and I am more happy with it than I was with the A7r.
The a7R shutter is the only thing I really hate about that camera, otherwise I really like it. And I am keeping it for two reasons:
1. The a7R gives me the ability to use an ND filter (a 1-10 stop variable ND no less!) with my 11-24mm. The 1-10 stop variable filter is built into the Fotodiox ND Throttle adapter. Super cool. Even if Lee or Fotodiox eventually make a front filter bracket for the 11-24mm I'll want no part of that monstrosity!

2. Love the EVF and tiltable screen for better handheld manual focus experience and for getting
...Show more →

I am also keeping my A7r and still like many things about it. The one thing i really miss in the 5DS R is the tiltable LCD. Dare I say, I miss it more than the extended DR of the A7r
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:43 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.30 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
The one thing i really miss in the 5DS R is the tiltable LCD. Dare I say, I miss it more than the extended DR of the A7r


Which is why an A99 II could be a very nice camera it Sony would finish putting the pieces of the puzzle all together in one place ... Or CaNikon would make an articulated display for one of their FF cameras, such as the D820 or 5D4
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:46 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.30 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
retrofocus wroteThere is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology.
I guess for those who need groundbreaking technology to advance their photography, that makes the 5Ds a colossal failure.

Still shooting SLR/C ... that was groundbreaking in 2004 ... and it still can handle its own at base ISO just fine. Feed it some light and it does very well. Starve it of light and not so much.

I dig that new technology can now see a fart in the wind ... but, that doesn't do much for teaching folks that still don't understand how to draw with light (i.e. photo + graph).

For some folks who use their cameras as
...Show more →
ggreene wroteThat said, the Sony A7RII high ISO looks pretty solid to me. If Sony ever decides to build a decent body to surround it with I would be tempted.


Like you say Rusty...tradeoff's...and there are many with any system you choose. You are starting to come off as if some systems have no tradeoff's...which is just not the case.

As far as not knowing how to take good photos with new technology...that is everyone's choice to make...and who are we to judge the enjoyment people get out of new technology. Everyone chooses their equipment based on their own needs ( desires more likely ) and I don't judge those desires. I can see why some people don't like the Sony platform and I respect that...but then I also see why many really enjoy the platform ( I'm one )...and I hope others can respect that as well.

Tradeoff's there are plenty no matter what system you choose...people make these tradeoffs for many reasons, some of which might not line up with others.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:49 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.30 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
retrofocus wroteThere is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology.
I guess for those who need groundbreaking technology to advance their photography, that makes the 5Ds a colossal failure.

Still shooting SLR/C ... that was groundbreaking in 2004 ... and it still can handle its own at base ISO just fine. Feed it some light and it does very well. Starve it of light and not so much.

I dig that new technology can now see a fart in the wind ... but, that doesn't do much for teaching folks that still don't understand how to draw with light (i.e. photo + graph).

For some folks who use their cameras as
...Show more →
ggreene wroteThat said, the Sony A7RII high ISO looks pretty solid to me. If Sony ever decides to build a decent body to surround it with I would be tempted.


I wouldn't consider the 5Ds(R) as failure - in fact I consider it the best DSLR put out in the market by Canon since the 5D MkII was released. My point is that it came simply too late and now more competitive products are out there. I can clearly say that I would have upgraded from my 5D MkII to the 5DsR if the 5DsR would have been available in 2012. I likely would have never looked outside of Canon considering Sony (even using MF lenses on FF mirrorless would have been a very attractive point, but assuming I had already a camera like the 5DsR, it would not have turned the table for me in favor to add with the A7 series).

I repeat what I said often before: the sensor is for me the heart of any kind of digital camera (the brain is the image processor, also very important!). Everything else has always been a secondary priority for me - AF, fps, all kind of bells and whistles. Main reason for me to upgrade to the A7R II is not for all the features like improved AF, IBIS etc etc.....it is simply how the new backlit sensor performs with some of my lenses. If there is enough of a benefit, then I do it. If not, I rather wait another generation.

Regarding timing, I am not aware that this kind of backlit sensor was introduced anywhere before the A7R II - so why do you think it could have been implemented in an older A77/A99 cameras?

But I agree in your point (and I pointed it out in earlier comments repeatedly in other threads) that Sony needs to work harder on getting lenses out, especially smaller sized ones which do not look like DSLR lenses in size. I absolutely agree that this currently is Sony's Achilles heel.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:50 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister