fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
rattlebonez
Offline
Details
p.31 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
If Sony released a "A7R EF" with a Canon EF mount they might have a useful camera.
But would have to solve the problem of slow focus using metabones.

My 5DS does not fail with slow focus, and lack of native lenses.

5DS is the clear winner for my needs where the subject is moving, wildlife, BIF, etc.
Aug 31, 2015 at 08:56 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.31 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Like you say Rusty...tradeoff's...and there are many with any system you choose. You are starting to come off as if some systems have no tradeoff's...which is just not the case.

As far as not knowing how to take good photos with new technology...that is everyone's choice to make...and who are we to judge the enjoyment people get out of new technology. Everyone chooses their equipment based on their own needs ( desires more likely ) and I don't judge those desires. I can see why some people don't like the Sony platform and I respect that...but then I also see why
...Show more →

As many times as I've stated "horses for courses" ... me starting to come off as suggesting "no trade-offs" seems a bit

As to respecting it both ways ... I'm good with that. Always have been, always will be. Now, if others would simply respect it reciprocally when folks prefer to use their tools of choice as well. But, there has been a plethora of threads from Sony fans advocating that Canon, non-Sony users are making a mistake at leaving something on the table. Well, that of course, cuts both ways (although certain folks seem quite refute to acknowledge those aspects as being meaningful, since it isn't meaningful to them).

If folks like shooting the little Sony ... super. If they prefer shooting (anything else) ... super. I like riding my Harley motorcycle and I like driving my Dodge truck. Big whoop if someone else is riding a new Goldwing fan with variable valve timing (don't know if that exists or not) and driving a Ford truck with Bluetooth and built in navigation. I don't need those things to A) get from point A to point B, and B) I don't need them to enjoy getting from point A to point B.

Horses for courses.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:03 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.31 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
alundeb wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.


Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:05 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.31 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteLike you say Rusty...tradeoff's...and there are many with any system you choose. You are starting to come off as if some systems have no tradeoff's...which is just not the case.

As far as not knowing how to take good photos with new technology...that is everyone's choice to make...and who are we to judge the enjoyment people get out of new technology. Everyone chooses their equipment based on their own needs ( desires more likely ) and I don't judge those desires. I can see why some people don't like the Sony platform and I respect that...but then I also see why many really enjoy the platform ( I'm one )...and I hope others can respect that as well.
As many times as I've stated "horses for courses" ... me starting to come off as suggesting "no trade-offs" seems a bit

As to respecting it both ways ... I'm good with that. Always have been, always will be. Now, if others would simply respect it reciprocally when folks prefer to use their tools of choice as well. But, there has been a plethora of threads from Sony fans advocating that Canon, non-Sony users are making a mistake at leaving something on the table. Well, that of course, cuts both ways (although certain folks seem quite refute to acknowledge those
...Show more →

Well Rusty this statement from you kind of seems to judge some folks who purchase new technology.

"I dig that new technology can now see a fart in the wind ... but, that doesn't do much for teaching folks that still don't understand how to draw with light (i.e. photo + graph)."

Maybe folks are happy "they don't understand how to draw with light"...whatever that is. I'm not judging these folks who buy these new technologies.

I bet many folks are purchasing the new Canon megapickle who won't print anything larger than 8x10 with the camera...but whatever turns their cranks is fine with me.

Aug 31, 2015 at 09:12 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.31 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
Regarding timing, I am not aware that this kind of backlit sensor was introduced anywhere before the A7R II - so why do you think it could have been implemented in an older A77/A99 cameras?


I think I said (or meant to say) ... the A77 II and the A99 II. (otherwise, we are in more agreement in your last post)

The A77 II was just recently released. They could have just as easily held off and put that BSI into the A77 II, or brought out the A99 II with it instead of the A7R II.

BTW ... because of the SLT translucent sharing of the light between the sensor and viewfinder, the SLT technology is essentially a full stop behind mirrorless or DSLR in term of the amount of light it puts to the sensor. From that, the SLT models stand the most to benefit from the BSI (more efficient retention of the light delivered to the sensor).

Drop the BSI technology into the SLT bodies ... and you've got something to raise the bar for them. They could also "double down" on the light reaching the sensor by making them BSI & mirrorless (rather than SLT) and still have a nice body wrapped around a good sensor.

While their Achilles Heel might be glass (in the E-mount in particular), their lack of a good body around their sensor is the "no can do" for me.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:14 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.31 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).


You are the one who makes assumptions without proof. I am just saying that we don't know.

The RX100 II had a BSI Exmor sensor 4 months before the release of the A7r.

Low ISO banding was present in all Canon sensors before the 5DII. the 5DII was worse than the best ones preceeding it, but the 5DS betters those old sensors by a fair margin. So that improvement is far from a joke.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:15 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:19 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.31 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I bet many folks are purchasing the new Canon megapickle who won't print anything larger than 8x10 with the camera...but whatever turns their cranks is fine with me.

+1 @ "more is better" doesn't necessarily mean "more is necessary" can take on a variety of manifestations. DR, MP, diminutive size, weight reduction, FPS, etc. ... know your poison(s) and threshold(s), then choose your tool(s).

Although, just because they aren't large printers, doesn't mean they aren't heavy croppers. But, your point also bodes well to the point that the 5D III or D810 (or A7r) is more than sufficient for many, while for others it can have real meaning.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:23 AM
jctriguy
Offline
Details
p.31 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).


BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:45 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.31 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?

Unlike Canon, Sony has to do a lot of R&D to make a new sensor family.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:52 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.31 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
retrofocus wrote:
But I agree in your point (and I pointed it out in earlier comments repeatedly in other threads) that Sony needs to work harder on getting lenses out, especially smaller sized ones which do not look like DSLR lenses in size. I absolutely agree that this currently is Sony's Achilles heel.


I think Sony (with some help from Zeiss) is doing an admirable job of churning out the basic zooms and primes people need. These things take time - no one can just start up a new lens mount and, in the space of two years, have a complete lens lineup.

Where I do fault Sony, somewhat, is on the optical quality of some of their lenses. If, for example, the F4 zooms (FE 16-35mm, 24-70mm, and 70-200mm) were the equal or better (or perhaps smaller/lighter) than the F4 zooms from Canon it would have made it easier for me to make a switch. And I bought and tried all those Sony zooms. They're nice, but not of the caliber I wanted. Now I have the Canon 11-24L, 24-70L II, and 70-200L f/4L IS and these zooms meet my optical performance expectations better.

Still the new Zeiss Batis lenses look very impressive and some of Sony's primes are quite excellent (35mm F1.4, 55mm F1.8, and the 90mm macro).

All in all Sony's doing a reasonably good job of addressing essential lens needs imo. When they circle back around to developing native f/2.8 zooms things might get interesting. Huge heavy lenses on a small body. I am intrigued as to how that's going to work in terms of appealing to photographers. Interesting times ahead.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:52 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.31 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
With today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.
Aug 31, 2015 at 09:56 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.31 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mogul wrote:
jctriguy wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wroteThe D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?
Unlike Canon, Sony has to do a lot of R&D to make a new sensor family.


Ah, that explains how Canon was supposed to be able to make a FF sensor with 7DII technology before the 7DII sensor, but Sony was not able to make a FF version of the RX100 II sensor right after the RX100 II. Canon can make sensor improvements without R&D and make them available in larger sensors before smaller. They just don't want to.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:05 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.31 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
With today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.


I agree, somewhat, but what works for you and me may not work for others...
The f/2.8 zooms are also the staple of many a portrait photographer - the convenience of a zoom combined with the appealing blur of thinner DOF @ f/2.8.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:14 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.31 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
darbo wrote:
chez wroteWith today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.
I agree, somewhat, but what works for you and me may not work for others...
The f/2.8 zooms are also the staple of many a portrait photographer - the convenience of a zoom combined with the appealing blur of thinner DOF @ f/2.8.


I would think events in darker venues is where the 2.8 zooms are really used the most. For portraits, its quite easy to zoom with your feet using a prime. We always hear about the 50 1.2, 85 1.2 and 135 f2 being great portrait lens.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:28 AM
Imagemaster
Online
Details
p.31 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
With today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.


Not everyone wants to use a higher ISO, and the f2.8 is still going to focus better than the f4 in low light.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:37 AM
mogul
Offline
Details
p.31 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Imagemaster wrote:
chez wroteWith today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.
Not everyone wants to use a higher ISO, and the f2.8 is still going to focus better than the f4 in low light.


A 2.8 will focus better in low light if your model of camera has a 2.8 AF sensor, usually only found in the center array.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:41 AM
retrofocus
Offline
Details
p.31 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
jctriguy wrote:
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote
alundeb wrote
retrofocus wrote. Great camera which should have been released already in 2012 instead of or in parallel to the 5D MkIII.
The D800 should have been released with or instead of the D700, which had too low resolution. The A7rII fixes many of the problems with the A7r, so it should have been released instead of the A7r. Now, since all cameras ever released are one generation too late, we can reset the counter and regard all current camera releases as what they are. Or wait for the next generation, that will be all the current gen should have been, except the little snag that at that time, we will expect more.
You forget here that the sensor in the A7R II is a totally different one than in the A7R even its resolution increase between 36 and 42 MP is not a lot. Canon's FF sensor technology remains pretty stagnant since the 5D MkII was released, no big changes here other than some improvement in high ISO (no hardware change but done with software algorithms). Even the 5Ds(R) finally has a great resolution, it relies on 7D MkII sensor technology simply doubling its resolution.

In fact the 5Ds(R) sensor easily could have been released 3 years ago. There is nothing groundbreaking new in its technology. Sony's technology is very different here, each generation so far showed a big advancement in sensor technology.
I don't think you know anything about when Canon could have released 50 MP without low ISO shadow banding ( a great acheivement from Canon since the 5DII ), and when Sony Could have released FF BSI. The order may be reverse of what you think.
Give me any proof for your assumption that the backlit sensor technology could be older and deriving from formerly implemented Sony or Nikon cameras. Pointing out that it was an improvement to remove sensor banding is a big joke IMO - it was an issue with the 5D MkII sensor which shouldn't have been there in the first place (BTW, the banding was still present in an lower extent in the 5D MkIII sensor since it was nearly the same anyway).
BSI sensor was sold by Sony in 2009. Why did it take 6 years to release in FF?


Because it is not the same sensor type. The one you refer to is the first of its kind which found a few years later its use in cell phone technology. It took a few more generations of this backlit sensor technology to make it feasible for FF. And this just has happened this year.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:46 AM
darbo
Offline
Details
p.31 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
darbo wrote
chez wroteWith today's great high ISO abilities, I'm seeing less need for 2.8 zooms and am opting for the f4 zooms. If I need to photograph in ultra dark environments, I'll turn to 1.4 primes. This is working out for me.
I agree, somewhat, but what works for you and me may not work for others...
The f/2.8 zooms are also the staple of many a portrait photographer - the convenience of a zoom combined with the appealing blur of thinner DOF @ f/2.8.
I would think events in darker venues is where the 2.8 zooms are really used the most. For portraits, its quite easy to zoom with your feet using a prime. We always hear about the 50 1.2, 85 1.2 and 135 f2 being great portrait lens.


They are nice portrait lenses, but you're all out of touch with what portrait shooters want if you think they don't want or need a 70-200mm f/2.8.
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:48 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.31 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
One question I have about the A7rII is - if Sony's lossy compression reduces 14-bit capture to only 11 bits, what happens when the camera switches to 12-bit capture? Does that drop the compressed "RAW" file to 9 bits, which is essentially a JPEG file?
Aug 31, 2015 at 10:55 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister