fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2015 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2015Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII

  
 
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #1Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
Rusty...can you elaborate on the type of shooting you do that you need a so called "professional" camera. I'd be interested in your demanding photography.


Sure, I shoot a lot of things predicated on timing. The responsiveness of my camera relates to my ability to capture such a moment in time. There are times when I work very slow and very methodically. There are times when I work in the split second of timing. To your point about size being able to be enlarged with a grip, yet you can't go smaller ... the same applies to you can always go slower, but you can't go faster (i.e. more responsive).

Where some folks are concerned by size as a significant attribute to be backed up against, others are concerned by responsiveness as a significant attribute to be backed up against ... more horses for courses.

But, whether or not ... I need or don't need one (or just prefer / want ) ... has no bearing (i.e. faulty logic) on the objective comparison between the cameras, nor the objective / subjective review provided. I'm merely pointing out my agreement to the points made in the review as one of a similar sentiment. As I mentioned (and so does the review), if those things are inconsequential to someone, so be it.

Denoting the differences is ... well, simply denoting the differences.

Aug 27, 2015 at 07:34 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #2Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wroteRusty...can you elaborate on the type of shooting you do that you need a so called "professional" camera. I'd be interested in your demanding photography.
Sure, I shoot a lot of things predicated on timing. The responsiveness of my camera relates to my ability to capture such a moment in time. There are times when I work very slow and very methodically. There are times when I work in the split second of timing. To your point about size being able to be enlarged with a grip, yet you can't go smaller ... the same applies to you can always go slower, but you can't go faster (i.e. more responsive).

Where some folks are concerned by size as a significant attribute to be backed up
...Show more →

I solve the issue by having two systems, one for my mythodical work, travel and street photography and one for my sports and wildlife photography. I haven't found one camera that is optimal for both roles. I've given up trying to fit a square into a hole.

As far as comparing the two cameras, they have a lot of similarities and many differences. To me the tradeoffs are between image quality, AF abilities, manual focus abilities and bulk / weight. Neither is optimal for sports or fast action...but the 5ds is better suited for that whereas the a7R2 delivers better dynamic range and is a more convenient travel.

No matter what camera you choose, both deliver "professional" results.
Aug 27, 2015 at 07:49 AM
Gunzorro
Offline
Details
p.29 #3Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Chez -- Did you mean your "mythological work" ?

chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote
chez wroteRusty...can you elaborate on the type of shooting you do that you need a so called "professional" camera. I'd be interested in your demanding photography.
Sure, I shoot a lot of things predicated on timing. The responsiveness of my camera relates to my ability to capture such a moment in time. There are times when I work very slow and very methodically. There are times when I work in the split second of timing. To your point about size being able to be enlarged with a grip, yet you can't go smaller ... the same applies to you can always go slower, but you can't go faster (i.e. more responsive).

Where some folks are concerned by size as a significant attribute to be backed up against, others are concerned by responsiveness as a significant attribute to be backed up against ... more horses for courses.

But, whether or not ... I need or don't need one (or just prefer / want ) ... has no bearing (i.e. faulty logic) on the objective comparison between the cameras, nor the objective / subjective review provided. I'm merely pointing out my agreement to the points made in the review as one of a similar sentiment. As I mentioned (and so does the review), if those things are inconsequential to someone, so be it.

Denoting the differences is ... well, simply denoting the differences.
I solve the issue by having two systems, one for my mythodical work, travel and street photography and one for my sports and wildlife photography. I haven't found one camera that is optimal for both roles. I've given up trying to fit a square into a hole.

As far as comparing the two cameras, they have a lot of similarities and many differences. To me the tradeoffs are between image quality, AF abilities, manual focus abilities and bulk / weight. Neither is optimal for sports or fast action...but the 5ds is better suited for that whereas the a7R2 delivers better dynamic
...Show more →

Aug 27, 2015 at 07:56 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #4Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
I solve the issue by having two systems


And some folks don't want to use two systems, so they aspire to find the one system that "best satisfies" their wants / desires / needs. That's why some folks have a small sedan and a large pickup, while others have an SUV. There is no such thing as a perfect solution ... just a preferred one.

No matter what camera you choose, both deliver "professional" results.

Okay, so we're in agreement.

RustyBug wrote:
That is not to say that the Sony can't make a mighty fine picture, it can. That is not to say the Sony can't be used for professional purposes, it can.


But, to your other points @ how you get there can be different. Well, that is always going to be matter of personal preference, so allowing the differences to be openly noted affords us the opportunity to make our own informed choices toward areas of interest / concern. Incessantly trying to squelch / dismiss those differences through re-direct / deflection as inconsequential helps no one to better understand the nuance of the inherent differences ... so they can make their own decisions for themselves.
Aug 27, 2015 at 08:12 AM
dgdg
Offline
Details
p.29 #5Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
What stops me from buying either of them after a little depreciation are reports about long exposure noise. I do well with the 5D3 and A7R up to seven minutes for night sky work. I can't step backwards with this even if other features are improved.
Aug 27, 2015 at 08:20 AM
alundeb
Offline
Details
p.29 #6Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
dgdg wrote:
What stops me from buying either of them after a little depreciation are reports about long exposure noise. I do well with the 5D3 and A7R up to seven minutes for night sky work. I can't step backwards with this even if other features are improved.


The 5DS would not be a step backward from the 5D3, they should be about equal for long exposures, with the A7r a little better and the A7rII quite a bit worse.
Aug 27, 2015 at 08:31 AM
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.29 #7Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Ouch.
Some of the comments make entertaining reading too
gdanmitchell wrote:
Another point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/

Aug 28, 2015 at 01:38 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #8Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
More "entertaining" reading over in the Nikon side of the house.

trenchmonkey wrote:
This thread still goin'
That lil Sony stuff's ok...if you have hands like a girl. Just saying'



https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370153/4

Aug 28, 2015 at 09:07 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.29 #9Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
gdanmitchell wrote:
Another point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/


-1, to make those stories more complete, we can throw this one in as well: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150822_1402-SonyA7R_II-focus.html

There is not much to argue from an engineering platform stand point.
Aug 29, 2015 at 05:54 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #10Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteAnother point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/
to make those stories more complete, we can throw this one in as well: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150822_1402-SonyA7R_II-focus.html


I'd say he's rather smitten by his keeper rate (+1 @ cool to hear its really good), yet seemingly he has likely lost sight of long glass users when he sums up things with ... IDK, maybe just a wee bit of hyperbole.

... it’s going to be very hard to argue in favor of any DSLR for 99% of shooters, including my workhorse Nikon D810.

With a comment like that, his earlier comment @ lacking credulity seems to be looking back at him in the mirror. 99% of shooters (defined in my mind as ILC shooters, not P&S / phones) ... kinda absurd. Likely the most ridiculous thing I've heard (albeit not a subscriber) from him, unless we consider it to be smitten hyperbole ... that or he's including camera phones / P&S shooters in his numbers (you know, the ones that make up his base readership ).

I dig his salient point at a good working AF system (meanwhile, proliferated with observations that it doesn't work so well with long glass), but his writing style on that one really took him down toward the basement of questionable objectivity from a previous perception of world renowned objectivity in my estimation. I"ll consider it a faux pas @ momentary lapse of reason.

When he sells his workhorse and all associated glass, and shoots 99% mirrorless platform, then his "talk" on this will match his "walk" ... otherwise, it never will ... at least, not until that happens. Imo, this is pretty hyperbolic commentary that belies my former perception of his reputed objectivity.

Kinda sad really.



Edited on Aug 29, 2015 at 07:13 AM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2015 at 06:25 AM
mttran
Offline
Details
p.29 #11Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
mttran wrote
gdanmitchell wroteAnother point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/
to make those stories more complete, we can throw this one in as well: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150822_1402-SonyA7R_II-focus.html
I'd say he's rather smitten by his keeper rate, and has likely lost sight of long glass users when he sums up things with ... maybe just a wee bit of hyperbole.

Earlier quoteit’s going to be very hard to argue in favor of any DSLR for 99% of shooters, including my workhorse Nikon D810.
With a comment like that, his earlier comment @ lacking credulity seems to be looking back at him in the mirror. 99% of shooters (defined in my mind as ILC shooters, not P&S / phones) ... kinda absurd. Likely the most ridiculous thing I've heard (albeit not a subscriber) from him, unless we consider it to be smitten hyperbole ... that or he's including camera phones / P&S shooters
...Show more →

Imo, his review does not limit to that level. There is not much room for DSLR system to grow when we compared to MILC system in the long run.
Aug 29, 2015 at 06:35 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #12Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
Imo, his review does not limit to that level. There is not much room for DSLR system to grow when we compared to MILC system in the long run.


There is not much room for gasoline powered cars to grow when compared to electric cars in the long run. Yet, that hardly makes it A) current and B) 99% applicable.

It's cool to see Sony continue on ... it's good for all @ rising tide floats all boats. Will we see an EVF in an D820 or D830 and D830EV option as it sounds that he would like to have. Sure, maybe, why not (although, I can think of a few folks who will tell you why not). But, it is still going to be one heck of a long day away before the mirrorless platform can supplant the DSLR platform.

This is particularly true, since the mirrorless platform is HEAVILY reliant on the DSLR glass for long glass and or specialty glass (like TS's). I mean, Sony themselves is CURRENTLY reliant on their A mount glass (ummm, dslr) for anything in the 2.8 realm or in order to reach beyond 200mm. 99% ... come on, that's ridiculous, and will remain to be so much into the future. Come back and re-read this five years from now. I highly expect that 99% still won't be at fruition then either (unless you're counting phones / P&S).

So, here we have two seemingly respected reviewers, both shooting the same cameras. One says, thanks but no thanks. The other says I'm gonna sell off my entire workhorse DSLR platform (well, that's the argument @ death of DSLR that 99% suggests) in favor of mirrorless. But, of course, he likely won't do that (and technically didn't say that), because he will remain in the 1% that the 99% doesn't apply to.

The odd thing is that while he did raise my perception of the AF system being good (presumably with native mount lenses, or moderate focal length glass), he lowered my perception of his objectivity by his hyperbolic summation. For someone unfamiliar (I'm marginally familiar @ non-subscriber) with his work, this one wreaks of one-sided, fan-boy, "oooh-oooh" something new, style writing. Hopefully, it's just a "one off", rather than an indication of more things to come ... hmmm, at what his paid / future readership base thinks about it.

Time will tell.

really

Edited on Aug 29, 2015 at 07:22 AM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2015 at 06:46 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #13Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
mttran wroteImo, his review does not limit to that level. There is not much room for DSLR system to grow when we compared to MILC system in the long run.
There is not much room for gasoline powered cars to grow when compared to electric cars in the long run. Yet, that hardly makes it A) current and B) 99% applicable.

It's cool to see Sony continue on ... it's good for all @ rising tide floats all boats. Will we see an EVF in an D820 or D830 and D830EV option as it sounds that he would like to have. Sure, maybe, why not (although, I can think of a few folks who will tell you why not). But, it is still going to be one heck of a long
...Show more →

Everyone has an agenda when they post a review...so I don't trust anyone of them to be totally bias free. But reading multiple reviews with varying opinions allows you to get a good picture. Renting the gear and trying it out yourself is the best review as far as I'm concerned. Only you can judge if equipment functions for your type of shooting. Relying on others to tell you a camera's buttons are uncomfortable or the view finder is awkward just paints the picture from their use...not yours.
Aug 29, 2015 at 07:20 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #14Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
chez wrote:
RustyBug wrote
mttran wroteImo, his review does not limit to that level. There is not much room for DSLR system to grow when we compared to MILC system in the long run.
There is not much room for gasoline powered cars to grow when compared to electric cars in the long run. Yet, that hardly makes it A) current and B) 99% applicable.

It's cool to see Sony continue on ... it's good for all @ rising tide floats all boats. Will we see an EVF in an D820 or D830 and D830EV option as it sounds that he would like to have. Sure, maybe, why not (although, I can think of a few folks who will tell you why not). But, it is still going to be one heck of a long day away before the mirrorless platform can supplant the DSLR platform.

This is particularly true, since the mirrorless platform is HEAVILY reliant on the DSLR glass for long glass and or specialty glass (like TS's). I mean, Sony themselves is CURRENTLY reliant on their A mount glass (ummm, dslr) for anything in the 2.8 realm or in order to reach beyond 200mm. 99% ... come on, that's ridiculous, and will remain to be so much into the future. Come back and re-read this five years from now. I highly expect that 99% still won't be at fruition then either (unless you're counting phones / P&S).

The odd thing is that while he did raise my perception of the AF system being good, he lowered my perception of his objectivity by his hyperbolic summation. For someone unfamiliar (I'm marginally familiar @ non-subscriber) with his work, this one wreaks of one-sided, fan-boy, "oooh-oooh" something new, style writing. Hopefully, it's just a "one off", rather than an indication of more things to come ... hmmm, at what his paid / future readership base thinks about it.

Time will tell.

really
Everyone has an agenda when they post a review...so I don't trust anyone of them to be totally bias free. But reading multiple reviews with varying opinions allows you to get a good picture. Renting the gear and trying it out yourself is the best review as far as I'm concerned. Only you can judge if equipment functions for your type of shooting. Relying on others to tell you a camera's buttons are uncomfortable or the view finder is awkward just paints the picture from their use...not yours.


I don't disagree that it will come down to personal preferences and hands on beats a review. To that we can agree. Reviews can be helpful as a primer for things of consideration that folks should look into for themselves (based on objectivity and/or acknowledged subjectivity). But, the reviewer didn't say anything remotely close to that. Instead, he overtly stated that it would be "very hard to argue in favor of any DSLR for 99% of shooters".

That just does not compute ... not even remotely. There are a myriad of factors that simply boil down to personal preference. He is essentially dismissing any possibilities for personal preference ... never mind the gross omission of any discussion regarding issues with long glass AF (which I'll assume he didn't shoot on that outing). How one omits such a pertinent component and still presents a conclusion that applies to "99% of shooters" ... well, let's just say it befuddles my concept of rational logic and objectivity.



Edited on Aug 29, 2015 at 07:44 AM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2015 at 07:31 AM
Cliff L.
Offline
Details
p.29 #15Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
mttran wrote:
gdanmitchell wroteAnother point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/
-1, to make those stories more complete, we can throw this one in as well: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150822_1402-SonyA7R_II-focus.html

There is not much to argue from an engineering platform stand point.


Lloyd does have a habit of taking his hyperbole to the extreme - the first time he gets one even slightly fuzzy image, the A7R II will suddenly become the "worst-focusing piece of $hit ever made"... (which would put it back in line with all the previous Sony models...)
Aug 29, 2015 at 07:41 AM
RustyBug
Offline
Details
p.29 #16Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
molson wrote:
mttran wrote
gdanmitchell wroteAnother point of view: http://blog.mingthein.com/2015/08/25/the-sony-a7r-ii-a7rii/
-1, to make those stories more complete, we can throw this one in as well: http://diglloyd.com/blog/2015/20150822_1402-SonyA7R_II-focus.html

There is not much to argue from an engineering platform stand point.
Lloyd does have a habit of taking his hyperbole to the extreme - the first time he gets one even slightly fuzzy image, the A7R II will suddenly become the "worst-focusing piece of $hit ever made"... (which would put it back in line with all the previous Sony models...)


Hmmm, sounds like the old adage of sensationalism / controversy sells ... I always thought folks were subscribing to him for consistent objectivity. I guess everything you hear on the internet isn't necessarily true.
Aug 29, 2015 at 07:49 AM
chez
Online
Details
p.29 #17Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
chez wrote
RustyBug wrote
mttran wroteImo, his review does not limit to that level. There is not much room for DSLR system to grow when we compared to MILC system in the long run.
There is not much room for gasoline powered cars to grow when compared to electric cars in the long run. Yet, that hardly makes it A) current and B) 99% applicable.

It's cool to see Sony continue on ... it's good for all @ rising tide floats all boats. Will we see an EVF in an D820 or D830 and D830EV option as it sounds that he would like to have. Sure, maybe, why not (although, I can think of a few folks who will tell you why not). But, it is still going to be one heck of a long day away before the mirrorless platform can supplant the DSLR platform.

This is particularly true, since the mirrorless platform is HEAVILY reliant on the DSLR glass for long glass and or specialty glass (like TS's). I mean, Sony themselves is CURRENTLY reliant on their A mount glass (ummm, dslr) for anything in the 2.8 realm or in order to reach beyond 200mm. 99% ... come on, that's ridiculous, and will remain to be so much into the future. Come back and re-read this five years from now. I highly expect that 99% still won't be at fruition then either (unless you're counting phones / P&S).

The odd thing is that while he did raise my perception of the AF system being good, he lowered my perception of his objectivity by his hyperbolic summation. For someone unfamiliar (I'm marginally familiar @ non-subscriber) with his work, this one wreaks of one-sided, fan-boy, "oooh-oooh" something new, style writing. Hopefully, it's just a "one off", rather than an indication of more things to come ... hmmm, at what his paid / future readership base thinks about it.

Time will tell.

really
Everyone has an agenda when they post a review...so I don't trust anyone of them to be totally bias free. But reading multiple reviews with varying opinions allows you to get a good picture. Renting the gear and trying it out yourself is the best review as far as I'm concerned. Only you can judge if equipment functions for your type of shooting. Relying on others to tell you a camera's buttons are uncomfortable or the view finder is awkward just paints the picture from their use...not yours.
I don't disagree that it will come down to personal preferences and hands on beats a review. To that we can agree. Reviews can be helpful as a primer for things of consideration that folks should look into for themselves (based on objectivity and/or acknowledged subjectivity). But, the reviewer didn't say anything remotely close to that. Instead, he overtly stated that it would be
Earlier quote"very hard to argue in favor of any DSLR for 99% of shooters"
.

That just does not compute ... not even remotely. There are a myriad of factors that simply boil down to personal preference. He is essentially dismissing any possibilities for personal preference ... never mind the gross
...Show more →

Exactly...goes for any review where the reviewer adds their own bias. What I take away from Lloyd's review is that the AF accuracy of the camera is fantastic. Very encouraging. Haven't read that from other reviews so its just one more piece of info to accumulate.
Aug 29, 2015 at 08:19 AM
KKFung
Offline
Details
p.29 #18Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Data are for the engineer or statistic, review are for entertainment / marketing, consumer can only know how fast the car is when you really drive it.
Aug 29, 2015 at 08:39 AM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.29 #19Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
RustyBug wrote:
More "entertaining" reading over in the Nikon side of the house.

trenchmonkey wroteThis thread still goin'
That lil Sony stuff's ok...if you have hands like a girl. Just saying'
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370153/4


That is interesting. I see so much less of the thread-bombing in the Nikon forums, but it is clear that others think (as I do) that the bigger companies who are long established players in this market do have serious development work going on related to adapting mirrorless concepts to their line-ups and that (as I believe to be the case) that they are not unwilling to take a bit more time and let the "new guy" take some of the initial arrows.

I had not thought about one obvious thing mentioned in that thread, and that is the extent to which DSLRs adopt (or first used?) some of the features of mirrorless — "live view" was an obvious one, and PDAF is another. After all, there is little in the fundamental technology of digital photography that doesn't find its way into pretty much all brands eventually — the technology is fairly ubiquitous.

One antidote to overly strong "my brand is the only brand" thinking is to spend some time on the other brand's forums. You'll see much the same stuff you see in this one, with the same sorts of characters interacting and a similar mix of positive enthusiasm and angry resentment and everything in between. Eventually, the "in between" zone may offer the most useful context.

Reading the other forums is also a much better way to get a well rounded idea of the pluses and minuses of those systems, especially if you read threads that are not focused on the brand comparison stuff, which all too often degenerate into yelling matches. Just read the regular old threads that attract folks who want to know more about their own gear and how to best use it and you'll find a lot of forthright and illuminating discussions.

About the relative merits of reviews and personal hands on experience... One bit of "common knowledge" holds that one person's own experience renting a camera will tell him/her more than reading reviews. In its extreme form this idea holds that reviews are biased and not to be trusted. I don't think it is quite that simple.

Regarding personal experience from using the gear yourself, I agree that over a long period of time and with extensive use in a variety of situations we get to know the ins and outs of our gear in very deep ways. On the other hand, a shorter period of personal use, while revealing some interesting things, can also be a bit misleading. How many of us have acquired some new thing and during the initial period of "wow, that's coo!" though it was the best thing there was... only to find after a longer period of use that the shine wore off and the warts and rough edges became a bit more prominent?

Regarding reviews, I agree that uncritical acceptance of what reviews say is risky business. I also agree that no one is without bias — and that holds equally for reviews we agree with as much as the reviews that we find disagreeable. But by reading about and critically considering the responses of a range of experienced photographers and writers to a new piece of gear we can learn a lot of useful information about it. This is especially true if we consider both the positive and negative observations, looking for patterns and trying to create a larger impression from the sum of these other experiences.

Dan

Edited on Aug 29, 2015 at 04:57 PM · View previous versions
Aug 29, 2015 at 08:40 AM
Jon Tainton
Offline
Details
p.29 #20Canon 5Ds vs. Sony A7rII
Although the Nikonians don't seem to be afflicted with Sony acolytes to the same extent that the Canon forum suffers from.

I was puzzled in Ming Thein's review when he expressed some disappointment in the build quality on the A7R2 the word 'toy' was referenced, again, and then I came across this 'entertaining' Ifixit teardown www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Sony+a7R+II+Teardown/45597


RustyBug wrote:
More "entertaining" reading over in the Nikon side of the house.

trenchmonkey wroteThis thread still goin'
That lil Sony stuff's ok...if you have hands like a girl. Just saying'
https://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/topic/1370153/4

Aug 29, 2015 at 04:02 PM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister