This topic is in the 2014 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.
Archive 2014Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
p.7 #1Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
It looks like a real nice matchup on the T4i, Landpirate!
Jan 18, 2014 at 03:02 PM
p.7 #2Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
First Snowy Owl shot with the 150-600?
600mm, f/6.3, 1/800, ISO 200.
Edited on Jan 18, 2014 at 07:11 PM · View previous versions
600mm, f/6.3, 1/800, ISO 200.
 |
||
| http://scottweberpal.zenfolio.com/img/s2/v58/p550189835.jpg | ||
|
Edited on Jan 18, 2014 at 07:11 PM · View previous versions
Jan 18, 2014 at 06:24 PM
p.7 #3Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Pictures are looking pretty soft, but no sample picture I've seen looks over-sharpened. Is there room for more sharpening to bring some detail and contrast out, perhaps?
Don't mean to be negative about the lens. Can't help but observe that images don't seem sharp, and contrast seems lacking. Certainly we grasp that the lens takes affordability to a new level, but the tradeoffs may be a bit significant.
John Caldwell
Don't mean to be negative about the lens. Can't help but observe that images don't seem sharp, and contrast seems lacking. Certainly we grasp that the lens takes affordability to a new level, but the tradeoffs may be a bit significant.
John Caldwell
Jan 18, 2014 at 06:45 PM
p.7 #4Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
AV...I'd love to see a larger version or raw image of your owl...I think a lot more can be done with it in post process.
I agree with John...many of the shots lack contrast and sharpness that is there...just hasn't been brought out in post processing.
I agree with John...many of the shots lack contrast and sharpness that is there...just hasn't been brought out in post processing.
Jan 18, 2014 at 06:47 PM
p.7 #5Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Unfortunately we will see a lot of soft images from this lens, as those with no experience shooting at over 400mm think they can get the same sharpness as with shorter focal lengths, without implementing long-lens technique. Many will shoot at shutter speeds that are too slow for handheld 600mm shots and will think that image stabilization is the cure-all for soft images at 600mm.
Many of those same people that have no experience at long-lens shooting also have no experience at efficient post-processing. The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me, but I don't know if that is the fault of the lens or the photographer, or both.
Many of those same people that have no experience at long-lens shooting also have no experience at efficient post-processing. The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me, but I don't know if that is the fault of the lens or the photographer, or both.
Jan 18, 2014 at 06:54 PM
p.7 #6Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
can't wait to see more samples.. Not going to buy Canon version, but will be a valuable one on D800
Jan 18, 2014 at 07:25 PM
p.7 #7Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Imagemaster wrote:
Unfortunately we will see a lot of soft images from this lens...
The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me...
In all fairness, the image wasn't intended to give an example of potential image quality. It was shot quickly, handheld, and from the inside of a running car. If you want some shots in a controlled environment, I have some here...
150-600 vs 100-400L
Unfortunately we will see a lot of soft images from this lens...
The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me...
In all fairness, the image wasn't intended to give an example of potential image quality. It was shot quickly, handheld, and from the inside of a running car. If you want some shots in a controlled environment, I have some here...
150-600 vs 100-400L
Jan 18, 2014 at 08:04 PM
p.7 #8Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Mark K wrote:
can't wait to see more samples.. Not going to buy Canon version, but will be a valuable one on D800
Do you really think the Tamron has the MTF to match that pixel pitch on FX?
EBH
can't wait to see more samples.. Not going to buy Canon version, but will be a valuable one on D800
Do you really think the Tamron has the MTF to match that pixel pitch on FX?
EBH
Jan 18, 2014 at 08:15 PM
p.7 #9Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
EB-1 wrote:
Do you really think the Tamron has the MTF to match that pixel pitch on FX?
EBH
Do you think everyone cares?
Mark K wrote
can't wait to see more samples.. Not going to buy Canon version, but will be a valuable one on D800EBH
Do you think everyone cares?
Jan 18, 2014 at 08:19 PM
p.7 #10Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
AvianScott wrote:
The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me...In all fairness, the image wasn't intended to give an example of potential image quality. It was shot quickly, handheld, and from the inside of a running car. If you want some shots in a controlled environment, I have some here...
150-600 vs 100-400L
Thanks for sharing these!
The Tamron looks very slightly softer and less contrasty than the Canon, but not by much. It would be interesting to see how the Canon images looked when they are up-scaled to 600mm. Another interesting test would be to slap a 1.4X TC on the Canon, and shoot both at 560mm.
Can you do any of those tests?
Depending how the 1.4X TC test goes, it may be difficult for some Canon owners to give up their 100-400mm zoom. However, for those who don't already have that lens, it's probably a no-brainer to pickup the Tamron at this price point.
Imagemaster wrote
Unfortunately we will see a lot of soft images from this lens...The sharpness of the above owl shot would be unacceptable to me...
150-600 vs 100-400L
Thanks for sharing these!
The Tamron looks very slightly softer and less contrasty than the Canon, but not by much. It would be interesting to see how the Canon images looked when they are up-scaled to 600mm. Another interesting test would be to slap a 1.4X TC on the Canon, and shoot both at 560mm.
Can you do any of those tests?
Depending how the 1.4X TC test goes, it may be difficult for some Canon owners to give up their 100-400mm zoom. However, for those who don't already have that lens, it's probably a no-brainer to pickup the Tamron at this price point.
Jan 18, 2014 at 09:45 PM
p.7 #11Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
If this Tamron was a 150-400mm lens, no one would care. The reason people are interested is the 400-600mm range. So- like others, I'm more concerned about what options I have to get out to near 600mm with full autofocus on a non-1D/5D3 body. Those are the comparison tests I think matter to the most people- the 100-400 at 560mm f/8 vs. the Tamron 150-600 at 560mm f/8.
I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.
I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.
Jan 18, 2014 at 09:56 PM
p.7 #12Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
gocolts wrote:
If this Tamron was a 150-400mm lens, no one would care. The reason people are interested is the 400-600mm range. So- like others, I'm more concerned about what options I have to get out to near 600mm with full autofocus on a non-1D/5D3 body. Those are the comparison tests I think matter to the most people- the 100-400 at 560mm f/8 vs. the Tamron 150-600 at 560mm f/8.
I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.
Agreed.
The most "important" field test is from 400mm to 600mm with the Tamron vs. 400mm to 560mm with the Canon and the 1.4X TC.
In post, the most "important" test is how well 400mm images from the Canon zoom look when up-scaled to 600mm.
I'd like to see both of those tests performed. Can anyone do them in the SAME controlled environment?
If this Tamron was a 150-400mm lens, no one would care. The reason people are interested is the 400-600mm range. So- like others, I'm more concerned about what options I have to get out to near 600mm with full autofocus on a non-1D/5D3 body. Those are the comparison tests I think matter to the most people- the 100-400 at 560mm f/8 vs. the Tamron 150-600 at 560mm f/8.
I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.
Agreed.
The most "important" field test is from 400mm to 600mm with the Tamron vs. 400mm to 560mm with the Canon and the 1.4X TC.
In post, the most "important" test is how well 400mm images from the Canon zoom look when up-scaled to 600mm.
I'd like to see both of those tests performed. Can anyone do them in the SAME controlled environment?
Jan 18, 2014 at 10:47 PM
p.7 #13Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
cameron12x wrote:
I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.Agreed.
The most "important" field test is from 400mm to 600mm with the Tamron vs. 400mm to 560mm with the Canon and the 1.4X TC.
In post, the most "important" test is how well 400mm images from the Canon zoom look when up-scaled to 600mm.
I'd like to see both of those tests performed. Can anyone do them in the SAME controlled environment?
+1
gocolts wrote
If this Tamron was a 150-400mm lens, no one would care. The reason people are interested is the 400-600mm range. So- like others, I'm more concerned about what options I have to get out to near 600mm with full autofocus on a non-1D/5D3 body. Those are the comparison tests I think matter to the most people- the 100-400 at 560mm f/8 vs. the Tamron 150-600 at 560mm f/8.I could actually see some owning both the 100-400 and the 150-600, and use the Canon when it's 400mm or below, and pull out the Tamron when you need more than 400mm.
The most "important" field test is from 400mm to 600mm with the Tamron vs. 400mm to 560mm with the Canon and the 1.4X TC.
In post, the most "important" test is how well 400mm images from the Canon zoom look when up-scaled to 600mm.
I'd like to see both of those tests performed. Can anyone do them in the SAME controlled environment?
+1
Jan 18, 2014 at 11:06 PM
p.7 #14Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Did you see these.
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
Jan 19, 2014 at 02:11 AM
p.7 #15Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
hoodlum90 wrote:
Did you see these.
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
The samples aforementioned has clearly stated that the Tamron produced overall better image than the Canon 100-400mm combined with 1.4x TC. Sharpness, contrast, colour are so much better than the former settings. Under good light, this is going to be a one hell of zoom lens available at the moment given the price, its almost a no brainer. I have 70-200mm but this Tamron 150-600mm would be a good companion to my EF500mm II if it ticks all the boxes
Did you see these.
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
The samples aforementioned has clearly stated that the Tamron produced overall better image than the Canon 100-400mm combined with 1.4x TC. Sharpness, contrast, colour are so much better than the former settings. Under good light, this is going to be a one hell of zoom lens available at the moment given the price, its almost a no brainer. I have 70-200mm but this Tamron 150-600mm would be a good companion to my EF500mm II if it ticks all the boxes
Jan 19, 2014 at 03:22 AM
p.7 #16Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
This is at f7.1, ISO250, 1/400th, handheld
A good 72% crop from around 5-6 meters and sitting deep in a bush
AF had no problem locking on the bird rather than the bush on the 7D
http://www.flickr.com/photos/87805817@N00/12028415053/
A good 72% crop from around 5-6 meters and sitting deep in a bush
AF had no problem locking on the bird rather than the bush on the 7D
http://www.flickr.com/photos/87805817@N00/12028415053/
Jan 19, 2014 at 05:45 AM
p.7 #17Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
Karl Witt wrote:
Seems to be working fine
Quickly I have a lot of respect for this lens. It arrived from FedEx and it was ice cold so I quickly wanted to see how smooth zoom ring and manual focus was...........very pleasant feel to both.
Extended out the zoom ring to full extension, there was no wobble or slop detected.
Looked down the front element, pretty wicked!
Mounted on camera, firm and secure, perfect actually, snug and reassuring fitment.
Randomly pointed to obtain focus, super silent and very quick
Turned on VC......don't hear a thing but man it works! Took a few shots at 600mm @ 1/50...Show more →
Hey Karl ,
Congrats ! Looks like you have a great copy
Keep those samples coming !
Thanks for sharing ....
Seems to be working fine
Quickly I have a lot of respect for this lens. It arrived from FedEx and it was ice cold so I quickly wanted to see how smooth zoom ring and manual focus was...........very pleasant feel to both.
Extended out the zoom ring to full extension, there was no wobble or slop detected.
Looked down the front element, pretty wicked!
Mounted on camera, firm and secure, perfect actually, snug and reassuring fitment.
Randomly pointed to obtain focus, super silent and very quick
Turned on VC......don't hear a thing but man it works! Took a few shots at 600mm @ 1/50...Show more →
the EXIF finds this Tamron as a Canon 90-300 at the moment, interesting based on jeffries viewer exif
Hey Karl ,
Congrats ! Looks like you have a great copy
Keep those samples coming !
Thanks for sharing ....
Jan 19, 2014 at 06:01 AM
p.7 #18Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
hoodlum90 wrote:
Did you see these.
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
Wow - significant!
Did you see these.
100-400 + TC @ 560mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027588743&k=GNDRJpT&lb=1&s=O
150-600mm @ 600mm f8
http://www.holzphotoclient.com/Gear/Tamron-150-600-vs-Canon-100/36103071_bF47Ws#!i=3027594229&k=VBwChtP&lb=1&s=O
Wow - significant!
Jan 19, 2014 at 07:09 AM
p.7 #19Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
micloi wrote:
This is at f7.1, ISO250, 1/400th, handheld
A good 72% crop from around 5-6 meters and sitting deep in a bush
AF had no problem locking on the bird rather than the bush on the 7D
http://www.flickr.com/photos/87805817@N00/12028415053/
This is a good shot!
For me and my interest, I'm looking to see what the lens can do for birds in flight shots. I haven't seen any of those yet. This shot is difficult in that you you turn off the distance limiter since the subject is less then 15 m. Have you played with the AF limiter, that is, turn it on when the subject is over 15m (15m to infinity setting) or do you always leave it off and have no limiter set at all?
This is at f7.1, ISO250, 1/400th, handheld
A good 72% crop from around 5-6 meters and sitting deep in a bush
AF had no problem locking on the bird rather than the bush on the 7D
http://www.flickr.com/photos/87805817@N00/12028415053/
This is a good shot!
For me and my interest, I'm looking to see what the lens can do for birds in flight shots. I haven't seen any of those yet. This shot is difficult in that you you turn off the distance limiter since the subject is less then 15 m. Have you played with the AF limiter, that is, turn it on when the subject is over 15m (15m to infinity setting) or do you always leave it off and have no limiter set at all?
Jan 19, 2014 at 07:11 AM
p.7 #20Early Adopters - Tamron 150-600mm
I've got a half a mind to pre-order it. Definitely thinking about it.
Reckon I should wait for a little more evidence though. But the tiger shots has just about convinced me that this would be a very useful lens for handheld birding on a sunny day.
Reckon I should wait for a little more evidence though. But the tiger shots has just about convinced me that this would be a very useful lens for handheld birding on a sunny day.
Jan 19, 2014 at 07:25 AM