fredmiranda.com Login

The 58mm F/1.4G Thread

  
 
rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.23 #1The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Donzo98 wrote:
Nope... not insecure... but you guys continue to try to convince us that the lens is overpriced and not worth it.

We simply disagree... that's all.

Lots of haters on FM about the 58G.



I don't know about others, but none of my posts contain any arguments meant to convince other's to adopt my viewpoints about this lens. None at all. I merely stated MY opinion that this lens is exceedingly soft at f/1.4, which makes the selling price more than a bit ridiculous since every 50mm lens looks great stopped down.

Lots of haters on FM who hate people who have their own opinion.

Aug 02, 2014 at 12:07 AM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.23 #2The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
rattymouse wrote:
Donzo98 wroteNope... not insecure... but you guys continue to try to convince us that the lens is overpriced and not worth it.

We simply disagree... that's all.

Lots of haters on FM about the 58G.
I don't know about others, but none of my posts contain any arguments meant to convince other's to adopt my viewpoints about this lens. None at all. I merely stated MY opinion that this lens is exceedingly soft at f/1.4, which makes the selling price more than a bit ridiculous since every 50mm lens looks great stopped down.

Lots of haters on FM who hate people who have their own opinion.



Question then....

Do you find these 2 samples below exceedingly soft @ 36 mpix & F1.4? Personally, I do not, and I print images like this shot at F1.4 that look much better than the record breaking sharpness from the Sigma 35mm. I was also a hater of this lens like you when It was first released. I thought it was "exceedingly soft" as well, but I finally came around to the fact that this lens does in fact render better. So I purchased it and was pleasantly surprised by how sharp this lens really is and how usable it is when you print it.

http://coreyhardcastle.smugmug.com/Other/58mm/i-GkT8F36/O

http://coreyhardcastle.smugmug.com/Other/58mm/i-VRJ8RC7/O

P.S. These 2 samples are at close focus distance where this lens is the worst. As you stretch it out further, the sharpness improves and I'd say surpasses the Sigma 35mm at infinity.

Aug 02, 2014 at 08:34 AM
photorebel
Offline
Details
p.23 #3The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Hardcore wrote:
I was also a hater of this lens like you when It was first released. I thought it was "exceedingly soft" as well, but I finally came around to the fact that this lens does in fact render better. So I purchased it and was pleasantly surprised by how sharp this lens really is and how usable it is when you print it.


I felt the same way, maybe not so much a hater of the lens, but had no interest. But I kept seeing some stellar images posted, after photographers learned how to use the lens. I tried one, and now I'm learning how to use the lens.

The two examples you linked…look very good to me, and certainly not exceedingly soft. Eyes look rather sharp, IMO. However, it's the overall rendering, that I find pleasing.
Aug 02, 2014 at 09:01 AM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.23 #4The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
photorebel wrote:
Hardcore wroteI was also a hater of this lens like you when It was first released. I thought it was "exceedingly soft" as well, but I finally came around to the fact that this lens does in fact render better. So I purchased it and was pleasantly surprised by how sharp this lens really is and how usable it is when you print it.
I felt the same way, maybe not so much a hater of the lens, but had no interest. But I kept seeing some stellar images posted, after photographers learned how to use the lens. I tried one, and now I'm learning how to use the lens.

The two examples you linked…look very good to me, and certainly not exceedingly soft. Eyes look rather sharp, IMO. However, it's the overall rendering, that I find pleasing.


No, I don't think they look soft either. I would actually use the term sharp, but what do I know.

The images uploaded onto FM's website lately are showing a lot of compression and blocking and artifacts which is why I choose to upload those full resolution images to my smugmug page. The same 100% crops I posted here on FM loose a lot of sharpness by the compression....

But, if your honestly going to sit here and tell me that those samples are exceedingly soft, then I better get my eyes checked!
Aug 02, 2014 at 09:08 AM
Donzo98
Online
Details
p.23 #5The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
A big part of the problem is the 36mp bodies...

Who cares about a 100% crop on a 36mp body The pics looks insanely good on print and on the computer at the desired sizes.

If you look at 100% crops with ALMOST ALL LENSES... they will most certainly fall short.

I remember I had 17-35 that was excellent... when I looked at 100% crops on my older bodies, they didn't look so hot. The overall rendering however was amazing.

With that said... I recently bought a Siggy 50 ART to try...





Aug 02, 2014 at 10:47 AM
photorebel
Offline
Details
p.23 #6The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Hardcore wrote:
But, if your honestly going to sit here and tell me that those samples are exceedingly soft, then I better get my eyes checked!


I'm not going to say they are soft..at all. Because the eyes look good and sharp on my monitor.



Aug 02, 2014 at 11:42 AM
ohsnaphappy
Offline
Details
p.23 #7The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
rattymouse wrote:
Jason_Brook wroteAfter reading the "comments" the past page or two, I'm going through about 100 photos or so from the past 24 hours for the first time. I'm giggling like a school girl at the people saying this isn't sharp at f/1.4.

People say the 85/1.8g is OMFG sharp; I've had three, it's not. The 58/1.4 is sharp when focus is nailed, but people are saying it's OMFG soft. I don't get it....

The people saying this lens is soft either don't understand DoF or can't recognize when someone missed focus. I'll back all this up with 100% crops in an hour or so, along with a comparison to the 50/1.8...which to me is identical IQ wise to the 1.4
I have a Canon 85L II, so I understand both depth of field (meaning narrow) as well as sharp, wide open at F/1.2.

This Nikon lens is exceedingly soft even when the focus has been hit.

But as long as your amused, I guess that's worth $1600.



If you know a lot about Canon glass, you're no doubt aware of the unique rendering characteristics of the 50 1.2L. Also a soft dreamy lens when shot wide open. Both lenses from both manufactures have a cult following, both are quite expensive. both are very unique. I don't see anything to complain about.
Aug 02, 2014 at 11:56 AM
ohsnaphappy
Offline
Details
p.23 #8The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
I'll also add that this lens offers the best bokeh of any lens under $2000. I think it's better than 85 1.4 G. I think it's as good, if not better than the 85L or 50L. For many photographers the bokeh more than warrants the price. Try using this lens with the Brenizer method and you create magic.

With all that said. This lens has its faults. All of which have been documented throughout the thread.
Aug 02, 2014 at 12:08 PM
Donzo98
Online
Details
p.23 #9The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Here's a 1.4 portrait with the Siggy.

Comments??





Aug 02, 2014 at 03:02 PM
mpedersen
Offline
Details
p.23 #10The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
ohsnaphappy wrote:
I'll also add that this lens offers the best bokeh of any lens under $2000. I think it's better than 85 1.4 G. I think it's as good, if not better than the 85L or 50L. For many photographers the bokeh more than warrants the price. Try using this lens with the Brenizer method and you create magic.

With all that said. This lens has its faults. All of which have been documented throughout the thread.


+1
In the last six months I had the 50L and 50 Art; neither of them are close. Only one I think that comes close (bokeh wise) is probably the 55mm Sonnar for Sony.

I wouldn't compare the 85's. They're different.
Aug 03, 2014 at 12:00 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

rattymouse
Offline
Details
p.23 #11The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Hardcore wrote:
rattymouse wrote
Donzo98 wroteNope... not insecure... but you guys continue to try to convince us that the lens is overpriced and not worth it.

We simply disagree... that's all.

Lots of haters on FM about the 58G.
I don't know about others, but none of my posts contain any arguments meant to convince other's to adopt my viewpoints about this lens. None at all. I merely stated MY opinion that this lens is exceedingly soft at f/1.4, which makes the selling price more than a bit ridiculous since every 50mm lens looks great stopped down.

Lots of haters on FM who hate people who have their own opinion.
Question then....

Do you find these 2 samples below exceedingly soft @ 36 mpix & F1.4? Personally, I do not, and I print images like this shot at F1.4 that look much better than the record breaking sharpness from the Sigma 35mm. I was also a hater of this lens like you when It was first released. I thought it was "exceedingly soft" as well, but I finally came around to the fact that this lens does in fact render better. So I purchased it and was pleasantly surprised by how sharp this lens really is and how usable it is
...Show more →

Sorry, no photos loaded when I clicked these links. Only the smugmug background loaded. I'm in China, where the internet rarely works so that probably is the cause.
Aug 03, 2014 at 04:56 PM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.23 #12The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Do you guys use your 85s much since getting the 58? I'm unloading my d700 and wanna add glass, but dunno what.
Aug 03, 2014 at 07:04 PM
hijazist
Offline
Details
p.23 #13The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Jason_Brook wrote:
Do you guys use your 85s much since getting the 58? I'm unloading my d700 and wanna add glass, but dunno what.


The prefect companion for the 58 would be a 135, pray Nikon or Sigma introduce one in Photokina
Aug 03, 2014 at 07:27 PM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.23 #14The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Yeah the 135dc is high on my list. I shoot only for me these days so I like trying different glass. A new version would be nice.
Aug 03, 2014 at 07:35 PM
Joseph.
Offline
Details
p.23 #15The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Jason_Brook wrote:
Do you guys use your 85s much since getting the 58? I'm unloading my d700 and wanna add glass, but dunno what.


I sold my 85 1.4G after getting the 58. The perfect complement to the 58 is the 200/2, or the Zeiss 135/2.
Aug 03, 2014 at 08:19 PM
Hardcore
Offline
Details
p.23 #16The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Jason_Brook wrote:
Do you guys use your 85s much since getting the 58? I'm unloading my d700 and wanna add glass, but dunno what.


Hey Jason,

I never liked the 85mm focal length much. Didn't do much more me and I much prefer 135mm. I also like the 35mm length, but not that I have the 58mm it just seems to suit my shooting much better was well. I agree with a 58/135mm combo!
Aug 04, 2014 at 07:14 AM
Jason_Brook
Offline
Details
p.23 #17The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Yeah, I think I'm going to hold onto the cash for Photokina and see what comes out.

I currently have:
16-35G
28/1.8G
50/1.4 pre ai
50/1.8G
58/1.4G
60/2.8G
135/2.8 pre ai
70-200vr

I sold the 35/1.4A and 85/1.8G to fund the 58.
Aug 04, 2014 at 07:27 AM
Jorge Torralba
Offline
Details
p.23 #18The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Hardcore wrote:
Question then....

Do you find these 2 samples below exceedingly soft @ 36 mpix & F1.4? Personally, I do not, and I print images like this shot at F1.4 that look much better than the record breaking sharpness from the Sigma 35mm.
http://coreyhardcastle.smugmug.com/Other/58mm/i-GkT8F36/O

http://coreyhardcastle.smugmug.com/Other/58mm/i-VRJ8RC7/O



Absolutely soft. The freckles and eye lashes are obviously soft. No offense intended. Please don't take this the wrong way. but if you think that is sharp then you should consider glasses.

On the other hand look at this. shot at f4 from another lens. This is only posted to show what I would consider sharp. Granted . It is at f4. butit is NOT an otus.







And here is one at f2 hand held at 1/15 of a second







Aug 04, 2014 at 11:13 AM
low325
Offline
Details
p.23 #19The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
Jorge,
i see what youre talking about, but at this level, whats the point of cropping out what this lens does best?

i mean do folks crop out the bokeh of a 200 f2 just to see whats sharp? dont folks want to see just as much as the entire image as possible when photographing people/living things out in the open?
Aug 04, 2014 at 11:36 AM
Jorge Torralba
Offline
Details
p.23 #20The 58mm F/1.4G Thread
low325 wrote:
Jorge,
i see what youre talking about, but at this level, whats the point of cropping out what this lens does best?


You mean, you want to see bokeh rendering etc .. ?

ok, here are just a few. Remember this is not from an otus
























Aug 04, 2014 at 11:45 AM


FM ForumsNikon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister