rattymouse wrote:
Jason_Brook wrote
After reading the "comments" the past page or two, I'm going through about 100 photos or so from the past 24 hours for the first time. I'm giggling like a school girl at the people saying this isn't sharp at f/1.4.
People say the 85/1.8g is OMFG sharp; I've had three, it's not. The 58/1.4 is sharp when focus is nailed, but people are saying it's OMFG soft. I don't get it....
The people saying this lens is soft either don't understand DoF or can't recognize when someone missed focus. I'll back all this up with 100% crops in an hour or so, along with a comparison to the 50/1.8...which to me is identical IQ wise to the 1.4 I have a Canon 85L II, so I understand both depth of field (meaning narrow) as well as sharp, wide open at F/1.2.
This Nikon lens is exceedingly soft even when the focus has been hit.
But as long as your amused, I guess that's worth $1600.
If you know a lot about Canon glass, you're no doubt aware of the unique rendering characteristics of the 50 1.2L. Also a soft dreamy lens when shot wide open. Both lenses from both manufactures have a cult following, both are quite expensive. both are very unique. I don't see anything to complain about.