DontShoot wrote:
What's with everyone's obsession with sharpness? Whenever I see people posting cropped 100% of people's eyes, it makes me laugh. What moron looks at photos like that? when you take family pics, do you just crop their eyes, blow it up and print just the eyes? Whatever happened to appreciating the ENTIRE photo because of the way it's presented, composed, and rendered?
The 58G to me represents the current benchmark for the portable 'normal' prime. It has great rendering performance wide-open while being well-corrected for lateral CA and vignetting unlike alternatives from Nikon's or Canon's systems; it's closest competitor, really, is the now discontinued Sigma 50/1.4 EX.
But unlike the old Sigma, or the new Sigma, the 58G is light; it's only 2/3rd the weight of the Canon 50L that it's positioned against, and less than 100g heavier than either company's 50/1.4 options.
Further, it sharpens up nicely in the center when stopping down from wide open, and it sharpens up across the frame when stopping down to studio or landscape apertures.
On Canon, if I were to pick up the 50L or 50 Art, I'd want to keep my 50/1.4 USM as the lightweight option- but on Nikon, I'd be satisfied with the 58G fulfilling this role alone. I'd like to see Canon try to match the 58G's flexibility as they look to upgrade their aging 50mm line.