p.6 #13D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
MaxBerlin wrote:
This elephant is really incredible. It is something you can create again and again with this lens or one of those lucky times when everything came together?
I can not always create popped out look with my Cron-R 90. Sometimes I got lucky that I got the perfect condition or environtment to produce that look. But statistically this lens produce the popped out look more than my other lens. I think because it has micro contrast and not so creamy bokeh I guess.
But as other mentioned it depends on the environtment. For example my elephant photo in the previous page. The lighting on that photo and the distance between the elephant and the BG gave big contribution for popped out look. Because some other shots where the elephant is under the shade and the BG is very close gave less p-o look.
Plus the pose of that elephant that walk towards us gave more plus point to add the popped out illusion
p.6 #23D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
nixland wrote:
I used to use the word "popped out" rather than 3D ... cause the word "3D" tends to make other people mock or make fun on your photos ... hahaha
My lens that often gives me a popped out look is Summicron-R 90 ... but it depends on several factors as already described in the older thread.
We're not worthy! We're not worthy! Just kidding, but this is one of the best photographs I've ever seen in having a 3-dimensional feel. Truly impressive.
p.6 #43D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
dthrog00 wrote: nixland wroteI used to use the word "popped out" rather than 3D ... cause the word "3D" tends to make other people mock or make fun on your photos ... hahaha
My lens that often gives me a popped out look is Summicron-R 90 ... but it depends on several factors as already described in the older thread.We're not worthy! We're not worthy! Just kidding, but this is one of the best photographs I've ever seen in having a 3-dimensional feel. Truly impressive.
Dave
Thanks Dave & SKumar25.
Mostly I never think about getting popped out look when I take photos. So that shot is more a lucky shot than a planned 3D shot .. haha
Currently it's not my passion to explore it, so the popped out look is just a bonus. If I got it, it's good and I am lucky .. if not, it doesn't matter
p.6 #53D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
SKumar25 wrote:
Lots of people believe 3-d look only come about with shallow DOF. I am of the contrary opinion.
.
What I'm seeing in the images is an isolated subject that falls well inside the DOF—a sharpness from front to back.
p.6 #63D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I disagree about the need for more "rules".
I do agree about too much OOF wrecking the 3D effect. I also agree that the right light makes all the difference. Somewhere I have some pretty decent 3D popping shots taken with the lowly 35L when I still had my 5D... it was all to do with the (flat) light, being stopped down a little, and being at the right working distance.
When I look at an image, having the entire subject in focus is important. If the entire subject is in focus and the background blur is subtle, that's a good starting point. If the angle of the sun is low, or from the side or back that always seems to help with some nice edge contrast and improving the 3D feeling.
Here are a few taken with my NEX that I think have some 3D impression, or at least a "good presence"... (all with Nokton 40 by the way)
p.6 #73D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Atlasman2 wrote: SKumar25 wroteLots of people believe 3-d look only come about with shallow DOF. I am of the contrary opinion.
.What I'm seeing in the images is an isolated subject that falls well inside the DOF—a sharpness from front to back.
I would agree, the part showing "3D effect" is normally within DOF.
p.6 #93D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I just looked again all photos from page 1 and I like these photos for giving popped out look :
ebookman - man on the couch
briantho - yellow leaves
trenchmonkey - horsewoman
JaKo - pipes & trinity baptist daycare sign
rscheffler - cute dog
dthrog00 - statue
wfrank - men and old car
mortyb - trees
SKumar25 - landrover car
lifthard2001 - boy in the rain
Jacob D - the oldman in the kitchen
SKumar25 - rolls-royce car
Below are 2 more examples from the same location as my previous photo.
On the first one, the background is closer but the elephant is closer too .. still looks popped out.
On the second one, the elephant is under the shade (lighting factor is gone) and the popped out illusion is gone too
p.6 #133D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
nixland wrote:
I just looked again all photos from page 1 and I like these photos for giving popped out look :
ebookman - man on the couch
briantho - yellow leaves
trenchmonkey - horsewoman
JaKo - pipes & trinity baptist daycare sign
rscheffler - cute dog
dthrog00 - statue
wfrank - men and old car
mortyb - trees
SKumar25 - landrover car
lifthard2001 - boy in the rain
Jacob D - the oldman in the kitchen
SKumar25 - rolls-royce car
Below are 2 more examples from the same location as my previous photo.
On the first one, the background is closer but the elephant is closer too .. still looks popped out.
On the second one, the elephant is under the shade (lighting factor is gone) and the popped out illusion is gone too
You're right, the look is diminished in the shade.
Like your term "popped out". Were that the adopted term for the look, so much grief would be averted with the guys who take the term 3D for it's literal meaning.
p.6 #143D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
SKumar25 wrote:
so much grief would be averted with the guys who take the term 3D for it's literal meaning.
Which is why I tend to use the term "3D-ishness" and refer to trompe l'oeil @ "fool the eye" ... it is an illusion/perception.
One thing I noted in reviewing the lens data of the Zeiss (et al) design for those lenses that are most prominent for achieving such a drawing style vs. those lenses that aren't, is that I saw a correlation between the exit pupil size and the entrance pupil size. Those lenses that seemed to be more prominent in the ability to render the 3D-ishness effect often times had a relationship getting closer to 1:1 (i.e. .85, .92, etc.) between the exit pupil size and the entrance pupil size.
Just like micro-contrast alone isn't sufficient to render this drawing style, it seems neither is simply having a large exit pupil. But, it did seem that those lenses with a combination of excellent micro-contrast at least partway into Zone B, AND a stronger exit pupil size /entrance pupil size ratio made for a more prominent effect than those with low micro-contrast overall, early falloff of micro-contrast or smaller ratio of exit pupil size to entrance pupil size.
I tend to keep these design parameter in mind whenever choosing glass. While actual data will vary significantly between focal lengths, comparing lens A vs. lens B of a given FL ... greater micro-contrast, further into Zone B and larger exit pupil size:entrance pupil size are things I look for ... and how well corrected they are. With edge contrast playing such a strong role in the perception, CA/fringe doesn't help much.
I lost the link to some of the old Zeiss C/Y data sheets ... as they were very good at giving entrance pupil and exit pupil sizes, as well as mtf charts that showed the micro-contrast and it's falloff pattern.
If anyone has those links (or where they moved to), I'd appreciate them again.
p.6 #153D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
RustyBug wrote:
I lost the link to some of the old Zeiss C/Y data sheets ... as they were very good at giving entrance pupil and exit pupil sizes, as well as mtf charts that showed the micro-contrast and it's falloff pattern.
If anyone has those links (or where they moved to), I'd appreciate them again.
p.6 #163D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
RustyBug wrote:
I lost the link to some of the old Zeiss C/Y data sheets ... as they were very good at giving entrance pupil and exit pupil sizes, as well as mtf charts that showed the micro-contrast and it's falloff pattern.
If anyone has those links (or where they moved to), I'd appreciate them again.
p.6 #203D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
This is certainly one of my most 3D photos and is of Dead Horse Point State Park looking into the Island in the Sky portion of Canyonlands NP in Utah. It was taken in 1995 with my Linhof Technikardan 45S 4" X 5" camera and my Rodenstock 90mm f6.8 MC Grandagon N lens set to f32 and with Heliopan Polarizing filter and Tiffen 812 Warming Filter on Fujichrome Velvia 50 film. Image taken at about 8:30 AM and no tilts were used (infinite # of planes) in this situation and everything is in sharp focus from around 4 or 5 feet to about 35? miles. It is printed and displayed at Art Shows as a 32" X 40" Metal Print but has easily been printed to 40" X 50".