p.5 #13D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Here's a NEX-7 + Zeiss 24 at f/2
To me the sequins on the shirt make it pop.
I see the 3D look having a few general traits:
1) wide angle at close to MFD
2) very wide aperture short tele focussed further away to get separation from foreground
3) uninteresting edges of the photo - no bokeh necessary on edges because your eye isn't drawn there
4) a little vignetting?
p.5 #43D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
FlyPenFly wrote:
People are just posting in focus subjects with out of focus bg as "3D".
There should be a rule about these threads, do not post images with an out of focus background.
I agree, there's little distinction being made in many of these images between subject isolation (with shallow depth of field) and actual "dimensionality" of the image (a more subjective consideration). However, ruling out all defocused backgrounds might not be best --- for example, consider Nixland's elephant image on the preceding page. It's got the usual subject isolation against a blurry background --- but I think it's also quite "3D", in that the elephant itself is rendered with a strong sense of dimensionality (and its surrounding space is also reasonably well defined), which is entirely lacking in several of the background-blurred portraits above.
p.5 #73D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
mpmendenhall wrote: FlyPenFly wrotePeople are just posting in focus subjects with out of focus bg as "3D".
There should be a rule about these threads, do not post images with an out of focus background.I agree, there's little distinction being made in many of these images between subject isolation (with shallow depth of field) and actual "dimensionality" of the image (a more subjective consideration). However, ruling out all defocused backgrounds might not be best --- for example, consider Nixland's elephant image on the preceding page. It's got the usual subject isolation against a blurry background --- but I think it's also quite "3D", in that the elephant itself is rendered with a strong sense of dimensionality (and its surrounding space is also reasonably well defined), which is entirely lacking in several of the background-blurred portraits above....Show more →
The OP only speaks of a "3D effect", so any example that creates an impression of depth would be allowed. Depth perception seems to be subjective, anyway.
p.5 #93D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
FlyPenFly wrote:
People are just posting in focus subjects with out of focus bg as "3D".
There should be a rule about these threads, do not post images with an out of focus background.
+1 @ others that oof bg can be part of it, but moreover, it is the ability to have the perception of dimensionality in the area/subject that is is focus or to create a strong sense of spatial perception. This is of course something very different from simply having "flat subjects" with a strong separation from the background by virtue of dof/bokeh.
I think it's one of those things where "if you have to ask" if it has "3D-ishness" ... it probably doesn't.
We could put the "Like" button to good use on some of these images, to better illustrate which ones are conveying the kind of "3D-ishness" that is different from subject/bg separation alone. Then, we would somewhat be defining the difference for all to see ... if that makes any sense ... single image posts would like serve the purpose best in that regard.
p.5 #123D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
This elephant is really incredible. It is something you can create again and again with this lens or one of those lucky times when everything came together?
p.5 #163D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
To me, the 3D-ness disappears with too short DOF. It just doesn't look natural. The same goes for B&W and high contrast PP. Flat lighting and high local contrast lenses seem to get me there.
p.5 #173D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Certain Leica R can do this easier than others, but it is about "things comming together". I think nobody can squeeze 3D on demand with any lens. And not because we wouldnt try.
Good light can help a lot too.
That part about weak or no AA is true. Its cause some lens do have microcontrast (even if you would normally said they dont), but its killed by AA filters, so you actually never know.. I remember seeing pics with new Nikkor 1.4 Gs and old Kodak SLR/n and almost all had bit of 3D, yet if you put them on regular Nikon camera, its not there..
Processing does have effect, cause you need bit of contrast to make it pop. But thats sorta working for every photo. Yea and you can actually destroy 3D, if you apply too much contrast tweaking stuff. I found that by accident, when I tried to enhance "3D" and result was after some tonal/micro contrast tweaking worse than before..
Btw. its possible to process pics way that actually sorta create 3D, problem is that it always looks a bit fake.
Small demonstration (maybe I have better samples somewhere, cant remember).
This one is bit weaker..
Is it 3D? No not really, its just non-flat how I like it. Feel free to guess what was used to make it.
I will try to post something "naturally" 3D later..
p.5 #183D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Makten wrote:
To me, the 3D-ness disappears with too short DOF. It just doesn't look natural. The same goes for B&W and high contrast PP. Flat lighting and high local contrast lenses seem to get me there.
Rarely do I find myself agreeing with you but here we are.
p.5 #203D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
BenV wins ... haha
FlyPenFly wrote: Makten wroteTo me, the 3D-ness disappears with too short DOF. It just doesn't look natural. The same goes for B&W and high contrast PP. Flat lighting and high local contrast lenses seem to get me there.Rarely do I find myself agreeing with you but here we are.
I totally agree. From my experience the popped out look often come out if the bokeh is not so blurry or not os destroyed or too creamy.