Great example Carsten. I find a lot of images here show bokeh, not 3D..Hard to explain but studying the whole 3D thing further, I started noticing that shallow DOF photos have a sense of subject isolation, but the effect is more immediate than progressive, which, to my eyes results in "flat" images, with a clear differentiation between front and back, but no 3D.
If I were to verbalize my experience, would be that the eye moves from the subject to the background too swiftly to feel "drawn in", thus realizing a certain manufactured quality to the image.
In contrast, I remember the most successful 3D images in the original thread were in pretty much full focus, with light, subject placement and the camera /lens combo creating the effect, not the lack of focus.
p.11 #63D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I followed (and have been part of) the previous lengthy thread about 2-D images with the appearance of 3-D. I have seen some images that did not employ selective focus and still achieved the effect -- images in which most planes were in focus. How the eye (brain) interprets things can be very complex and I would emphasize that I see differences with 2 different types of monitors -- which may explain why some people don't see it and others do.
Here's an example which (for me) shows a strong 3-D effect (you may have to stare at it for a second or two). Don't know what it proves, however.
p.11 #83D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
"3D" has always been something of a mystery to me because I'll buy lenses that are known for it and not see it, and other times get a pretty good sense of depth from even a lowly kit lenses
This shot for example was from testing the Sony FE 28-70 "kit" zoom I got last week, on my patio, with the whole area in shade from the house, yet I think its got a pretty good sense of depth. But no fancy glass, no special light...
p.11 #93D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I also don't really get the 3D thing, but trawling through some old photos there were some that did "pop". A few here (if I can remember how to post images here ...)
p.11 #103D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
All pictures below show 3D look to some extent,without any PP.Most often achieved with Zeiss lenses,but other primes esp. Minolta Rokkors,Konica Hexanons and Voigtlanders SL/SL II can also do that quite often.
p.11 #133D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
nixland wrote:
I used to use the word "popped out" rather than 3D ... cause the word "3D" tends to make other people mock or make fun on your photos ... hahaha
My lens that often gives me a popped out look is Summicron-R 90 ... but it depends on several factors as already described in the older thread.
Now THAT is the 3D most talk about, no question about it.
p.11 #153D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
PhotoDes wrote:
I followed (and have been part of) the previous lengthy thread about 2-D images with the appearance of 3-D. I have seen some images that did not employ selective focus and still achieved the effect -- images in which most planes were in focus. How the eye (brain) interprets things can be very complex and I would emphasize that I see differences with 2 different types of monitors -- which may explain why some people don't see it and others do.
Here's an example which (for me) shows a strong 3-D effect (you may have to stare at it for a second or two). Don't know what it proves, however.
A study of Trompe L'oeil and how painters create the effect can give some insight into the perceptual issues that our eye/brain system yields from visual cues toward dimensionality. Even in "real world", some people have difficulty perceiving 3D as well as others. I would imagine that great baseball hitters have developed excellent visual dimensional cue recognition so they can "read the ball". For others, the ball looks the same no matter what is thrown their way.
To that end, imo much of the photographic 3D-ish effect is rooted in the rate of transition changes that certain lens designs employ (yes, Zeiss does it quite a bit more than others, but they aren't the only ones) ... AND ... having your subject in one area of transition rate vs. the non-subject portion in a different transition rate. When your subject is positioned relative (within, or near the edge of) to the transition zones of the lens, the distinction of the difference is more noticeable. Combine this with a DOF that also changes in harmony with the transition rate change of a given glass and the effect can be rather notably accentuated (which is not the same as simply a shallow DOF).
Without a rate of transition transition, we often see that "cutout" look from an isolated shallow DOF. Granted it can yield a "pop" and a projection effect from the bg/fg, however the subject itself then lacks its own dimensionality cues.
Color,tonal value contrasts and sharpness transitions can all be visual cues to how our eye/brain assesses depth. So yes, while we are certainly in a 2D medium, the 3D-ish perception can be generated to a greater / lesser degree based on these (and others, i.e. lighting contrast, scale, perspective, etc.) factors ... just like a painter who is masterful in Trompe L'oeil.