p.2 #13D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
mp - I'm just learning here but you seem to be saying that 3d is more an aspect of the spatial relationships of the composition and less the nature of a given lens?
p.2 #23D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
I can't see any "3D" at all in the OP photo.
My interpretation is that the 3D-look is caused by hard, clean edges (no abberations) of the well focused main subject, against an unfocused background. It's an optical illusion that makes the subject "pop" against the background. Leaves can often show this effect.
p.2 #103D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
briantho wrote:
I can't see any "3D" at all in the OP photo.
My interpretation is that the 3D-look is caused by hard, clean edges (no abberations) of the well focused main subject, against an unfocused background. It's an optical illusion that makes the subject "pop" against the background. Leaves can often show this effect.
Exactly. Bokeh and or thin DOF alone, at least to me, do not make an image 3-d. A sharply outlined, in-focus subject plane with great separation from a recognizable background is what does it for me. Micro-contrast goes a long ways towards helping this but isn't the only determinant.
I also have to agree with others, I see nothing in the OP photo which portrays a 3d effect. Maybe I can dig up a few I have later, which aren't a lot in number .
p.2 #113D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
briantho wrote: My interpretation is that the 3D-look is caused by hard, clean edges (no abberations) of the well focused main subject, against an unfocused background. It's an optical illusion that makes the subject "pop" against the background.
Brian, just to add to your comment, I feel that there are, IMO, at least two 3D effects in 2D images; one where a single subjects 'pops' or creates an illusion of being isolated in space from its background, and second where multiple planes/layers are present in DoF (Orio's example posted earlier)
Please see below. 'Pop' in the first image isolates pipes creating kinda 3D effect. However, the second image is more interesting as it shows multiple layers; the yellow info card (clearly positioned in the middle of a stove), cardboard image of a woman (positioned between stove and the second stove/back wall) and background image (approximately 6' behind the cardboard image)
ebookman's image on previous page clearly shows multiple layers as well.
p.2 #123D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
While I don't really make an effort to pursue a 3D effect in my images, this one comes to mind because it was one of the first of mine where I felt the effect was kind of obvious. M9 & 21/1.4. It's an interesting lens because one isn't accustomed to seeing shallow depth of field at this focal length. I believe this was done very near to the minimum focusing distance of 70 cm, which also gives you a pretty good idea that the lens is not great for close ups.
p.2 #133D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
JaKo wrote: Earlier quotebriantho wrote: My interpretation is that the 3D-look is caused by hard, clean edges (no abberations) of the well focused main subject, against an unfocused background. It's an optical illusion that makes the subject "pop" against the background.Brian, just to add to your comment, I feel that there are, IMO, at least two 3D effects in 2D images; one where a single subjects 'pops' or creates an illusion of being isolated in space from its background, and second where multiple planes/layers are present in DoF (Orio's example posted earlier)
Please see below. 'Pop' in the first image isolates pipes creating kinda 3D effect. However, the second image is more interesting as it shows multiple layers; the yellow info card (clearly positioned in the middle of a stove), cardboard image of a woman (positioned between stove and the second stove/back wall) and background image (approximately 6' behind the cardboard image)
ebookman's image on previous page clearly shows multiple layers as well. ...Show more →
I agree, great examples, but we're talking about lenses giving a 3D effect. The second image is kinda staged to render a 3D-like result, and it wouldn't matter much which lens was used to get a feeling of 3D. The first image displays the spontaneous effect that Zeiss lenses are famous for.
p.2 #143D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
@jako. I would argue the layers explanation also includes the aforementioned "outline" theory.
For instance, there are many great photos of distant mountain / fog layers which while pretty, often display no 3d effect because of this lack of distinctive outlining.
I would instead modify your points into two subsets.
p.2 #163D effect! Let's see your best photo - discuss how it happens.
Thank you briantho & cputeq for sharing your opinions.
It's clear from current and previous posts on FM and elsewhere that we all have different takes and explanations when it comes to 3D in two dimensional imaging.
On Sunday morning with a cup of java in hand all opinions are welcome and fun to read.
Cheers
PS
This image was not 'staged' for 3D effect, but I feel it has multiple layers within (sign --> red bush --> tree & the background)