carstenw wrote:
Daran wrote
carstenw wrote
Nonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree. Using that logic pretty much all modern lenses have 3D. Well, no, not at all. I did write agree or disagree,
Doesn't matter. If you do not see the effect in an image, that does not mean that the lens used can not produce it. I have seen the effect, but I can't see it in most images presented here. Meanwhile I do not doubt that the proud presenters of those image did in fact see it and are not all just trolling. Hence all those lenses can probably produce it, whether I can see it or no.
Besides, due to understanding how the effect comes to be, it is obvious that the lens used plays only a small role. This is confirmed by no one here on 150 pages even trying to show a significant difference in a back to back comparison using different lenses on the same scene. All you get is loads of single lens examples that may or may not be significant and of course a ton of slop from Phillip.