fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.149 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nothing intellectual about 3D itself, it's simply a matter of knowledge and furthering your understanding of trends in optical achievements and directions users and lens designers take. Serious people, who invest large sums in what they do, in producing their work.

It's the same as anything else in the field. So I stubbornly persist in presenting actual information, because many people view such threads without commenting, as they don't enjoy the argy-bargy. It rolls off some of us like water off a raincoat, and we have our says.

I'm not a fan of bird images but I don't go and dirty up their threads. Photography, video and cine are all broad churches, as they say - so it's rather perplexing the heat and acrimony the subject invokes. The controversy itself is just fine, it stimulates critical thinking and that is in short supply these days.

It's the naysayers that get peoples' goat - their message seems to be 'I don't see it, so you can't either and you're a dope who is fair game for disparagement', and we shouldn't learn more about why it is so important in many optical fields these days.

I read the sad news that myopia is accelerating fast and will reach 50% of all people by 2050. And also that most people view images at 1.05-1.2-1.6 times the image diagonal as viewing standards - too close to see the forest for the trees IMO, and seeing the whole image in one take is critical to seeing 3D in images because you need to observe all the elements in one go, not move your eyes to each part sequentially. And I wonder if this has anything to do with the generated heat. cheers.
Aug 22, 2026 at 03:07 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.149 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Here is a lengthy observation that helps explain why older lenses have remained in strong demand, both the lenses themselves and the look that many lens producers are trying to reproduce in newly manufactured lenses.

A lot of 3D was easily seen in last century's lenses, so it's intriguing to try and find out why that was so, and see where the industry 'went wrong' and lost touch so badly. But a lot of people are disturbed to realise progress is often regress, and you see that happening everywhere these days: car design, architecture, and yes, imagery.
--
'Modern coatings are advanced molecular stacks designed for precise spectra. They favor high contrast and digital optimization, yielding clean, neutral imagery. Yet many shooters find that vintage coatings—less perfect but more soulful—produce subtler tonal transitions that flatter skin and film emulsions.

Some old lenses perform better than modern ones, simpler coating formulas can yield images that feel more alive. Some old coatings actually complement the simple optical designs they were built for.

With fewer glass elements, light travels a purer path, giving images micro-contrast that feels rich and tactile. Instead of hyper-saturated tones, you get a balanced palette—especially appealing for portrait or black-and-white work.

Modern coatings can sometimes over-correct, creating sterile visuals devoid of atmosphere. Vintage coatings allow controlled flare that gently wraps highlights, producing depth modern lenses struggle to emulate.

Pros include: Organic color and smoother shadows; Natural highlight roll-off in bright light; Distinct rendering perfect for storytelling.

Creative reasons to keep vintage coated lenses in your Kit, how classic coatings add emotion and story to modern photography. Vintage coated lenses excel when character matters more than perfection. Soft flares, dreamy warmth, and pastel rendering inspire both still shooters and filmmakers seeking nostalgic moods. Combining old glass with digital bodies creates endless experimental possibilities.

Why do some old lenses perform better than modern ones?
Because simpler optical formulas and unique coating materials produce more natural color tones and softer contrast that modern lenses sometimes lose.'

https://dutchthrift.com/blogs/blogs/the-secret-power-of-vintage-lens-coatings

All these characteristics produce, or are related to, dimensionality. An image is naturally more appealing when it exhibits 3D, so say the advocates of it.
Aug 22, 2026 at 03:38 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.149 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
Surely there must be some way to test the lenses and measure the 3D effect. Saying that people should use moldy old lenses often designed for film doesn't solve the problem and creates severe constraints in the field. What are people supposed to do in ten years with the cameras of the future?

EBH
Aug 22, 2026 at 04:14 PM
philip_pj
Offline
Details
p.149 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
More on 3D issues from Cooke, about their latest fast full frame lenses, the s8/i range, retailing for $35,000 a piece:

TL/DR Keywords: balanced approach to sharpness; greater sense of depth; smooth focus fall-off; natural, organic transition; rolling through focus; bokeh impacts depth; out-of-focus areas that complement..the subject.

'The lens delivers a balanced approach to sharpness and smooth focus fall-off, creating clear subjects against smoothly rendered backgrounds. This separation generates a greater sense of depth in what is essentially, once captured, a two-dimensional image.

Even more remarkably, while the depth of field can be extremely narrow when shooting wide open, the transition is forgiving – rolling through focus rather than abruptly “snapping” between in-focus and out-of-focus areas. This natural, organic transition is what cinematographers have long sought but rarely found in a lens that performs consistently at every aperture.

Bokeh and Focus Transition – the aesthetic quality of the out-of-focus areas – known as “bokeh” – significantly impacts how we perceive depth in an image… elegant bokeh characteristics create pleasing out-of-focus areas that complement rather than distract from the subject.'

That is a significant recipe for 3D. These were design targets developed by one of the most respected cine lens makers, on par with Zeiss and Leitz, who are doing very similar things.

You can tell them you don't see it and they are going the wrong way about it! They know their Director / DP / Cinematographer audience and they know how to reach them, to give them what they want to show in their imagery.
Aug 22, 2026 at 04:21 PM
gdanmitchell
Offline
Details
p.149 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
No still photography lens has $35,000 worth of “pop.” ;-)
Aug 22, 2026 at 04:50 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.149 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Philip,

In my case I would rather go for today's modern lenses vs. the vintage ones. First of all I am only interested in AF lenses. Also, even if you are right that the old ones are 10/10 in 3D, I would rather have a 7/10 in 3D but have AF. Lastly and this is judging from my newest lens--Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N---if all the lenses going forward can virtually eliminate CA---I'm all for it!
Aug 22, 2026 at 05:00 PM
Jeff Kott
Offline
Details
p.149 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
If you’re looking to use Eye AF, an option is to use vintage M mount, Contax or even Pentax lenses with an AF adapter. That won’t work for sports, but certainly will for portraiture.
Aug 22, 2026 at 05:05 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.149 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
ummmmmmmmm, Techart LM-EA9 + Voigtlander Nokton 40/1.2 = AF!!! ummm, CAD$ 573+1126 = $ 1699.ummm indeed. OTOH, that price is pretty close to a brand new Sigma 50/1.2 ART. Gotta think about this. Thanks very much Jeff!!
Aug 22, 2026 at 05:19 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.149 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
Here is a lengthy observation that helps explain why older lenses have remained in strong demand, both the lenses themselves and the look that many lens producers are trying to reproduce in newly manufactured lenses.

A lot of 3D was easily seen in last century's lenses, so it's intriguing to try and find out why that was so, and see where the industry 'went wrong' and lost touch so badly. But a lot of people are disturbed to realise progress is often regress, and you see that happening everywhere these days: car design, architecture, and yes, imagery.
--
'Modern coatings are
...Show more →

I love modern zoom lenses, IMHO they have a lot of pop! Here's from my the Sigma 28-105/2.8 DG DN ART. Ok, I cheated---it was taken on a beach near Melbourne at the golden hour--so it's gotta pop!! I created a vintage one for Ti---her inner Janis Joplin so she can show it to her grandma.






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/1600s f/2.8 at 94.2mm iso100




Aug 22, 2026 at 07:56 PM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.149 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
philip_pj wrote:
It's the naysayers that get peoples' goat

No, it is the constant spouting of utter nonsense by self-proclaimed experts that drives people up the wall—and rightly so. The worst part is that these people live in their own little universe; not only do they write drivel, but they also do the exact opposite of what they preach. They refuse to engage in actual discussion, instead delivering page-long monologues, making all sorts of claims, and then posting images that show absolutely *nothing* of the sort. The fact that there hasn't been a single 1:1 comparison over the years fits right into this pattern. After all, it does no good to cobble together random snippets from every corner of the internet and then feed them to an AI. That is precisely how you end up with completely moronic statements like the following:
philip_pj wrote:
Besides consumer optics, there was much more at stake in very important high tech fields - it actually threatened to disable MRI machines because they lost the ability to image the blue channel.


And the absolute icing on the cake is that there is absolutely no reaction from "these people"—even when other forum members kindly explain to them why what they’ve just written is utter nonsense. No, they simply ignore it and carry on, undeterred, churning out moronic diatribes.

So much for the topic philip_pj wrote:
So I stubbornly persist in presenting actual information


Aug 23, 2026 at 01:32 AM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.149 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Makten wrote:
"I can't tell any difference, so no one else can either."

Why are you posting in a thread where the whole topic is beyond your intellectual reach? You are not contributing anything of value to those who actually can see a difference and think it matters. Please go somewhere else.


In these remarks of yours, you demonstrate your complete inability to hold any sort of discussion, let alone one of a technical nature.
You have fallen into the ad hominem fallacy, in which you attack the person speaking (“the whole topic is beyond your intellectual reach”) rather than addressing their argument.
Furthermore, attributing words to someone that they have never said, in order to make it easier to criticise their opinion, is known as the straw man fallacy. This technique constitutes another logical fallacy. In fact, you are attributing statements to me that I have never made (“I can’t tell any difference, so no one else can either”); I’ve written exactly the opposite (probably you aren't able to understand a written text): show us the same scene photographed, under same lighting conditions, with different lenses and demonstrate to all of us that lens A has more three-dimensionality than lens B.
I myself have written several times in this thread – which is as long as it is pointless – that I consider some of my lenses to be less flat than others (and I’ve even explained why: go and read it).
And to reach this conclusion, its pointless to look at a photo of a gorgeous woman taken with lens A and then compare it to a boring image of a bucket and a spade taken with lens B. And then conclude that both lenses have 3D pop. Silly.
But like all functionally illiterate people, when it comes to discussing the merits of the matter and you’ve run out of arguments, you resort to insulting others. Well done. But why don’t you go and be a keyboard bully somewhere else instead.
Aug 23, 2026 at 02:01 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.149 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
Anyone who knows anything about photography (or art) knows that the factors that can create the illusion of three-dimensionality in a two-dimensional image are different—and far more important—than this or that lens.


Which means?


And if we were to evaluate the least important factor in creating the illusion of three-dimensionality—namely, a lens’s performance—we’d have to compare its images with those taken by other lenses.


Not at all, it is entirely possible to look at one photo and say whether this photo has 3D or not.


So EVERYTHING in this thread is pointless until photos are taken under controlled conditions of the same subject, with the same lighting, and using different lenses.


No, one photo is enough, if it has 3D.


Surely, you can take flat-looking images even with the lens that emerges as the winner in the test. And so we’re back to the staring point: to achieve the 3D effect/illusion, you need something else—you need to be a photographer.


Everyone on this board is a photographer, that is a non-statement.
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:22 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.149 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
Makten wrote
Nifty Fifty wroteWell, it makes absolutely no difference to me who sees what or doesn't. I just find it pretty ridiculous to elevate the whole thing into an intellectual achievement.
Understanding what the thread is about (lenses), is strangely enough an intellectual achievement, that not everyone reaches.

Over and out.
With all due respect, that statement falls even below the intellectual level of this thread.


With all due respect, I see where he is coming from, even if he is getting exasperated and resorting to sarcasm. This thread, according to its title, is simply about posting photos which supposedly demonstrate 3D, and the discussions of the same. Talking about the talking about the lenses and their properties without naming them is kinda beside the point. Telling a forum full of photographers that one has to be a photographer is insulting, without adding anything.
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:27 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.149 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Ripolini wrote:
In these remarks of yours, you demonstrate your complete inability to hold any sort of discussion, let alone one of a technical nature.
You have fallen into the ad hominem fallacy, in which you attack the person speaking (“the whole topic is beyond your intellectual reach”) rather than addressing their argument.


And there is your ad hominem attack.


And to reach this conclusion, its pointless to look at a photo of a gorgeous woman taken with lens A and then compare it to a boring image of a bucket and a spade taken with lens B. And then conclude that both lenses have 3D pop.


"Boring" is a value statement. Makten's photo is meant to demonstrate 3D. With "a gorgeous woman" I presume you are referring to our Canadian friend, who has freely admitted that his definition of 3D is that the foreground and the background are distinct, which is fine, that is one position. The conclusion that both photos have 3D is by people from the two different positions, i.e. one is foreground/background separation, and the other is 3D texture/rendering.


Silly.


You've got to stop accusing people of ad hominems and then using ad hominems.


But like all functionally illiterate people, when it comes to discussing the merits of the matter and you’ve run out of arguments, you resort to insulting others. Well done. But why don’t you go and be a keyboard bully somewhere else instead.


As do you.
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:36 AM
sergun
Offline
Details
p.149 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Does it look like 3D?
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:49 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.149 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
carstenw wrote:
Not at all, it is entirely possible to look at one photo and say whether this photo has 3D or not.
No, one photo is enough, if it has 3D.


As I have written, there are several factors that contribute to the illusion of three-dimensionality of a two-dimension image.
This is well know to those who have studied art history and photographic composition.
Saying that a photo conveys a sense of three-dimensionality has nothing to do with how three-dimensional the lens makes the image appear.
I mean, along with lighting, shadows, geometric factors (e.g., lines), also focal length, subject distance, aperture, oof rendition can contribute to the 3D effect. But to prove that "a specific lens" plays a role or adds something due to the chemical composition of some glass elements, you need to photograph the same scene with multiple lenses to rule out the possibility that the 3D effect is determined by other aspects (lighting, lines, focal length, aperture, etc.), and instead demonstrate that it stems from the “special” rendering (3D pop) of that particular lens.
As for my tone, let me point out that I wasn’t the one who started by asking provocative questions and then resorting to insults. Self-defense is legitimate, and bullies and rude people should be treated the way they deserve.

Goodbye.
Aug 23, 2026 at 03:59 AM
carstenw
Offline
Details
p.149 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.

About the nature of response, you have made your bed, now lie in it.
Aug 23, 2026 at 04:47 AM
Ripolini
Offline
Details
p.149 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
You can keep repeating over and over that the Earth is flat. That doesn't prove it's flat.
Anyway, if you think that looking at a photo that gives you a sense of three-dimensionality proves it's because of the specific lens used, well, good luck!
Aug 23, 2026 at 05:12 AM
Daran
Offline
Details
p.149 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
carstenw wrote:
Nonsense, to determine if a lens has 3D you just look at a photo which demonstrates the 3D, and decide if you agree or disagree.

Using that logic pretty much all modern lenses have 3D.
Aug 23, 2026 at 06:01 AM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister