carstenw wrote:
Not at all, it is entirely possible to look at one photo and say whether this photo has 3D or not.
No, one photo is enough, if it has 3D.
As I have written, there are several factors that contribute to the illusion of three-dimensionality of a two-dimension image.
This is well know to those who have studied art history and photographic composition.
Saying that a photo conveys a sense of three-dimensionality has nothing to do with how three-dimensional the lens makes the image appear.
I mean, along with lighting, shadows, geometric factors (e.g., lines), also focal length, subject distance, aperture, oof rendition can contribute to the 3D effect. But to prove that "a specific lens" plays a role or adds something due to the chemical composition of some glass elements, you need to photograph the same scene with multiple lenses to rule out the possibility that the 3D effect is determined by other aspects (lighting, lines, focal length, aperture, etc.), and instead demonstrate that it stems from the “special” rendering (3D pop) of that particular lens.
As for my tone, let me point out that I wasn’t the one who started by asking provocative questions and then resorting to insults. Self-defense is legitimate, and bullies and rude people should be treated the way they deserve.
Goodbye.