fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
j4nu
Offline
Details
p.146 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
tuxounet wrote:
"The key thing to notice here is that there is no difference in the 3D “pop” of the image at f/1.4 versus f/4. That makes the lens exceptionally versatile, with aperture not the determining factor for image quality."


Well, to me f/1.4 pops more in that shot ...

Aug 13, 2026 at 04:29 AM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.146 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
Here’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might handle that better. Still, I keep coming back to this lens because I genuinely enjoy its rendering and character.

Since some have seriously claimed that I 'manipulated' sharpness or other aspects in this series, here’s a quick breakdown of my Lightroom processing:

Exposure and white balance adjusted

Contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)

The overexposed sky was toned down

A subtle vignette was added for mood

And of course: sharpening and noise reduction applied as usual

That’s it – just basic raw development to bring out what was already there.

f1.4
DSC08210 by stm geist, auf Flickr

DSC08211 by stm geist, auf Flickr

Edited on Aug 15, 2026 at 03:02 PM · View previous versions
Aug 14, 2026 at 03:22 AM
fotografur
Offline
Details
p.146 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
SpecFoto wrote:
jojib wrotecontinuation....

Perplexity AI's comments are for image below (again Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N). SOOC jpeg (yeah, A7V rules!!!)

Yes — this one has a very strong 3D / “reaching out” feel.
2DSC06599.jpg

The extended arm toward camera creates immediate foreground projection, and the railing acts like a depth line that pulls the viewer into the scene while the water and skyline recede behind her. The shallow depth of field helps, but what really sells it is the pose: the hand closest to camera becomes the dominant spatial cue.
2DSC06599.jpg

What makes it work best:

The arm is angled toward the lens, which creates strong perspective exaggeration.
2DSC06599.jpg

The body is separated from the background by blur and lighting.
2DSC06599.jpg

The railing and deck provide a clear leading line into the distance.
2DSC06599.jpg

Compared with the earlier images, this is probably the most “pop-out of the monitor” shot so far. It feels more dynamic and immersive than the bridge portraits because the foreground hand gives the eye a clear point of entry.

https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176462437.Bvc4jT8X.2DSC06599.jpg
Hmmm jojib, I have to disagree with you on this one, as being a long time portrait photographer I just see too many negatives that make this photo distracting for me.

1. The forward hand is the brightest part of the photo and my eye is drawn to it, rather than on the womans face, which is in the dark. A handheld reflector or small flash here would help balance her face with the rest of the body.

2. The 35mm perspective distortion shows up here way more than in your other photos, notice how her angled forward hand is almost as
...Show more →

I will say this,

If you look at fashion magazines there are a lot of images shot with a wide angle. Even some much wider than 35mm. It seems to be trending that way.
Aug 14, 2026 at 03:52 AM
tuxounet
Offline
Details
p.146 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might
...Show more →

This minibus is amazing. Is it yours?

The 50ZA is rated as still amazingly sharp those days.
Aug 14, 2026 at 04:14 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.146 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might
...Show more →

No complaints here, fantastic image! Love your Batis series as well.
Aug 14, 2026 at 05:43 AM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.146 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might
...Show more →

Compared to when you posted the image earlier I think you have increased the vignetting, the saturation a,d the local contrast more. The 2024 version was nicer, less impact but more realism and alredy then discussed thanks to being an excellent image.

So, a schlimmerbesserung to my eyes. That's interesting. Have your preferences changed, or is it the massive amount of overprocessed images causing you to boost your image? Or is it me - my old eyes have started to hurt more the last years probably from seeing more of the augmented very colorful world on-line?
Aug 14, 2026 at 11:57 AM
gregfountain
Offline
Details
p.146 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
I hate to see this thread drop off the front page so I'm going to suggest another lens with great 3D Pop, at least in one of the ways I interpret it: FUJIFILM XF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6 R LM OIS WR Lens.

Whadda ya think?




  X-T3    XF100-400mmF4.5-5.6 R LM OIS WR lens    400mm    f/5.6    1/1000s    200 ISO    0.0 EV  

Aug 14, 2026 at 12:55 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.146 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Definitely it qualifies for my 'monitor breaking' look so it's 3D for sure. Besides, it's a Fuji so the colours pop! Thanks for sharing.
Aug 14, 2026 at 01:20 PM
gregfountain
Offline
Details
p.146 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
Definitely it qualifies for my 'monitor breaking' look so it's 3D for sure. Besides, it's a Fuji so the colours pop! Thanks for sharing.


Thanks. That camera and lens took good pictures
Aug 14, 2026 at 01:43 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.146 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
gregfountain wrote:
jojib wroteDefinitely it qualifies for my 'monitor breaking' look so it's 3D for sure. Besides, it's a Fuji so the colours pop! Thanks for sharing.
Thanks. That camera and lens took good pictures


I was just kidding (maybe half because I got a Fuji too). Of course great composition and lighting! Well done!!
Aug 14, 2026 at 01:46 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.146 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
Schwarzlicht wroteHere’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might handle that better. Still, I keep coming back to this lens because I genuinely enjoy its rendering and character.

Since some have seriously claimed that I 'manipulated' sharpness or other aspects in this series, here’s a quick breakdown of my Lightroom processing:

Exposure and white balance adjusted

Contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)

The overexposed sky was toned down

A subtle vignette was added for mood

And of course: sharpening and noise reduction applied as usual

That’s it – just basic raw development to bring out what was already there.

[image]
Compared to when you posted the image earlier I think you have increased the vignetting, the saturation a,d the local contrast more. The 2024 version was nicer, less impact but more realism and alredy then discussed thanks to being an excellent image.

So, a schlimmerbesserung to my eyes. That's interesting. Have your preferences changed, or is it the massive amount of overprocessed images causing you to boost your image? Or is it me - my old eyes have started to hurt more the last years probably from seeing more of the augmented very colorful world on-line?


The "overprocessed" look might be due to too much "contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)"
I process in Capture One, where the better way of dealing with flat images is to apply auto-Levels. I rarely use Contrast (and, to think of this, also rarely use sharpening in Capture One).
If I am not mistaken, Lr doesn't have Levels, but Ps sure has this tool (my guess is that the processing was done in LR/ACR - I might be wrong).
Aug 14, 2026 at 02:05 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.146 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
The "overprocessed" look might be due to too much "contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)"
I process in Capture One, where the better way of dealing with flat images is to apply auto-Levels. I rarely use Contrast (and, to think of this, also rarely use sharpening in Capture One).
If I am not mistaken, Lr doesn't have Levels, but Ps sure has this tool (my guess is that the processing was done in LR/ACR - I might be wrong).


Schwarzlicht wrote this version was processed recently using Lightroom. I think the adjustments all were globally as the bokeh is worse now asking for more attention at the same time as the vehicle is very shiny.

@Schwarzlicht: I find this interesting, all this about personal preferences and how they change, your new take on the image make it look so modern and with a cellphone style to it that I don't think is necessary at all. I hope you don't mind these comments and I wonder if it's me (maybe I'm in need of some sort of recalibration to fit better in the modern days of our time) or if it's you who changed the way you look this image or if you just got carried away due to something else.
Aug 14, 2026 at 02:41 PM
gregfountain
Offline
Details
p.146 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
Overall, I really like this image - very cool minibus -- great color and detail, but the OOF areas aren't quite as pleasing to the eye. It's a minor nit for most.

Schwarzlicht wrote:
Here’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might
...Show more →

Aug 14, 2026 at 03:02 PM
Nifty Fifty
Offline
Details
p.146 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?
Jonas B wrote:
(...) your new take on the image make it look so modern and with a cellphone style to it that I don't think is necessary at all. I hope you don't mind these comments and I wonder if it's me (maybe I'm in need of some sort of recalibration to fit better in the modern days of our time) or if it's you who changed the way you look this image or if you just got carried away due to something else.



Don't let it trouble you; I feel exactly the same way you do. However, I don't ask myself whether I should adapt my taste to the prevailing one. What would be the point of that?

Aug 14, 2026 at 03:09 PM
Jonas B
Offline
Details
p.146 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
Nifty Fifty wrote:
Don't let it trouble you; I feel exactly the same way you do. However, I don't ask myself whether I should adapt my taste to the prevailing one. What would be the point of that?


There’s really no point to it at all—I wrote it mostly to spark some kind of train of thought.
The only exception I can think of is if I want to present a collection of photos to a younger audience that isn’t into photography. In that case, the first photo or the cover of the portfolio would have to be a bit more eye-catching rather than showcasing shadow details.
Aug 15, 2026 at 02:50 AM
Al Trujillo
Offline
Details
p.146 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
rsrsrs wrote:
hi
which lens has the most 3D POP?

i guess a Zeiss, but which one?
did anybody compare the 4 zeiss 50ies (2x C/Y, N, ZE)?

Gruss
reinhard



February 17, 2011...a day that will live in Photographic Infamy...when this thread was started by rsrsrs when he asked this relatively innocuous question about Zeiss lenses.

I love this thread and it has become my favorite in FM.

Al
Aug 15, 2026 at 07:15 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.146 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
Al Trujillo wrote:
rsrsrs wrotehi
which lens has the most 3D POP?

i guess a Zeiss, but which one?
did anybody compare the 4 zeiss 50ies (2x C/Y, N, ZE)?

Gruss
reinhard
February 17, 2011...a day that will live in Photographic Infamy...when this thread was started by rsrsrs when he asked this relatively innocuous question about Zeiss lenses.

I love this thread and it has become my favorite in FM.

Al


Hear, hear. It's my fave thread as well!!! Whether one would achieve the 3D focus or not the journey is the one that counts. Borrowing the quote from her shirt that tennis phenom Alex Eala wore recently.....'once it grows, it cannot be stopped.'






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/2000s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/640s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100






SONY ILCE-7M5
1/640s f/1.2 at 35.0mm iso100


Aug 15, 2026 at 07:59 AM
gregfountain
Offline
Details
p.146 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Al Trujillo wrote:
rsrsrs wrotehi
which lens has the most 3D POP?

i guess a Zeiss, but which one?
did anybody compare the 4 zeiss 50ies (2x C/Y, N, ZE)?

Gruss
reinhard
February 17, 2011...a day that will live in Photographic Infamy...when this thread was started by rsrsrs when he asked this relatively innocuous question about Zeiss lenses.

I love this thread and it has become my favorite in FM.

Al

It is an entertaining thread Al, for more reasons than the topic would suggest
Aug 15, 2026 at 01:00 PM
Schwarzlicht
Offline
Details
p.146 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
gregfountain wrote:
Overall, I really like this image - very cool minibus -- great color and detail, but the OOF areas aren't quite as pleasing to the eye. It's a minor nit for most.

Schwarzlicht wroteHere’s another shot from the same series with the classic minibus – this time freshly processed in Lightroom.
This is the legendary Kässbohrer Setra S6 with a special paint job, built around 1960. It comes factory-equipped with a lot of analogue-era technology – and, as you can clearly see, a generous amount of 3D POP was also part of the original construction spec.

The lens is the 50mm Planar 1.4 ZA – certainly not the newest or most clinically sharp design out there. It’s no CA monster, but wide open it can show some chromatic aberration or colour fringing. Modern lenses might handle that better. Still, I keep coming back to this lens because I genuinely enjoy its rendering and character.

Since some have seriously claimed that I 'manipulated' sharpness or other aspects in this series, here’s a quick breakdown of my Lightroom processing:

Exposure and white balance adjusted

Contrast boosted (the scene was quite flat with little light/shade contrast)

The overexposed sky was toned down

A subtle vignette was added for mood

And of course: sharpening and noise reduction applied as usual

That’s it – just basic raw development to bring out what was already there.

f1.4
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/26117200727_33c3ee9f4b_k.jpgDSC08211 by stm geist, auf Flickr



Thank you very much! Yes, the bus is really great. You don't see models from that era very often these days. Since the town hall was right nearby, I suspect it was used to take a wedding party to the registry office.

I have to agree with you about the bokeh – it is a bit busy. Depending on the situation, the bokeh can be absolutely beautiful. But there are also scenarios where the Planar gets a little restless, and sometimes it can even be too soft (mushy).

Back then, I took about 10 shots with almost the same framing but different focus points. I ended up developing 3–4 of them. The RAW for the image I posted now just hadn't been developed yet. It's always the same story with me – over the last few decades, I've accumulated over 20,000 RAWs in my Lightroom Cloud. Whenever I go through them to do some cleaning up, I end up getting stuck on a RAW and developing it instead of deleting anything...

I've now updated my post and added the image that I probably originally posted back then (second image). To be honest, I don't think the difference is that big. The second one has slightly cooler colors, but there's a lamp post on the left that unfortunately intrudes into the frame. Today, I would just crop that out. In the current image, the colors appear more vibrant, probably due to the higher color temperature. The saturation is at 0 – unedited. Personally, I prefer the current image.

By the way, I don't think the location is particularly great for photography. The ground consists of reddish cobblestones that are very matte and don't reflect much light. Unfortunately, you see that in other cities too – sometimes you can't even tell that the stones are red. I think I once posted a shot of an old red Porsche 356 in this thread. It was the same situation – the Porsche was the only thing that had any color, because those matte red cobblestones barely reflected any light:

DSC09514 by stm geist, auf Flickr

Aug 15, 2026 at 04:50 PM
EB-1
Offline
Details
p.146 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
tuxounet wrote:
ruthenium wrote"3D is when things in the scene look so real that if you didn't know you were looking at a photograph, you could be looking through a window" that is a surprisingly good way of thinking about the perception.
However, this means no bokeh, isn't it? Perhaps only a gentle blur of things in the distance. I like this, as I never liked blurring everything around a subject as a way of subject isolation.
This is completely correct. Zeiss, in all communications, differentiates "Pop" and bokeh. "Pop" is related to micro contrast.
https://lenspire.zeiss.com/photo/en/article/micro-contrast-and-the-zeiss-pop-by-lloyd-chambers/

"The ZEISS micro contrast “pop” is evident at every aperture until diffraction flattens performance with a heavy hand […]"
"The key thing to notice here is that there is no difference in the 3D “pop” of the image at f/1.4 versus f/4. That makes the lens exceptionally versatile, with aperture not the determining factor for image quality."
"The “pop” or “3D rendering” or “brilliance” or “bite” of fine details that results from high micro contrast lends a feel to an image that many lenses
...Show more →

What are the units of the microncontast or "3D Pop?" Can't they be plotted multi-dimensionally for various lenses rather than using flowery, ambiguous language?

EBH
Aug 16, 2026 at 12:08 AM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister