fredmiranda.com Login

which lens has the most 3D POP?

  
 
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #1which lens has the most 3D POP?
Got a few tips from Perplexity AI mainly on the composition. I showed this picture.







"Yes, it has a strong 3-D like feel, especially because the subject is sharp and well separated from the background by shallow depth of field.

The subject does not fully 'pop out of the monitor' in an exaggerated stereo sense, but the image does create good foreground to background layering: the model sits clearly in front of the walkway, and the blurred trees and bridge rails fall away behind her.

What limits the leaping out effect:

-the subject is mostly alligned with the scene rather breaking beyond the frame boundary
-the pose is relatively upright and static, so the image feels elegant and dimensional rather than aggressive or hyper-3D.

If you want a more of that monitor-breaking look, a wider lens, stronger foreground overlap and a pose with an arm or shoulder closer to the camera would push the effect further.

My comment: Ok, thanks I think I got it....I'll show Perplexity another pic in my next reply. Oh BTW, the lens is Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N (with my Sony A7V)
Aug 01, 2026 at 08:44 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #2which lens has the most 3D POP?
continuation....

Perplexity AI's comments are for image below (again Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N). SOOC jpeg (yeah, A7V rules!!!)

Yes — this one has a very strong 3D / “reaching out” feel.
2DSC06599.jpg

The extended arm toward camera creates immediate foreground projection, and the railing acts like a depth line that pulls the viewer into the scene while the water and skyline recede behind her. The shallow depth of field helps, but what really sells it is the pose: the hand closest to camera becomes the dominant spatial cue.
2DSC06599.jpg

What makes it work best:

The arm is angled toward the lens, which creates strong perspective exaggeration.
2DSC06599.jpg

The body is separated from the background by blur and lighting.
2DSC06599.jpg

The railing and deck provide a clear leading line into the distance.
2DSC06599.jpg

Compared with the earlier images, this is probably the most “pop-out of the monitor” shot so far. It feels more dynamic and immersive than the bridge portraits because the foreground hand gives the eye a clear point of entry.





Aug 01, 2026 at 08:48 AM
Bruce Marriner
Offline
Details
p.144 #3which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
Perplexity AI's comments are for image below


And ya'll thought this thread was off track yesterday..

Are we really using AI to define the quality of art for us now? This is very disheartening to the whole genre and for humanity.


Aug 01, 2026 at 12:26 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #4which lens has the most 3D POP?
well at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!
Aug 01, 2026 at 12:31 PM
Garmadon
Offline
Details
p.144 #5which lens has the most 3D POP?
Those are great .You are getting very nice results with this lens.
Did you use a flash for those 2?

jojib wrote:
Happy Friday 3D popists! Another great day and Aloha from Lake Ontario!

Absolutely love that look of subject trying to leap from my monitor while the background stays behind.

https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176457142.0V17BOmy.1DSC09886.jpg
https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176460007.ua8KNp4j.1DSC00115.jpg

Aug 01, 2026 at 12:56 PM
Bruce Marriner
Offline
Details
p.144 #6which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
well at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!



I'll agree you got some harsh criticism here recently and it could have probably been worded better, though I do think it was honest criticism and not intended to be mean to you personally. I still find replacing humans with AI to decide the value of art to be quite disheartening.
Aug 01, 2026 at 12:58 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #7which lens has the most 3D POP?
Garmadon wrote:
Those are great .You are getting very nice results with this lens.
Did you use a flash for those 2?

jojib wroteHappy Friday 3D popists! Another great day and Aloha from Lake Ontario!

Absolutely love that look of subject trying to leap from my monitor while the background stays behind.

https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176457142.0V17BOmy.1DSC09886.jpg
https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176460007.ua8KNp4j.1DSC00115.jpg


Thanks for your kind words Garmadon!

No, I didn't use flash in any of those two images.

I'm looking at some of my images from the Canon EF 50/1.2 L shot wide open. Sometimes the 'look and feel' of the Viltrox 35 has some similarity. I started inquiring for the Sony 50/1.2 GM on FM Marketplace---maybe I should just save my money.

Cheers,

Joji

Edited on Aug 01, 2026 at 02:41 PM · View previous versions
Aug 01, 2026 at 01:03 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #8which lens has the most 3D POP?
Bruce Marriner wrote:
jojib wrotewell at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!
I'll agree you got some harsh criticism here recently and it could have probably been worded better, though I do think it was honest criticism and not intended to be mean to you personally. I still find replacing humans with AI to decide the value of art to be quite disheartening.


Fair enough Bruce, thanks.

Joji
Aug 01, 2026 at 01:04 PM
RustyRus
Offline
Details
p.144 #9which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
continuation....

Perplexity AI's comments are for image below (again Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N). SOOC jpeg (yeah, A7V rules!!!)

Yes — this one has a very strong 3D / “reaching out” feel.
2DSC06599.jpg

The extended arm toward camera creates immediate foreground projection, and the railing acts like a depth line that pulls the viewer into the scene while the water and skyline recede behind her. The shallow depth of field helps, but what really sells it is the pose: the hand closest to camera becomes the dominant spatial cue.
2DSC06599.jpg

What makes it work best:

The arm is angled toward the lens, which creates strong perspective exaggeration.
2DSC06599.jpg

The body
...Show more →

I look at this picture and don't see pop- Since you are using AI to judge yoru photos. Here is my honest opinion.

I see a poorly lit main subject under harsh lighting conditions-

I think cameras have become so easy to use we sometimes skip the basics- I just read this book again for the 5th time-

Light — Science & Magic
An Introduction to Photographic Lighting

Its always a great reminder of how light can impact the picture far more than any fast aperture lens or flash combo-

Keep shooting and doing whatever makes the art you want-
Aug 01, 2026 at 03:22 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #10which lens has the most 3D POP?
RustyRus wrote:
jojib wrotecontinuation....

Perplexity AI's comments are for image below (again Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N). SOOC jpeg (yeah, A7V rules!!!)

Yes — this one has a very strong 3D / “reaching out” feel.
2DSC06599.jpg

The extended arm toward camera creates immediate foreground projection, and the railing acts like a depth line that pulls the viewer into the scene while the water and skyline recede behind her. The shallow depth of field helps, but what really sells it is the pose: the hand closest to camera becomes the dominant spatial cue.
2DSC06599.jpg

What makes it work best:

The arm is angled toward the lens, which creates strong perspective exaggeration.
2DSC06599.jpg

The body is separated from the background by blur and lighting.
2DSC06599.jpg

The railing and deck provide a clear leading line into the distance.
2DSC06599.jpg

Compared with the earlier images, this is probably the most “pop-out of the monitor” shot so far. It feels more dynamic and immersive than the bridge portraits because the foreground hand gives the eye a clear point of entry.

https://a4.pbase.com/o12/30/64330/1/176462437.Bvc4jT8X.2DSC06599.jpg
I look at this picture and don't see pop- Since you are using AI to judge yoru photos. Here is my honest opinion.

I see a poorly lit main subject under harsh lighting conditions-

I think cameras have become so easy to use we sometimes skip the basics- I just read this book again for the 5th time-

Light — Science & Magic
An Introduction to Photographic Lighting

Its always a great reminder of how light can impact the picture far more than any fast aperture lens or flash combo-

Keep shooting and doing whatever makes the art you want-


Of course you are entitled to your own opinion. For me pop is the vibrancy of colours and it certainly has it. I like the way the light strikes her because it reminded me that it was an early morning shoot. And there were probably no more than 10 of us in the ferry boat. Again to each their own.

As to the AIs recommendation, it was indeed beneficial for me as I learn more about the 3D-effect. I always thought that just like in the 3D movies it's as if the subject is trying to burst out of the screen. I gave AI a few images and selected the one in the ferry boat as a great example of 3D. Of course, once I do a shoot---I'm not going to be thinking---heck I need this to get the 3D-effect . Overall, I love shooting portraits wide open and I will just continue that.

What I also learned from AI is getting pop is easy but the 3D-effect is more of composition. Like these ones have pop but not so much 3D.




















Aug 01, 2026 at 03:40 PM
 


Search in Used Dept. 

RoamingScott
Offline
[X]
Details
p.144 #11which lens has the most 3D POP?
"AI kissed my ass so I must be doing something right!"

Yikes, bro.
Aug 01, 2026 at 04:29 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #12which lens has the most 3D POP?
RoamingScott wrote:
"AI kissed my ass so I must be doing something right!"

Yikes, bro.


Did it? Or just gave me a few pointers. Maybe I should put a tape of my modern tennis forehand and send it for analysis.
Aug 01, 2026 at 04:32 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #13which lens has the most 3D POP?
I should be nice to you. Fall is just around the corner. You might be the selected few to get the 50/1.2 LAB and test it for 3D-pop. So yeah would like to see your review and a discount coupon.
Aug 01, 2026 at 04:52 PM
ruthenium
Offline
Details
p.144 #14which lens has the most 3D POP?


jojib wrote:
well at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!


Mean comments are not o.k., however, this is relatively rare on this forum - not a real problem. Harsh, that is, direct comments are o.k. when these are constructive. Such comments can be useful. I find your posts problematic for simple technical reasons that I shall state below. Personally(!), I expect we should have good time shall we meet in Toronto, or if you happen to visit me in Kitchener-Waterloo.
To state my reasons: first, the number of photos you post is a bit excessive. E.g., there are seven in one post on the previous page (all presumably demonstrating 3D "pop"). To me, this number was not justified by the content. Second, photos from you tend to look repetitive (to me), and as such they are (mostly) lacking originality. Third, the subjects of your photos are anonymous. These are random females that have been photographed in a blurry environment. There's no apprent connection between the subjects and the background. Thus, by displaying your work you make me wonder about your intent, that is why do you want me to spend time viewing your photos? The subject is invariably a female. Thus, apparently there's something about these females that you expect me to find interesting or worth looking at. This is why (I believe) you make your subjects regularly adopt poses that can be described as alluring or seductive. To me, these posed females tend to look unnatural, artificial, even sexualized. Some may like this kind of portraying female subjects, while I don't and I cannot help it.

Seeking advice on composition from AI is an interesting experiment, but I am sure that you are not that naive to take the advice too seriously. In the particular example that you posted, the DoF is narrow. The attention is 100% on the face of the subject, while the extended hand is too blurry to play a role in the composition. The composition is slightly unbalanced to my eye. There is too much empty (unused?) blurry space on the right side. Furthermore, I get the impression that the upper deck of the ferry boat rests on the head of the subject. This looks awkward. Don't get me wrong, this photo would've been judged "nice" if it had been taken with a phone, by a boyfriend/girlfriend of the subject, as something intended for personal use, to look back and remember a pleasant boat trip. Things change when this photo is presented on a photography forum where no one knows the subject, the location, and why this photo was taken in the first place. There are subjects that don't need explanations (e.g. an exotic bird, or a well-known figure in politics or sports, etc.) - but why this unknown girl?
Aug 01, 2026 at 06:53 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #15which lens has the most 3D POP?
ruthenium wrote:
jojib wrotewell at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!
Mean comments are not o.k., however, this is relatively rare on this forum - not a real problem. Harsh, that is, direct comments are o.k. when these are constructive. Such comments can be useful. I find your posts problematic for simple technical reasons that I shall state below. Personally(!), I expect we should have good time shall we meet in Toronto, or if you happen to visit me in Kitchener-Waterloo.
To state my reasons: first, the number of photos you post is a bit excessive. E.g., there are seven in one post on the previous page (all presumably demonstrating 3D
...Show more →

Thanks for your comments. First of all I don't have any issues asking AI for help---I've done so in many occasions. I find them invaluable especially in travel advice. For photos this is a photography forum so people love to take pictures no matter what the genres is and we love to show it.

As to the image in the ferry boat---it is indeed 3D! It surely matches my criterion of subject trying to leap from the monitor while the background stays behind. It doesn't matter what the pose was, based on that I achieve a 3D picture!

Regarding the poses---I usually tell my models to mix it up. A lot of them do the pouting and alluring poses. I often have to remind them I want some smiling and laughing pictures. A lot of them have beautiful teeth---so why not show that tantalizing smile. I have no problems with alluring or sexy poses. As long as they are over 21, I'm good with it.

I am mostly an outdoor photographer so during the summer (you know that it is short here) I'd love to focus on outdoor fashion/lifestyle and swimsuits on the beach. That's why I got myself a Sigma 28-105/2.8 so I can shoot street then beach with one lens.

I used to shoot a lot of sports (i.e. tennis and indoor volleyball) and my idol is Walter Iooss, Jr. Not only he is great in sports photography but I love the way he photograph Maria Sharapova in a bikini shoot for SI Swimsuit. Thus I love to shoot bikinis on the beach. I do that too when travelling. I would love to show a lot of bikini photos here but judging the animosity for alluring images I've been selective about it.

At the end of the day, if I see an image with 3D (thanks to the lengthy and very articulate description from Perplexity A) I will post it here. Lastly we're not super pros here or Getty photographers---the pictures don't need to be award winning!!! Heck I play tennis and I have a one-handed backhand. I don't have to play like Roger Federer---but I enjoy the game. Similarly, I enjoy photography.
Aug 01, 2026 at 07:11 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #16which lens has the most 3D POP?
After much hoopla---rsrsrs, I finally got an answer for you. At least in my honest opinion the most 3D pop lens ever is the Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N!!!
-cuts like a knife in sharpness even wide open
-AF is relatively fast although occasionally it might hunt when your subject is in the shade and the background is very bright.
-the price is reasonable for an f/1.2 lens
-the bokeh is silky smooth!!!
-the rendering is DROP DEAD GORGEOUS
-CA is well controlled as a matter of fact I haven't seen it in any of my pictures
-slight vignetting with ND filter but maybe this is a user error

Just a bit of a warning---with this lens it is highly addictive to shoot wide open all the time!!!

Side note: in the past I would substitute 24-70/2.8 lens for a fast 35mm and 70-200/2.8 for 135mm. I’ll do that again today. The Viltrox 35 and Sony 135GM make one heck of a 1-2 punch for portraits!!
Aug 01, 2026 at 08:59 PM
SpecFoto
Offline
Details
p.144 #17which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
continuation....

Perplexity AI's comments are for image below (again Viltrox 35/1.2 LAB N). SOOC jpeg (yeah, A7V rules!!!)

Yes — this one has a very strong 3D / “reaching out” feel.
2DSC06599.jpg

The extended arm toward camera creates immediate foreground projection, and the railing acts like a depth line that pulls the viewer into the scene while the water and skyline recede behind her. The shallow depth of field helps, but what really sells it is the pose: the hand closest to camera becomes the dominant spatial cue.
2DSC06599.jpg

What makes it work best:

The arm is angled toward the lens, which creates strong perspective exaggeration.
2DSC06599.jpg

The body
...Show more →

Hmmm jojib, I have to disagree with you on this one, as being a long time portrait photographer I just see too many negatives that make this photo distracting for me.

1. The forward hand is the brightest part of the photo and my eye is drawn to it, rather than on the womans face, which is in the dark. A handheld reflector or small flash here would help balance her face with the rest of the body.

2. The 35mm perspective distortion shows up here way more than in your other photos, notice how her angled forward hand is almost as large as her face, when it should be about 1/2 that height when angled. Her back hand is about 1/3 the size of the forward one. There is a strong reason why most portrait photographers use a 50 or 85mm lens when shooting people closeup to avoid such unnatural body distortions caused by wider angle lenses. While having a hand as a leading line is OK, an exaggerated limb throws the photo out of balance.

3. The large pole in the background is coming out of her head, this is a cardinal rule in portrait photography to avoid at all costs.

Just giving you my honest opinion, as I would never show this photo to a client.

Aug 01, 2026 at 10:42 PM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #18which lens has the most 3D POP?
Thanks very much for your comments, I truly appreciate the constructive criticism.

I saw the bright hand as well and I would have 'burned' that on post but I wanted to show an SOOC jpeg just to make a point about 3D. I still believe that I was able to achieve the leaping from the monitor look. The below one is from the same shoot but the 3D effect is not as strong. Again I was just trying to make a point about 3D.














Julia Trotti uses a lot of 35mm for her shoots and it's her fave focal length



Lastly I do agree that a longer lens is more appropriate especially for headshots. That's why I either bring the Batis 85 or the Sony GM. In that shoot I got the Batis.

And I enjoy taking headshots on location

















And of course the 135GM

















Once again thanks for taking the time for your comments.
Aug 02, 2026 at 03:58 AM
SpecFoto
Offline
Details
p.144 #19which lens has the most 3D POP?
jojib wrote:
Thanks very much for your comments, I truly appreciate the constructive criticism.

Julia Trotti uses a lot of 35mm for her shoots and it's her fave focal length



Julia Trotti has numerous videos with every focal length and brand saying how great they all are, she is a yt influencer to the max $$$.

Yes, Julia likes the 35mm F/L for the environmental portrait style, BUT she is well aware of the perspective distortion a 35mm lens brings. See the video below from 5 years ago comparing a 35/50/85 where she mentions the 35mm distortion issues numerous times. She says most times she shoots around it to mitigate the facial or body distortion only the 35 brings, but at other times she uses it.



Nothing personally against the 35mm F/L, I have 3 including the GM. But for me, as most of my portraits are outside and my F/L lens use ranking is the 85 first, followed by 135/50 and 35mm last. No lens is a do all F/L for portraits, and this is further complacated for prime lens lovers like you and me.

Aug 02, 2026 at 05:40 AM
jojib
Offline
Details
p.144 #20which lens has the most 3D POP?
Thanks again for your comments and I agree. I'd like to say more but it will veer off topic from 3D.

Cheers,

Joji
Aug 02, 2026 at 05:52 AM


FM ForumsLeica & Alternative GearJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister