jojib wrote:
well at least AI was able to criticize my images (which I believe have pop/3D) without being mean and harsh (like some people here and weird comments about the models)---so hey I'll take AI any day!!!!!!!
Mean comments are not o.k., however, this is relatively rare on this forum - not a real problem. Harsh, that is, direct comments are o.k. when these are constructive. Such comments can be useful. I find your posts problematic for simple technical reasons that I shall state below. Personally(!), I expect we should have good time shall we meet in Toronto, or if you happen to visit me in Kitchener-Waterloo.
To state my reasons: first, the number of photos you post is a bit excessive. E.g., there are seven in one post on the previous page (all presumably demonstrating 3D "pop"). To me, this number was not justified by the content. Second, photos from you tend to look repetitive (to me), and as such they are (mostly) lacking originality. Third, the subjects of your photos are anonymous. These are random females that have been photographed in a blurry environment. There's no apprent connection between the subjects and the background. Thus, by displaying your work you make me wonder about your intent, that is why do you want me to spend time viewing your photos? The subject is invariably a female. Thus, apparently there's something about these females that you expect me to find interesting or worth looking at. This is why (I believe) you make your subjects regularly adopt poses that can be described as alluring or seductive. To me, these posed females tend to look unnatural, artificial, even sexualized. Some may like this kind of portraying female subjects, while I don't and I cannot help it.
Seeking advice on composition from AI is an interesting experiment, but I am sure that you are not that naive to take the advice too seriously. In the particular example that you posted, the DoF is narrow. The attention is 100% on the face of the subject, while the extended hand is too blurry to play a role in the composition. The composition is slightly unbalanced to my eye. There is too much empty (unused?) blurry space on the right side. Furthermore, I get the impression that the upper deck of the ferry boat rests on the head of the subject. This looks awkward. Don't get me wrong, this photo would've been judged "nice" if it had been taken with a phone, by a boyfriend/girlfriend of the subject, as something intended for personal use, to look back and remember a pleasant boat trip. Things change when this photo is presented on a photography forum where no one knows the subject, the location, and why this photo was taken in the first place. There are subjects that don't need explanations (e.g. an exotic bird, or a well-known figure in politics or sports, etc.) - but why this unknown girl?