RustyRus wrote:
There is a Leica look though-
Shoot with any Leica lens and you have it- That one is extremely simple to quantify!
Hier ist die Übersetzung als flüssiger, natürlicher Forumsbeitrag:
How can there be one single “Leica look” when people have been talking about it for decades, even though Leica lenses differ so dramatically in their rendering and character that there simply isn’t one consistent visual style?
There are the Mandler lenses, the Karbe lenses and the much older designs. Some have an incredible glow wide open, while others are already extremely sharp at maximum aperture, with no glow at all, strong contrast, lots of microcontrast, punchy colours and a very modern rendering. Others look completely retro, vintage and nostalgic.
Then there are the SL lenses, which seem to aim for near-perfection. You could hardly make a lens more clinical, if that’s how you want to describe it.
There’s the famous 35mm APO-Summicron-M, which many consider to be the ultimate M lens. People talk about its “Leica look”, but they also talk about the “Leica look” of the 35mm Summilux Steel Rim. Those two lenses could hardly be more different, yet both supposedly have the Leica look.
The same applies to the cameras.
In the days of film, the colour rendering came entirely from the combination of the film stock and the lens mounted in front of it. The camera itself was basically just an empty box. Yet people still talked about the Leica look.
Then came Leica’s first digital rangefinders, the M8 and M9. Their colours could hardly be more different, but both are still said to have a Leica look. With the M9, I can understand it to some extent. Its old CCD sensor produces very distinctive colours with a character of its own.
The M240 generation rendered colours completely differently, yet again people spoke about the Leica look. The M10 and M10-R changed things again. The colours of the M10-R in particular have become almost legendary, but they are very different from those of every Leica digital camera that came before it.
Then the M11 renders colours differently yet again. The original SL, the SL2, SL2-S and the various SL3 models all have their own colour rendering as well.
So colour cannot be what defines the Leica look.
Strictly speaking, the lenses cannot define it either, because their character varies so enormously. Some have a very distinctive character, while others are designed to have almost none at all.
It cannot simply be high microcontrast either, because not every Leica lens has strong microcontrast wide open. Some are so glowy that it is difficult to speak of real sharpness, let alone strong contrast.
So what is left?
Perhaps there are some characteristics associated with rangefinder photography. The subject is often placed near the centre because that is where the rangefinder patch is located and where focusing happens. Placing the subject near the edge can be more difficult, especially since many fast Leica lenses also show some very interesting, although technically far from perfect, behaviour towards the edges of the frame. You really have to appreciate that kind of rendering.
Slightly missed focus is not exactly uncommon with the M system either. But of course, a good photograph does not require perfect sharpness.
So in the end, although people constantly talk about one Leica look, nobody can really define or describe it. There have been countless discussions about it, yet you never find one clear and universally accepted definition.
What you can define are different Leica looks, depending on what exactly you are talking about: the colours of a particular camera generation, Mandler lenses, Karbe lenses, SL lenses or lenses with a Steel Rim-style rendering.
But at that point, we are no longer talking about the Leica look. At best, we are talking about Leica looks, in the plural. And those looks differ so fundamentally that it makes little sense to describe them as one consistent visual identity.
The best definition I’ve ever heard is still this one:
The Leica look is the look on your wife’s face when she sees how much you spent on your Leica cameras and lenses.