Beggars can’t be choosers, and we often have to photograph people in strange light. The best dramatic light for portraits enters from the side, the worst (you might say) evenly lights the face. That’s because the even lighting seems to encourage what I call ‘flat face’.
And this is the condition that damages dimensionality badly if the subject is overexposed. This choice destroys facial image ‘content’, also known as skin! We are photographing light falling on the subject, and it often does not fall with great evenness on objects that have shaped depth and contours, such as a human face in sunlight or incidental light.
It’s a current trend that will not age well. The rising concern in the cine business right now is the challenge of how to instill texture into digital imagery.
The breakthroughs that will eventually domesticate digital will come from the cine world because they know what they are looking at, and even better, they know what they are looking for. Motivation is very high.
(You can look up ‘film outs’ for more on this expensive technique. Rightly so, people hate the look of digital, they want something more akin to reality, even if it incurs great cost to achieve it.
‘A "film out" is a post-production technique where digital video footage is printed frame-by-frame onto physical motion picture film stock using a laser or CRT recorder, chemically developed in a lab, and then scanned back into a digital file.’
A good primer: ‘Why Movies Suddenly Look Like Film Again’ by Jimmy on Film. On The Batman (2022) and Dune (2021), cinematographer Greig Fraser shot these massive digital productions on high-end sensors, but intentionally ran a film-out pass to physical stock and re-scanned it to inject organic grain and authentic analog texture.)
But sensible exposure and a little retouching is a solid start to:
. retain texture in faces,
. to make them not look anemic,
. to use contour shaping to render them with dimensionality (the technically accepted word for 3D, and it’s the third D we care about in this discussion).
Correct exposure reveals the character that draws from their innate identity. And it’s easy enough to fix in post, if it matters enough to you. We need many more portrait-oriented lenses to be made primarily for artistic people photography, not directed only at commercial expedience, where the high tone fashion look most likely originated, to then be propagated out to the imaging industrial complex. You see it seemingly all the time in event photography.
Why does it all matter? Why does it matter to have people look more like themselves? Because, if we can’t image the human face aesthetically such that it respects and compliments the person for who they are in real life, what does that say about photography?