fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sony goes pellicle!

  
 
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.3 #1Sony goes pellicle!
phidong wrote:
katzung1 wroteMichael Reichman over on Luminous-Landscape just put up a very positive review.
Bert
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony-a55-preview.shtml

link for the lazy


thanks, i definitely fit in that category.
Aug 24, 2010 at 07:32 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #2Sony goes pellicle!
gasrocks wrote:
Does this mean that any dirt, scratch on the mirror show up in your results?


No. The distance between the mirror and the sensor is relatively so far that dust would be so out of focus as to be a non issue. The image does not come into focus until the film (sensor) plane. Dust on the actual sensor or sensor cover glass is a completely different situation (and note even then it's often not visible until stopped down quite a bit).
Aug 24, 2010 at 07:37 PM
Jammy Straub
Offline
Details
p.3 #3Sony goes pellicle!
This seems like an interim solution until you can just take an EVF feed directly from the sensor. There's no good reason other than heat why they can't do it now, and once you get rid of that, there's little reason to have a mirror at all. At least as far as I know, anyone know of reasons why that wouldn't be preferable?
Aug 24, 2010 at 11:32 PM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.3 #4Sony goes pellicle!
Jammy Straub wrote:
This seems like an interim solution until you can just take an EVF feed directly from the sensor. There's no good reason other than heat why they can't do it now, and once you get rid of that, there's little reason to have a mirror at all. At least as far as I know, anyone know of reasons why that wouldn't be preferable?


the evf feed is directly from the sensor. the mirror is just for the autofocus (fast phase detect autofocus cannot be done on the sensor).
Aug 24, 2010 at 11:38 PM
EOS20
Offline
Details
p.3 #5Sony goes pellicle!
sebboh wrote:
Jammy Straub wroteThis seems like an interim solution until you can just take an EVF feed directly from the sensor. There's no good reason other than heat why they can't do it now, and once you get rid of that, there's little reason to have a mirror at all. At least as far as I know, anyone know of reasons why that wouldn't be preferable?
the evf feed is directly from the sensor. the mirror is just for the autofocus (fast phase detect autofocus cannot be done on the sensor).


Fuji has recently developed through the lens phase detection technology:

http://www.dpreview.com/news/1008/10080505fujifilmpd.asp

Aug 25, 2010 at 12:06 AM
MaxiKana
Offline
Details
p.3 #6Sony goes pellicle!
It's not all a dance of roses, from dpreviews review...


On paper, the SLT A55 should be an ideal tool for shooting fast action. It can shoot at 10fps with continuous autofocus. The A55 also has a trick up its sleeve that even the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV cannot match - because its mirror is fixed, the AF sensor can operate full-time, without interruption. This should ensure more accurate continuous AF performance, since the camera is constantly being fed data with which to make the necessary calculations. That's the theory, but unfortunately it isn't born out in practice. We have found that when presented with fast moving subjects (we shot...Show more →

Whilst the A55 gives very impressive performance in terms of speed and burst depth, two things let it down when shooting continuous bursts. The first is a recovery time of 50 seconds, for some of which time the camera is essentially unusable... ...if after finishing a burst, you try to access image review, the A55 freezes. Both EVF and LCD black out, the camera remains completely frozen (except for AF, oddly, which still operates) for roughly 20 seconds. After this time has elapsed the A55 wakes up again, and allows image review, albeit it with a lag of several seconds...Show more →

The A55's 'headline' 10fps rate is impressive, and is a feat only matched by two other cameras currently on the market, the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV and Nikon D3S. To get the maximum 10fps performance, it is necessary to switch to the dedicated setting on the A55's exposure mode dial. In this mode, exposure is automatic.
Aug 25, 2010 at 01:54 AM
ClausC
Offline
Details
p.3 #7Sony goes pellicle!

On paper, the SLT A55 should be an ideal tool for shooting fast action. It can shoot at 10fps with continuous autofocus. The A55 also has a trick up its sleeve that even the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV cannot match - because its mirror is fixed, the AF sensor can operate full-time, without interruption. This should ensure more accurate continuous AF performance, since the camera is constantly being fed data with which to make the necessary calculations. That's the theory, but unfortunately it isn't born out in practice. We have found that when presented with fast moving subjects (we shot...Show more →

Whilst the A55 gives very impressive performance in terms of speed and burst depth, two things let it down when shooting continuous bursts. The first is a recovery time of 50 seconds, for some of which time the camera is essentially unusable... ...if after finishing a burst, you try to access image review, the A55 freezes. Both EVF and LCD black out, the camera remains completely frozen (except for AF, oddly, which still operates) for roughly 20 seconds. After this time has elapsed the A55 wakes up again, and allows image review, albeit it with a lag of several seconds...Show more →

But this has really nothing to do with the pelicle mirror. You could easily put a 1dMkIV grade AF into the camera, if you wanted it and the price point allowed it - and the EVF update is mostly a money question.

I find the mechanical simplicity of the A55 attractive, no mirrors clanging around, no motors etc It must make it much cheaper to produce.

Regards

Claus
Aug 25, 2010 at 05:07 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #8Sony goes pellicle!
MaxiKana wrote:
It's not all a dance of roses, from dpreviews review...

Earlier quoteOn paper, the SLT A55 should be an ideal tool for shooting fast action. It can shoot at 10fps with continuous autofocus. The A55 also has a trick up its sleeve that even the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV cannot match - because its mirror is fixed, the AF sensor can operate full-time, without interruption. This should ensure more accurate continuous AF performance, since the camera is constantly being fed data with which to make the necessary calculations. That's the theory, but unfortunately it isn't born out in practice. We have found that when presented with fast moving subjects (we shot a range of subjects, including cyclists on a track), focus accuracy is far from 100%. In 10fps mode it is clear that the A55's AF system is simply unable to predict subject position accurately when presented with fast-moving subjects at relatively close range...
Earlier quoteWhilst the A55 gives very impressive performance in terms of speed and burst depth, two things let it down when shooting continuous bursts. The first is a recovery time of 50 seconds, for some of which time the camera is essentially unusable... ...if after finishing a burst, you try to access image review, the A55 freezes. Both EVF and LCD black out, the camera remains completely frozen (except for AF, oddly, which still operates) for roughly 20 seconds. After this time has elapsed the A55 wakes up again, and allows image review, albeit it with a lag of several seconds between images. Only after the full 50 seconds of recovery time has elapsed does it return to its normal level of responsiveness. The second major issue with the A55's continuous shooting is that it cannot maintain live view in 10fps and 6fps capture. In 10fps mode the A55 shows a constantly updating slide show of the image you just took, which means that you can't accurately tell where you subject is, - only where it just was. This can be rather disconcerting when panning as you keep being given the impression that the subject is further back than it now actually is.
Earlier quoteThe A55's 'headline' 10fps rate is impressive, and is a feat only matched by two other cameras currently on the market, the Canon EOS-1D Mark IV and Nikon D3S. To get the maximum 10fps performance, it is necessary to switch to the dedicated setting on the A55's exposure mode dial. In this mode, exposure is automatic.


No doubt these issues will be addressed in the higher end, pro model which it is speculated is coming. At their price point, these cameras offer a lot. Just imagine what Sony will offer at the price of the current a900 or even a850.
Aug 25, 2010 at 06:13 AM
AhamB
Offline
Details
p.3 #9Sony goes pellicle!
ClausC wrote:
I find the mechanical simplicity of the A55 attractive, no mirrors clanging around, no motors etc It must make it much cheaper to produce.


The mirror still has a mechanism to go up though, but just for sensor cleaning.
Aug 25, 2010 at 06:17 AM
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.3 #10Sony goes pellicle!
indifference to CK I came up with these

positive
constant AF during movie mode
fast frame rate
whatever benefits are realised with an EVF vs an OVF

deficit
cost, having both a mirror/mirrorbox and an EVF
parts count, production cost
complexity, having both mechanical and electronic componentry
reduced light performance by e/v, and ISO
delivers less light to the AF sensor
all images must pass through a diagonal plate of glass, optical aberration
whatever problems are realised with an EVF vs an OVF
Aug 25, 2010 at 08:05 AM
ClausC
Offline
Details
p.3 #11Sony goes pellicle!

delivers less light to the AF sensor

today the AF-light is routed the same way (via a pellicle area in the main mirror to a secondary mirror on the back of this) to the AF sensor, so I don't think that one counts. The AF sensor probably gets the same amount of light.

There is also the saving of a pentaprism, so all in all I think there could be a saving compared to a traditional design.

/Claus
Aug 25, 2010 at 08:17 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #12Sony goes pellicle!
Rob Riley wrote:
indifference to CK I came up with these

complexity, having both mechanical and electronic componentry



Hmm. I'm not aware of a digital camera that does not contain both mechanical and electronic componentry.

Aug 25, 2010 at 08:28 AM
abam
Offline
Details
p.3 #13Sony goes pellicle!
the constant af during movie mode alone is provocative.

(there are some great examples of this in action over at vimeo.com.)
Aug 25, 2010 at 09:43 AM
adam613
Offline
Details
p.3 #14Sony goes pellicle!
My big issue with this is that it uses normal Sony Alpha lenses...so the size of the body decreases, but the overall size of the system doesn't. The great thing about Micro Four Thirds is that due to the smaller sensor and the fact that there's no mirror, they can use a much smaller registration distance, which leads to much smaller lenses with decent IQ. So unless someone comes up with a hybrid mount that uses a smaller registration and lenses to match, the only big win here is the phase detection AF during video. (Which, I admit, is very cool...)
Aug 25, 2010 at 12:18 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #15Sony goes pellicle!
adam613 wrote:
My big issue with this is that it uses normal Sony Alpha lenses...so the size of the body decreases, but the overall size of the system doesn't. The great thing about Micro Four Thirds is that due to the smaller sensor and the fact that there's no mirror, they can use a much smaller registration distance, which leads to much smaller lenses with decent IQ. So unless someone comes up with a hybrid mount that uses a smaller registration and lenses to match, the only big win here is the phase detection AF during video. (Which, I admit, is very
...Show more →

That market is what Sony addresses with the NEX series, not this range specifically. NEX = APS sensor, no mirror/extremely thin body and small registration distance.
Aug 25, 2010 at 12:26 PM
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.3 #16Sony goes pellicle!
Tariq Gibran wrote:
Rob Riley wroteindifference to CK I came up with these

complexity, having both mechanical and electronic componentry
Hmm. I'm not aware of a digital camera that does not contain both mechanical and electronic componentry.



it still contains a mirrorbox with all the associated complexity (due to the need to be able to clean the sensor), yet it has an EVF as well. And for the price of it all in cost and reliability, it loses as 1/3 stop in light performance and all that means.
Aug 25, 2010 at 01:29 PM
James10013
Offline
Details
p.3 #17Sony goes pellicle!
ClausC wrote:
Earlier quotedelivers less light to the AF sensor
today the AF-light is routed the same way (via a pellicle area in the main mirror to a secondary mirror on the back of this) to the AF sensor, so I don't think that one counts. The AF sensor probably gets the same amount of light.

There is also the saving of a pentaprism, so all in all I think there could be a saving compared to a traditional design.

/Claus

The price difference between the a580 and the a55 or the a560 and the a33 might be a way to evaluate the cost/savings differential.
Aug 25, 2010 at 01:50 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.3 #18Sony goes pellicle!
Rob Riley wrote:
Tariq Gibran wrote
Rob Riley wroteindifference to CK I came up with these

complexity, having both mechanical and electronic componentry
Hmm. I'm not aware of a digital camera that does not contain both mechanical and electronic componentry.
it still contains a mirrorbox with all the associated complexity (due to the need to be able to clean the sensor), yet it has an EVF as well. And for the price of it all in cost and reliability, it loses as 1/3 stop in light performance and all that means.


I guess I don't follow the logic here. 1/3 stop is negligible, price to consumer is extremely reasonable, cost to Sony - who knows (obviously if these cameras are a success, it will go down) and reliability? There is no reason or historical evidence to suggest this will be an issue. Why would it be any less reliable then any other modern DSLR (they seem to be extremely reliable as a group)?
Aug 25, 2010 at 02:45 PM
curious80
Offline
Details
p.3 #19Sony goes pellicle!
Tariq Gibran wrote:
I guess I don't follow the logic here. 1/3 stop is negligible, price to consumer is extremely reasonable, cost to Sony - who knows (obviously if these cameras are a success, it will go down) and reliability? There is no reason or historical evidence to suggest this will be an issue. Why would it be any less reliable then any other modern DSLR (they seem to be extremely reliable as a group)?


+1
Aug 25, 2010 at 03:06 PM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.3 #20Sony goes pellicle!
Agreed, although I've been mistaken, and it's actually about 3/5 of a stop light loss.
Aug 25, 2010 at 03:21 PM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister