fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Sony goes pellicle!

  
 
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.4 #1Sony goes pellicle!
why not just rejoice in the positive things, instead of the negative
10fps isnt bad, and PDAF in video is worth it, if you are into video

"I guess I don't follow the logic here. 1/3 stop is negligible, "

but not non existent, people pay dearly for better ISO performance, 'those' people wouldnt be as interested in a camera that suffers by design

"price to consumer is extremely reasonable, cost to Sony "

Sony are known to fund there way into a market

"- who knows (obviously if these cameras are a success, it will go down) and reliability? "

more parts, more things to go wrong, less reliability

"There is no reason or historical evidence to suggest this will be an issue."

outside of logic, which as you say you cant follow anyway, guess not. But then theres this
http://forums.dpreview.com/forums/readflat.asp?forum=1000&thread=36120458

Aug 26, 2010 at 02:18 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #2Sony goes pellicle!
Rob Riley wrote:
why not just rejoice in the positive things, instead of the negative
10fps isnt bad, and PDAF in video is worth it, if you are into video

"I guess I don't follow the logic here. 1/3 stop is negligible, "

but not non existent, people pay dearly for better ISO performance, 'those' people wouldnt be as interested in a camera that suffers by design

"price to consumer is extremely reasonable, cost to Sony "

Sony are known to fund there way into a market

"- who knows (obviously if these cameras are a success, it will go down) and reliability? "

more parts, more things to
...Show more →

Yes, Sony does buy market share - great for consumers!

There are really no more parts involved then any other DSLR, perhaps fewer in fact due to the lack of a traditional pentaprism.

Funny thread, and completely inconclusive. The only way to tell if there is a real issue with the translucent mirror would be to use the same lens on a non-pellicle Sony DSLR...200% magnifications of typically poor dpreview sample jpegs don't tell you much. A first hand, controlled test would need to be done but if your looking this hard for a flaw in a camera or lens, I'm sure you will find one!
Aug 26, 2010 at 06:35 AM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.4 #3Sony goes pellicle!
MaxiKana wrote:
It's not all a dance of roses


Nothing ever is.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Aug 26, 2010 at 05:05 PM
theSuede
Offline
Details
p.4 #4Sony goes pellicle!
The 10FPS was usable on static objects only - even trying to pan on a car passing at normal/low inner city speeds was very troublesome via the EVF/main display. I wonder why they mixed a high speed capability with two huge high speed handicaps in the same (new) camera. The tearing in the EVF was HORRID when you panned too fast, and "too fast" wasn't really that fast according to me. It was actually a lot easier to aim via the line you got from the hot-shoe passing the lens hood than to try looking at the screen/through the EVF.

Otherwise, I just loved it. But I'm buying it DESPITE the 10/6fps shooting modes, not because of them.

I liked the size (I wanted a small, compact complementary camera to my Nikon systems and my A850), the button-placement and grip is better than in previous Sony midrange cameras, and the picture quality is excellent. It will be an excellent macro/daytime leisure camera.

BUY 1+ EXTRA BATTERY IMMEDIATELY!
I ran out in 25 minutes of test-shooting, starting on a full charge. Sure, I tied some panning focus ability and a lot of long focus throw back/forth as well as actually shooing, but 305 pics before the battery gave in is a little bit too weak when planning for a day out in the park.
Aug 26, 2010 at 07:18 PM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #5Sony goes pellicle!
theSuede wrote:
The 10FPS was usable on static objects only - even trying to pan on a car passing at normal/low inner city speeds was very troublesome via the EVF/main display. I wonder why they mixed a high speed capability with two huge high speed handicaps in the same (new) camera. The tearing in the EVF was HORRID when you panned too fast, and "too fast" wasn't really that fast according to me. It was actually a lot easier to aim via the line you got from the hot-shoe passing the lens hood than to try looking at the screen/through the EVF.

Otherwise,
...Show more →

I guess another drawback to the EVF is more battery drain. 305 pics, yikes!

How to use that 10 FPS - perhaps an optical finder slid into the hot shoe? But then the issue is that the hot shoe is not standardized so an adapter is required. Ouch.
Aug 26, 2010 at 07:46 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #6Sony goes pellicle!
MaxiKana wrote:
It's not all a dance of roses



Yakim Peled wrote:
Nothing ever is.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.



True. But after reading the dpreview write up I kinda think it's not even "good" and that actually it may kinda suck. It's "different". So many folks are freaking out about it. But when I look at the images and try to imagine actual usage it's not very good - just different. After a short continuous burst you have to wait a whole minute before the camera is operable once again. The noise at high ISO is fairly typical and nothing really special. They had the chance to reduce the registration depth in order to design smaller lighter lenses for it (not to mention accept more lenses via adaptor) and they didn't. They had the opportunity to seal the sensor in a dust-free compartment and they didn't do that either. While installing an EVF every company has the opportunity to make it tilt and/or swivel - again Sony chose not to make the effort. Naw, the a55? I don't think so! Maybe after several generations or with the pellicle in a different maker's body.

At least Sony knows they created a so-so not-so-good camera and priced it accordingly:

Like $450 for the a55 body only, and $700 with the 18-55mm kit lens.




I dunno, that's my 2¢ at this point anyway.
Aug 28, 2010 at 04:05 AM
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.4 #7Sony goes pellicle!
I see it as a stop gap camera until phased CDAF is competitive with PDAF
Aug 28, 2010 at 04:12 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #8Sony goes pellicle!
Why do you think CD-AF is not competitive with PD-AF? And what about the differences are critical? I personally like CD-AF much better than PD.

Aug 28, 2010 at 04:23 AM
Rob Riley
Offline
Details
p.4 #9Sony goes pellicle!
focussing speed

CDAF doent know which way to move a lens focussing element when it begins to focus, and doesnt know when to stop when it gets there. That adds time to achieving correct focus.

Adding phasing to CDAF cures all that, making CDAF speed competitive, where it is more accurate and less failure prone than PDAF anyway.

Aug 28, 2010 at 04:27 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #10Sony goes pellicle!
K, I guess I'm a little confused about CD vs. PD even after reading. I always associate PD with fixed (etched) focus points and a separate AF sensor. I associate CD with the ability to have a free-floating cursor and usually works directly off the sensor without the need for a dedicated AF sensor. Right?

I was all ready to challenge PD's speed by citing the 7 year old tech found in the Konica/Minolta A2 which I assumed was a hybrid CD. But upon gathering the facts behind my case I discover that it uses PD. And it has all the functionality I associate with CD. Free floating cursor, "3D" Predictive Focus Control, and Subject Tracking across the entire frame, etc.

So now I'm wondering if PD can do all that why on Earth would we want CD anyway?


Ref:

    "The DiMAGE A2 provides both manual and automatic focus control. The camera's specification sheet describes the autofocus system as a "Video AF system," which uses phase-detection focusing technology rather than the much more common contrast-detection system. The advantage is that the camera not only determines whether or not the lens is in focus, but also how far out of focus it is, and in which direction (near or far). With this information, the camera should be able to focus much more quickly, since it "knows" roughly how much, and in which direction, to adjust the focus, rather than having to "hunt" for the best focus at the outset. The AF system will still have to do some hunting for the best setting, but it should spend less time doing so than a contrast-based system. This system does seem to be pretty effective, as the A2 shows among the fastest shutter lag times I've seen for autofocus-equipped prosumer digicams."

    http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/A2/A2A5.HTM

Aug 28, 2010 at 06:01 AM
douglasf13
Offline
Details
p.4 #11Sony goes pellicle!
I'm not sure why IR is calling the "video af" of the A2 phase detect. Read this:
Link
Aug 28, 2010 at 09:50 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #12Sony goes pellicle!
Oh, thank you!

Well then, Video AF
    "Video autofocus is, like phase detection autofocus, a passive system and is exclusively used in digital cameras. This system works by evaluating the signal of the CCD, where the autofocus-software tries to detect contrasts. The focus is adjusted, until the contrast has reached its maximum value. The time it takes to determine the focus, depends for example on the frequency, with which the CCD is read from. In the DiMAGE 7, it is read 15 times per second, in the modern DiMAGE A1 50 times a second.

    The most important factor for the speed of the autofocus is the capacity of the autofocus processor, which is one reason why the speed of the cameras in focusing has, like resolution, improved significantly over the years.

    The flexible focus point of the DiMAGE 7 and A series makes it possible for example, to focus on a single spot that can be freely moved around the image. One disadvantage of the video AF is, that this system is not capable of detecting if the sharpness is located in front or behind the subject. In older cameras, it is possible that the focus is "pumping", that means that the camera is continuously focusing back and forth across the point of maximum sharpness, without stopping the focusing-process.

    For video AF to work properly, it is necessary that the CCD generate image data during focusing. To improve focusing in a camera with video AF, it is possible to activate only one autofocus sensor (flexible focus point). The camera isn't then wasting time analyzing different parts of the image, but only the desired spot."


or "Vertical Contrast Detection" as eqqmc2 calls it is already faster than PD or at least "plenty fast enough" as of 7 years ago! The A2 for example can focus it's lens faster than all other entry level DSLRs on the market for the 4 years following it's release. Also most if not all mid-level models too. So if the A2's AF was 50 FPS 7 years ago and doing all that the A2 could do I think CD should have already passed up PD by now. Isn't it just that most of the "pocket" cameras that incorporate CD or VAF "VCD" are too underpowered to use it properly - in a speedy way?

Quite seriously if the A2 had an interchangeable lens system and a M43 sized sensor it blow all of the current M43 offerings out of the water IMHO. Well... At least there would never have been a need for me to "upgrade".


Aug 28, 2010 at 02:03 PM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.4 #13Sony goes pellicle!
Bifurcator wrote:
MaxiKana wroteIt's not all a dance of roses
Yakim Peled wroteNothing ever is.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
True. But after reading the dpreview write up I kinda think it's not even "good" and that actually it may kinda suck. It's "different". So many folks are freaking out about it. But when I look at the images and try to imagine actual usage it's not very good - just different. After a short continuous burst you have to wait a whole minute before the camera is operable once again. The noise at high ISO is fairly typical and nothing really special. They had the chance to reduce the registration depth in order to design smaller lighter
...Show more →

Well, I think it is different enough to seriously consider it as a second camera to my Canon setup. I dunno either, that's my 2¢ at this point anyway.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Aug 29, 2010 at 10:47 PM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #14Sony goes pellicle!
I guess I understand considering it. In another discussion it came out that AF lenses don't work properly with it either. I dunno... It sure seems to have a lot of problems. It looks to m like Sony is just pumping out poorly planned junk - but I guess I could be wrong.

Aug 31, 2010 at 08:14 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #15Sony goes pellicle!
Bifurcator wrote:
I guess I understand considering it. In another discussion it came out that AF lenses don't work properly with it either. I dunno... It sure seems to have a lot of problems. It looks to m like Sony is just pumping out poorly planned junk - but I guess I could be wrong.



Poorly planned junk? Hmm.

"I know of no other video camera that can track AF like this, at any price."

From LL:
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/reviews/cameras/sony-a55-preview.shtml
Aug 31, 2010 at 08:30 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.4 #16Sony goes pellicle!
Bifurcator wrote:
In another discussion it came out that AF lenses don't work properly with it either.


where did you hear that? all the reviews i've seen say that it's autofocus beats the pants off everything lower end than a canon 7D or nikon D300 and that the autofocus is better than any current camera during video.
Aug 31, 2010 at 08:35 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #17Sony goes pellicle!
It was DPR but here's the direct information:

http://www.sony.net/Products/ilc/A-series/a55va33/features01.html

"Exposure control during movie shooting is automatic in all AF modes (AF-A, AF-S, and AF-C), with the aperture fixed at F3.5 or the maximum aperture of the lens in use, whichever is smaller."


so... between you, Tariq Gibran and some others here it seems at least to be a mixed bad... Shrug.

Aug 31, 2010 at 10:32 AM
sebboh
Offline
Details
p.4 #18Sony goes pellicle!
Bifurcator wrote:
It was DPR but here's the direct information:

http://www.sony.net/Products/ilc/A-series/a55va33/features01.html

"Exposure control during movie shooting is automatic in all AF modes (AF-A, AF-S, and AF-C), with the aperture fixed at F3.5 or the maximum aperture of the lens in use, whichever is smaller."

so... between you, Tariq Gibran and some others here it seems at least to be a mixed bad... Shrug.



ah, i thought you meant AF lenses didn't work normally in normal shooting or didn't actually autofocus. yes, the fixed aperture during video is a side effect of using phase detect autofocus which requires a wide aperture to function. it's a trade off if you want the advantages of phase detect autofocus you can't vary the aperture. if you want to vary the aperture your stuck with manual focus or contrast detect autofocus (i don't remember if the a55 offers cdaf as an option or not). i don't care about video (or autofocus as of late) so these issues are neither here nor there for me. what is attractive about this for me is the image stabilization and ability to magnify the viewfinder for manual focus. that combined with the high pixel density and good high iso performance might make it a good birding camera for me (not great for tracking bifs, but i don't do much of that anyway).
Aug 31, 2010 at 11:02 AM
Tariq Gibran
Offline
Details
p.4 #19Sony goes pellicle!
Bifurcator wrote:
It was DPR but here's the direct information:

http://www.sony.net/Products/ilc/A-series/a55va33/features01.html

"Exposure control during movie shooting is automatic in all AF modes (AF-A, AF-S, and AF-C), with the aperture fixed at F3.5 or the maximum aperture of the lens in use, whichever is smaller."

so... between you, Tariq Gibran and some others here it seems at least to be a mixed bad... Shrug.



That is how it's designed and, while the aperture range is limiting, the AF performance is unbeatable during video recording. So, yes, it's a mixed bag with this model if you require a huge amount of dof for video with AF. Most people want large sensors for video usage for the opposite use though and welcome a more shallow dof...and you can always use manual focus at any aperture, right?One has to keep in mind the low price point of this camera. A higher end model will likely have no such restrictions.
Aug 31, 2010 at 11:02 AM
Bifurcator
Offline
Details
p.4 #20Sony goes pellicle!
Are there many adapters from other mounts to Sony's a-mount? I haven't really looked? What lenses are sure not to work?

There's about 25 for M4/3. I have 16 now.

Aug 31, 2010 at 11:58 AM
FM ForumsSony ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister