1bwana1 wrote:
Nifty Fifty wrote
1bwana1 wrote
If I am reading your text correctly the sample scan is underexposed? No! The negative is underexposed. What I meant was the negative in the sample scan is underexposed?
Oh, I see — yes, then we’re on the same page. In my opinion, the scan shows an underexposed negative. It’s hard to determine the exact degree from a scan, but basically, your digital camera (you used that to scan, right?) always exposes in a way that makes the subject average out to a middle gray; that’s why the overall brightness of the subject looks reasonably correct. But that’s misleading, because it’s being rendered too bright—which you can tell by the fact that black appears as dark gray rather than true black. To see if your negative is exposed correctly, you’d actually need to scan it so that the film base renders as black in the positive. Then, by looking at the brightness of the actual subject, you can tell whether it’s underexposed, overexposed, or correctly exposed. It’s a relatively straightforward process with the analog method; I’m not sure exactly how it translates to digital, given the automatic adjustments that are always happening there. It’s also possible that the whole thing would look a bit less dramatic if you simply increased the contrast. That might be enough to lower the shadows down. As I said, it’s difficult to judge based on a digital scan.