Peter Bui wrote:
Well, I tried to put together a few comparison images together but it's pretty damn hard. Because of the difference in focal length between the two lenses, I had to try to adjust the camera-to-subject distance so that the subject would be the same magnification factor. It turns out this is really damn hard to do and I don't want to spend my entire Sunday trying to get it right haha.
So as a consolation prize here's a pic of the two lenses together:
wayne seltzer wrote
Peter Bui wrote
wayne seltzer wrote
You can see from the MTF's for both 24/1.4G and 35/1.4G that the 24 is sharper in the center wide-open and the 35 is optimized to be more consistent across the frame.Unless you need AF, I would go with the new Zeiss ZF.2 35/1.4. I've owned both for a few days now and while I haven't done an apples-to-apples comparison I also lean towards the 35/1.4G not being as sharp wide open as the 24/1.4G. That said, it's still sharp wide open, just not as much as the 24 which is an exceptional lens.
The 35 1.4 is also a cheaper lens ($1799 vs the 24 1.4G's original $2199 price at release) and has no ED glass in it so you got to keep this in mind.
Check out the 35mm 1.4G thread I posted a few pics.
Meanwhile, I'll try to get a few comparison images of the two. Thanks, the comparison shots will be very interesting.
With the recent/near future arrivals of the 35G, ZF.2 35/1.4, and Samyang 35/1.4 there are a lot of choices now for a fast 35.
So would you keep the 24 or the 35? Assuming you could only keep one?