fredmiranda.com Login
This topic is in the 2010 archive. You can read it and like its posts here. It is read only.

Archive 2010Mark IV hands-on only thread

  
 
Adam L
Offline
Details
p.17 #1Mark IV hands-on only thread
rd4tile wrote:
Adam L wrote
pookipichu wroteWow, that is pretty disheartening. I wonder if they purposely hobbled the AF system as to not compete with camcorders.

ragebot wrote
pookipichu wroteCan anyone share their thoughts on how the AF is in movie mode?
I have not found words to describe how bad AF is in movie mode.

Most vid web sites recommend you focus normally and then switch the lens to MF then switch to LV and then press the start movie button (FE for me). There are expensive MF add on for lens to assist in keeping the subject in focus; and it is common to also use a remote monitor to judge the focus.

On the upside you will be shooting at 1/60 or 1/125 (twice the frame rate of 30fps or 60fps) so it is easy to stop down to f16 or even f22 and still have plenty of light. In fact you may need to use ND filters or something similar. There are variable ND filters for sale on ebay that go up to ND9 or more.
Camcorder?? It's in no way a competitor to a camcorder. I could count on one hand the amount of people who buy a Mk IV to take to Disneyland to film the kids with.

The AF isn't good in Movie Mode. That much is agreed. But it's a professional tool, and professionals in the video area manual focus. We have to learn to do the same.
The auto focus isn't all that great on HD camcorders in a similar price range, nobody uses it as you pointed out.


And how many people are making TV shows and movies with HD camcorders?? Camcorders? They are the XXXDs of the video world.

DSLRs might not have the exact quality of the big cinema video cameras, but they are being used as such BY professionals. Have a look at any movie set. 99% of filming is done with manual and pre-focus
Feb 23, 2010 at 05:42 AM
Adam L
Offline
Details
p.17 #2Mark IV hands-on only thread
dehowie, they are awesome!
Feb 23, 2010 at 05:43 AM
Breitling65
Offline
Details
p.17 #3Mark IV hands-on only thread
dehowie wrote:
Pretty stoked with my pair of Mk4's.
After three weeks shooting in Japan and about 35000 frames im happy to say im happy.
Love the MK4



Great shots but no EXIF info, would you please specify ISO on last two shots?
Feb 23, 2010 at 06:38 AM
dehowie
Offline
Details
p.17 #4Mark IV hands-on only thread
Hey Brietling the 747 shot with the colorful background is 6400 and the final shot is 1600.
The post processing on these are pretty average as im in the middle of transitioning from PC to Mac and so didnt have time to really work on the noise in the 747 shot so its pretty grainy.
Im sure they would clean up a little more with more time and effort.
Darren
Feb 23, 2010 at 07:23 AM
John Caldwell
Offline
Details
p.17 #5Mark IV hands-on only thread
Nick, Thanks for discussing your NR method. I'm just buying the NIK bundle right now, including Define which will be my first contemporary NR software. Your results at 12800 are inspiring to me.

Thanks again.

John-
Feb 23, 2010 at 09:30 AM
Nick Nishizaka
Offline
Details
p.17 #6Mark IV hands-on only thread
John Caldwell wrote:
Nick, Thanks for discussing your NR method. I'm just buying the NIK bundle right now, including Define which will be my first contemporary NR software. Your results at 12800 are inspiring to me.

Thanks again.

John-


No problem. I've been getting much better results once I stopped trying to apply NR in once pass. It makes so much more sense to target the detail/highlight and shadow areas separately since they have different levels of apparent noise. It takes longer but you can put it in an action. I think the trick is to not try to eliminate grain b/c once you try to eliminate grain on a higher ISO image, you end up with that ugly pastel look.

I like dFine a lot. I have that b/c it deals with banding pretty well on my 5DMKII high ISO shots. But it's a little slower than say Noise Ninja or Neat Image Pro+. I've abandoned NoiseNinja for a while but recently started to use it again.
Feb 23, 2010 at 09:40 AM
rd4tile
Offline
Details
p.17 #7Mark IV hands-on only thread
Adam L wrote:
rd4tile wrote
Adam L wrote
pookipichu wroteWow, that is pretty disheartening. I wonder if they purposely hobbled the AF system as to not compete with camcorders.

ragebot wrote
pookipichu wroteCan anyone share their thoughts on how the AF is in movie mode?
I have not found words to describe how bad AF is in movie mode.

Most vid web sites recommend you focus normally and then switch the lens to MF then switch to LV and then press the start movie button (FE for me). There are expensive MF add on for lens to assist in keeping the subject in focus; and it is common to also use a remote monitor to judge the focus.

On the upside you will be shooting at 1/60 or 1/125 (twice the frame rate of 30fps or 60fps) so it is easy to stop down to f16 or even f22 and still have plenty of light. In fact you may need to use ND filters or something similar. There are variable ND filters for sale on ebay that go up to ND9 or more.
Camcorder?? It's in no way a competitor to a camcorder. I could count on one hand the amount of people who buy a Mk IV to take to Disneyland to film the kids with.

The AF isn't good in Movie Mode. That much is agreed. But it's a professional tool, and professionals in the video area manual focus. We have to learn to do the same.
The auto focus isn't all that great on HD camcorders in a similar price range, nobody uses it as you pointed out.
And how many people are making TV shows and movies with HD camcorders?? Camcorders? They are the XXXDs of the video world.

DSLRs might not have the exact quality of the big cinema video cameras, but they are being used as such BY professionals. Have a look at any movie set. 99% of filming is done with manual and pre-focus


I agree, I've owned a few lower end pro cams like the HVX200 and Sony EX1 and I never used the continuous AF in those. Their AF systems just weren't consistently accurate.
Feb 23, 2010 at 09:45 AM
Danpbphoto
Online
Details
p.17 #8Mark IV hands-on only thread
Nick Nishizaka wrote:
John Caldwell wroteNick, Thanks for discussing your NR method. I'm just buying the NIK bundle right now, including Define which will be my first contemporary NR software. Your results at 12800 are inspiring to me.

Thanks again.

John-
No problem. I've been getting much better results once I stopped trying to apply NR in once pass. It makes so much more sense to target the detail/highlight and shadow areas separately since they have different levels of apparent noise. It takes longer but you can put it in an action. I think the trick is to not try to eliminate grain b/c once you try to eliminate grain on a higher ISO image, you end up with that ugly pastel look.

I like dFine a lot. I have that b/c it deals with banding pretty well on my 5DMKII
...Show more →


John, I think Nick will agree, that the NIK "control point" technology is extremly "user friendly and very selective on what you manipulate. I have Dfine 2.0 and Viveza 2. Hope those are in your bundle.
Dan
Feb 23, 2010 at 10:29 AM
Nick Nishizaka
Offline
Details
p.17 #9Mark IV hands-on only thread
mdbassman wrote:
John, I think Nick will agree, that the NIK "control point" technology is extremly "user friendly and very selective on what you manipulate. I have Dfine 2.0 and Viveza 2. Hope those are in your bundle.
Dan


These plugins are very nice indeed.
The only issue I have with the control point way of doing things is that it can't really be automated since it's specific to an image.

So the trick for me is to settle on a set of NR Parameters so I can create an action for each ISO level...

But when it comes to ISO12800, each image needs a little TLC anyways, so I guess that's somewhat of a moot point.
Feb 23, 2010 at 10:44 AM
Nick Nishizaka
Offline
Details
Feb 23, 2010 at 10:47 AM
Nick Nishizaka
Offline
Details
p.17 #11Mark IV hands-on only thread
Yakim Peled wrote:
Nick Nishizaka wroteIt's when you turn the camera on and off, or leave the camera in sleep for an extended period of time that kills the battery.
Why?

Happy shooting,
Yakim.


I can only assume it eats up more juice when you turn the camera on. Not sure. That's just from experience.

I can easily shoot 2k-3k frames if I am just firing off shots in bursts over a course of a day or 2. But if I am shooting here and there, then turn the camera off, only to turn it back on a few hours later or the next day, shoot some more, then repeat, the battery will drain faster and I definitely won't get 2k shots.
Feb 23, 2010 at 10:50 AM
Danpbphoto
Online
Details
p.17 #12Mark IV hands-on only thread
Nick Nishizaka wrote:
mdbassman wroteJohn, I think Nick will agree, that the NIK "control point" technology is extremly "user friendly and very selective on what you manipulate. I have Dfine 2.0 and Viveza 2. Hope those are in your bundle.
Dan
These plugins are very nice indeed.
The only issue I have with the control point way of doing things is that it can't really be automated since it's specific to an image.

So the trick for me is to settle on a set of NR Parameters so I can create an action for each ISO level...
But when it comes to ISO12800, each image needs a little TLC anyways, so I guess that's somewhat of a moot point.


Great Nick! So that is indeed manipulation as I stated! That is why I like NIK sw.
Great work BTW!!
Dan
Feb 23, 2010 at 11:40 AM
Yakim Peled
Offline
Details
p.17 #13Mark IV hands-on only thread
Nick Nishizaka wrote:
Yakim Peled wrote
Nick Nishizaka wroteIt's when you turn the camera on and off, or leave the camera in sleep for an extended period of time that kills the battery.
Why?

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
I can only assume it eats up more juice when you turn the camera on. Not sure. That's just from experience.

I can easily shoot 2k-3k frames if I am just firing off shots in bursts over a course of a day or 2. But if I am shooting here and there, then turn the camera off, only to turn it back on a few hours later or the next day, shoot some more, then repeat, the battery will drain faster and I definitely won't get 2k shots.


10X. That's a very interesting info.

Happy shooting,
Yakim.
Feb 24, 2010 at 05:06 AM
chesapeake
Offline
Details
p.17 #14Mark IV hands-on only thread
Forgive me if this has already posted, this thread is now so long it's hard to go back and check. However, it is a revealing article that puts things into perspective and gives some hints on selecting autofocus settings.

http://www.sportsshooter.com/news/2380

Cheers-Chuck
Feb 24, 2010 at 08:17 AM
Mr Zoom
Offline
Details
p.17 #15Mark IV hands-on only thread
Another hands on veiwpoint....

With my previous 1D Mark II and III I never felt comfortable shooting at anything above ISO 400 due to noise. I'd push it on occassion to "get the shot" but the noise still had to be delt with. The Mark IV is producing ISO 400 quality shots at ISO 1000 - ISO 1600 and with a light pass of NR is equally as good and the detail stands up will.

The below shot was taken at ISO 1000 and cropped 50%. You'll notice that much of the peli-ken is oof except the head and that is what you get when you're shooting a peli-ken whizzing by 25 ft away and you have a 500 mm lens mounted on the camera. The DOF is shallow at best

1D Mark IV, ISO 1000, 1/2000th, f/5.6, all AF points activated, CF's all at factory defaults, processed in DPP from RAW.

http://ken.smugmug.com/Birds/Upload/Peli-Ken-1/796115131_bvY4b-XL.jpg
Feb 24, 2010 at 09:00 AM
Nill Toulme
Offline
Details
p.17 #16Mark IV hands-on only thread
Very good article... thanks Chuck.

Nill
Feb 24, 2010 at 10:09 AM
rd4tile
Offline
Details
p.17 #17Mark IV hands-on only thread
Mr Zoom wrote:
Another hands on veiwpoint....

With my previous 1D Mark II and III I never felt comfortable shooting at anything above ISO 400 due to noise. I'd push it on occassion to "get the shot" but the noise still had to be delt with. The Mark IV is producing ISO 400 quality shots at ISO 1000 - ISO 1600 and with a light pass of NR is equally as good and the detail stands up will.

The below shot was taken at ISO 1000 and cropped 50%. You'll notice that much of the peli-ken is oof except the head and that is
...Show more →

Based on that image and your previous posts I'd say your MKIV is working well - nice job!
Feb 24, 2010 at 10:41 AM
keithreeder
Offline
Details
p.17 #18Mark IV hands-on only thread
rd4tile wrote:
Based on that image and your previous posts I'd say your MKIV is working well - nice job!

I'll say!

I'll probably get flayed alive for saying this, but I can see something of the MK IV's IQ in my 7D - something about the fine grained, unobtrusive nature of the noise, and the excellent detail and sharpness, that they share.
Feb 24, 2010 at 10:49 AM
rd4tile
Offline
Details
p.17 #19Mark IV hands-on only thread
keithreeder wrote:
rd4tile wroteBased on that image and your previous posts I'd say your MKIV is working well - nice job!
I'll say!

I'll probably get flayed alive for saying this, but I can see something of the MK IV's IQ in my 7D - something about the fine grained, unobtrusive nature of the noise, and the excellent detail and sharpness, that they share.


No arguments from me. I had the 7D for a couple of months and if it could AF over f5.6 and was a 1.3X crop I would have been perfectly happy with it. If one pixel peeps you can start seeing differences in the files at ISOs 400 and up but there certainly isn't the huge disparity like I saw between the MKIII and 50D.
Feb 24, 2010 at 11:05 AM
ragebot
Offline
Details
p.17 #20Mark IV hands-on only thread
I agree that the 7d is a great camera and I really like the way video is implemented on it; IMHO better than on the 1d4. But the 1d4 wins hands down for hi ISO, fast AF, and straight out of the camera sharpness.

Bang for the buck wise the 7d may be the champ; but the more I use the 1d4 the happier I am.
Feb 24, 2010 at 11:15 AM
FM ForumsCanon ForumJoin Upload & Sell
  
 

You are not logged inLog inRegister